The Person I Loved Asked Me to Die in My Sister's Stead Manga Reviews (P.11)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒーローの心境変化に期待が高まる！

Expectations are high for the hero's change of mind!

聖剣を求めて来たという境遇的にどうしても主人公の望まざる客人になってしまう【主人公の初恋の人の息子】が、主人公と両親を取り巻く残酷な真実を知らないこと。そして何も知らないまま主人公と師弟関係を結び共同生活をする中で、主人公への想いが徐々に変化していくこと。まだまだ始まったばかりですが、2巻だけでも作品の面白さの片鱗はわかると思います。続きがとても楽しみです！

[The son of the protagonist's first love], who inevitably becomes the protagonist's unwanted guest due to the circumstances of coming in search of a sacred sword, doesn't know the cruel truth surrounding the protagonist and his parents. Then, as they form a teacher-pupil relationship with the protagonist and live a shared life without knowing anything, feelings for the protagonist gradually change. It's just getting started, but I think you can get a glimpse of the fun of the work from volume 2 alone. I'm really looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いけど

It's interesting but

最初に誤解がないように言うと、この漫画は面白いよ。続きが気になります！そんでもってね、本題は…、2巻まで読んでわかった。モヤモヤした。やっぱり甥っ子は無理。仮にも初恋の相手に瓜二つだろうが、そもそもお父さんが無理だから、息子も無理。どうにか当て馬召喚して欲しいと思ったの。だからさぁ……サルト、擬人化してくれねぇかなぁ……切に。サルトぉ……あんたしかいねぇよ。うーーーん、ムカムカするぅ……

To make sure there aren't any misunderstandings at first, this comic is interesting. I'm curious about the continuation! Well, I understood the main subject... by reading up to 2 volumes. It was a mess. After all, nephews can't do it. Even if I had to be the partner of my first love, my son couldn't do it either because my father couldn't do it. I wanted them to somehow summon the beating horse. So come on... Saruto, I wonder if you can personify me... seriously. salto... you're the only one. Hmm, I'm so upset...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

とりあえず2巻最後まで読んで…!!

For now, read until the end of volume 2...!!

原作小説を知る者としては、コミックの1巻は超～序盤で、その後に起こるアレコレが本当に面白いので、せっかく読むなら1巻で投げ出さないでね!! と言いたくなっちゃう。2巻からグッと面白くなり始めるから、2巻までは絶対読んで…!! 2巻のラストがたまらなく良いから!! 3巻以降も楽しみすぎます。続き気になる人はぜひ、原作沼へ♪ 最新4巻が最高なので激推しです?

As someone who knows the original novel, volume 1 of the comic is super early, and the stuff that happens after that is really interesting, so if you read it all the way, don't throw it out in volume 1!! It makes me want to say that. It starts getting really interesting from volume 2, so definitely read up to volume 2...!! Because the last volume 2 is irresistibly good!! I'm really looking forward to volume 3 and beyond. If you are interested in the continuation, please go to the original Swamp ♪ The latest 4 volumes are the best, so I highly recommend them?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

そんなー、、、

that's...

そんなこと言われたら悲しすぎるーそりゃ息子ともかぶって、精神不安定になるよ。てか剣の言うことがちょこちょこ面白い（笑）2人の関係が今後どうなっていくのか、、、楽しみにしてます！

It would be too sad to be told that — then wearing it with my son would make me mentally unstable. What Heck Sword says is a bit interesting (lol) I'm looking forward to seeing what the relationship between the two will look like in the future...!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

切なくてキュン

Don't be sad

This review contains spoilers. めちゃくちゃ好きです。始まりはえげつない程哀しいのですが、絵とサルティスに癒されながら読めます。どうにかヒロインには幸せに、ハピエンになってほしい！続きものすごーく楽しみにしてます！

This review contains spoilers. I really like it. The beginning is so sad, but I can read it while being healed by the pictures and Sartis. I want the heroine to somehow be happy and happy! I'm really looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻よいよ♦

Volume 2 is good ♦

まず1巻はえぐいくらい悲しいから、その傷を和らげるためにも最低2巻まで読み終えてほしい！！！ 2巻でヒーロー君のこととか色々掘り下げられて分かってきたら、悲しい気持ちより続き楽しみな気持ちの方が上回るはず。2巻は恋愛的な意味でキュンとするシーンもあるし。単話もいいんだけど、コミックスの描きおろしがどれも読みごたえあるから、こちらのコミックスで揃えるのを推します?

