The Person I Loved Asked Me to Die in My Sister's Stead Manga Reviews (P.10)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 07, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

丁寧なラブストーリーに美麗な絵がぴったり

A beautiful picture is perfect for a careful love story

主人公にどっぷり感情移入するタイプの読み方していると、ストーリーはかなりシリアスに感じると思います。私もそのタイプですが、漫画版は絵柄がシリアスすぎず軽すぎずで凄く合ってるし読みやすいと感じました。抜群の綺麗さと程よい可愛らしさがあって好きです。原作が本当に面白く胸熱で漫画で見たいシーンが山ほどあるので、この絵のクオリティが保たれたまま連載が続くことを願っています。

If you read it in a way that completely empathizes with the main character, I think the story feels pretty serious. I'm that type, too, but I felt that the comic version fits really well and is easy to read because the design is not too serious and not too light. I like it because of its outstanding beauty and just the right amount of cuteness. The original story is really interesting and there are so many exciting scenes I want to see in comics, so I hope the series will continue while maintaining the quality of this picture.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 07, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒーローの、主人公への態度軟化が良い！

The hero's attitude towards the hero softens is good!

主人公が可哀想すぎて残酷な展開に心痛みますが、2巻以降はヒーロー(弟子)の主人公に対する態度がどんどん柔らかくなっていくので、だいぶ救いがあります。なので1巻と2巻はセットで読むべきですね！先に進むほど面白さを感じるタイプのストーリーだと思います。態度軟化、心情変化に伴うヒーローの表情の変化が絶妙でドキドキします?

The main character is so pitiful and I'm heartbroken by the cruel development, but after volume 2, the hero (apprentice)'s attitude towards the main character gets softer and softer, so there's quite a bit of relief. So you should read volume 1 and 2 as a set! I think it's a type of story where the further you go, the more interesting it is. The changes in the hero's facial expressions associated with softening attitudes and changes in mood are exquisite and exciting?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

憐れなヒロイン

My Poor Heroine

幼くして両親を亡くし、引き取られた先では実子同様に育てられたが、妹の代わりに生け○になる。その最後の後押しをしたのが自分の愛する人。自分の事を好きでいてくれるような振る舞いをしながら（無意識にしていたかもしれない）いつの間にか妹と恋人になっていた。自分の恋心を胸に秘め○け贄の地へ向かう。月日は流れ、妹夫婦の子供が自分を手にかけようとやってくる。そして、自分がいなくなってから妹夫婦や他の国民たちはヒロインの事を好き勝手に貶めている事をしる。余りにも不憫なヒロイン。可哀想過ぎる！！

She lost her parents at a young age, and when she was taken in, she was raised in the same way as her biological child, but she became a living child in place of her younger sister. The person who gave that last boost was someone I loved. While behaving in a way that they liked me (I may have been unconscious), I had become lovers with my sister before I knew it. Hide your love in your heart and head to the land of sacrifice. The months and days go by, and my younger sister's couple's children are coming to take control of themselves. Also, it shows that my younger sister, her wife, and other citizens have been disrespecting the heroine without permission since she was gone. A heroine who is too pitiful. That's too pathetic!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが読みたい好きな作品

Favorite works I want to read more

This review contains spoilers. 1巻を読みました。最初の方だけ分冊版を読んで、その後こちらの単行本を読みました。ストーリーは、ページをめくる手が止まらないような面白さがあり、単行本なのにすぐに読み終わってしまいました。好きだった男性に酷いことを言われて、その男性が自分の(義理ですが)妹と結婚して、そのふたりの間に生まれた子どもが主人公の前に現れるというのは、精神的に辛いと感じるものがあります。でも、続きが読みたくなります。好きな作品です。

This review contains spoilers. I read volume 1. I read only the split edition at the beginning, then I read this book later. The story was so interesting that I couldn't stop turning the pages, and I finished reading it right away even though it was a book book. There is something mentally painful when a man you like says terrible things, and that man marries his (in-law) sister, and a child born between them appears in front of the protagonist. But it makes me want to read more. It's my favorite work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

トリコになりました

It's now Toriko

This review contains spoilers. タイトルや最初のシーンからずっと胸が苦しくなるほど惹かれてしまうストーリーです。作者さん凄すぎます。ウィステリアが精神的に苦しむシーンはもう見たく無いけど、まだまだあるんでしょうね。3人も子供がいて仲睦まじいと思われるブライト夫妻にはぎゃふんお願いします。続きも楽しみにしています！

This review contains spoilers. It's a story that fascinates me so much that it makes my heart ache from the title and the first scene. The author is amazing. I don't want to watch any more scenes where Wisteria suffers mentally, but there are probably more. Please kindly ask Mr. and Mrs. Bright, who have 3 children and seem to be on good terms. I'm looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

好き！

I like it!

