When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! Manga Reviews (P.6)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

庶民としてやっていけるのか？貴族の生活はできているのか？婚約者との関係はどうなる？それぞれのゆくえが気になる！！面白くて、続きが楽しみ！！

Can we do it as common people? Is the life of an aristocrat ready? What will happen to your relationship with your fiancé? I'm worried about the future of each one!! It's interesting and I'm looking forward to the continuation!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗で好み。

The picture is beautiful and I like it.

This review contains spoilers. 『私は人間が大好きよ』『これは愛情表現なの。彼女たちの喜怒哀楽のすべてを愛でに来ただけよ』迷惑な妖精の好奇心で、取り替えられたアンナとアネット。①巻は貴族として育てられたアンナのターン。ラスト、真実を打ち明けなかったことをメチャクチャ責められるアンナ。そんなにヒドイこと？１年前に打ち明けたからってナニができたのさ、お兄様？モヤモヤしつつ、②巻へ。今度は、平民として育てられたアネットのターン。貴族として迎え入れられても、戸惑い、違和感を感じるだけの彼女。今まで育った家のことが心配で、会いたい人もいる。そう、アンナもアネットも、本当の家族ではなかったとしても、受け入れられていなかったとしても、“家族”を想っているのだ。二人とも今、自分に出来ることを頑張っている。③巻で、アンナの婚約者エドに動きがあったので、どう立ち回ってくれるのか次巻が楽しみ。

This review contains spoilers. “I love humans.” “This is an expression of affection. I just came here with love for all of their emotions.” Anna and Annette were replaced due to annoying fairy curiosity. Volume ① is Anna's turn when she was raised as an aristocrat. Finally, Anna is blamed for not telling the truth. is that so awful? What were you able to do because you confided in it a year ago, big brother? While being confused, I went to volume ②. Now it's Annette's turn when she was raised as a commoner. Even though she is welcomed as an aristocrat, she just feels confused and uncomfortable. There are also people I want to meet because I'm worried about the house I grew up in until now. Yes, both Anna and Annette think about their “family,” even if they aren't a real family, or even if they aren't accepted. They are both doing their best right now to do what they can. Anna's fiancee Ed made some moves in volume ③, so I'm looking forward to the next volume to see how they will fight back.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

主犯妖精にグーパンチしたいっっ！

I want to punch the main culprit fairy!

This review contains spoilers. 妖精のいたずら……酷すぎるだろおい！と胸ぐらつかんでグーパンチしてもいいぐらい。そしてそれすら面白がる主犯の妖精が貴族よりも最低な心根のやつみたいで。だから人間はいとおしいというには、酷すぎる。産みの親より育ての親というが、それがいまいち薄いのでつらい。また主人公も取り違えの少女も二人ともいいコなのがこれまたつらい。この2人が本当に望む幸せになる未来があってほしい。貴族って庶民の税金で暮らしてるくせにクソすぎてイライラする(そういうものだから致し方ないとはいえ)。ないかもしれないが、主犯の妖精と貴族にはギャフンがあってほしい。後悔して泣き暮らせ。そんな展開あっても主人公たちの慈悲が助けるのだろうなあ。

This review contains spoilers. fairy prank... that's too bad, huh! It's enough to grab it around the chest and punch it with a goo punch. And it seems like the main culprit, the fairy, who is even amused, has the worst heart than the aristocrats. So it's too bad to say that humans are nice. They are called nurturing parents rather than birth parents, but it's hard because they are so weak. Also, it's hard that both the main character and the mistaken girl are good girls. I want these two to have a happy future that they really want. Even though aristocrats live on common people's taxes, they're so damn frustrated (even though it's unavoidable because it's like that). Maybe not, but I want the main culprit, the fairies and the aristocrats, to have Gafn. Live a life of regret and crying. I wonder if the protagonists' mercy will help even if there is such a development.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

私が幼い頃によくあったお話

A story that happened a lot when I was young

This review contains spoilers. 妖精達の悪戯で、庶民と貴族の子どもを交換してしまうお話。まだ1巻しか読んでいませんが、これからどうなってゆくのか、気になります。それにしても、兄ヘンリーのアンに対する刃の向け方は、悲しい。アンも犠牲者で、両親から愛されず、自分が庶民だと知った日からの一年間は、料理を覚えるなど、葛藤の中暮らして来たと言うのに、そばで見ていて気づかなかったなんて、兄ヘンリーは、偽善者。続きは、気になりますが、ちょっとお高いので、2巻以降、クーポン次第で購入したいです。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story about fairies exchanging children between common people and aristocrats. I've only read volume 1 yet, but I'm curious about what's going to happen in the future. Even so, the way my older brother Henry turned his sword against Anne is sad. Anne was also a victim, was not loved by her parents, and her older brother Henry is a hypocrite even though she said she lived in conflict for a year from the day she learned she was a common man, such as learning how to cook, but she watched by her side and didn't notice. I'm curious about the continuation, but it's a bit expensive, so I'd like to buy volume 2 and beyond, depending on the coupon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 20, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

3巻からが…

Starting with volume 3...

