My Beautiful Man Manga Reviews (P.8)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

めっっっっっちゃ良かった！

that was really good!

This review contains spoilers. 絵がきれいでずっと気になっていたけれど、レビューが原作かドラマファンの方ばかりだったので、なんだか購入ね至らず…。クーポンで試しに1巻だけ購入したら、続きが気になりすぎて3巻まで購入、一気に読んでしまいました！ほんと買って良かった！！ドラマも小説とみたことないですが、とにかく終始清居がきれいで…、主役はほんとキモいのですが、段々主役の清居すき！綺麗！が伝染して来た気がします。4巻の予告で清居が今までと違う感じになっていて、めちゃめちゃ気になる！2024年初夏発売と書いてあったので、首をながーくながーーーくして待ってます！4巻配信日、速攻拝読！初の清居目線。めっっっっちゃ良かった～o(*ﾟ∀ﾟ*)o大丈夫だよ、清居！って励ましたくなった。いや、心の中でめっちゃ励ました。平良、分かれよー。ってめっちゃうずうずした。5巻の予告すごいきになる。やっと少し進展するのかな？清居がますます可愛くなりそうで楽しみすぎる！

This review contains spoilers. The picture was beautiful and I've always been interested in it, but since the reviews were mostly based on the original story or drama fans, I somehow couldn't buy it... I bought only 1 volume as a trial with a coupon, then I was so worried about the continuation that I bought up to 3 volumes and read them all at once! I'm really glad I bought it!! I've never seen a drama as a novel, but anyway, Kiyoi is beautiful from beginning to end... and the leading role is really creepy, but gradually I like Kiyoi, the leading role! beautiful! I have a feeling that it has become infected. According to the 4-volume preview, Kiyoi feels different from what it used to be, and I'm really curious! It said it would go on sale in early summer 2024, so I've been waiting a long time! Read volume 4 as soon as possible on release date! First Kiyoi's perspective. That was so good ~ o (**) o it's fine, Kiyoi! It made me want to encourage it. No, I worked really hard in my heart. Taira, split up. I was so excited. The preview for volume 5 is amazing. Will we finally make some progress? Kiyoi seems to be getting cuter and I'm having so much fun!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが楽しみです

I'm looking forward to the continuation

互いに接点がないような二人の人物によって繰り広げられるストーリーも良く、絵も全体的な雰囲気によく合って良かったです。次回も楽しみにしています。

The story unfolds between two people who don't seem to have any contact with each other, and I'm glad that the picture fits the overall atmosphere well. I'm looking forward to next time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 15, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

早く続きが見たい！

I want to see the continuation soon!

小説も実写も両方見ていて漫画でも見たいなぁと思っていたので良かったです！小説だと表情が見えないので漫画は色々な表情が見れて小説とは違う楽しさがありました！漫画は小説や実写に比べたら進みが遅いので長く楽しめそうだしまた楽しみが増えて良かったです！続き楽しみに待ってます！

I'm glad I watched both the novel and the live action and wanted to watch comics too! I can't see facial expressions in novels, so I was able to see various expressions in comics, and it was fun that was different from novels! Manga progresses slowly compared to novels and live action, so it seems like you can enjoy it for a long time, and I'm glad the fun has increased again! I'm looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 09, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

一気読みしちゃった

I read it all at once

思いがけず見かけたドラマ版のCMに惹かれ読んでみることに。原作を一気読みした後ドラマにまで手を出し、徹夜が続いたけど決して後悔はありません。

I was drawn to a commercial for the drama version I saw unexpectedly and decided to read it. After reading the original story all at once, I even dabbled in dramas, and stayed up all night, but I have absolutely no regrets.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 29, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

最高

highest

美しい…美しすぎる…そして語彙力が消える。早くも続きが読みたくてたまりません。初夏が待ち遠しいです。

It's beautiful... too beautiful... and my vocabulary disappears. I'm dying to read the continuation as soon as possible. I can't wait for early summer.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 24, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

早く続きを

Continue quickly

盲信的な愛欲を向ける陰キャ男子。その愛にいつの間にか囚われる孤高の貴公子然とした男子。決して対等な関係ではないので高校卒業で一度接点が無くなるものの、偶然、再会してこのあとの展開が気になる。

An obscure boy with a blind desire for love. A man who looks like a lone noble prince who is imprisoned by that love before he knows it. It's definitely not an equal relationship, so they lost contact once they graduated from high school, but by chance, they met again and I'm worried about developments after this.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

