My Beautiful Man Manga Reviews (P.18)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

丁寧なコミカライズ

Careful comicalization

小説読了済です。これまでコミカライズは、どうしても急が足で、小説の短縮版というイメージだったけど、こちらの作品に関しては、その逆！かなりゆっくりです。コミカライズ3巻まで一気読みして、続きは小説に戻って読んでしまった。小説の1巻目が終わるまで、あと2冊くらいかかるかも？キヨイくん視点の心の声を早く漫画で見てみたいな

I've read the novel. Until now, comicalize was always hasty, and the image was that it was an abbreviated version of a novel, but the opposite is true for this work! It's pretty slow. I read up to 3 volumes of Comicalize at once, then went back to the novel and read the rest. Maybe it will take about 2 more books until the first volume of the novel is over? I want to see Kokoro's Voice from Kiyoi-kun's point of view in comics as soon as possible

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 25, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

原作が好きなので購入

I like the original, so I bought it

原作は番外編を含め全て読んでいます。原作の挿絵の葛西リカコさんのイメージが大きいため、実写版はあまり観る気にならなかったけど、コミックス版の北野先生は原作挿絵の雰囲気に似ていたので購入。原作ファンの期待を裏切らない内容で良かった。

I've read all of the original stories, including extra editions. The image of Kasai Rikako in the original illustration was large, so I didn't really feel like watching the live-action version, but Kitano sensei from the comic book had a similar atmosphere to the original illustration, so I bought it. I'm glad the content didn't disappoint the expectations of fans of the original story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 23, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが早く読みたい…

I want to read more soon...

完結していないのもあり積本になっていたのをやっと読みました。なにこれ、めちゃめちゃ好き。たしかに攻め？はキモいと言えるのだけど…めっちゃ応援しちゃう、これは沼るね。清居への想い、綺麗、大好き、が終始一貫していて心地いい。早く続きが読みたい！小説は苦手なのでコミカライズの続きを待ってます！

I finally read it because it wasn't complete, so I finally read it because it was packed. What is this, I love it so much. really an attack? I can say it's gross, but... they cheer so much, this is swampy. My feelings for Kiyoi, being beautiful, and loving, are consistent from beginning to end, and it's comfortable. I want to read more soon! I'm not good at novels, so I'm waiting for Comicalization to continue!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

レビューが高評価だったので購入しました。普段読まないタイプのストーリーでしたが面白かったです。おすすめです。

I bought it because the reviews were highly rated. It was a type of story I don't usually read, but it was interesting. I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

最近、知りました

Recently, I found out

最近、このお話を知りました。漫画も是非読みたいです。今朝どちらがウケなのか調べたレベル。ドラマを先に漫画を先に思案中

I recently learned about this story. I definitely want to read comics too. This is the level where I looked up which one was popular this morning. Thinking about dramas first comics first

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

良いです

It's good

小説のことは知らないのですが、高評価で北野先生というので読んでみました。きっと小説もこんな雰囲気なのかなって思いました。ストーリーにキャラが合ってるし、静かなのにどこか危うい雰囲気がね。個人的には好きではない人間の汚い世界だけど、この二人がどうなるのか漫画で追いたいとは思います。

I don't know about novels, but they are highly rated and Kitano-sensei, so I read them. I was wondering if the novel had this kind of atmosphere. The characters fit the story, and even though it's quiet, it has a dangerous atmosphere. It's a dirty world of humans that I personally don't like, but I'd like to follow what happens to these two in comics.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

友達が

A friend

This review contains spoilers. ドラマにハマってる薦めてきた、私は北野先生の絵柄が好みで購入未読でした?普段、溺愛スパダリラブラブか子育てBLが多いので学園カーストは気持ちが左右されるし～と渋ってましたが、読み始めると想像以上に胸が苦しくなるのに先が気になって一気読み、あーー小説も読もうかな、ドラマから映画化もされてるし、アレっ戦略にハマってしまった？！次作も先生の絵柄でどんな表現がされるのか楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. I'm addicted to dramas and have recommended it; I like Kitano-sensei's design, bought it and unread it? Normally, there are a lot of doting spadari love couples or child-rearing BL, so I was reluctant to think that my feelings were influenced by the school caste, but when I started reading it, my heart became more painful than I had imagined, so I was worried about the future, so I read it all at once, and ah, I wonder if I should read novels, and they have also been made into movies from dramas, and I'm addicted to that strategy?! I'm looking forward to seeing what kind of expressions the teacher's designs will bring to the next work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 26, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

コミカライズ

Comicalize

原作が好きでこちらも。原作の雰囲気がしっかりあって、とってもよかったです〜〜やっぱり表情が見えるっていいですね！

I like the original story and this one too. The atmosphere of the original story was perfect, and it was so nice to be able to see facial expressions after all!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ひらくん、がんばれ。

Hira-kun, do your best.

先に原作を読んでいます。ストーリーは最高です。漫画は少し私のイメージと違うと思う絵はあります。でも、読む人によってイメージが違うものなのですから、当たり前なんですよね。セリフやコマ割りは、丁寧、かつ繊細で好きです。大切に描かれているので、ふかーく物語の世界に浸れます。原作、漫画、ドラマとそれぞれの個性はありますが、この「美しい彼」の世界を、できるだけ長く、深く、楽しみたいと思っています。迷ってる人は是非、読んでください。読まず嫌いは損ですよ!