First of all, volume 1 is so sad, so I want you to finish reading at least 2 volumes to ease that scar!! If you delve into various things about Hero-kun in volume 2 and get to know it, the feeling of continuing to be happy should surpass the feeling of being sad. There are also scenes in volume 2 that make you cringe in a romantic sense. Single episodes are good too, but since all of the comics drawn are worth reading, I recommend arranging them with this comic?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻発売が楽しみです！

I'm looking forward to the release of volume 2!

2巻は単話5～8話収録とのこと (コミックス1～2巻が原作ノベル1巻に相当) 単話のほう読んでみたらスゴく良かったし、コミックスだけの描き下ろしストーリーも楽しみなので2巻も買います。これから手を出す人は、とりあえず単話8話/コミックス2巻までぜひ読んでみてください。8話が最高なだけに、途中で見切ってしまったら非常にもったいないので。

Volume 2 contains 5 to 8 single episodes (volumes 1 to 2 of the comics are equivalent to 1 volume of the original novel), which was great when I read the single episode, and I'm also looking forward to the story drawn only from comics, so I bought 2 volumes as well. If you are trying your hand at it, be sure to read up to 8 single episodes/2 volumes of comics. Episode 8 is the best, so it would be very wasteful to miss it in the middle.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

コミックス2巻は5/15発売と聞いて

I heard that volume 2 comics will be released on 5/15

楽しみにしています。1巻と同様、描き下ろしの漫画と小説 (SS) 付くそうなので買わなければ！1巻は悲しい展開メインでめちゃくちゃ切ないけど、2巻収録予定の話は単話読む限り1巻より明るさが増してて面白い展開で読みやすいと思います。

I'm looking forward to it. Like volume 1, it seems that it comes with a comic drawn up and a novel (SS), so I have to buy it! Volume 1 is mainly a sad development and is insanely sad, but I think the story scheduled to be recorded in volume 2 has more brightness than volume 1 as long as you read a single episode, so it's an interesting development and is easy to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

描き下ろし漫画もよいです♦

The comics drawn down are good too ♦

描き下ろし漫画読んだ後、表紙イラスト見ると二人の身長差に目が釘付けでドキドキしちゃいます? すごく良かったので、単話のみ読んでる人も単行本の描き下ろし漫画読んでみてほしいです！

After reading the comic you've drawn down, when you look at the cover illustration, your eyes are glued to the height difference between the two and you're excited? It was really good, so I want people who only read single stories to read comics drawn from the book!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

本編で涙、描き下ろし話でまた涙?

tears in the main story, tears again in the story drawn down?

綺麗で性格も良さそうなのに、養子だったり身長コンプレックスだったりで自己肯定感低めな主人公。私好みの謙虚なヒロインだけど、課せられた運命があんまりにも可哀想すぎて涙、涙? いつか幸せになってくれることを信じて最後まで読み続けようと思います！描下ろし漫画もボリュームたっぷりで良かったです❤

Even though she is pretty and seems to have a good personality, the main character has a low sense of self-affirmation due to being adopted and having a height complex. she's my favorite humble heroine, but the fate she was imposed on her was so pitiful, tears, tears? I believe that one day they will be happy and I will keep reading until the end! I'm glad that the comics I drew also had plenty of volume ❤

