The Person I Loved Asked Me to Die in My Sister's Stead Manga Reviews (P.9)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

可哀想だけど面白い。好き。

It's a pity, but it's funny. I like it.

1巻読んでヒロインが可哀想すぎて泣いちゃったけど、2巻で救われる部分もあったので2巻読めて良かったです！

I read volume 1 and cried because I felt so sorry for the heroine, but there was also a part where I was saved in volume 2, so I'm glad I was able to read volume 2!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がきれいで面白い！特に２巻

The picture is beautiful and interesting! Especially volume 2

1巻だと初恋の人の息子が印象あんまりだったけど、2巻読んだら良い方に印象変わったし、出会った時の態度がなぜ良くなかったのかも解明されてスッキリした。そこからどんどん面白くなってきたから2巻推しておきますね！

Volume 1 made a big impression on the son of my first love, but after reading volume 2, my impression changed for the better, and it was refreshing to find out why their attitude when we met wasn't good. Since then, it became more and more interesting, so I'll recommend volume 2!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 30, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

どハマりしましたー！

I'm addicted to it!

1話を読んで面白そうだったので続きを読みます。タイトルがとっても気になる。この先どうなるのかとても楽しみです。追記漫画購入しましたが先が気になりすぎてノベライズまで買っちゃいました！めっちゃいいです！この先のノベライズのストーリーが漫画になるのがとても楽しみです。早く漫画で見たーい！キュンキュンなシーンを絵で見たいです

I read episode 1 and it seemed interesting, so I'll continue reading. I'm really interested in the title. I'm really excited to see what the future holds. Postscript I bought the comic, but I was so worried about the future that I even bought Novelize! It's really good! I'm really looking forward to the upcoming novelization story being turned into a comic. I want to watch comics soon! I want to see a funny scene in pictures

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

^_^

^_^

なんだか物騒な題名に不幸臭がしてきたので読むのを控えていましたが…試し読みをしたら先が気になり２巻まで購入してしまいました(^_^;)

There was an unfortunate smell in the title, so I refrained from reading it... after doing the trial reading, I was worried about the future and bought up to 2 volumes (^_^;)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

私だったら絶対に耐えられません〜(泣)

If I were you, I would never be able to endure it~ (crying)

This review contains spoilers. 初恋が失恋に終わるだけでも相当キツいのに、その初恋相手から義妹の代わりに死ぬように頼まれるなんて・・・私だったら絶対に耐えられません〜(泣)。物語の序章があまりにも切なすぎたので心が折れて挫折しそうになったのですが、美しくて健気なヒロインが報われる姿が見たいと思い、続行を決めました。彼女の傷を癒やしてくれるかもしれない相手があの残酷な初恋相手の息子だと思うと、なんだかとても複雑な気持ちになるのですが、息子に罪はありませんからねぇ・・・。とにかくヒロインが幸せになってくれるのなら、私は満足です。（ああと初恋相手の悪行が明るみになってくれれば、更に大満足です！）

This review contains spoilers. It's pretty tough just for my first love to end in heartbreak, but being asked by that first love partner to die in place of my sister-in-law... I would definitely be unbearable ~ (crying). The preface to the story was so sad that my heart was broken and I almost felt frustrated, but I wanted to see the beautiful and healthy heroine being rewarded, so I decided to continue. When I think that someone who might heal her wounds is the son of that cruel first love partner, it somehow makes me feel very mixed, but that's because my son isn't guilty... Anyway, if the heroine makes me happy, I'm satisfied. (Also, if your first love partner's misdeeds come to light, I'm even more satisfied!)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

作画が良い。ストーリーは2巻が好き。

The drawing is good. I like volume 2 of the story.