I read the original story first. The story is amazing. There are pictures that I think are slightly different from my image of comics. However, the image differs depending on who reads it, so it's natural. I like the dialogue and frame division because they are polite and delicate. It's carefully drawn, so you can immerse yourself in the world of the story. Each original story, manga, and drama is unique, but I want to enjoy this “beautiful guy” world for as long and as deep as possible. If you are unsure, please read it. If you don't like it without reading it, it's a loss!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

まだまだ序盤

It's still early

思っていた話と全然違いました。まだまだ序盤。これから、どうなっていくのか。評判がいいだけに期待値が高まります。

It was completely different from what I had anticipated. We're still in the early stages. What's going to happen in the future? Expectations increase just because the reputation is good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

原作未読です。

I haven't read the original story.

まだ序盤戦という感じでした。読んでいて辛い場面も多く、読み終えたあとは正直疲れました。でも、続きが気になるので早く読みたいという気持ちもあります。楽しみに待ちます。

It felt like we were still in the early stages. There were a lot of difficult scenes to read, and to be honest, I was tired after I finished reading. However, I'm worried about the continuation, so I also have a feeling that I want to read it quickly. I'm looking forward to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

まだまだ

There's still more

序盤ですよね、、関係がなかなか進まないのでヤキモキしちゃいます。小説で読んだ方がいいかなぁ。でも絵が好きなので漫画で読みたいなぁ

It's the beginning... the relationship isn't progressing easily, so I'm excited. I wonder if I should read it as a novel. But I like pictures, so I want to read them in comics

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

確かに

surely

This review contains spoilers. 美しい清居くん。佇まいが綺麗だしみんなとは一線引いてるようなカーストの上位にいる感じだから主人公が憧れる気持ちも理解できる。今後どうなるのか気になります

This review contains spoilers. Kiyoi-kun is beautiful. The appearance is beautiful, and it feels like they are at a higher rank in the caste where they draw a line with everyone, so I can understand the feelings that the main character admires. I'm curious about what will happen in the future

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

めっちゃ気になる！

I'm really curious!

この作品のことは全く知らず、ライトノベルもドラマ？も、知りません見てません、レビューも見ずに購入しましたが、ここからどう展開していくのかとっても気になります！まだキモい、としか思われてないヒイくん。これからどのようにキヨイとの関係が進んでいくのか楽しみです！！

I don't know anything about this work, and is the light novel also a drama? I don't know, I haven't seen it, I bought it without looking at any reviews, but I'm really curious about how it will unfold from here on out! Hii-kun is still only thought to be gross. I'm looking forward to seeing how the relationship with Kiyoi will progress in the future!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ドラマを見て購入しました。

I watched the drama and bought it.

This review contains spoilers. 友人に勧められてドラマを全部見た後に、漫画の方も気になって購入しました。原作は漫画ではないみたい？ですが、絵が美しくて素晴らしかったです！

This review contains spoilers. I was recommended by a friend and after watching all the dramas, I was also interested in comics, so I bought them. Looks like the original isn't a comic? But the picture was beautiful and amazing!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

まーだまだ序盤

Well, it's still early

小説の世界観が絵にちゃんと反映されている。まだまだ序盤の展開でラブラブさもないけど、小説で内容を知っているだけにこれからの展開に期待大！

The novel's worldview is properly reflected in the picture. It's still early development, and it's not even lovey-dovey, but since I know the story from the novel, I have high expectations for future developments!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

これから

From now on

絵が大好きで購入。まだ序章という感じです。主人公にちょっとイライラしますが、絵が綺麗なので読める。続きが読みたい。

I loved the picture and bought it. It feels like it's still the beginning. I'm a little frustrated with the main character, but the pictures are beautiful, so I can read them. I want to read more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

漫画化！

Cartoonize!

ドラマを見てハマり小説まで全部読みました。コミカライズされたとのことで買いましたが、絵は綺麗です！ただ、このペースだといつまで続くのだろうという感じでした。早く次巻が読みたいです。

I watched dramas and read all the novels I was addicted to. I bought it because it was comicalized, but the picture is beautiful! However, I was wondering how long it would continue at this pace. I want to read the next volume soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 15, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

まだ1巻なので

Since it's still volume 1

無神経な先生や心無い同級生には心底嫌気がさしたし、ヒラくんのじっとりした暗さにも気持ちが沈む感じでしたが、まだ1巻なので。2巻も読もうと思えたのは期待が持てたからだと思う。

I was really disgusted by the insensitive teachers and heartless classmates, and I felt like my feelings sank in the quiet darkness of Hira-kun, but it's still volume 1. I think the reason I decided to read volume 2 was because I had high expectations.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 12, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

初めての「美しい彼」

My first “beautiful boyfriend”

小説やドラマで結構目にしたタイトルがコミカライズになったと言うので表紙をみたらイメージに近い「彼」がいたので読んで見ました。続きが楽しみです。

It is said that titles I've seen quite a bit in novels and dramas have been comicalized, so when I looked at the cover, there was a “he” close to my image, so I read and watched it. I'm looking forward to the continuation.

Helpful

Reviews for My Beautiful Man Manga