My Beautiful Man Manga Reviews (P.9)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

本当に美しい♦

It's really beautiful ♦

This review contains spoilers. 原作にどハマりし、実写化のドラマも映画もハマり、そして今度はこのコミカライズ…。もちろん原作は素晴らしいし、実写化にも感動したが、この漫画にもめちゃくちゃ感動している。美しい、とにかく美しいし、世界観が完璧。吃音のある平良(ひら)×クラスのキング清居(きよい)。平良はとにかくキモいし(ファンにとってこれは褒め言葉)、清居はとにかく美しいし実はピュアなんだよなぁ。ツンデレがすごいんだからwww。まだ3巻で、このあと何が起きるか知ってるのに次巻が待ち遠しい作品。

This review contains spoilers. I'm addicted to the original story, I'm addicted to both live-action dramas and movies, and now this comicalization... Of course, the original story is wonderful, and I was moved by the live-action adaptation, but I'm also insanely moved by this comic. It's beautiful, just beautiful, and the view of the world is perfect. Taira (Hira) x Class King Kiyoi (Kiyoshi) stutters. Taira is just gross (this is a compliment for fans), and Kiyoi is just beautiful and actually pure. Tsundere is amazing lol lol. It's still 3 volumes, and even though I know what's going to happen after this, I can't wait for the next volume.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

超絶おすすめします。5巻最高です

I recommend it transcendently. Volume 5 is the best

This review contains spoilers. 私が最初にこの作品を知ったのはまさにドラマ化された時に番宣でテレビに出てる清居役の子が目にとまり、なんだこの綺麗な男の子はと思ったのがきっかけでした。あんまり誰かを見てカッコイイ！ってならない私がなんとなしにネットに今すごくカッコイイ子を見た。顔が綺麗なのに筋肉あるしめっちゃタイプって書き込んだらそれに対してそんなあなたに美しい彼をぜひ見てほしいって言われ、なんだそれと検索したらもうほぼ終わってるドラマで、そこから気になりYouTubeで検索して見たり(その時にもう惚れ惚れ)そこからまず小説にいきつき全巻読みました。それがもうおもしろくておもしろくて…！！この二人の奇妙な関係というか両想いなのに絶対的片想いみたいな関係が尊すぎて凪良ゆう先生を私は崇拝してます。基本的にもう内容知ってたら漫画はもういいかな小説あるしなと普段なら絶対買わない私ですが、何度も何度も私の目に入ってくる漫画、美しい彼。負けました。買いました。今のところ2巻のみですが、小説の世界観をそのままに繰り広げられていくストーリーがおもしろくておもしろくて、読んでる間楽しくて仕方ありません。目に焼き付くほどしっかり内容を覚えていますがそれでもおもしろい！ていうかこの二人をもう一度美しい絵で見られるのが幸せです。読めば読むほどおもしろくなっていくので未読の方はぜひ最後まで読んで下さい。本当におすすめします。ちなみに私はドラマは見れませんでしたが、映画化されたことを知り、一人で映画なんて絶対ありえないと思う私をなんと人生初の一人映画に出向かせた作品です。笑　結果最高すぎました。追記、5巻、最高です。みんな早く5巻読んで‼︎

This review contains spoilers. I first learned about this film when it was made into a drama when the child in the role of Kiyoi, who appeared on TV in Banzen, caught my eye, and I thought he was this pretty boy. It's so cool to see someone! Why did I see a really cool kid on the internet right now. When I wrote that he has a beautiful face but has muscles, and in response, I was told that I wanted you to watch him so beautiful, and when I searched for it, it was a drama that was almost over, and I was curious from there and searched and watched it on YouTube (I was already in love at that time), and from there, I first went to the novel and read the whole volume. That was already so funny and so interesting...!! I adore Nagi Ryoyu sensei because the strange relationship between these two people, or rather the relationship that seems like an absolute unrequited love even though they have both feelings, is so precious. Basically, if I knew the content, I wonder if comics would be good enough, and I wouldn't usually buy them, but comics that catch my eye over and over again are beautiful. I lost. I bought it. There are only 2 volumes so far, but the story that unfolds in the same way the world view of the novel is interesting and interesting, and I can't help but enjoy it while I read it. I remember the content so well that it burns into my eyes, but it's still interesting! I mean, I'm happy to be able to see these two in beautiful pictures once again. The more you read, the more interesting it becomes, so if you haven't read it, be sure to read it until the end. I really recommend it. Incidentally, I wasn't able to watch the drama, but I learned that it was made into a movie, and it made me go to a one-person film for the first time in my life because I think it's absolutely impossible to do a movie alone. lol the results were too great. Additional notes, volume 5, is awesome. Everyone read volume 5 as soon as possible ‼ ︎

