Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time Manga Reviews (P.25)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

かうべき！

You should save it!

This review contains spoilers. めちゃめちゃよかった。2人でいるのに一人な感じがするのが本当に一番つらいんですよね、その二人の視点からの話すべてが満点、最高！

This review contains spoilers. It was really, really good. Feeling alone even though there are 2 people is really the hardest part, isn't it? All of the stories from their perspectives are perfect, great!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

別れからはじまるストーリー

A story that begins with a break up

4年付き合って同棲してきた桐生（とうい）と尽（つくし）が別れてからのリスタートストーリー。日頃のちょっとしたすれ違い、相手へのもやもや…何年も一緒にいると、馴れ合いで日々積み重なる歪み。離れてみて、気付くこと、残るもの。きっと誰もが共感できる、人間味ある2人の感情。桐生側、尽側それぞれの葛藤や気付きが、これまで2人が一緒に過ごした思い出を織り交ぜながらとてもリアルに描かれて、着地点へと向かっていきます。サッカーの試合でのロスタイムと、2人のロスタイムが重なるところ、口にするのが苦手な桐生が素直な言葉を口にするところは胸熱でした。性別関係なく、人と人とが理解し合う、一緒に生活することの難しさ。言葉にすること、相手のことを慮ることの大切さ。自分のことも思わず振り返ってしまう…そんな沁みいる読後の余韻タイムになりました。

This is a restart story after Kiryu (Toi) and Zane (Tsukushi), who have been dating for 4 years and have been living together, break up. Slight daily misunderstandings, haze towards your partner... Distortions that accumulate day by day due to familiarity when you've been together for years. What you notice when you walk away is something that remains. I'm sure everyone can sympathize with these two human feelings. The conflicts and realizations on Kiryu side and the other side are depicted very realistically while interlacing memories of the two of them spending time together until now, and they move towards the landing point. When the lost time at the soccer game overlapped with the lost time between the two, it was heartbreaking that Kiryu, who is not good at speaking, utters straightforward words. Regardless of gender, it is difficult for people to understand each other and live together. The importance of putting it into words and being considerate of the other person. I can't help but look back on myself... it was such a refreshing afterglow time after reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

よかったね

That was great

まぁ、こういった状況は男同士じゃなくても男女CPでもありえると思います。所詮他人だから嫌なとこもあるよね。とりあえずハピエンでよかった。絵がほんわかしてるけど、エチシーンはリアル！薄消しー。あと、タチネコが思ってたのと逆だったw攻めが美容師っていうのもあって、ほんわかだけどオシャレな雰囲気でしたー。

Well, I think this kind of situation is possible not between men but also between male and female CPs. After all, I'm a stranger, so there are things I don't like. Anyway, I'm glad it was Happien. The picture is really fuzzy, but the ethi scene is real! faintly erased. Also, the double attack, which was the opposite of what Tachineko thought, was called a hairdresser, so it was a warm yet stylish atmosphere.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

感動

touching

別れから始まるストーリーでなかなか斬新で面白かったし凄く考えさせられる内容だった?何回か読み返したくなる作品♪♪

It was a story that began with a break up, was quite novel, interesting, and really thought provoking? It's a work you'll want to reread several times ♪♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

もう！もう！もう！笑

already! already! already! lol

This review contains spoilers. 語彙力崩壊。4年って本当リアル。つくしのこんなに好きなのに。こんなに尽くしてるのに、返してもらえない気持ちに感情移入して、とういの言葉にできない気持ちもわかって、、、もう！もう！もう！！！！ってなってしまいました。笑お互いがお互いをある程度理解して、好きで一緒にいるんだけど、小さいことが積み重なり、言葉にする程の事ではないからこそ積み重なり好きが嫌いになる。長く共にいると多分誰もが通る道かと思います。そこの感情を本当によく表現していて胸がギュッとなりました?個人的にBLにはエロを求める傾向にありますが、この作品は基本エロ少なめですが修正甘めで、最後のデートで最後の約束を果たした後の2人の気持ちをぽつりぽつりさせながらが本当にもう！もう！もおおお！っとなりました。笑愛があるのはすばらしい！ストーリー重視、えろ少なめ、だけどリアルで大好きな作品になりました?2回目のレビュー。気持ちを文字に起こすのは大変ですね?でもぜひみんなさんに読んでいただきたい作品です！

