When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! Manga Reviews (P.5)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 09, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

予想と違った

It was different from what I expected

この手のタイトルにありがちな、断罪からの「ふふっ★なーんてね！やったわ～！これから私は自由よ～！」みたいな感じかと思ったら、普通にシリアスでびびった。このタイトルにしないと今は手にとってもらえないんだろうけど、普遍的なテーマのガチガチの悲運ヒロインファンタジーだった……。読めなくならない程度に辛い塩梅でとてもよかった。コミカライズの大岩さんってあれか、NHKにようこその人か！絵も素晴らしい

“Huh ★ huh!” from conviction, which is common in titles like this I did it! Now I'm free!” When I thought it was something like that, I was freaked out by the fact that it was usually serious. If you don't use this title, you probably won't be able to get your hands on it now, but it was a really sad heroine fantasy with a universal theme... It was so nice that the salt was so spicy that I couldn't read it. Is Mr. Oiwa from Comica Rise like that, or the person who came to NHK! The picture is also wonderful

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 09, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良き

good

一気に4巻まで読んでしまいました。2人の女の子の話がそれぞれ丁寧に描かれているなーと思いました。主人公が可哀想で涙が止まりませんでした。これから先の展開は色々考えられるので、先は長いのかなと思います。

I read up to 4 volumes at once. I thought the stories of the two girls were each carefully drawn. I couldn't stop crying because the main character felt sorry. We can think of many future developments, so I think we have a long way to go.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

大人買い

Buy an adult

面白くてをポイントあまってたので、大人買い。続きがきになる。ありがちだけど、色々MIX。キッチン最後はハッピーエンド、目線がかわり面白い

I had a lot of interesting points, so I bought it for adults. It will be continued. It's common, but there are various mixes. The end of the kitchen has a happy ending, and it's interesting to change your gaze

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

描写が丁寧で深みがある

The depiction is careful and deep

This review contains spoilers. 4巻まで読みました。少し展開が遅いように感じますが、その分描写が丁寧でそれが後からじわじわ効いてきて深みのある話になっていると思いました。兄のヘンリーは情が深いけど正論で相手を追い詰めるタイプですね。けっこうキツイです。自分の正しさを正当化するために相手を攻撃するのはやっぱりろくでもないと思う。4巻で主人公が逞しくなってカッコいいと思いました。このまま頑張ってほしいです。

This review contains spoilers. I've read up to 4 volumes. I feel like the development is a bit slow, but I thought the description was so careful that it gradually came into effect later, making it a deep story. My older brother Henry is the type who has deep feelings but hunts down his opponents with his right arguments. It's pretty tough. After all, I don't think it's easy to attack an opponent in order to justify one's own correctness. I thought it was cool that the main character became strong in volume 4. I want them to keep up the good work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

タイトル…

The title...

これじゃなくてよったんじゃと思ってました。妖精さんのイタズラで別々の生活を送ることになった二人。どっちも良い子で切ないわ。お互いに思ってる相手がいるだけに余計に…話はとても面白いけど、貴族ってほんとにと思う。お兄様には頑張って欲しい。

I thought this wasn't it. The two ended up living separate lives due to the fairy's prank. They're both good kids and it's sad. It's superfluous just because there are people we both have feelings for... the story is very interesting, but I really think aristocrats are real. I want my older brother to do his best.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

イタヅラ?

a prank?

主人公は本当に地味ですよね。庶民だからだけど、この先強く生きてほしいです?元婚約者とどうなるのか楽しみです?

The main character is really plain, isn't he? it's because they're common people, but do you want them to live strong in the future? I'm excited to see what happens with my ex fiance?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

??

??

初めの一巻で、購読をどうしようか悩みましたが、読み進めるとどんどんハマりました。これから、２人がどんな道を進んで変わって行くのか気になります

It was the first volume, and I was worried about how to subscribe, but as I read on, I became more and more addicted to it. I'm wondering what path the two of them will take and change from now on

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

描写に惹かれる！

I'm attracted to the depiction!