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない… 切なすぎる

sad... too sad

This review contains spoilers. 婚約者？？最低? まぢ無いわ?義妹もなに？まだ1巻ではヒロインが生贄になった後の残った家族達がどうなったのか明らかになっていないが、現に元婚約者と義妹の息子がヒロインの前に現れたってことはくっついて子供まで作っていたということ。しかもヒロインの事をちゃんと説明している様子もなくとにかく失礼極まりない態度。お前が生きているのもヒロインを犠牲にしてのこのこくっついたお前の親からだろ？ヒロインに感謝してもいきなり魔女扱いなんてあり得ない。どんな育て方をアイツらはしたのか？とにかく自分勝手なヒロインの元義理の家族と婚約者に腹が立つ始まり。しかも、偽善者っぽいのが余計に腹立つ。ヒロインを虐めまくっているような家族の方がまだ普通に理解できる。めちゃくちゃ感情移入してしまうストーリーの始まり方にハマってしまいました。今後どのような展開になるのか楽しみ。とにかく幸せになって欲しい

This review contains spoilers. fiancé?? the lowest? that's not serious, is it? What's my sister-in-law too? It's still unclear what happened to the families left after the heroine was sacrificed in volume 1, but in fact, the fact that her former fiancé and sister-in-law's son appeared in front of the heroine means they stuck together and even made children. Moreover, she didn't seem to be properly explaining the heroine, and her attitude was extremely rude anyway. You're still alive because of your parents who stuck together at the expense of your heroine, right? Even if you thank the heroine, it's impossible for her to suddenly be treated like a witch. How did they raise them? Anyway, it's the beginning of getting angry with the selfish heroine's former in-laws and fiancé. What's more, the fact that they seem like hypocrites is extra infuriating. I can still understand the family that bullies the heroine a lot. I'm addicted to the way the story starts, which makes me feel so empathic. I'm looking forward to seeing what developments will take place in the future. Anyway, I want them to be happy

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

1巻は序盤。2巻以降は飛躍的に面白くなる

Volume 1 is the beginning. Volume 2 and onwards will be dramatically more interesting!

コミック単話と原作小説で内容先取りしてるので、今後の面白さは確約できるのですが、1巻の内容だけ見ると果てしなくシリアスで悲しいですね。。。初っ端から地面にたたきつけられた感が凄い。ただしこの反動で今後の展開がますます面白く感じられるはず！！自分は原作推しだけれど、高い画力のおかげですんなり物語に入り込めるのが良く、コミックの方もすっかりハマりました。

It preempts the content with single comic episodes and the original novel, so I can guarantee that the future will be interesting, but if you only look at the contents of volume 1, it's endlessly serious and sad... The feeling of being knocked to the ground from the beginning is amazing. However, future developments should feel more and more interesting due to this reaction!! I recommend the original story, but thanks to my high drawing ability, I was able to easily get into the story, and the comics were completely addicted to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 22, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない！！続きが待ち遠しい

that's sad!! I can't wait for the continuation

コミカライズ単話→原作ラノベ3巻→コミックス1巻の順で読みました。コミックではまるっとカットされてる原作シーンがあり惜しいなと思いつつも、漫画としてはカットしたおかげでテンポ良くまとまってると思います。シリアスストーリーの漫画は絵が上手くないとしらけるため、綺麗な絵を描かれる漫画家さんで満足です。コミックス1巻は序盤だし辛い始まりのお話なので、早く2巻が読みたいですね。

I read it in the order of Comicalize Single Episode → Original Light Novel Volume 3 → Comics Volume 1. While I think it's a pity that the original scene was completely cut in the comic, I think it's organized at a good tempo thanks to cutting it as a comic. I'm satisfied with manga artists who can draw beautiful pictures because they don't draw comics with serious stories. Volume 1 of the comic starts at the beginning and is a story about a painful beginning, so I want to read volume 2 as soon as possible.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