1〜2巻を読んだ時救いが見えなくて読んでて辛かったけど３巻から希望がみえてきた…ヒロイン2人とも幸せになって欲しいー！続き楽しみです！

When I read volumes 1 to 2, I couldn't see salvation, so it was hard to read, but I saw hope from volume 3... I want both of the heroines to be happy! I'm looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

妖精の悪戯に翻弄されるお話

A story at the mercy of fairy pranks

This review contains spoilers. 貴族の可愛いアンナちゃんが大好きで、エドも小さな紳士でとてもお似合いでキュンキュンします。そこから妖精の悪戯に翻弄されて庶民になり、何もかもゼロからスタート。泣きました。これからいろんな方向へ展開できる要素満載で、妄想がたのしいです。

This review contains spoilers. I love Anna, who is a cute aristocrat, and Ed is also a small gentleman and looks great with her. From there, they were at the mercy of fairy pranks and became common people, and everything started from scratch. I cried. It's full of elements that can be developed in various directions from now on, and delusions are fun.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 25, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

タイトルと印象が違うけど面白い

The impression is different from the title, but it's interesting

最初に悲痛な展開が予想できて、読むのがキツい事もありましたが、庶民になってからのヒロインは逞しくほっこりしました。婚約者も絡みますが、「妖精に赤ん坊を取り替えられた庶民と貴族の物語」と思って読んでます。

I was able to anticipate a heartbreaking development at first, and there were times when it was difficult to read, but the heroine felt strong and relaxed after becoming a commoner. My fiancee is also involved, but I'm reading it thinking it's “a story about common people and aristocrats whose babies were replaced by fairies.”

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

とても面白かったです。

It was very interesting.

時間を忘れてあっと言う間に読んでしまいました。心理描写が鋭く、深くてとても面白かったです。早く続きが読みたいです。

I lost track of time and read it in a blink of an eye. The psychological depiction was sharp, deep, and very interesting. I want to read more soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

更新が楽しみ

I'm looking forward to the update

更新されたら読んでるけど読み返したくてコミックスでも買っちゃうくらい楽しみにしている作品です。早く続きが読みたい

I'm reading it when it's updated, but I'm looking forward to it so much that I even bought comics because I wanted to reread it. I want to read the continuation soon

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 26, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが楽しみ

I'm looking forward to the continuation

絵柄がミュシャっぽい感じで、とても綺麗です。瞳の描き方に特徴がありますね。ストーリーが面白くて、この先いったいどうなるのか続きが楽しみです

The design looks like Mucha, and it's very beautiful. The way eyes are drawn is unique, isn't it? The story is interesting, and I'm looking forward to seeing what exactly happens in the future

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 20, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

評価を見て買うのを躊躇ってましたが。

I was hesitant to buy it after seeing the reviews.

This review contains spoilers. あまりにも過酷で、読むのも辛くなるくらいと書かれており、また、ストーリーの進行度もスローペースという評価などを目にして買うのを躊躇ってましたが。どうしても気になり購入しました。3巻まで読み終えて感じたのは、とても丁寧に心理描写が描かれているし、それぞれの行き違いやそこに気がつくまでなど、スルスルと読めました。確かに、理不尽！ってなりますが、あの嫌な感じの妖精も何か意図がありそうだし。なにより、ヒロイン2人が腐る事なく前に進もうとする姿には、感動すらしてます。2人を取り巻く人間模様も今後楽しみです。そして、絵が綺麗。頭身も細かな描き込みも、どれも好みです。

This review contains spoilers. It was written that it was so harsh that it was difficult to read, and I was hesitant to buy it because I saw reviews that the progress of the story was slow paced. No matter what, I was curious and bought it. What I felt after reading up to 3 volumes was that the psychological descriptions were drawn very carefully, and I was able to read them smoothly, such as each misunderstanding and until I noticed them. Certainly, unreasonable! But that disgusting fairy also seems to have some intention. Above all, I'm even moved by the sight of the two heroines trying to move forward without rotting. I'm also looking forward to the human pattern surrounding the two of them in the future. And the picture is beautiful. I like both the head and the detailed drawing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

辛い?けど見応えある！！

painful? But it's worth seeing!!

