From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman Manga Reviews (P.10)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 25, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おっさんが可愛い

Old man is cute

剣聖のおっさん、弟子を愛しているのがよくわかる。肝心のおっさんはいつも頼りないのが可愛い。久々にハマりました。

You can clearly see that Kensei's old man loves his disciples. The bottom line is that old men are always cute when they can't be relied upon. I'm addicted to it after a long time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 22, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おっさんラブ

Old man love

こ、これはっ面白い！！ストーリーも無理なく絵も丁寧で、特に剣を振り回すシーンの躍動感というか、線だけですごい伝わってくる。普段は自己評価の低いおっさんが、戦うと神…な漫画、こんな謙虚なおっさんだったらラブだわ。そして青年マンガカテゴリーなのによくあるあるな下品なエロさが無い所がとても良い！

this, this is so interesting!! The story is reasonable and the pictures are careful, and in particular, the sense of dynamism in the scene where the sword is swung around is conveyed just by the lines. An old man who usually has a low self-esteem is a comic called God when he fights... it would be love if he were such a humble old man. Also, it's very nice that it doesn't have the vulgar eroticism that is common even though it's a youth manga category!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 22, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

片田舎の剣聖（おっさん）

Kensei in the countryside (old man)

すごく面白いです！主人公が日々の研鑽と努力ですごく強くなり、でもその力を自慢したり見せびらかしたりするのではなく、謙虚にしているところが好印象です。でも自分の実力がどれくらいかを自覚していないところがあるような気がするのでそこはもっと見極めてほしいと感じます。あと、登場する弟子がやたら女の子ばっかりなのが疑問です。

It's really interesting! I am impressed by the fact that the main character has become very strong through daily study and effort, yet he is humble rather than bragging about or showing off his power. However, I feel that there are places where I am unaware of my ability, so I feel that I want to evaluate that more. Also, it is questionable that all the apprentices that appear are girls.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

良い作品です。

It's a good work.

異世界漫画にハマっていますが、画作が良くない・幼い物も有りますが、この作品は、絵も丁寧で綺麗です。ストーリーもテンポ良く次作を毎回期待します。

I'm addicted to Isekai manga, but the artwork isn't good, and there are some young ones, but the pictures in this work are also careful and beautiful. The story also has a good tempo and I look forward to the next one every time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

謙遜しすぎる主人公と漫画で描かれる戦闘の強さとのギャップが面白いです。日本の剣豪を思わせる剣技と人を思いやる心、頭が下がります。RPGだとレベルカンストなんだろうな。

The gap between the protagonist, who is too humble, and the strength of combat depicted in comics is interesting. The sword skills reminiscent of Japanese swordsmen and the compassion for people make me bow my head. If it's an RPG, it's probably level quits.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

web小説も読んでいますが、漫画の方は戦闘シーンなどの魅せ方が上手で面白いです！出てくるモンスターとの戦いもごちゃごちゃしていないから、読みやすいです。小説をアレンジはしてないけど、ワンランク上げて書かれているような感じで、この先も楽しみです！主人公は自信のないオッさんだけど、剣士でシュッとしてるから全然アリです。優しすぎるんだろうなー。

I also read web novels, but comics are interesting because they are good at showing battle scenes etc.! The battles with the monsters that come up aren't a mess either, so it's easy to read. I haven't arranged the novel, but it feels like it was written a notch higher, and I'm looking forward to the future! The main character is an old man who doesn't have confidence, but since he's a swordsman, he's totally mad. I guess they're too kind.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

いいです

It's good

こういう内容の漫画は読んでておもしろいです。ベリル先生の自己評価の低さが謙虚すぎるというか…ずっと田舎で育ってきたから鈍感なんですよね。もっと自分に自信を持ってほしいです。

It's interesting to read comics with this kind of content. I mean Beryl's low self-esteem is too humble... I've always grown up in the countryside, so I'm insensitive. I want them to have more confidence in themselves.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おっさん

old man

This review contains spoilers. なんでこんなに事故評価が低いのか。これから明かされていくのかな。そして弟子たちの先生への思いが熱くてほっとします。早く続きがみたいです。

This review contains spoilers. Why are accident ratings so low? I wonder if it will be revealed from now on. And I'm relieved that the disciples feel so passionate about their teacher. I want to see it continue soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おっさん頼もしい

Old man is reliable

自分の実力を全く自覚してないところが面白いです。周りが歯がゆく思うところは一緒に応援しいです。是非、続きを早く読みたくなります。

It's interesting that I'm not aware of my abilities at all. I cheer together when people around me feel teething. It definitely makes me want to read the continuation as soon as possible.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おっさんがしっかり強くてかっこいい！

The old man is so strong and cool!