他の方のレビューにも挙がってるけど、絵が童話の絵本のようでかわいいのが第一印象！それぞれのキャラクターの個性も際立っているし、ストーリーもスラスラ読めちゃうから一巻読み切るのがあっという間に終わっちゃうのがちょっと残念です笑個人的には妖精の人間に対する愛情のかけ方が面白くてすき！人間から見たら結構ヒドイ事してるけど、妖精は偏見なく人の善悪とか愚かさを全部ひっくるめて全力で愛している様はなんか憎めないなー笑小説の評価はあまり良くないようで読んでないけど、コミックの方はもっと心情とか関係性を色濃くしていって欲しいな。

It's been mentioned in other people's reviews, but my first impression was that the pictures look like children's story picture books and are cute! The individuality of each character also stands out, and since I can read the story smoothly, it's a bit disappointing that I finished reading the first volume so quickly lol Personally, I love the way fairies apply their love to humans is interesting! It's pretty terrible from a human point of view, but I can't hate how fairies love all of people's good, evil, and foolishness without prejudice lol lol I haven't read the novel's reviews so I haven't read it, but I want comics to have more intense feelings and relationships.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がかわいい！癒される

The picture is cute! Be healed

絵が可愛くて、読みやすい！おとぎ話の絵本を読んでいる気分。ストーリーのメイン部分はありがちかな展開かなと思ったけど、各キャラクターの気持ちの流れが緻密に書かれていたり、読み進めていくにつれ意外と、というと失礼だが奥行きを感じた。サクサク読めてしまうので、一冊が早く感じてしまう。

The pictures are cute and easy to read! I feel like I'm reading a fairy tale picture book. I thought the main part of the story was an easy development, but the flow of feelings of each character was written in detail, and it was surprising as I read on, which was rude, but I felt a sense of depth. It's easy to read, so I feel like one book is fast.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

とても面白い！みんなそれぞれの想いがあって、みんなが幸せになる道はあるのかしら？続きがとても気になります。

So funny! Everyone has their own feelings, and I wonder if there is a way for everyone to be happy? I'm really worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

妖精の悪戯

Fairy prank

This review contains spoilers. 最初アンナは庶民としてやっていけるのか？と心配だっだけど意外とすぐ馴染んでいて逞しさを感じる。今後、エドとの関係性も気になるしこの妖精の悪戯が、庶民と貴族との関係性を変える何かしらのきっかけになるなでは？と思わせる部分もあって先が気になります。

This review contains spoilers. Will Anna be able to do it as a commoner at first? I was worried, but surprisingly, they quickly got used to it and I feel strong. In the future, I'm also worried about the relationship with Ed, so isn't this fairy prank going to be some kind of trigger to change the relationship between the common people and the aristocrats? There is also a part that makes me think, so I'm worried about the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

泣きたくなっら読もう

I want to cry let's read

ザマー系の転生ぶっ壊れ設定かと想いつつ読み進めるも世界観を壊さず貴族様時代に合わせた令嬢物です。3巻でプロローグ（ダブルヒロインの生い立ちと覚悟）、此の後どの様にイケメンたちが右往左往するか楽しみになりました。次巻が待ち遠しい。

It's a young lady that matches the aristocrat era without breaking the worldview even though you read it while thinking that it's a Zamer series of reincarnation settings. The prologue (double heroine's upbringing and preparations) was volume 3, and I was excited to see how the handsome guys went right and left after that. I can't wait for the next volume.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

じっくり読みたい作品

Works I want to read carefully

妖精によって取り替えられた身分の違う2人の少女の物語で、恋愛模様というより全体の人間模様が見どころの作品だと思いました。それぞれの身分における厳しさ、価値観の違い、家族の在り方、どう生きていくか等、展開にずしっとした重みを感じます。メインヒロインはタフなわけでも飛び抜けて優秀なわけでもないけれど、物事をきちんと受けとめて努力できる子です。うまくいくことよりうまくいかないことの方が多く、それが生々しさを帯びて胸がギュッとなりますね。4巻では逞しくなってきた主人公が見られてホッとすると同時に嬉しくなりました！痛快さを求める方にとっては不向きかもしれませんが、じっくり楽しめる面白い作品だと思います。続きも楽しみです！

It's a story about two girls with different statuses who were replaced by fairies, and I thought the highlight of the work was the overall human pattern rather than the love pattern. I feel the severity of each status, differences in values, the way families are, how to live, etc., and the weight of development is heavy. The main heroine isn't tough or outstanding, but she's a kid who can properly accept things and make an effort. There are more things that don't go well than things that go well, and that takes on a vividness and makes my heart feel tight. I was relieved and happy at the same time to see the protagonist, who has become stronger in volume 4! It may not be suitable for those looking for exhilaration, but I think it's an interesting work that you can enjoy thoroughly. I'm looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵です！

It's wonderful!