ノスタルジックな雰囲気の絵柄で、繊細に描かれており、ストーリーにも見応えがあります！心理描写も上手いので、ファンタジーものとして引き込まます✨タイトルの｢貴族から庶民に｣っていうのが、よくある異世界令嬢系のコミカルな軽さはなく、辛くて悲しいです。主人公がどう活躍していくのか、婚約者がどう動いていくのか、家族との関係など、続きが気になります?

The design has a nostalgic atmosphere, is delicately drawn, and the story is impressive! It's also good at depicting psychology, so it draws me in as a fantasy ✨ The title “From the Aristocrats to the Common People” doesn't have the comical lightness of common Isekai Hostess, and it's painful and sad. I'm curious about the continuation, such as how the main character will play an active role, how his fiancee will move, his relationship with his family, etc.?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

感動します

impresses

ファンタジーなんだけどしっかり人間ドラマがあって人を思いやる気持ちとか、どうしようもない不条理に振り回される人達の感情が素直にかかれていて読みごたえあります。続きがかなり気になります。

It's a fantasy, but there's a solid human drama, and it honestly captures the feelings of people being swayed by unavoidable absurdity, and it's worth reading. I'm quite worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

アンナもアネットもいい子すぎる…

Anna and Annette are too good kids...

せつない。絵も綺麗、ストーリーも素敵です。皆幸せになって欲しい。評価低めですが、私はとてもいい漫画だと思います。

That's annoying. The pictures are beautiful and the story is wonderful. I want everyone to be happy. The reviews are low, but I think it's a very good comic.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

This review contains spoilers. 泣きます。何か、凄く心に響く。１巻２巻で絶望的な悲しさの中に2人の強さがある。ってか、悪戯を楽しむ妖精って、どんだけ質が悪いんだよ！それも止められないとか、おかしいでしょ。３巻はアンナが頑張るのを応援したくなる。でも、エドを想って涙するのが悲しい。４巻はどんな展開になるんだろう。

This review contains spoilers. I'm going to cry. Something really resonates with my heart. There is strength between the two in volume 1 volume 2 in hopeless sorrow. I mean, how bad are the quality of fairies that enjoy mischief! It's strange that you can't stop it either. Volume 3 makes me want to cheer Anna for her hard work. But it's sad to cry thinking about Ed. I wonder what volume 4 will unfold.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

涙なしでは読めません…

I can't read without tears...

This review contains spoilers. 妖精による入れ違いのお話でした。魔法も上手くなってきっとぎゃふんがあるはず…と読んでますが、展開はゆったりです。生活に慣れてきてこれからというところですが、これから事件が起きるのかな？？予想は帰ってきたお父さんの悪巧みで一波乱あったあと、なんやかんやで学校に通うのではと思っています。庶民から養子にして貴族にもどすことはできないのでしょうか…？婚約者とくっつくといいですね…

This review contains spoilers. It was a story about a mistake made by a fairy. I'm reading that they've gotten better at magic, and there must be gyafun... but things are unfolding slowly. I'm getting used to life and it's about to come, but I wonder if an incident will happen in the future?? The prediction was full of turbulence due to the bad tricks of my father who came back, and then I think I'll go to school with something. Isn't it possible to adopt children from common people and return them to the nobility...? It would be nice if you stick with your fiancé...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

題名で買わない方がいいかも…

Maybe it's better not to buy it under the title...

チェンジリングという題材のお話を読んだことが無かったのですが、これはなかなかハード…(汗貴族の方は分かりやすく愛はなく、庶民の方は生活苦による余裕のなさからかやはり愛に満たされてはいないように感じます。複雑な人間の心は十分に表現されていて、読んでいてまぁ辛い事…笑。唯一の救いはダブルヒロイン両名の心が強く優しい事でしょうか。ヒーローの役割である黒髪の少年も性格が随分捻くれているので優しく包み込んでくれるタイプでは無さそう。ヒロインよ、何故好きになった…？ファンタジーの世界でありながらご都合主義は最小限にリアリティーを追求したような作品ですね。複雑な気持ちになる作品ですが、それでも続きが気になります。ギャフンはあるのか？！窮困の現状打破はいつ頃？！などなど、とても楽しみです。とはいえ、このタイトルだと流行りのギャフン系と勘違いされそうなので、一応注意喚起。3巻にやっとヒーローっぽい少年の心理描写が出て来る程度で恋愛色は強くないです。正直こっちにはあまり期待してないので大いに結構結構ですが(ヒーローが好みじゃない)、タイトル詐欺に合わないようにだけ気を付けてください。