今いちばん続きを楽しみにしてるラブストーリー。丁寧なつくりで、通して読むと面白いです！最初はヒロインの不憫な境遇に感情移入して泣きそうになりつつ読んでたけど、3話で23年の時が過ぎてからはシリアスさが少し落ち着いて、ぐっと読みやすくなった。時折コメディ風味もあるしね。そしてその後に現れた恋のフラグに歓喜…二人は両片想いなの？どうなの？ってやきもきしながら続きを待ってます?

This is the love story I'm looking forward to the most continuation right now. It's carefully crafted, and it's interesting to read through! At first, I was reading it while empathizing with the heroine's pitiful circumstances and almost crying, but after 23 years passed in episode 3, the seriousness calmed down a bit, and it became much easier to read. Occasionally, it also has a comedic flavor. And rejoicing at the love flag that appeared after that... do they both have unrequited love? how is it? are you excited and waiting for the continuation?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

続きをはやく～

Continue quickly~

This review contains spoilers. ヒロインの最初がヘビーで、少しすると更にヘビー！(*/ω＼*)ｷｬｰ!!なにこれなにこれ！1番好きなネタかもしれない！

This review contains spoilers. The heroine is heavy at the beginning, and even heavier after a little while! (*/omega\ *) lol!! What's this what's this! Maybe it's my favorite story!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ふぉ〜。

whoa.

ぬぁーっ❗もう、切ないですよ。妹にしろ想い人(後の妹の旦那)にしろほんと人でなしだわ?身代わりにしたくせに居なくなった後、悪い噂が流れても否定せず知らんぷりで自分達の幸せしか考えてない。息子ともとんでもない理由での初対面だけど・・・

Wow ❗ it's already sad. Whether it's a younger sister or lover (later sister's husband), they're really not people, right? After they were gone even though they took their place, they didn't deny it even when bad rumors spread, and they just thought about our own happiness. I met my son for the first time for a ridiculous reason, but...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絵もストーリーも丁寧で綺麗

The pictures and story are careful and beautiful

シリアスな作風を引き立て、かつ読みやすくしている絵の魅力が凄いです。主人公が超絶不憫でシリアスな話なんだけど、クスッと笑えたり恋を予感させるドキドキポイントが所々織り込まれていて、そこも魅力。ストーリーがしっかりしていて読み応えあります。続きが早く読みたい！

The appeal of the pictures, which complement the serious style and make them easy to read, is amazing. It's a serious story where the main character is transcendental and pitiful, but there are some heartwarming points that make you laugh and pretend love, and that is also fascinating. The story is solid and worth reading. I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 25, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

切なくて残酷な始まりだけど愛おしい物語

It's a sad and cruel beginning, but it's an adorable story

原作から先に入った者ですが、原作の良さを損なうことなく引き出しており、絵のきれいさもあいまって読みやすいコミックになってると思いました！表情やキャラクターの描き分けがとても絶妙で素晴らしいです。原作をさらっと読んだだけだと分かりにくい表現が、コミカライズではパッと見で分かりやすくなってる親切設計箇所もいくつか。他のレビュー通り2巻最終話 (単話8話) で本格的に面白くなるので、少なくとも8話までは読んでみてほしいなぁ。

They came first from the original story, but they brought out the goodness of the original without compromising, and I thought it was a comic that was easy to read, combined with the beauty of the pictures! The drawing of facial expressions and characters is so exquisite and wonderful. Expressions that are hard to understand if you just read the original story quickly, are also a few friendly design parts that are easy to understand at first glance in comicalization. As per other reviews, the final episode of volume 2 (8 single episodes) makes it really interesting, so I want you to read at least episode 8.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

まだまだ続きます&先へ進むほど面白くなる

It's still going on & the further you go, the more interesting it gets

コミックきっかけで原作ノベルも全て読みましたが、他のレビューに多数あるように、コミック2巻最後まで読むと、この物語の方向性が分かってグッと面白くなると思います? 人間関係や設定とそれに伴う心の動きがそこそこ複雑なので、その説明のためにも必要な最初の2巻なんだなと。無事に完結したらコミック10巻越えになりそう。原作がジレジレ感ありつつも間違いなく面白かったので(特に4巻) コミックにも期待が持てます♦

I read all of the original novels because of the comics, but as there are many other reviews, if you read until the end of volume 2 of the comics, you'll understand the direction of this story and it will be really interesting. The relationships, settings, and mental movements associated with them are pretty complicated, so I think these are the first 2 volumes necessary to explain them. It seems like it will be over 10 volumes of comics once it's successfully completed. The original story was definitely interesting even though it had a sense of giraffe (volume 4 in particular), so I can look forward to comics too ♦

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

切なすぎてイラっとする。

It's so sad that it's frustrating.