This review contains spoilers. 始めはアンナが庶民としてやって行けるか貴族の時からどうなるやらと不安でしたがアンナが強い女性でよかった！そしてアンナの良い性格が離れていた家族とも少しずつ近づいて行けるきっかけになったし庶民になったあとの友人作りや、貴族であったときの知人との良い関係に繋がっていると思うと庶民として彼女のこれからの生活を見て行くのが楽しみです！心配なのが一生懸命頑張ってきたアネット、貴族になっても居心地が悪くて、、、元の家族は(父親意外)愛しているんだよ心配してるんだよって教えてあげたい！2人のこれからがとても気になる！！もちろんエドとの恋も今後が気になります！！

This review contains spoilers. At first, I was worried about whether Anna would be able to do well as a commoner or what would happen when she was an aristocrat, but I'm glad Anna is a strong woman! Also, Anna's good personality was an opportunity for me to get closer little by little with her separated family, and I'm looking forward to watching her future life as a common man when I think it led to making friends after becoming a common man and having good relationships with acquaintances she knew when she was an aristocrat! What I'm worried about is Annette, who has worked so hard, and even when she became an aristocrat, she doesn't feel comfortable... I want to tell you that her original family (unexpectedly, her father) loves and is worried! I'm really worried about the future of the two of them!! Of course I'm also worried about the future of my love with Ed!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

子を見守る親の気持ちで読んじゃいます

I read it with the feeling of a parent watching over their children

This review contains spoilers. 最初は14年も一緒に暮らした子を捨てるなんざ何事かぁぁ！と怒り心頭でしたが、子供たちがよいこに育っていて良かった...2人ともお互いを思いやれる子で良かった...永遠に見守っていたいふたりです?

This review contains spoilers. I wonder what it is like to abandon a child we've lived with for 14 years at first! I was furious, but I'm glad the kids are growing up well... I'm glad they're both children who can take care of each other... are they the two you want to watch over forever?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公可愛い

The main character is cute

This review contains spoilers. チェンジリングで今までの生活を、捨てるしかない未来が待っている主人公の心情と葛藤がうまく書かれています。絵柄も繊細でピッタリ。今後の展開がどうなるのか楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. The feelings and conflicts of the protagonist, whose future has no choice but to abandon his life up until now awaits in Changeling, are nicely written. The design is also delicate and perfect. I'm looking forward to seeing what the future unfolds.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵なイラスト

nice illustration

最新巻まで購入。美麗で繊細な絵が大好きです。漫画としても読みやすいしページを送って流し見するだけでこんなに多幸感のある作画は滅多にないです。

Buy up to the latest volume. I love beautiful, delicate pictures. It's also easy to read as a comic, and there are few drawings that have such a sense of euphoria just by sending a page and watching it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けてくる?

it makes me cry?

アンナとアネット、2人とも人間性に優れていて周りを思いやる心を持っている。読んでいて温かい気持ちになる。

Anna and Annette both have excellent human nature and are considerate of those around them. It makes me feel warm when I read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

タイトル詐欺

Title fraud

タイトルの音感からは想像できない、割と地に足の着いた感じのお話。状況や心理を丁寧に描いている分、展開はゆっくりめになってしまうのかなと思うけれど、それにのんびりつき合うのもいいかな、とゆったり構えてます。ドラマチックな展開がポンポン起こるストーリーを好む方には向かないかも知れないけど、個人的には好きなお話です。

It's a relatively down to earth story that you can't imagine from the pitch of the title. As I carefully draw the situation and mentality, I think the development will slow down, but I'm relaxed wondering if it would be good to just hang out with it. It may not be suitable for those who like stories where dramatic developments take place, but I personally like it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒロインが

The heroine

健気で可愛いです。可哀想な展開ではあるのですが、もう一人の取り替えられた子も感じが良いのが救いになっていますし、３巻までくるとだいぶ明るい感じになってきています。原作未読なので続きが気になります。ヒーローがカッコいい展開期待してます。

She is healthy and cute. It's a sad development, but the fact that the other replaced child is also feeling good has been a relief, and it's starting to feel pretty bright when you get to volume 3. I haven't read the original story, so I'm worried about the continuation. I'm looking forward to the hero's cool development.

Helpful

Reviews for When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! Manga