キャラデザが好み

I like character designs

全体的に絵が見やすいキレイさでヒット。各キャラのデザインとか表情も好き。単話版読んでたけど、こっちは書き下ろし目当てで買った。作画コスト高くて大変そうな主人公の異界衣装、お洒落で素敵。ストーリーはまだ始まったばかりか。主人公これまで散々犠牲になってきた分、幸せになってくれ！！

Overall, it was a hit with how beautiful the picture was easy to see. I also like the designs and expressions of each character. I was reading the single story version, but I bought this one just to write it down. The main character's otherworldly costume, which is expensive to draw and seems difficult, is stylish and wonderful. Has the story just begun? The main character has sacrificed a lot so far, so be happy!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

漫画単行本1巻は、原作小説1巻前半の内容

Manga volume 1 is the content of the first half of volume 1 of the original novel

コミカライズ1巻 (単話1～4話 + 書下ろし漫画と小説) はおそらくこの作品の最もしんどいフェーズなので、何度読んでも泣いてしまう。。でも絵のきれいさのおかげで多少しんどさ和らいでる感あるし、何より主人公の美しい泣き顔を見れるのが良い。奈落の底に突き落とされた主人公が23年を経ても若く美しい姿のままで、ある日初恋の人の息子に出会い、どう変わってゆくのか今後に期待です！

Volume 1 of Comicalize (single episodes 1 to 4 + written comics and novels) is probably the hardest phase of this work, so I cry no matter how many times I read it... But thanks to the beauty of the picture, there is a feeling that the situation has been relieved a little bit, and above all, it's nice to be able to see the main character's beautiful crying face. The main character, who was thrown into the abyss, remains young and beautiful even after 23 years, and one day he meets the son of his first love, and I'm looking forward to seeing how that will change in the future!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

描き下ろし漫画と小説付の単行本は良コスパ

Books with drawn comics and novels are good cost effective

一つだけ不満があるとしたら、表紙は単話のイラストの方が惹かれるなー。微妙な違いだけど、あっちの絵の方が課金したくなる魅力があるというか。単話と単行本でわざと画風変えてると思うし仕方ないけど。それ以外は単行本、全部良かった！

If I had one complaint, I'd be more attracted to the single-story illustrations on the cover. It's a subtle difference, but I think that picture over there has an appeal that makes you want to pay for it. I think they're deliberately changing the style of painting between the single story and the single book, and I can't help it. Other than that, the books were all good!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 12, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

描き下ろし漫画が良く、単行本買って満足

The comics I've drawn are good, and I'm satisfied with buying the book

This review contains spoilers. 主人公、何であんな男にこだわってたの〜！？という疑問に応えるかのような描き下ろし漫画のストーリーが良かったです。見初めてきた数ある男達のたった一事例とはいえ、あんなハズレに遭遇してしまったら、そりゃ初恋の男の方がよく見えて諦められないよね、、しかしその初恋の男に、ある日残酷すぎる仕打ちを受ける訳ですが、、主人公の想い人である男は、主人公の義妹に惚れていて、主人公は「義妹がいなくなったら自分が彼と結ばれるかも」と思ってしまう。しかしその彼に、義妹の身代わりを頼まれてしまい、主人公はここで断っても自分は幸せになれないと思わされたのだろう。あまりにやり切れない。。実子もいる貴族家庭の養子で自己肯定感が低く、姉妹の姉育ちで男慣れしていない主人公だからこそ、こういう行動を取るんだなって終始納得できました。まさかの初恋の人の息子が登場して、今後どんな展開となるのか？主人公は幸せになれるのか？続きがひたすら気になります。

This review contains spoilers. Why was the main character obsessed with such a man!? I liked the story of the comic drawn as if it were in response to the question. Although it is only one example of many men who have come to see it for the first time, if you run into such a loss, then you can see the man in your first love better and you won't be able to give up... but one day, the man who is the main character's lover is in love with the main character's sister-in-law, and the main character thinks “if my sister-in-law is gone, I might be tied to him.” However, he asked him to take the place of his sister-in-law, and the main character probably made him think that he wouldn't be happy even if he refused here. I can't do it too much.. I was convinced from beginning to end that it was the protagonist who was adopted by an aristocrat family with biological children and had a low sense of self-affirmation, and because he was raised by older sisters and wasn't used to men, he took this kind of action. Unexpectedly, the son of First Love appeared, and what kind of developments will it take place in the future? Can the main character be happy? I'm just curious about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