This review contains spoilers. もう読んでいて、切ないしイラッとします。ブライトと妹とその家族。何してんの。自分の我儘で追いやっておいて、自分達はさっさと結婚して子供3人も作り幸せに生活している。罪悪感なし、しかも冤罪広めて何しているの。この家族にざまぁならないのか。この家族、人の犠牲で成り立っているの忘れたのか。申し訳ないけど、この家族はそれ相当の罰があっていいと思う。イレーネには本当に幸せになって欲しい。報われて欲しい。

This review contains spoilers. I've already read it, and it makes me sad and annoyed. Bright and her sister and their family. what are you doing. They chased them away at their own selfishness, got married quickly, had 3 children, and are living a happy life. Why are you spreading false accusations without feeling guilty. don't you feel comfortable with this family? Have you forgotten that this family is made up of human sacrifices? I'm sorry, but I think it's okay for this family to be punished accordingly. I really want Irene to be happy. I want to be rewarded.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻の最後がよかった?

was the last part of volume 2 good?

なので、ぜひぜひ1巻と2巻をまとめて読んでみてください? 続き気になる人は、小説に抵抗なかったら原作4巻まで一気に読んでほしいくらい、かなり面白い原作なのでお薦めです◎ ウィステリアと出会い弟子として接していくうちに、ロイドの内面も態度も変化していって好感度どんどん上がってくのが大きな見どころ。たぶん皆が期待してる胸熱展開は原作4巻以降の内容なので、原作に手を出さない勢は首を長ーくして待つと良さそう。それまでのお話も定期的にドキドキ展開あるからきっと楽しめる?

So be sure to read volume 1 and 2 together? For those who are interested in the continuation, I recommend it because it's a pretty interesting original story, so if you don't resist the novel, I recommend it ◎ As you meet Wisteria and treat him as an apprentice, Lloyd's inner world and attitude change, and his likability rises steadily. The heartbreaking development that everyone is probably expecting is about volume 4 of the original story and beyond, so it seems good for those who don't touch the original story to wait a long time. The stories up to that point also have regular exciting developments, so I'm sure you'll enjoy them?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 31, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いとは思う。

I think it's interesting.

原作がＴＯブックで４冊目が出たので、コカライズは終わるまで巻数は２桁は掛かりそう。途中で連載が止まるて事がないかと少し心配です。原作はソフトカバーなので結構分厚いと思われ。ちなみこう書いていますが原作は未読なので、読んだ人からすればトヤカク言うなでしょうが、何しろ途中で止まるのが怖い。物語はなんせ最初の主人公の片思いの相手も、今の相手もイラっとする。早く、事情が全部分かって後悔するがいいって思う。特に父親になった主人公の初恋の人が痛い目に合えばいいなてなるな。しかし、話し悪くないけど顔が一緒だから惚れてしまうのもなんか間違いのような、違う人間だけど顔が一緒で「キュン」となっているヒロインも中々です。２３年も思い続けるとか結構激重。最新刊まで読みましたが、次の巻読んで見て続き買うか考えます。あの一緒にいる剣が人になれないものかと、あの剣の方が余程いいと。何しろ、ヒロインの過去が焦れる人にはお勧めです。

The original is a TO book and the 4th book came out, so it seems that the number of volumes will take 2 digits until Cocalise is over. I'm a little worried that the serialization will stop in the middle. The original is in soft cover, so I think it's pretty thick. By the way, it's written like this, but the original story is unread, so if you read it, don't say it's ridiculous, but I'm afraid of stopping in the middle anyway. After all, the story annoys both the original protagonist's unrequited partner and his current partner. I think it's better to quickly figure out all the circumstances and regret it. In particular, it would be nice if the protagonist's first love, who became a father, was in pain. However, it's not bad to talk to, but it's kind of a mistake that they fall in love because their faces are the same, and there are also some heroines who are different people but have the same faces and are “amazed.” It's pretty heavy to keep thinking about it for 23 years. I've read up to the latest issue, but I'll read the next volume and think about whether to buy it again. I wonder if that sword I'm with can't become a person, and I think that sword is too good. After all, I recommend it to people who are impatient about the heroine's past.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 26, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

