Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time Manga Reviews (P.24)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良

Good

This review contains spoilers. 色々考えさせられる作品でとてもお気に入りです、、別れから始まるBLなんて読んだことがなかったので新感覚でとても面白いです。ふたりのすれ違う思いに泣きながら読みました、幸せになってくれてほんとにほんとにありがとう、

This review contains spoilers. It's a work that makes me think a lot, and I really like it... I've never read BL that starts with a farewell, so it's very interesting with a new feel. I read it while crying over their passing thoughts, thank you so much for making me happy,

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

そりゃ別れたくないけど別れたくなるよね

Well I don't want to break up but I want to break up

This review contains spoilers. すみません。なんかこちらの作品は、自分も似たような経験をしたのを思い出し、複雑な気持ちになりました。私は桐生よりの人間なので、桐生を擁護してしまうと言うか…ゴメンなさい(>_<)いやいや本当、本当に桐生はダメダメ人間なんです！尽様にもっと感謝せんかい！！ペチンです…ペチンではなく左フックですわ(>_<)！！そんな気持ちで読んでいました…。意味不明ですみません。やっぱり恋愛って愛だけじゃなくて、一緒に生活する上でいかに相手を思い、行動できるかが大切だと思いました。けどそれが平等になるって相当相性が合う人でないとやっぱり不満はたまるしその度に喧嘩を繰り返し成長していくのかな？って思ったり。何が正解とかいいとかはわからないけど、相手を思いやることを忘れてはダメだなって思いました。どうか尽様、一緒にいてあげてください。また新しい2人のスタートに乾杯！とても好きな作品でした(*´∀｀*)

This review contains spoilers. I'm sorry. Somehow, this work made me feel mixed because I remembered that I had a similar experience. I'm more human than Kiryu, so if I say I'll defend Kiryu... sorry (>_<) No, really, Kiryu is really a bad person! Why don't you thank Jinsama even more!! It's pectin... it's not pettin, it's a left hook (>_<)! I was reading it with that feeling... Sorry for the unclear meaning. After all, romance isn't just about love, I thought it was important how we can think and act about the other person in our lives together. But when it comes to equality, if they aren't people who are quite compatible, dissatisfaction will accumulate after all, and fights will grow over and over again each time? That's what I thought. I don't know what is the right answer or what is good, but I thought it was no good to forget to be considerate of the other person. Please stay with them. Cheers to two new starts again! It was a work I really liked (*'∀｀*)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

別れから始まる物語

A story that begins with a break up

This review contains spoilers. それぞれの視点で交互に話が進むので、お互いの切なさがじわりじわりと胸にきます。両方の気持ちを聞いてるけど、２人の問題だから見守るしかないな…とか思ってる２人の共通の友達役になった感覚でした。こういう喧嘩は誰しも経験することで、すごく共感できて、同時に自分の過去を反省しました。そういう反省の気持ちも全部吹き飛ぶほどの素敵なラスト。読み終えて、心がとてもスッキリします。

This review contains spoilers. The story progresses alternately from each point of view, so each other's sadness slowly creeps into my heart. I'm listening to both of their feelings, but it felt like they played the role of mutual friends of two people who thought it was their problem, so I had no choice but to keep an eye on them... Everyone experienced this kind of fight, so I was able to really sympathize with it, and at the same time I reflected on my past. It was such a wonderful end that it blew away all those feelings of remorse. After reading it, my mind feels so refreshed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

つくしに共感して大泣き

Empathize with Tsukushi and cry a lot

This review contains spoilers. 話題になっていたので購読。大いに泣きました。一緒にいても、言葉や態度で伝える大切さを実感する話です。なんとなく、私も世話を焼きがちなので、攻めくんの気持ちにすごく共感してしまって涙が止まりませんでした。世話焼きな美容師のつくし×マイペースな小説家の桐生。付き合って、同棲して４年も経ったカップルの２人ですが冒頭から既に別れていて、お互いにモヤモヤと気持ちが燻ったまま過ごしているところからのスタートです。別れたところからなので、このまままた復縁するんだろうなと想像がつきつつも、なかなか素直になれない２人を見守りながら読んでいくのが凄く胸にきました。特に、自分とつくしが重なる部分が多々あって、桐生のそのマイペースさが好きだったのに、振り回されてばっかりの自分にイライラしちゃったり、もう我慢が限界を迎えてバッサリ別れるって言ったけど未練タラタラで縋ってくれるのを待ってたり、どうして欲しいのか聞かれても自分でもよくわからなかったりするのが凄く共感してしまって、自分のことのように泣きました。今のままじゃダメなのはわかるけど、どうしていいかもわからない。今回、ちゃんとつくしが桐生と距離をとって冷静になれたことがまず良かったかなと思います。ちゃんとお互い好きだから、距離を置いて冷静になって、一緒にいることの尊さを実感できたのが大きいかなと。特に桐生はマイペースなので、自分の中のつくしの存在の大きさが実感できたんじゃないかなと思いました。縋ったりするのはみっともないと思っていた桐生が、「帰ってきて」と言ったのはとても大きい出来事ですよね。お互いに居て当たり前になってしまっていた2人の関係も、今回の一件で少し締まったかなと思うので、また一緒にいる時間が長くなっても感謝や愛情の言葉を忘れずに、ずっと一緒にいて欲しいなと思います。