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

小説版と読み比べてはいちいち感心&感動

I am impressed and moved every time I read and compare it with the novel version

This review contains spoilers. 小説版も読みましたが、セリフだけ、描写だけの場面を、こんな風に描くのか...‼︎といちいち感動！特に2人だけで教室にいるあのシーン‼︎...などなど。平良よ、そんな風にアレするのか‼︎（うぉ〜‼︎）キモ可愛いな‼︎そして清居は凛として美しい（はぁ...）3巻までは平良の視点で描かれ、清居は美しく冷酷に描かれてるけど、原作ですと、ここから先は清居目線も描かれるわけでしょ？そしてキモ平良が恐らくカッコよく描かれていくわけで...えー！えー！どんな風に⁈3巻発売を機に、また小説版も何度も読み返しては想像し、でゅふふ...となってしまいます。。。にしても、タイトル最高。もう、まんま。一文字も、削っても足してもいけない感じ、しませんか。

This review contains spoilers. I also read the novel version, but I wonder if they draw scenes with only lines and only descriptions like this... ‼ ︎ and I'm moved one by one! Especially that scene where there are only 2 people in the classroom ‼ ︎... etc. Taira, are you going to do it like that ‼ ︎ (wow! ‼ ︎) creepy and cute ‼ ︎ and Kiyoi is beautiful (huh...) Up to volume 3 is drawn from Taira's point of view, and Kiyoi is drawn beautifully and ruthlessly, but if it's the original story, Kiyoi's point of view is also drawn from here on out, isn't it? And Kimo Taira is probably being drawn in such a cool way... huh! Eh! After rereading the novel version over and over again when volume 3 of was released, I imagined it, and it ended up... hehehe... Even so, the title is great. That's enough. Doesn't it feel like one letter can't be removed or added?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

3巻！ここからだ！！

Volume 3! it starts here!!

小説と実写版それぞれの良さがありとても良かったですが、やはり漫画も素晴らしい！！！そして3巻！原作でもわたしはこのあたりから一気に引き込まれました！北野先生の作画で読めるなんて幸せです！楽しみに待ちたいと思います♪何年かかっても良いので小説のシリーズ全て漫画化してもらえたとてもとても幸せです。

It was great because the novel and the live-action version each had their merits, but after all, the comics are wonderful too!! And 3 volumes! Even with the original story, I was drawn in all at once from around here! I'm so happy to be able to read it with Kitano sensei's drawings! I'm looking forward to it ♪ It doesn't matter how many years it takes, so I'm very, very happy that all of my novel series were made into comics.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 12, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

オススメ

recommended

小説が元になってるのってけっこう当たりが多いきがします。メディア化にもなってるので、安心して楽しく読めます、何より絵がキレイです。

I feel like there are quite a few hits that it's based on a novel. It's also made into a medium, so you can enjoy reading it with peace of mind, and above all, the pictures are beautiful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

3巻までぜひ！読んでほしい！！！！

Be sure to go until volume 3! I want you to read it!!!!

This review contains spoilers. ふぉぉぉお‼︎4巻、2024年初夏…かぁ〜（泣）そんなに待てない！今すぐ読みたいよ〜‼︎やっとやっっっと動き出したね！（泣）一巻、二巻を使ってじっくり描かれた2人の時間？関係性っていうのかな、それがあるからこそ3巻の清居の言動にギュンってなった‼︎でも平良は相変わらず平良だし、清居も清居なんだけど、口数少ないしプライド高くて自分からは言えないながらも「じゃ、また」とか「打ち上げくる？」に全てが詰まってて作者さん天才か？！ってなりました。キャラの構築がものすごいです！なんだかすごいものに出会った気がします。読んでよかった〜！四巻もぜったい買います！！