レビューで2巻が良いと教えてくれた皆様ありがとうございます！1巻だけだとこのストーリーの本当の良さに気づけなかったです。久々に続きが待ち遠しくて仕方ない漫画に出会えました。キャラデザやアクションシーンひっくるめて作画もとても良いです。

Thank you to everyone who told me volume 2 is good in their reviews! I didn't notice how good this story really was if it was only volume 1. I came across a comic that I couldn't help but look forward to continuing after a long time. The drawing is also very good with character designs and action scenes.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻！

Volume 2!

絵がとても綺麗ですごく気になっていたお話だったのですが、タイトルが切なすぎて読むのをなんとなく躊躇していました。でも、2巻以降からがすごいとレビューを見て購入してみました。本当にすごかったです！そして面白い！！購入して良かった！！主人公には、もう本当に幸せになって欲しいので、早く続きが読みたいです。

The pictures were so beautiful that I was really interested in it, but the title was so sad that I was kind of hesitant to read it. But I bought it after looking at the reviews that volume 2 and later were amazing. It was really amazing! and interesting!! I'm glad I bought it!! I want the main character to be really happy already, so I want to read more soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

しっかりしたファンタジーの物語でした

It was a solid fantasy story

ラブストーリーを期待する人は、少なくとも2巻まで一気に読むのがオススメ。主人公が異界に行かされ、後にそこでヒーローと出会い師弟関係になるまでが1巻の内容。世界観とストーリーがしっかりしている分、説明のために進みが早くはないですが、そのぶん読みごたえあって面白かったです。

If you're expecting a love story, I recommend reading at least 2 volumes at once. Volume 1 is about the main character being sent to a different world until he later meets the hero there and has a teacher-pupil relationship. Since the world view and story are solid, the progress isn't fast for explanation, but it was quite satisfying to read and interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻が良かった！

Volume 2 was good!

1巻はほとんどシリーズの導入という感じですかね。レビュー見て2巻が良いとあったので読みましたが、その通りでした

Volume 1 is almost like the introduction of a series, isn't it? Looking at the reviews, they said volume 2 was good, so I read it, and that was true

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 26, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

タイトルに惹かれて読んでみたら絵柄がかわいくて最高でした！！！ストーリー性もおもしろくてめっちゃいい作品だなって思いました！1巻の途中までしか読めてないので続きがものすごく気になります！！！

I was attracted to the title and read it, the design was cute and awesome!!! The story was interesting and I thought it was a really nice work! I've only been able to read the middle of volume 1, so I'm really curious about the continuation!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻末にしてようやく

At last at the end of volume 2

1巻目は哀しくて、切なくて、可哀想過ぎて…。皆さんのレビューを信じて2巻目はヒーロー視点が良かったです。新たな恋の兆しが見えてきたこの先にウィステリアの幸せへと繋がって欲しい。絵が綺麗で感情移入してしまって、読み出すと没頭してしまいます(笑)

The first volume was sad, sad, and too pathetic... I believed everyone's reviews and the hero's point of view was good in volume 2. The signs of a new love have come into view, and I hope it will lead to Wisteria's happiness in the future. The picture is so beautiful that I empathize with it, and when I read it out, I'm immersed in it (laughs)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

すごく切ないけど、続きに希望が持てそう

It's really sad, but it seems like I can continue to have hope

1巻 (1～4話) だけだと、2話目のインパクトが強すぎて悲しさと切なさの余韻がすごいので、2巻 (5～8話) まで読むと良いと思います? 切なさが持ち味のお話だと思うけど、それだけじゃない新たな恋への希望とかが徐々に見えてくるので。不憫すぎる主人公の、強く美しく優しいところがいつか報われて誰よりも幸せになりますように……ちなみにこちらが好きという人には原作小説もかなりお薦めです！

If it's only volume 1 (episodes 1 to 4), the impact of episode 2 is so strong that the afterglow of sadness and sadness is amazing, so do you think it's good to read up to volume 2 (episodes 5 to 8)? I think it's a story about sadness, but not only that, I gradually begin to see hope for a new love. I hope that the strong, beautiful, and kind character of the protagonist, who is too pitiful, will one day be rewarded and made happier than anyone else... Incidentally, I highly recommend the original novel to anyone who likes this one!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 20, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いし全体的に絵がきれい