男女みんなかっこよく描かれてて、主人公のおっさんも強くてかっこいい！何回も読み返しちゃってます。次の巻が待ち遠しい…

Both men and women are drawn in a cool way, and the main character, the old man, is strong and cool too! I've reread it over and over again. I can't wait for the next volume...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメ化希望

I want it to be animated

どれだけのトラウマ抱えてるんだよってくらい自己評価が低い主人公だけど、若い時の失敗を引き摺るオジが他人のためには己を忘れて頑張れるってカッコいい。オジ好きには推せる。

The main character has such a low self-esteem due to how much trauma he has, but it's cool that an old man who dragged him to failure when he was young can forget himself and do his best for others. I recommend it to old man lovers.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

王道の様で王道でない

Like a royal road, not a royal road

This review contains spoilers. 世界観は良くある異世界ものだが、主人公の視点と周りからの視点のズレが従来のものと真逆に作られており、これによってストーリー展開が予想と若干のズレが有りながらも、成程と納得いく気持ち良さがある。主人公がチート並の能力者では無いというのもとても良い。続きが楽しみ過ぎて常に更新を確認してしまうくらいには素晴らしい。

This review contains spoilers. The worldview is a common otherworldly one, but the gap between the protagonist's point of view and the viewpoint from the surroundings is made the exact opposite of the conventional one, and even though there is a slight gap between the story development and predictions due to this, there is a sense of satisfaction with the progress. It's also very nice that the main character doesn't have the same abilities as cheats. It's so great that I enjoy the continuation so much that I always check for updates.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

とてもバランスが取れた話の流れになっていて引き込まれます。ハーレムで浮かれてぐずぐずにならずにしっかりと主人公が引き立ってきて素敵です。続きがとても気になります！あと、主人公の過去が気になりますね

The flow of the story is very balanced, and it draws me in. It's wonderful that the main character stands out firmly without floating around in a harem and getting bogged down. I'm really curious about the continuation! Also, I'm curious about the protagonist's past

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった！

That was interesting!

どうせ弟子とイチャつく系だろって期待してなかったんだけど面白かったし次の話も読みたいから新刊自動購入登録した！他の漫画みたいに変なエロ要素強調した話じゃなくてバトル強めで好き！おまけ漫画も面白かった?

I wasn't expecting them to flirt with my apprentice anyway, but it was interesting, and I wanted to read the next episode too, so I signed up for automatic purchase of the new issue! It's not a story that emphasizes weird erotic elements like other comics, it's strong in battles, and I like it! were the bonus comics interesting too?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

地味なおっさんなのに

Even though he's a plain old man

地味で自己評価低いのに強い系のおっさんのお話。凄く面白いです。自己評価低いのに要所要所でカッコいい、まさにいぶし銀って感じです。続きが楽しみ、早く出ないかな～でも弟子が女の子ばかりなので男衆も欲しいところ。副団長くんや道場引き継いでくれた男弟子もいるけど、老若男女問わず一目置かれるおっさんが見たいのです。

A story about a strong old man who is plain and has a low self-esteem. It's really interesting. Even though my self evaluation is low, it's cool at key points; it just feels like oxidized silver. I'm looking forward to the continuation, and I wonder if it will come out soon, but since all of my apprentices are girls, I want guys too. There are also male apprentices who have taken over the dojo from Suidan Longen, but I want to see old men and women of all ages who stand out at first sight.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ハーレムものと思わず読める

You can read it without thinking it's a harem thing

それぞれが思うことにそれなりの理由があるのがしっかりわかる。思ったより胸熱漫画なのかも知れない。今後が楽しみです。

I can clearly see that each of them has their own reasons for what they think. Maybe it's a more heart-warming comic than I thought. I'm looking forward to the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 13, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

まとう空気が変わるのが格好良い！

It's so cool that the atmosphere you wear changes!

普段はヌボっとしているのに、真剣な場面になると、おっさんのまとう空気が変わって、相手がハッとする。これが堪らなく良いです！

They usually look sluggish, but when it comes to serious scenes, the old man's atmosphere changes, and the opponent is taken aback. This is unbearably good!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる作品

Works I'm worried about continuing

This review contains spoilers. 謙虚通り越して過小評価なおじさん剣士のお話。コミック版だけの知識なので過去と師匠かしらとか勝手に妄想中。他の方のコメントにもありますが努力で無双になった系です。特に剣術シーンは見応えあります。主人公に近い年代には弟子(部下)が数年後に立派になって帰ってくるシーンは共感できるかと思います。3巻が待ち遠しい作品です。(単話で読んでるけどそれでも)

This review contains spoilers. A story about the underrated old swordsman who passed by humbly. I'm only familiar with the comic book version, so I'm delusional about my past and my mentor. There are comments from other people, but they have become unrivaled through hard work. The kenjutsu scene is particularly impressive. I think I can sympathize with the scene where the apprentice (subordinate) comes back in good shape a few years later in an age close to the main character. I can't wait for volume 3. (I'm reading it as a single story, but still)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おっさんがんばれ

Good luck old man

剣と魔法は大好物です。　おっさんが謙虚に奮闘する姿は泣けてくるほど楽しいこんな　漫画がもっとあったら楽しいです。

I love swords and magic. It would be fun if there were more comics like this that are so fun that the old man humbly struggles makes me cry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろすぎる

It's too funny

面白すぎてすぐに2巻目も購入した！主人公がおじさんってのも中々にはまるめっちゃいい所で終わったから早く続きが読みたい

It was so interesting that I bought the 2nd volume right away! Even though the main character is an old man, it ended in a really nice place where he fits in, so I want to read the continuation as soon as possible

Helpful

Reviews for From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman Manga