This review contains spoilers. Wow ‼ ︎ volume 4, early summer 2024... huh (crying) I can't wait that long! I want to read it right now~ ‼ ︎ it's finally starting to move! (Crying) Time for two people carefully drawn using volumes 1 and 2? I wonder if it's a relationship, and it's because of that that, I was so surprised by Kiyoi's words and actions in volume 3 ‼ ︎ but Taira is still calm, and Kiyoi is also Kiyoi, but even though he has few words and high pride, he can't say “well, see you again” or “launch it?” is everything packed into it and the author is a genius?! That's it now. The character construction is amazing! I feel like I've come across something amazing. I'm glad I read it! I'm definitely going to buy 4 volumes too!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 08, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

小説の世界観

The novel's worldview

作者への敬意を感じる作品。ドラマからの小説からの漫画でしたが、平良や清居の感情の流れが丁寧に描かれていると思います。

A work where I feel respect for the author. It was a comic from a novel from a drama, but I think it carefully depicts the emotional flow of Taira and Kiyoi.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

早く早く！！

fast fast!!

とにかく続きが見たくてたまりません。ドラマ→原作ときて、マンガも、素晴らしいです！北野先生、プレッシャーもあり大変だと思いますが、どうか楽しみにしてますので、次も待ってます！

Anyway, I'm dying to watch the continuation. The drama → the original, and the manga are amazing too! Kitano sensei, I think it will be difficult due to the pressure, but I'm really looking forward to it, so I'm looking forward to the next one!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

3巻

Volume 3

Netflixで同棲してるとこまで見たから、3巻も同棲してるのかと思いきやその前段階でした。Netflixでは平良の子の演技が格段に上がってて良かったな。4巻はいつでるのか…動画もいいけどマンガならではのキレイな絵と少ないセリフの静と動のバランス、清居と平良の独特の雰囲気がすごく好きなので続き楽しみです。

I even watched Where They Live Together on Netflix, so I thought they were living together for 3 volumes, but that was a step before that. I'm glad that Taira no Ko's performance has improved so much on Netflix. When will volume 4 come out... The video is great, but I really like the balance of stillness and movement unique to manga, and the unique atmosphere of Kiyoi and Taira, and the unique atmosphere of Kiyoi and Taira, so I'm looking forward to continuing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

1巻で止めないで！！3巻まで読んで！！

Don't stop at volume 1!! Read up to 3 volumes!

ドラマも原作も見たけれど、やっぱり漫画でしか表現できないものがあって、すごく良いです！！冷たい言葉ばかり吐くけれど、3巻のちょっとしたシーンにきゅんってしましたね♡♡原作も好きだけど、漫画の絵も美麗すぎて好き…

I've watched both the drama and the original story, but after all, there are things that can only be expressed in comics, which is really good!! I just spit out cold words, but I fell in love with a little scene in volume 3 ♡♡ I like the original story too, but the comic pictures are so beautiful that I like them...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絶対3巻まで観て！

Definitely watch up to 3 volumes!

This review contains spoilers. きも。うざい。って言葉が冷たすぎる清居。3巻のちょっとした嫉妬が嬉しく感じました。感想は色々あるけどまた1巻から見に行ってきます。

This review contains spoilers. Kimo. That's annoying. Kiyoi's words are too cold. I was happy to hear a little bit of jealousy in volume 3. I have a lot of impressions, but I'm going to watch it again starting with volume 1.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

最高なんですが、、、✨

It's awesome... ✨

清居の横顔があまりに綺麗すぎる✨凪良ゆう先生の原作を忠実に再現しつつ、漫画にしか出せないディテールを細部にまで表現し、線で、コマ割りで、登場人物の表情で、選び抜かれた言葉たちで紡ぐ物語、、、✨さ、最高です！！ドラマシリーズと違い、清居と平良の身長差と平良のキモさを感じる、素晴らしい作品です！！原作もドラマ、映画シリーズも大好きですが、こちらの漫画も、、、大好きだーっ！！

Kiyoi's profile is too beautiful ✨ A story that faithfully reproduces the original work by Nagi Ryoyu sensei, expresses details that can only be shown in comics down to the smallest detail, and is spun with lines, frame by frame, facial expressions of the characters, and selected words... ✨ well, it's amazing!! Unlike the drama series, it's a wonderful work where you can feel the difference in height between Kiyoi and Taira and the creepiness of Taira!! I love the original story, drama, and movie series, but I also love this comic...!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

清居〜！

Kiyoi~!