早く4巻が読みたい

I want to read volume 4 as soon as possible

平良のきもさがいいってコメを見てて、1巻ではよく分からず。読み進める中できもさがいいに共感出来ました。追記 4巻やばい清居の可愛さが爆発してるやばい

I was watching the comedy Taira no Kimosa is good, and I didn't really understand it in volume 1. I was able to really sympathize with the workmanship as I read on. Postscript volume 4 is crazy Kiyoi's cuteness is exploding

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 17, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

小説の美しい彼が何故美しいか

Why is the beautiful guy in the novel beautiful

This review contains spoilers. 小説の清居の何処が美しいのか漫画２巻清居が理不尽に階上からトマトジュースをかけられるシーンで漫画という表現方法でたくみに描かれています。小説をコミカライズ化にした幸福な成功例だと思います。漫画家を目指されていた凪良先生がXでこのシーンを感激した様子でピックアップされていました。作画の北野先生が真摯に小説を読みこんだ結果があのシーンの表現に繋がっていると思います。あのシーンを最初漫画で読んだ時清居が冤罪で叩かれて殉教を選ぶ人の様で無言で天を仰ぐ姿に凄みのある美しさを感じました。

This review contains spoilers. What part of the novel Kiyoi is beautiful in volume 2 is a scene where Kiyoi is unreasonably sprinkled with tomato juice from upstairs, and it is depicted in a manner of expression called a comic. I think it's a happy, successful example of comicalizing a novel. Nagi Ryo sensei, who was aiming to be a manga artist, was picked up looking moved by this scene on X. I think the result of the painter Kitano sensei reading the novel in earnest led to the expression of that scene. When I first read that scene in the comic, I felt the amazing beauty of Kiyoi looking up silently to heaven like someone who was beaten on a false charge and chose martyrdom.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 15, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

綺麗

It's beautiful

絵柄がとても綺麗で読みやすいです。実写化より気になってましたが、なかなか手が出せずにいました。読んだらやはり最高な作品でした。続きが気になります。

The design is very beautiful and easy to read. I was more interested in it than the live-action adaptation, but it wasn't easy to get my hands on it. After all, it was a great work after reading it. I'm worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ノベルの評価最強なので

Since the novel has the best reviews

あっち読んでからこっち見るべきだったのか？って感じだけど、漫画も絵が素晴らしくてですねいつかノベルも読むかも！

Should I have read it over there and then watched this one? It's like, but the comics and pictures are amazing, so maybe one day I'll read a novel too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 27, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

最高

highest

This review contains spoilers. 最近買ったBL漫画の中でダントツで好きです。清居のことを1番に優先するところ最高です。私は清井が卒業式の日にキスをしたシーンがとても印象的でした。あのシーンは驚いたし、みてて嬉しかったです。その後離れてしまったのは少し寂しさを感じました。しかし再会した清居が、絶対好きになってるじゃんって思う表情とか言葉をみせてくれたので一気に可愛さというか愛しさというかそういう幸せな気持ちでいっぱいになりました。次巻も楽しみにしてます。

This review contains spoilers. Of all the BL comics I've bought recently, I like it by far. Prioritizing Kiyoi as number one is the best thing. I was very impressed by the scene where Kiyoi kissed her on graduation day. I was surprised by that scene, and I was happy to watch it. I felt a little lonely when we left after that. However, Kiyoi, who I met again, showed me expressions and words that she thought she would definitely fall in love with, so I was filled with such a happy feeling of cuteness or loveliness all at once. I'm also looking forward to the next volume.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい彼と関係性面白いはまりました。

I had an interesting relationship with a beautiful guy.

This review contains spoilers. 凄く面白い展開、流浪の月とはまた違った特異性がありますね。ノベルで先読みしたけど二人とも仲良くなり俳優と写真家素敵です。コミックの続編是非読みたい。後、ドラマ見てないので、再放送望みます。

This review contains spoilers. It's a really interesting development, and it has a different specificity from Wandering Moon. I read it ahead in the novel, but they both became good friends and the actor and photographer are wonderful. I definitely want to read the comic sequel. After that, I haven't watched the drama, so I hope it will be broadcast again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

彼等の関係が変わる、衝撃の3巻

Their Relationship Will Change, Shocking Volume 3

This review contains spoilers. じわじわと目が離せなかった2人の関係が大きく変わろうとしている。揺さぶられ、反芻しながら心を砕き、でも内なる想いには背けず、、、変化していく平良から目が離せない。我が道を歩む王もさすが。ブレないキャラに満足すること間違いなしの巻。