とても綺麗な絵柄の作家さん

An artist with a very beautiful picture

This review contains spoilers. タイトルに惹かれて、絵柄も美しくて書いました、が、主人公が不憫すぎませんか？幼おなじみの好きな男と妹は自分を犠牲にしといて、3人も子供作って真実をねじ曲げて主人公が悪者に。このまま、息子殿と恋を育んでいくのがモヤモヤする、両親が罪が重すぎる、自分を俗世から切り離して幸せに暮らしてた両親の息子。なんか恋に落ちるにもそっくりとのことだし、なかなか気になる内容ですが相手の親が親だけにモヤモヤしますね

This review contains spoilers. I was drawn to the title, and the design was beautiful and I wrote it, but isn't the main character too pitiful? A man and his younger sister, who are childhood friends, sacrificed themselves, and made 3 children to twist the truth, and the main character became the villain. As it is, developing a love with his son is a son of parents who are confused, their parents' sins are too serious, and they have separated themselves from the world and lived a happy life. It is said that they look just like when they fall in love, and the content is quite worrisome, but the other parent is only confused by the parents

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 25, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

コミックも小説もどちらも素敵

Both comics and novels are wonderful

コミックは絵がきれいで色んなコマの表情に惹き付けられます！2巻収録の8話がすごく良いので、そこまで読まないともったいないって思います。原作小説を最新の4巻まで読んだら最高だったから、コミックの続きも楽しみ！だけどコミックの更新がそんなに早くなさそうなので気長に待ちます～

The comics have beautiful pictures and I'm attracted to the various expressions on the frames! The 8 episodes recorded in 2 volumes are really good, so I think it would be a waste if I didn't read that far. It would have been great if I read up to the latest 4 volumes of the original novel, so I'm looking forward to the continuation of the comic! But the comic doesn't seem to be updated that fast, so I'll be patiently wait~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが早く見たい❤

I want to see the continuation soon ❤

表情が細やかで引き込まれます〜これからどうなるのか、知りたいから原作を読みたいけど、コミックの世界を大切にしたいから、ガマンかなぁ?

The expression is detailed and draws me in ~ I want to read the original story because I want to know what will happen in the future, but I want to cherish the comic world, so I wonder if I can stand it?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない……

sad...

This review contains spoilers. 愛した人は妹に惹かれてしまい、仕舞いには妹の代わりに身代わりになれという始末。それだけではなく、息子がやってきて23年支えてくれたサルトを渡せと言われるわ、妹の代わりに犠牲になったのに何故か元の世界では犯罪者扱いされてるわ…。ウィステリア、早く幸せになってほしい……。ストーリーしっかり構成されていて、キャラクターの心理描写が細やかで素敵な作品です。これから原作も読もうと思います。

This review contains spoilers. The person she loved was attracted to her younger sister, and in the end, she was asked to take her place. Not only that, my son came and they told me to hand over Saruto, who supported me for 23 years, and even though she was sacrificed in place of my sister, for some reason she is treated as a criminal in the original world... Wisteria, I want you to be happy soon... The story is well-structured, and the psychological depictions of the characters are detailed, and it is a wonderful work. I think I'll read the original story now.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

個人的に

privately

個人的には聖剣Ｘウィステリアでええやん！辛い時にずっと側に居たのは聖剣サルトやん？色々事情を知ってるし、擬人化してくれてええんやで？甥っ子は嫌な奴ではないけど、あの両親が付いてくるの嫌すぎる。

Personally, it's fine with Seiken X Wisteria! it was Seiken Sart who was by your side the whole time when it was hard, wasn't it? I know a lot of circumstances, and they personify me, okay? My nephew isn't a bad guy, but I hate having those parents follow him too much.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

原作ファンであり漫画ファンである

I'm a fan of the original story and a manga fan

原作から入りました。原作はとにかく言葉の言い回しが上手く、とても綺麗な世界観が紡がれています。そこに恋愛のドロドロ。主人公の気持ちが痛いくらいに伝わってきて心臓が痛くなります。漫画版になるとそれが更に倍増。今のところ妹も婚約者も嫌な奴だけれど、原作で読み進めていくと、そんな印象も少しは薄まります。いもうとが自己中心的であることには変わりませんが。原作も良き、漫画も良きの良作なので是非読んでみてください。

I started with the original story. Anyway, the original story is very good at wording, and it has a very beautiful view of the world. There's a muddle of love there. The main character's feelings are transmitted to such an extent that it hurts my heart. When it comes to the comic version, it doubles even more. I don't like my sister and fiancé so far, but as you read on with the original story, that impression fades a little. That doesn't change the fact that Imoto is self-centered. The original story is good, and the comics are good, so be sure to read them.

Helpful

Reviews for The Person I Loved Asked Me to Die in My Sister's Stead Manga