This review contains spoilers. vocabulary collapse. 4 years is really real. Even though I love Tsukushi this much. Even though I've done so much, I empathize with the feeling that I can't get it back, and I understand the feeling that I can't put it into words... already! already! already!!! It has become like that. lol we both understand each other to some extent, and we like each other and we're together, but small things pile up, and it's only because it's not enough to put it into words, that our likes pile up and we don't like them. If we stay together for a long time, I think this is probably the path everyone will go through. it really expressed those feelings so well that it made my heart feel tight? Personally, I tend to look for eroticism in BL, but this work is basically less erotic, but revisions are laid-back, and it really makes the two feel after fulfilling their last promise on their last date! already! Wow too! It's amazing now. lol it's great to have love! It's a story focused, less erotic, yet realistic, and your favorite work? Second review. It's hard to put your feelings into words, isn't it? But I definitely want everyone to read it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

別れが始まり

The farewell has begun

This review contains spoilers. 別れから始まり、ハッピーエンドで終わる。良いっ！！なんだかリアルで、男女問わず今もきっとどこかで誰かが同じような恋愛をしてるんだろうなあ……と。感情移入して読んでました。

This review contains spoilers. It starts with a break up and ends with a happy ending. that's good!! It's kind of real, and I'm sure someone somewhere is in a similar relationship even now, regardless of gender... I read it with empathy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ありそうでなかった1冊

1 book that wasn't likely

愛情vs生活という普遍的なテーマですね。それだけにトラブル要因としてサラッと描かれることが多いテーマですが、丁寧でリアルででもしつこくない見事な心理描写で共感と涙まで出させてしまうという。今までありそうでなかったお話だと思いました。作者さまの才能に感嘆します。同業者だったら嫉妬してしまいそう。。。

It's a universal theme of love vs. life, isn't it? For that reason, it is a theme that is often depicted smoothly as a trouble factor, but it is said that it makes people feel sympathy and even tears with brilliant psychological depictions that are careful, realistic, and not clingy. I thought this was an unlikely story until now. I admire the artist's talent. If they were in the same industry, they would be jealous...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けた

I was able to cry

別れの瀬戸際な二人の距離感がリアリティあって、泣ける。人の行動で衝動的にこうなるよね人間って…というだいたいの人にはある感覚が描かれています。エロさはないですが、ガッツリちゃんと本番あります。絵も素晴らしく素敵な作家様を見つけられました

The sense of distance between the two, who are on the brink of parting ways, is realistic, and it makes me cry. It depicts a feeling that most people have, say humans impulsively become like this due to human actions... There's no eroticism, but there is a real performance with Gatsuri. The pictures were wonderful and I was able to find a wonderful artist

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

別れて始まる

It starts after breaking up

はっきり言って好きです。大好きです。小さな事が積み重なって、言いたい事も言えなくなって、聞きたい事も聞けなくなって、もうダメだと思って、別れたのに、別れて気付くことも沢山あって、後悔も沢山して、やっぱりって、思う事が頭から離れなくって。とても共感しました。ホント良い作品です。

Frankly speaking, I like it. I love it. Little things piled up, I couldn't say what I wanted to say, I couldn't listen to what I wanted to hear, I thought it wasn't good anymore, and even though we broke up, there were a lot of things I realized after breaking up, and I had a lot of regrets, and after all, I couldn't get the things I thought out of my head. I really sympathized with you. It's a really good work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 26, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

なんだこれは！！！

what is this!!!