This review contains spoilers. Slowly, the relationship between the two, who couldn't take their eyes off them, is about to change drastically. I'm shaken, my heart is broken while ruminating, but I can't take my eyes off my inner feelings... I can't take my eyes off Taira, who is changing. As expected, the king who walks his own path. There is no doubt that you will be satisfied with the unblurred characters.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

3巻まで読みました。最高です

I've read up to 3 volumes. It's the best

1、2巻同時購入で読んだ時の衝撃が凄かった。読後すぐレビューが書けなかったくらい衝撃的だった。原作も1冊読みました。原作の雰囲気通りのコミックスだと思う。「美しい彼」の美しく綴られた文章、美しい絵、サイコーです！次巻も楽しみで仕方ない！1巻P186、2巻P178、3巻P202。3巻の卒業式後の清居くん、あれどういう心境⁈ここまでエロ無しです。

I was shocked when I bought 1 and 2 volumes at the same time and read them. It was so shocking that I couldn't write a review right after reading it. I also read 1 book of the original story. I think it's a comic with the atmosphere of the original story. The beautifully spelled sentences and beautiful pictures of “The Beautiful Guy” are amazing! I can't help but look forward to the next volume too! Volume 1 P186, Volume 2 P178, Volume 3 P202 What kind of feelings did Kiyoi-kun feel after the graduation ceremony in volume 3? There's no eroticism up to this point.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

最高です

It's the best

小説全巻読んでます。ドラマと映画もみました。当然こちらコミック今出てる分は全て読みました。どれも良かったー。どれも世界観外さずバッチリハマれます。平良がとにかくツボです。最後までコミック出て欲しい。絵が綺麗なのが良いです。続き出たらまた買います。

I've read all the novels. I also watched dramas and movies. Naturally, I've read all of the comics that are out now. All of them were good. You'll be completely addicted to all of them without losing sight of the world. Taira is just a pressure point. I want the comic to come out until the end. It's good that the picture is beautiful. I will buy it again when more come out.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

きも男と

Kimo man and

This review contains spoilers. きもと言われても喜んでしまう。キングとキモ男。好きです。作画は最高きれいです。続きをください。ゆっくりだから原作で読んでしまいそう。

This review contains spoilers. It makes me happy even when they say you do it. The King and the creepy guy. I like it. The drawing is super beautiful. Please continue. It's slow, so it seems like I'll end up reading the original story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

実写から入りました

I entered from the live action

実写作品でも、凪良ゆうさんの書く人物の繊細な感情の動きは感じられましたが、私は漫画の方がよりその心情をじっくりと味わうことが出来ました。(読むペースを自分で調整できるからですかね笑)特に感想を書くこともないほど良い作品なのでとりあえず読んでいただきたいと思います。凪良ゆうさんは本当に世界観や人間の心を描くのが上手な方で、読むとすぐに世界に引き込まれていきます。次巻も購入します。

Even in the live-action work, I was able to feel the delicate emotional movements of the characters written by Ryoyu Nagi, but I was able to thoroughly enjoy that feeling more thoroughly in comics. (Maybe it's because I can adjust the reading pace myself lol) It's such a good work that I don't even write my impressions, so I'd like you to read it anyway. Nagi Ryoyu is a person who is really good at drawing worldviews and the human mind, and as soon as you read it, you are drawn into the world. I will be buying the next volume as well.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

共感できてしまう...

I can sympathize with you...

This review contains spoilers. コミック3巻までは平良視点でのストーリーで、他の方のレビューには「平良が気持ち悪い」との声が多かったですが、私には平良に共感できてしまってのめり込んでしまいました。平良視点ですが、清居は平良を一人の人として見ていたし、偽善でもなく芯があってそりゃ好きになるよね。。。って感じですオマケにいじめ上手だし(褒めてます)清居の取り巻き達の方がよっぽど気持ち悪かったな。人を笑顔で踏みつける、利用価値を天秤にかけて接する、プライドだけはいっちょ前。きもすぎる。清居視点がなく、コミックしか読んでないのですが清居にも幼少期からのトラウマ的なものがあって、その乾きを平良が潤してるのかもと思えます。エロは全然ないですが満足度高い作品です〜絵も美しいし目の保養♥4巻早く読みたいです。。