4.5☆

4.5 ☆

2巻読んだら評価あがりました。複雑なファンタジーとかミステリーが好きで、今のところはラブストーリーが主体なのにすごく好きになりました。原作も読んでみたらラブストーリーには収まらなないしっかりしたファンタジー作品だと思いました。この作品がどういう感じになるのかはまだわからないけど、キャラや作画が好きなのでこの先も読みたいです。キャラの顔が細部までとても美しいし、とても読みやすい。ただ、悲しい、辛い...辛過ぎて。ただただウィステリアが幸せになってほしいと思う。期待してます、完結したら再評価します、2巻までの評価は4.5☆

After reading volume 2, my evaluation went up. I like complicated fantasies and mysteries, and even though love stories are the main focus so far, I've really fallen in love with them. When I read the original story, I thought it was a solid fantasy work that didn't fit into a love story. I still don't know what this work will look like, but I like the characters and drawing, so I want to read it in the future. The characters' faces are very beautiful in every detail, and they are very easy to read. It's just sad, painful... too painful. I just want Wisteria to be happy. I'm looking forward to it, I'll re-evaluate it when it's done, the rating up to volume 2 is 4.5 ☆

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 07, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

切ないが、顔が瓜二つなだけでどうなの！？

It's sad, but how about just having two faces!?

ひでぇ！と思いつつ、例えばさ～、双子ちゃん三つ子ちゃんいるじゃん？みんな顔はそっくりでも性格違うから違う個体じゃん？ときめくかな～？あ～でも見た目そっくりなら当時の気持ち思い出すか～・・・めっちゃﾜｸﾜｸドキドキでしたわ。もう続き即購入したいんだけどさ～・・・よく考えたら連載中・・・我慢するの苦手なんで完結まで待って一気に購入しようと思います。でもきっと待ちきれなくてすぐ買っちゃいそう・・・令和5年春2巻発売ですってよ！！買うなあたし・・・|ω・)

that's awesome! While thinking, for example, there are twins and triplets, right? They all look alike but have different personalities, so they're different individuals, right? I wonder if it's going to be exciting ~? Oh, but if they look just like you, do you remember how I felt back then... it was so freaking exciting. I want to continue and buy it right away... well... if I think about it carefully, it's being serialized... I'm not good at putting up with it, so I think I'll wait until it's complete and buy it all at once. But I'm sure they can't wait and buy it right away... 2 volumes are on sale in the spring of Reiwa 5!! Don't buy it, I... |ω・)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

描き下ろし話あると知り1巻購入

I learned that there are stories drawn down, and I bought 1 volume

単話の方で全て読んでいたけど、描き下ろしの漫画があると知ってこちらも購入。結果買って正解でした。切なくて続きが待ちきれなくて、原作小説も全て制覇 (原作の3巻が更に続きが気になるところで止まっていて、早く続巻ください！と叫びそうになった。でも思い切って読んで良かった) スリリングなバトルあり、ドキドキするシーンありの壮大な原作ストーリーが、この漫画家さんの絵で追えるのは本当に楽しみ。

I read all of the single stories, but when I learned that there were comics drawn, I bought these too. As a result, I bought it and it was the right answer. I'm so sad that I can't wait for the continuation, and I've conquered all of the original novels (volume 3 of the original story stopped at a point where I'm worried about the continuation, so please continue as soon as possible! I almost screamed. (But I'm glad I took the plunge) I'm really excited to be able to follow the epic original story with thrilling battles and exciting scenes with pictures by this manga artist.

Helpful

Reviews for The Person I Loved Asked Me to Die in My Sister's Stead Manga