It's interesting and overall the picture is beautiful

1巻は全てヒロイン視点の大失恋から始まるシリアスストーリー。2巻は一転ヒーロー視点が増え、ヒロインへの好感度がぐんと上がっていく過程で救いがありました。コミックス1,2巻にのみ載ってる描き下ろし漫画を読むと、どちらも今後のラブストーリーを予感させるようで、続きが待ち遠しい。ヒロインが良い子なのに不憫な状況に追いやられ可哀想すぎて…感情移入しすぎると苦しくはあるけど、きっとヒーローがヒロインを助けてくれると信じてます

Volume 1 is a serious story that all begins with a great heartbreak from the heroine's point of view. Volume 2 completely changed the hero's point of view, and there was salvation in the process where the likability for the heroine increased dramatically. When I read the comics drawn only in volumes 1 and 2, they both seem to pretend future love stories, and I can't wait for the continuation. Even though the heroine is a good kid, she was driven into a pitiful situation and felt so pitiful... it's painful if you empathize too much, but I believe the hero will surely help the heroine

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ムハ

Muha

This review contains spoilers. こちらの作品に関しましてはと言いましたらですと、どういったストーリーになっておられるのかを説明させていただきましょう。両親を亡くし伯父夫婦に引き取られ育った令嬢は、片想いの男性と出会い新たなストーリーが始まるという異世界漫画です。すごくわかりやすい作品です。

This review contains spoilers. Speaking of this work, let me explain what kind of story it is. The daughter, who lost her parents and was taken in by her uncle and his wife, is an alternate world comic where she meets a man with unrequited love and a new story begins. It's a very easy work to understand.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

切ないし､イラッともする！！

It's both sad and frustrating!!

This review contains spoilers. 結局のところブライトとロザリーはどっちも魔法が使えない者同士で傷の舐め合いで愛し合ったんでしよ！！なのに、ウィスは2人の為に生贄になって…なのに何で悪者になってなきゃならないのか…！！本当に意味がわからない！！そしてこの先息子のロイドがまぁウィスを好きになるっていう展開なんだろうけど…どうしても納得がいきません！！ウィスの名誉の回復とできれば全然関係ない人との幸せな最後を望みます！！

This review contains spoilers. After all, both Bright and Rosalie were people who couldn't use magic, and they loved each other by licking each other's wounds!! And yet, Wiss was sacrificed for the two... so why does he have to become the bad guy...!! I really don't understand the meaning!! And it's probably going to be a development where my son Lloyd will fall in love with Wiss in the future... I'm not convinced by any means!! I hope for a happy ending with someone who has nothing to do with Wiss's restoration of honor if possible!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

私のことはイレーネと呼んでくれ

Call me Irene

This review contains spoilers. この言葉にどれだけの想いを込めたのか…。眉目秀麗ながらもルイニングの出来損ないとも揶揄されるブライトが、天真爛漫なロザリーを選ぶのは納得できる。でも、自分への恋慕を知っていながらロザリーの身代わりを頼むブライトは最低なヤツ。そのブライトにそっくりなロイド。これだけつらい状況の中でもまだブライトへの気持ちが残っているのはさすがに気の毒。ウィステリアの目は紫。やはり慈愛の強い女性なのだろう。今後の展開が楽しみ。

This review contains spoilers. I wonder how much thought I put into these words... It's understandable that Bright, who has beautiful eyebrows but is ridiculed for her poor ruining, chooses an innocent rosary. But Bright, who knows her love for herself and asks to take Rosalie's place, sucks. Lloyd looks just like that bright. I'm really sorry that my feelings for Bright still remain even in such a difficult situation. Wisteria's eyes are purple. After all, she's probably a very compassionate woman. I'm looking forward to future developments.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

師弟愛？師弟恋愛？続きが楽しみ?

teacher-pupil love? teacher-pupil romance? are you looking forward to the continuation?