私が今まで通ってなかっただけかもしれませんが、こういう展開のものもあるのか！と勉強になった1冊です。買ってよかった！！

Maybe it's just that I haven't gone there until now, but I wonder if there are things with this kind of development! This is one book I learned. I'm glad I bought it!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 25, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

どおなるの？

is that going to happen?

最初の始まりから、低空飛行だったけど、途中から、すごく、せつなくて、大好きで、お願いっておもうところがたくさんあって！よかった！！

From the beginning, it was a low altitude flight, but along the way, it was really hectic, I loved it, and there were so many things I wanted to do! That was great!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 25, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

切ないけど良かった！

It was sad but good!

別れから始まるもんだから終始切なくて、ハラハラしちゃいました。最後の方の、帰って来て…に涙が出てきた。持論としては一度別れた人とはうまくいかないと思ってしまうのだけど、この2人はうまくいってほしいな。

It started with a break up, so I was sad from beginning to end, and I was so nervous. Tears came out when I came back... towards the end. As a theory, I think it won't go well with someone you've broken up with, but I hope these two get along well.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

買って損なし！類稀なるBL

Buy it without loss! Unrivaled BL

This review contains spoilers. 作品はあくまでBLですが、性別に関係なく、長く付き合うカップルの少しずつすれ違う感じが細かく描かれており、共感と涙なしでは読めない作品です。セリフや表情による心理描写ももちろん素晴らしいのですが、指輪をつけたままの桐生の手に返された合鍵の1コマの描写など、さながら文学作品のクオリティ。最近、似たり寄ったりなBLが多い中、別れから始まる物語というちょっと異色な始まり方。そういう作品が少ないのは、きっと作者の心理描写の力量がもろに試されるせいなんでしょうね…とても読み応えある作品でした！

This review contains spoilers. The work is just BL, but regardless of gender, it depicts in detail the feeling of a couple who have been in a relationship for a long time passing by each other little, and it is a work that cannot be read without empathy and tears. Of course, the psychological depiction with lines and facial expressions is also wonderful, but the quality of a literary work, such as the depiction of one frame of a duplicate key returned to Kiryu's hand with the ring on. Recently, while there are a lot of similar and close BL, it's a slightly different way to start a story that begins with a breakup. I'm sure the reason there aren't many such works is because the author's ability to depict psychology has been put to the test... it was a very readable work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

別れは終わりじゃない?!

Isn't the break up over?!

両想いの先の素敵なお話。尽と桐生どちらの心情も描かれていて、どっちにも感情移入できるから2人を応援したくなる！ロスタイムという「猶予時間」に何をするかが大事と思わせてくれた。尽の「名は体を表す」だけかと思ったら、プレールが仏語で「つくしんぼう」だった(笑)他にも気付いていない意図があるのでは?!と何回も読みたくなる作品です♪

It's a wonderful story about where both feelings lie ahead. The feelings of both Jin and Kiryu are depicted, and being able to empathize with either one makes me want to cheer for them! It made me think that what to do during the “grace period” called lost time is important. If you think it's just that “the name represents the body,” Plère was “tsukushinbou” in French (lol), maybe there are other intentions you haven't noticed?! It's a work that makes you want to read it over and over again ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良作‼︎

Good work ‼ ︎

めっっっっちゃ良かったです！！！最初から最後まで、すごく共感できるというか、あー、こういうことあるよなぁって感じる、すごく現実味のあるストーリーでした。ひとつも、ん？となる部分がなくて、読んでいてすごく心地良かったです。心に沁みました。はじめての作者さんでしたが、他の作品も読んでみたくなりました。

that was really good!!! From beginning to end, it was a very realistic story that I could really sympathize with, or rather, I feel like this kind of thing exists. not even one, huh? There was no such part, and it was really comfortable to read. It sank into my heart. It was my first time as an author, and it made me want to read other works as well.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

愛しさとせつなさと…

loveliness and stubbornness...