This review contains spoilers. It was a hot topic, so I subscribed. I cried a lot. It's a story where you realize the importance of communicating with words and attitudes, even when you're together. Somehow, I also tend to take care of them, so I really sympathized with Attack Kun's feelings and couldn't stop crying. Tsukushi, a carefree hairdresser, and Kiryu, a self-paced novelist. They are two couples who have been in a relationship and have been living together for 4 years, but they have already broken up since the beginning, and they are starting from a place where they spend their time feeling fuzzy and full of feelings for each other. It's from where we broke up, so I was really excited to read it while watching over the two people who couldn't get back together easily, even though I could imagine that they would get back together again like this. In particular, there were many parts where I and Tsukushi overlapped, and I really sympathized with Kiryu's self-paced nature, and even though I was frustrated by Kiryu's self-paced nature, I said that my patience had reached its limit and I had a quick break up, and I really sympathized with the fact that I didn't really understand even when asked what I wanted them to do, and I cried like it was my own. I know it's no good as it is, but I don't know what to do. I think it was first of all good that Tsukushi was able to keep a proper distance from Kiryu and calm down this time. We really like each other, so I think it's great that we kept our distance, calmed down, and realized the preciousness of being together. Kiryu in particular is self-paced, so I thought I could feel the magnitude of Tsukushi's presence within me. Kiryu, who thought it was a shame to get angry, said, “Come back,” which is a huge event, isn't it? I think the relationship between the two, which had become commonplace after being with each other, has come to a slight end with this incident, so I want them to stay together the whole time without forgetting words of gratitude and affection even when they have been together for a long time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

まるで映画のような

It's just like a movie

This review contains spoilers. ４年という年月をワールドカップの熱狂と絡めて上質なラブストーリーです。(好きな人の好きな部分が4年も経つとどうして嫌いになってしまうのだろう)と、慣れと甘えにお互いが言葉足らずになって別れてしまうけれども、とても丁寧にひとコマひとコマが描かれていて何度でも読み返しています。言葉にしないと行動しないと終わってしまう事はたくさんあるなと、桐生が尽が教えてくれました。

This review contains spoilers. It's a high quality love story that combines four years with the enthusiasm of the World Cup. (I wonder why they don't like the part of someone you like after 4 years), and they break up because they get used to it and run out of words, yet each frame is drawn very carefully, and I reread it over and over again. Kiryu Ganjin taught me that there are many things that will end if you don't put them into words or don't act.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

言葉で言えない受けが良い。

Unspeakable reception is good.

This review contains spoilers. と言いましたが、現実欲しいのは言葉ですよね笑。この2人は言葉足らずさと思いやりの行き違いで別れてしまうんですが、そこから「戻ってきて」と言えない受けのやり方が幼すぎてかわいい笑。本当にその言葉足らずさが原因なんだよって教えてあげたくなるんですが、言葉足らずなのは攻めもなんですよねえ。とにかくもどかしい2人なんですけど、言葉足らずなりに頑張る受けが可愛いですし、最後きちんと言語化して終わりに向かおうとする2人も切ないですが愛おしいです。可愛い切ない愛おしいと感情が揺すられる作品で最後まで飽きずに読むことが出来ました。結末は自分の目で確かめて欲しい作品です！

This review contains spoilers. I said, but what I really want is words lol. These two broke up due to lack of words and misunderstanding, but their way of receiving them without being able to say “come back” from there is so childish and cute lol. It really makes me want to tell them that lack of words is the cause, but lack of words is also offensive, isn't it? Anyway, they are two frustrating people, but the reception of trying so hard without enough words is cute, and the two people who try to properly verbalize at the end and make it to the end are also sad but adorable. It's a cute, sad, adorable, and emotionally shaking work, and I was able to read it until the end without getting tired of it. I want you to see the ending with your own eyes!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

二人の関係がよい

The relationship between the two is good

付き合ってすれ違いの生活からのスタート。互いを大切に思う気持ちがじんわり伝わってきました。これからの平凡な何でもない日常も描いて欲しいです。表紙も素敵です！

Start with a life of dating and passing each other. The feeling that they care about each other slowly came through. I want them to depict everyday life without anything in the future. The cover is nice too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

別れからはじまるって新鮮

It's fresh to start with a break up

This review contains spoilers. 別れからはじまるストーリーが斬新。別れの理由も理解できるし、一緒にいたい気持ちにも寄り添える素敵なお話でした。

This review contains spoilers. The story that begins with a break up is novel. I was able to understand the reason for the breakup, and it was a wonderful story that was close to the feeling that we wanted to be together.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

離れてから気づくこと……

Things you notice after leaving...