2巻の最終話でラブストーリーの醍醐味が増して一気に面白くなったので、ぜひ2巻まで読むのをオススメします。1巻だけだと、ほぼタイトル通りのシリアスな導入部分のみだから、この物語の本当の面白さが分からなさそう。ちなみに原作ノベル読んできたらかなり先の方まで読めて感動する＆満足度高い内容だったんで、コミックにも期待できます? コミックも毎話丁寧に描かれていてクオリティが高いし続きが楽しみです

The real thrill of love stories increased in the final episode of volume 2, and it became interesting all at once, so I definitely recommend reading up to volume 2. If it's only volume 1, it's almost just the serious introduction part as the title says, so I don't seem to understand the true fun of this story. By the way, once you've read the original novel, you can read it for a long time, and the content was moving and highly satisfying, so can you look forward to comics too? Every episode of the comic is also carefully drawn and the quality is high, so I'm looking forward to the continuation

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

弟子が主人公を救ってくれることを期待…！

Hope the apprentice will save the protagonist...!

おもしろいです！1巻で出会った当初は、嘘の悪評を聞かされていたせいもあり主人公に対し好戦的な姿勢のヒーロー君。徐々に主人公の人柄の良さとか魅力に気づいて態度を改め、距離感縮まっていくのが見所 (好きなポイント) 二人は血の繋がりはないし倫理的には想い合っても問題ない関係だけど、これからどんな関係に発展するのか楽しみです (漫画の続きが待ちきれない人には原作小説が超おすすめ)

It's interesting! When we first met in volume 1, Hero-kun had a belligerent attitude towards the main character, partly because he was told false notoriety. The highlight (favorite point) is that they gradually notice the character's good personality and appeal, and their sense of distance shrinks (favorite point) The two have no blood connection, and there is no problem even if they have feelings for each other ethically, but I'm looking forward to seeing what kind of relationship it will develop into in the future (the original novel is highly recommended for people who can't wait for the continuation of the manga)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

せつない

It's annoying

まだ2巻までなのですが、とにかく切ない。でもこれから誤解が解けてざまぁして幸せになって欲しいと期待している作品です。

It's still up to volume 2, but it's just sad. However, it is a work I hope that misunderstandings will be resolved from now on, and that people will be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ブライトの揺れる気持・・・美麗イケメン！

The shaking feeling of the bright... beautiful handsome guy!

This review contains spoilers. 主人公のウィステリアは初恋の人ブライトに妹の身代わりに生贄になってくれと頼まれます。（自分が妹と結婚するために・・・良くもそんなことを言えたものだと・・・）ウィステリアは「ブライトのために」異界に旅立ちます。（決して妹のためじゃなく・・・同性に厳しく異性に甘い・・・）その異界でウィステリアを師匠と慕うロイドと出会います。これがブライトそっくりなんです！ところがブライトは妹と結婚したもののウィステリアを忘れられず・・・ウィステリアを挟んでブライトとロイドの三角関係が発生する物語です。ファンタジーラブロマンスの好きな人にお奨めの作品です。

This review contains spoilers. The main character, Wisteria, is asked to be sacrificed in place of her younger sister by her first love, Bright. (In order to get married to my sister... well, I was able to say that...) Wisteria leaves for a different world “for Bright's sake.” (It's definitely not for my sister... strict of the same sex, sweet for the opposite sex...) I meet Lloyd, who adores Wisteria as her mentor. This looks just like Bright! However, Bright married her sister but couldn't forget Wisteria... it's a story where a love triangle between Bright and Lloyd occurs between Wisteria. I recommend this work to anyone who likes fantasy love romance.

Helpful

Reviews for The Person I Loved Asked Me to Die in My Sister's Stead Manga