本当は大好きで大切な相手を、どうやって大切にすればいいのかわからなくなってしまった二人の選ぶ言葉や不器用な振舞いがやるせない。切なさの矢が胸にｷﾞｭﾝｷﾞｭﾝ突き刺さるのがだんだん快感になってきて、もういっそこのまま別れちゃってくれ！！と思ったくらい。なんでこんなリアルに、丁寧に細やかに描けるんだろう？何度も読み返しながら大切に手元に置きたい一冊。

I can't do with the words and clumsy behavior chosen by two people who don't know how to cherish someone they really love and are important to them. The arrow of sadness pierced my chest gradually became a pleasure, so let's just break up like this!! That's about what I thought. Why is it possible to draw so realistically, carefully and in detail? A book I want to keep on hand with care while rereading it over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

よかったです

I'm glad

よかったです。歯がゆさや戸惑い、ぐるぐると巡る捨てきれない想い、いろんな感情が切ないながらもキレイな流れになっていて、終盤の桐生の絞り出すようなセリフにぐっときました。先生の今までの作品とはちょっと雰囲気が違う感じがしましたが、とってもよかったです。絵も素敵でしたし、すでに何回か読み返しています。次も楽しみにしています。

That was great. My teeth were itchy and confused, the feelings that went round and round, and all kinds of emotions flowed in a sad yet beautiful manner, and I was really impressed by the lines that squeezed out Kiryu at the end. I felt that the atmosphere was slightly different from the teacher's previous works, but it was really nice. The picture was wonderful, and I've already reread it a few times. I'm looking forward to the next one.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

、

,

表題作のみ205pでした！”“別れてから始まる物語“”とっても素敵でした・・・2人の気持ちの動き方や、表情一つまで繊細に丁寧に描かれていて、映画を観たようなそんな気分になりました。なんと感想を述べたらいいのか、分からないほど本当に素敵な作品です。完結になってないので、続きが出ることを期待しながら、何度も読み返したいと思います。

Only the title work was 205p!” “The Story That Begins After Breaking Up “” was so wonderful... it delicately and carefully depicts the way the feelings of the two people move and even one facial expression, and it made me feel like I was watching a movie. It's such a wonderful work that I don't know how to express my impressions. It's not complete, so I'd like to reread it over and over again, hoping that more will come out.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

別れから始まる物語

A story that begins with a break up

主人公の心情がよく伝わってきます。終わりから始まる物語でシリアスで受けの子が諦めずに頑張る姿が切ないです。もっと素直に一言が言えればいいのに。リアルな恋愛に近いのかもしれません。

The main character's feelings are conveyed very well. It's a story that begins at the end, and it's sad to see the serious, receptive child doing his best without giving up. I wish I could say one word more honestly. Maybe it's close to a real love affair.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

めっちゃリアル

So real

This review contains spoilers. 長い間付き合ってるとお互いいい意味でも悪い意味でも気を使う部分が少なくなって、好きなところも嫌いなところで上書きされてしまったりして、結局別れてしまうなんてこと性別カップル限らずあると思うんだけど、描写がとてもリアルでした。前半のリアルさがあったからこそ、最後のデートにいこう、って提案が胸に突き刺さった。ハッピーエンドだってわかっているものの、約束したデートが最後だなんてーーって切なくなった。最後のデートからの、言葉なく行為が始まるのも本能的に相手を求めてる感が出てとても良かったし、受けの先生が気持ちを伝えてくれたのも良かった。ヨリが戻ってからの2人の生活をもっと読みたかったーーーー！！

This review contains spoilers. I think it's not limited to gender couples that when they've been in a relationship for a long time, there are fewer parts that they care about in both good and bad ways, and things they like are overwritten by places they don't like, and eventually break up, but the depiction was very realistic. It was precisely because of the realism of the first half that the suggestion to go on a final date stuck in my heart. I know it's a happy ending, but it made me sad that the promised date was the last one. Beginning the act without words from the last date was also very nice because it instinctively felt like they were looking for a partner, and it was also nice that Kakeru's teacher conveyed my feelings. I wanted to read more about the lives of the two since Yori came back!!

Helpful

Reviews for Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time Manga