I hadn't read a story about the subject of Changeling, but this is pretty hard... (I feel that the Khan aristocrats are easy to understand and have no love, and the common people are still not filled with love, probably because they can't afford it due to life hardships. The complicated human mind was fully expressed, and it was so painful to read... lol. I wonder if the only salvation is that both of the double heroines are strong and kind. The dark-haired boy, who plays the role of the hero, also has quite a twisted personality, so he doesn't seem to be the type to gently wrap him around. Why did you fall in love with the heroine...? Even though it's a fantasy world, it's a work that pursues reality with minimal expediency. It's a work that makes me feel mixed, but even so, I'm worried about the continuation. Is there a gaffn?! When will the current state of poverty be overcome?! And so on, I'm really looking forward to it. Nonetheless, this title is likely to be misunderstood as a popular gafn series, so be careful for the time being. The romantic color isn't strong, to the extent that a psychological depiction of a boy who looks like a hero finally appears in volume 3. Honestly, I'm not expecting much from this one, so that's pretty good (I don't like heroes), but just be careful not to fall for title fraud.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

毎回泣いちゃう

I cry every time

This review contains spoilers. 妖精のした悪戯は善も悪もない、例えば病気だとか自然災害だとか人間の力ではどうしようもない自然現象のようなものだと思います。それらに巻き込まれてしまい、冷たい態度をとってしまう貴族側や庶民側の家族の困惑も理解できますし、すぐに打ち明けられなかった主人公や、アイデンティティクライシスに陥った兄の気持ちも痛いほど伝わります(泣)それでも前向きに、そして他者を思いやる主人公に毎巻涙してしまいますし、丁寧な庶民の暮らしの描き方もツボです。可愛らしく温かみのある綺麗な絵も大好きです。次巻が楽しみすぎて仕方ありません！

This review contains spoilers. I think the mischief played by fairies is neither good nor bad; for example, diseases, natural disasters, or natural phenomena that cannot be helped by human power. I can understand the confusion of families on the aristocrats and common people who get caught up in them and take a cold attitude, and it painfully conveys the feelings of the protagonist who didn't confide right away and his older brother who fell into an identity crisis (crying). (crying) Even so, every volume brings tears to the main character who is positive and cares for others, and the careful way they draw the lives of common people is also a point. I also love cute, warm, and beautiful pictures. I'm looking forward to the next volume so much that I can't help it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

低評価もありますが………

There are also low ratings, but...

This review contains spoilers. 断然！私は！こちらに！星5を！いや星10を！送りたいです…ッ！！！！！！こちらは持っている令嬢ものの中でもかなり気にいって20回くらい読んでいる漫画です。確かにタイトルと内容の不一致は否めませんがそれにしても逸脱な作品、頑張り屋のヒロインアンナちゃんが大好きです…3巻もあっという間に読んでしまった…次巻はいつですか？！！また！！？また最初の巻を読んでは終わって次が待ち遠しくなっての繰り返し…！はよエドくんとアンナちゃんの！！進展を！幸せを！！

This review contains spoilers. Definitely! I am! over here! 5 stars! No, 10 stars! I want to send it... huh!!!!! This is a comic that I like quite a bit, and I've read it about 20 times, even though it's for my daughter. Certainly, the discrepancy between the title and content is undeniable, but even so, I love the hardworking heroine Anna... I read volume 3 in no time... when is the next volume?!! again!!? Read the first volume again, then it's over and over and over again and I can't wait for the next one...! Hajo Edo-kun and Anna-chan's!! Make progress! happiness!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

新刊待ってましたよ〜！！

I've been waiting for the new publication!!

そして早く続き読みたい!絵がとても魅力的で、引き込まれます！学園に通うのかしら(TOT)頑張れアンナ！！

And I want to keep reading soon! The picture is so fascinating and it draws me in! I wonder if they'll go to school (TOT) good luck Anna!!

Helpful

Reviews for When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! Manga