This review contains spoilers. Up to volume 3 of the comic, it was a story from Taira's point of view, and there were many comments from other people saying “Taira is disgusting,” but I was able to sympathize with Taira and I was so immersed in it. From Taira's point of view, Kiyoi saw Taira as a single person, and he had a core without being hypocritical, so he fell in love with it... As a bonus, they're good at bullying (I'm praising them), and Kiyoi's cronies were much more disgusting. Pride was a long time ago, stepping on people with a smile and treating them by putting a balance of use value on them. it's too loud. I don't have a Kiyoi point of view, and I only read comics, but Kiyoi also had traumatic things from his childhood, and I think Taira is relieving that dryness. It's not erotic at all, but it's a highly satisfying work ~ The pictures are beautiful and a feast for the eyes ♥ I want to read volume 4 as soon as possible..

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

良い

good

This review contains spoilers. 凪良ゆうさんの小説(汝、星のごとく)がとても良かったので、こちらも1～3巻購入しました。平良くん、う～んキモい笑でもルックスは良さそうだし、清居くんをかばってクラスメイトを殴る男らしさもあり、小山くんが惹かれるのも分かる。清居くんも格好いい。城田は消えて?凪良さんのお話ももちろんですが北野さんの絵もとっても綺麗ですね♦これは早く続きが読みたい‼しかし年に1冊くらいしか出ない？？BL初心者なものでよく分からないのですが、こんなものなのかなぁ。ラノベの方は同棲とかまで進んでいるようですが…。今のところラノベに手をつけるつもりはなく、次は新作の小説を読んでみるつもりです。「星のごとく」の続編みたいなので。なんだか小説のレビューみたいになってしまった?とにかくこちらの漫画は良きです。エロはキスのみです。4巻まで読みました…次巻は来春？嘘でしょ待ちきれない…

This review contains spoilers. Nagi Ryoyu's novel (You, Like a Star) was so good that I bought 1 to 3 volumes of this one too. He looks good even though he's flat out laughing, and he also has the masculinity of covering Kiyoi and hitting his classmates, so you can see that Koyama-kun is attracted to him. Kiyoi-kun is cool too. did shirota disappear? Of course, Nagira's story is also very beautiful, but Kitano's pictures are also very beautiful ♦ I want to read the continuation of this soon ‼ but only about 1 book comes out a year?? It's a BL beginner, so I don't really understand it, but I wonder if it's something like this. It seems that the light novel is progressing to cohabitation or something... I'm not going to work on light novels so far, and I'm going to read new novels next. It looks like a sequel to “Like a Star.” has it somehow become like a novel review? Anyway, this comic is good. Erotica is nothing but kisses. I've read up to 4 volumes... is the next volume next spring? that's a lie, can't wait...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

北野仁先生の凄さが冴え渡る

Kitano Hitoshi's awesomeness is clear

この作品を知る前から北野仁先生の作品が好きで、見開きページの使い方、絵だけで全ての心情を伝えきる、こまわりの天才だなとずっと思っていました。もちろん絵も大好き。フォローしている方のレビューで原作を拝読してあまりの面白さにハマりました。ファンが多い作品なのでプレッシャーも大きくて大変だったと思う。コミカライズでその万人が小説を読んだ時に想像する共通の世界を再現できるって凄すぎませんか？！本当に凄い才能に驚きしかありません。しかも作品ごとに絵が更に洗練されている。北野先生の絵は前のも既に美しく本当に大好きなのに、どんどん変わっていっている。凄い向上心の塊というか努力し続けているのが読者にもわかる。原作も読んで知ってるからいいや、とはならず本当に続きをわくわくしながら待って即日購入しています。

Even before I knew about this work, I loved Kitano Hitoshi's work, and I've always thought that he was a small genius who could convey all feelings with just pictures and how to use the spread pages. Of course I love painting too. I read the original story in a review from someone I followed, and I was addicted to how much fun it was. It's a work with a lot of fans, so I think it was difficult because of the pressure. Isn't it amazing to be able to recreate the common world that everyone imagines when they read a novel with Comicalize?! I am amazed at their truly amazing talent. Moreover, the paintings have been further refined with each work. Kitano-sensei's paintings are already beautiful and I really love them, but they are changing steadily. Readers can also see that it's a tremendous mass of ambition, or rather, that they continue to make an effort. I read and know the original story, so it's fine; I was really excited to wait for the continuation and bought it on the same day.

Helpful

Reviews for My Beautiful Man Manga