別れから始まるお話ってどうなるんだろう？と思って読ませて頂きました。結果、めっちゃ良かった♡離れて色々気づく好きだったこと、それがいつの間にか嫌いになっていたなんて。長く一緒に居ると分かってもらえてると勝手に思い込んでしまうけど、会話しなきゃダメ、コミュニケーション大事！って気づけて良かったな(*´ ˘ `*)と。幸せに終わってよかったです。長く一緒に居るからこそ、お互いの気持ち大事にしたいなと私も改めて気づかせて頂ける作品でした。ありがとうございました♡♡

What happens when a story begins with a break up? I thought so I read it. As a result, it was really good ♡ After leaving, I noticed a lot of things I liked, and before I knew it, I didn't like it. If people understand that you've been together for a long time, they'll assume without permission, but you have to have a conversation, communication is important! I'm glad I noticed that (*' `*). I'm glad it ended happily. It was a work that made me realize once again that we want to take care of each other's feelings precisely because we've been together for so long. Thank you very much ♡♡

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

別れから始まる物語

A story that begins with a break up

This review contains spoilers. ためし読みして即購入。小説家の桐生と美容師の尽。桐生のいい加減さがイヤになった尽に別れを切り出されたものの、小説家のくせに言葉で言われないとなぜ別れるのか理解できない桐生。2人で過ごした四年はそれなりに積もっている記憶も多く、2人ともいろいろ思い出して切なくなる。この積もっている記憶の出し方がうまいです。コマ割もうまい。たのしく流れるように気持ちよく最後まで読めました。

This review contains spoilers. Try it out and buy it right away. The novelist Kiryu and the hairdresser's death. Kiryu decided to break up because she didn't like Kiryu's sloppiness, but Kiryu couldn't understand why they broke up unless they were told in words even though they were a novelist. The four years they spent together also have many memories piled up in their own way, and both of them remember so many things that it makes them sad. It's a great way to put out this piled up memory. The frame breaks are good too. I was able to read it comfortably until the end as if it were flowing happily.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

評判がよかったので新刊で買いましたー

It had a good reputation, so I bought the new edition

This review contains spoilers. 4年間同棲していたカップルのお話です。大人向けというか大人なら理解できるかもしれませんね。結果として痴話喧嘩というか雨降って地固まるというか。男女問わず、未婚で同棲してたらこう言う問題はありそうです。結婚してたらこんなすれ違いで即離婚なんてできないですから…。出ていった方も即実家に逃げたし、出て行って即一人暮らしとか始めたら本気でダメだったかもしれませんし、そのぐらいの覚悟で別れろやと。(現実なら身近な実家って羨ましいな。甘えてるなぁと思ってしまう)本気で別れる気があったのかなかったのか、ついつい生活面でのイラつきで別れる！と言ったに過ぎないんだろうな。痴話喧嘩からの強がりなのか、戻らない！となっても結果としてお互いの大切さがわかってまた戻る…そんなお話でした。きちんとお話としてできていて、大人に好かれる内容と思います。

This review contains spoilers. This is a story about a couple who lived together for 4 years. It's for adults, or rather, adults might be able to understand it. As a result, it was a dirty talk fight, or rather the ground solidified when it rained. Regardless of gender, if you are unmarried and live together, there seems to be a problem like this. If you're married, you can't get divorced right away because of this misunderstanding... The people who left immediately fled to their parents' house, and if they left and started living alone right away, it might really have been useless, and they were prepared to break up. (If it were real, I'd envy my parents' house close to me. (It makes me think they're being spoiled) Whether they really wanted to break up or not, they just broke up due to frustration in terms of life! I guess I just said that. I wonder if it's strength from the idiot fight, there's no going back! Even so, as a result, they understood the importance of each other and went back again... it was such a story. It's properly structured as a story, and I think the content will be liked by adults.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良作です

It's a good work

すごくよかったです。ストーリーが感情移入しやすく何度かうるっとなりました。リアリティもあってよかった。

It was really nice. The story was easy to empathize with, and I was excited a few times. I'm glad it's realistic too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良きカプもたまには、ね。

Good caps are good once in a while, don't you think?