寝る前に30分だけって思ってたのにキモ！美し！キモ！美し！の連続に読む手が止まらず朝〜！！！！！今日は早番。でも悔い無し。

I thought it was only 30 minutes before going to bed, but that's gross! beautiful! gross! beautiful! I can't stop reading it continuously in the morning!!!! It's early today. But I have no regrets.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

清居〜

Kiyo~

This review contains spoilers. テレビドラマで放送されていて漫画も気になって購入してみました。少し違ったところもありましたが、それはそれでよかったなと思いました。清居と平良との関係性が少しずつ変わっていく描写がすごく好きです。早く続きが読みたいです。

This review contains spoilers. It was broadcast on TV dramas, and I was curious about comics, so I bought them. There were also things that were slightly different, and I thought that was good. I really like the depiction of Kiyoi's relationship with Taira changing little by little. I want to read more soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

びっくりするほど

Surprisingly

面白かった！ちょっと衝撃受けるほど。出だしで心を掴まれぐいぐい引き摺り込まれた。清居のキング感といい平良の忠誠心といいたまらないな…。清居がもうかっこよすぎて美しすぎてきもくなる平良の気持ちがわかる。平良が自分のことを馬鹿にされても黙ってたのに清居が馬鹿にされた途端に殴ったシーンは最高でした。キングの手に口付けるシーンが神々しくて美しかった。本当に印象に残るシーンばかりで読み応えがあって心を動かされる漫画。続きが気になって仕方ないから小説買います！

That was interesting! I was a little shocked. It grabbed my heart at the start, and I was dragged in so much. I don't like Kiyoi's sense of being king and Taira's loyalty... I understand how Taira feels that Kiyoi is already too cool and so beautiful. The scene where Taira was silent even when he was made a fool of himself but hit him as soon as he was ridiculed was amazing. The scene where the king kisses his hand was divine and beautiful. It's a comic that is easy to read and moves my heart, with only scenes that really leave an impression on me. I'm worried about the continuation and can't help but buy the novel!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ドラマを見て

Watch dramas

ドラマを見てハマり購入しました。絵がとにかくきれいで、内容もすごく好きな作品です。3巻発売が待ち遠しいです。続き楽しみにしています。

I was addicted to watching the drama and bought it. The pictures are absolutely beautiful, and I really like the content. I can't wait for volume 3 to be released. I'm looking forward to the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 22, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

こんなにハマったの久しぶり

It's been a while since I've been this addicted

まず絵が美しい。清居の美しさと気高さ、平良の自己肯定感の低さと清居への圧倒的な愛が紡ぐ物語に一気に引き込まれました。たまらずノベル版も購入！物語の先取りしてますが、コミックもノベルも絶対揃える。おすすめです！

First of all, the picture is beautiful. I was drawn all at once into a story spun by Kiyoi's beauty and nobility, Taira's low sense of self-affirmation, and his overwhelming love for Kiyoi. I also bought the Irresistible Novel Edition! I'm ahead of the story, but I definitely have comics and novels. I recommend it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

よかったです

I'm glad

This review contains spoilers. 心の声が多くて、小説を読んでいるかのようでした。まだ一巻しか読んでいませんが、学校の様子は現実的にありえそうだし、共感できる部分がたくさんありました。

This review contains spoilers. There were so many voices in my heart, it was as if I was reading a novel. I've only read one volume yet, but the state of the school seemed realistic, and there were a lot of parts I could sympathize with.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

やっぱり最高…

After all it's the best...

This review contains spoilers. 小説で読んでて漫画も気になったから読んでみたけどやっぱりよかった…一途な平良とツンデレな清井が最高です…ヤるとめっちゃ素直になる清井が可愛いすぎる…読んでてニヤニヤが止まりませんでしたw最初の方では2人の思い違いがもどかしくって「はやくくっ付けぇーーー！」って叫びたくなりますw

This review contains spoilers. I read it as a novel and I was curious about comics, so I read it, but I'm glad after all... the unwavering Taira and Kiyoi the tsundere are the best... Kiyoi, who is so honest when you do it, is too cute... I couldn't stop smirking while reading lol At the beginning, the two of them made me feel frustrated by their misunderstanding and said, “Stick it together quickly!” it makes me want to scream lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がきれい

The picture is beautiful

本当に画力のある作家さんで、絵がきれいなので特に清居をしっかり美しく描いてくださって本当にうれしいです。

The artist has really good drawing skills, and since his pictures are beautiful, I'm really happy that he drew Kiyoi so well and beautifully.

Helpful

Reviews for My Beautiful Man Manga