長いお付き合いをしていると気持ちがすれ違う事があります。それをとても上手く切なくでもとても優しく描かれた作品だったと思います。言葉に出さなきゃわからない事ってたくさんありますからね。こういう作品の最後はほんとハピエンだと安堵できますね。

If you've been in a relationship for a long time, there are times when your feelings get mixed up. I think it was a work that was drawn very well and very gently, even though it was sad. That's because there are a lot of things you don't understand until you put them into words. I'm relieved that the end of this kind of work is really a happy one.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

すごく良かった！

That was really good!

お薦めされたから読んでみたら期待以上に良かったです！長く一緒に暮らしていると、口に出さなくてもわかるよね、みたいな良い意味でも悪い意味でも甘えとか慣れとか出てくる。そんな2人の関係性がよくわかって共感しました！

It was recommended, so when I read it, it was better than I expected! If you've been living together for a long time, things like indulgence and getting used to it come up in a good or bad sense, like you can understand it without saying it. I really understood the relationship between these two people and I sympathized with it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

これはおもしろい

This is interesting

まず納得いくほどの２人の葛藤がきちんと描かれてます。ラストは、ページ都合のご都合主義がよくあるパターンなんですが、この作品にはないといえます。不思議なほど２人の流れが伝わってきました。心に響いた久々の作品です。

First of all, the conflict between the two, which is quite convincing, is properly depicted. The last one is a pattern where the principle of page convenience is common, but it can be said that this work doesn't have it. Strangely enough, the flow of the two was conveyed. This is my first work in a long time that has touched my heart.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

心に沁みる二人

Two people who sink into my heart

別れから始まる衝撃作。当たり前のように隣にいた恋人との関係が、綻び、絡まり、解け……彼らにとっての日常/非日常のなかで引き出される二人のさまざまな表情に胸がぎゅっと締めつけられました。ぜひ恋人だったふたりの行く末を見届けてください！

A shocking film that begins with a break up. The relationship with the lover who was next to them as a matter of course broke down, entangled, unraveled... My heart was tightened by the various expressions of the two brought out in their everyday life/extraordinary circumstances. Please take a look at the fate of these two lovers!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

初めて

first time

This review contains spoilers. 泣きながらえっちシーンみたの初めてです。別れから始まる恋。素敵です。失って気づくことってやはりありますよね。二人がずっとこんな風にこれから先も一緒にいることを心から願っています。

This review contains spoilers. This is the first time I've seen that scene while crying. Love begins with a break up. It's wonderful. After all, there are things you notice when you lose it, don't you think? I sincerely hope that the two of them will stay together like this for a long time to come.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

わかる

understand

This review contains spoilers. 同じような経験があるのでものすごく感情移入してしまいました(笑)長く一緒にいるからこそ、お互いへの配慮が足りなくなってしまうんですよね。一度離れて、自分の事を見つめ直し、相手を想い考えることが出来て本当に良かったです。途中胸が締め付けられる想いでした。一度離れていなかったから、きっと桐生はいつまでも変わらなかったでしょう。また4年後に同じような事が起きても、また同じようにお互いを見つめ直してくっついてくれると信じています。修正が甘くてエロシーンが少なくても満足できました。受け攻めが思ってたのと逆だったのも自分的には最高でした〜！面白かったです!!!!

This review contains spoilers. We had a similar experience, so we empathized so much (laughs) It's precisely because we've been together for so long that we don't have enough consideration for each other. It was really nice to be able to leave once, look back at myself, and think about the other person. It was a feeling that tightened my heart along the way. We haven't left once, so I'm sure Kiryu hasn't changed forever. Also, even if something similar happens in 4 years, I believe they will look back at each other in the same way and stick together again. I was satisfied even though the correction was poor and there were few erotic scenes. The fact that the attack was the opposite of what I had thought was great for me! That was interesting!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

同棲あるあるな話なのでBLじゃなくても成立します。長く一緒にいるとだんだんトキメキだけじゃなくなっていくよね

It's a story about cohabitation, so it's possible even if it's not BL. If you stay together for a long time, it's not just about getting excited, right

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

別れから始まる物語

A story that begins with a break up

This review contains spoilers. 知り合いのお勧めで読んだけど、さすがにめちゃくちゃよかったです…。最後の「おかえり」がどうしようもなく大好き。好きすぎ！

This review contains spoilers. I read it on the recommendation of an acquaintance, and it was really good... I can't help but love “Welcome Home” at the end. I like it too much!

Helpful

Reviews for Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time Manga