When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! Manga Reviews (P.7)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 01, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

せつない

It's annoying

最初は王子がひどい！と思ったけど、兄のほうがひどいわ（笑）元庶民で再び庶民に戻ったヒロインがどうやって幸せになるのか、今後に期待！

The prince was terrible at first! I thought, but my older brother is worse (laughs) I'm looking forward to seeing how the heroine, who is a former commoner and has returned to being a common man, will be happy in the future!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 16, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

出生とりかえ、つら！

It's hard being born again!

設定重いけど、チェンジニングなんて珍しいから単純に興味がある。絵も綺麗だし。今2巻まで読んだけど、悲壮感からやっと片足抜けだしそう…ってくらいだけどwキャラ達も現実を受け止めて、今からは上がって行く展開しかないと思うので期待を込めて★5！

The settings are heavy, but changing is rare, so I'm simply interested. The picture is beautiful too. I've read up to 2 volumes now, and it seems like they're finally leaving one leg out of a sense of sadness... but the W characters also accepted reality, and I think there is no choice but to improve from now on, so stay tuned ★ 5!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

好きです

I like it

絵柄が可愛い。繊細な雰囲気の絵が好きです。主人公も力強く生きていくところが好感がもてます。早く続きが読みたいです！

The pattern is cute. I like paintings with a delicate atmosphere. I like the fact that the main character also lives a strong life. I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 25, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

涙

tears

This review contains spoilers. 一巻目を読んだ時は、心が痛みました。どうして妖精はこんな酷い事を笑って出来るのかと。2巻目を読んで、少し気持ちが救われたようなきがします。生活スタイルが変わって、これから2人が気になります。次回作が早く読みたいです。

This review contains spoilers. My heart ached when I read the first volume. I wonder how fairies can laugh at such terrible things. Reading volume 2 seems to have saved my mind a little bit. My lifestyle has changed, and I'm worried about the two of them from now on. I want to read my next work soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 25, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

きっつ

Kitsu

This review contains spoilers. かわいそすぎだし、水色(青？)の妖精さん意地悪すぎ…。「愛しい」って哲学なのかな？読んでて胸糞悪くなりましたが、そこがうまくかかれてるのかなと感じました。1巻の途中までは兄の言う通り「兄の言うことが正しくて、言わなかったヒロインが悪い」って思いましたが2巻を読んだら違う感じがしたし兄が後悔？してました。兄にヒロインを手助けしてほしいですが貴族と庶民は違うので難しいかもですよね…。まだ婚約破棄まで行っていないので「つづきはやくー！」ってなりました。今のとこラノベも1巻しか発売されてないみたいだから続きでるまで長いのかな…

This review contains spoilers. That's too pitiful, light blue (blue?) the fairy is too mean... Is “lovable” a philosophy? My heart got really bad when I was reading it, but I felt like that was well applied. Until the middle of volume 1, as my older brother said, I thought “what my older brother said was right, and the heroine I didn't say it was bad,” but after reading volume 2, I felt a different feeling and my older brother regretted it? I was doing it. I want my older brother to help the heroine, but since aristocrats and common people are different, it might be difficult... I haven't even annulled my engagement yet, so “the continuation is quick!” That's it now. It seems like only 1 volume of the light novel has been sold so far, so I wonder if it will be a long time until it continues...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

妖精の

Fairy's

いたずらって…こんな感じ！？２人の運命も生活もかわいそう…幸せになってほしい！！読みやすい作品でした。

Prank is... like this!? Their fate and lives are pitiful... I want them to be happy!! The work was easy to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

良かったです。

That was great.

まだお話は途中といったところです。２巻まで読んで、みんなが幸せになってほしいと思わせる内容でした。おすすめします。

We're still in the middle of the conversation. I read up to 2 volumes, and the content made me want everyone to be happy. I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 18, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

複雑な心理。

complex psychology.

This review contains spoilers. アンナの両親のこれまでの対応にも、娘じゃないと知ったあとの対応にもものすごく腹が立つ。唯一、兄がまともかと思いきやこれまた寒空の下に即座に置き去りとか、、、騙されたって思いあまる気持ちもわからなくはないけど、荷馬車のくだりからの見捨て方にはあっぱれというほどひどい仕打ち。そもそもアンナが真実をなぜすぐ打ち明けなかったのかとか、騙した悪女！以外の理由とかアネットに指摘されるまで1ミリも思いつかなかったのか？と。しかも指摘されて急に情が戻ってきたのか涙されてもなと。むしろこれまでだって妹への愛というより、かわいそうな妹(とされる毛色違いの少女)を居心地悪くないよう色々おもんばかってあげた俺！優しいでしょ的な、裏切られたと逆恨みのこれまでの労力返せよ的な、自分に酔ってる感が嫌い。でもこれが物語のいいスパイスになってくのだろうと思うと早く3巻が読みたい。アンナも自分可愛さもあって、しかも疎まれてると両親の態度から感じている中で兄に真実を伝えられないでいた気持ちは理解できる。彼女が聖女の様ないい人でも、よくある物語に出てくる前向きチートな悪役令嬢的な女性でもなく、弱さと強くありたさのバランスに揺れてる感じが凄く人間味があって胸が痛かった。そして、何よりもアネットがまともな女性で良かった。ここまで読んで、いたずらを仕掛けた青い髪の妖精がとても病んでいて苦手。

This review contains spoilers. I'm extremely angry at how Anna's parents have dealt so far, and how they have dealt with her since she learned she wasn't her daughter. The only thing is that I don't understand the feeling that I thought my older brother was decent, but I was immediately left behind under the cold sky and was deceived, but it was such a terrible treatment that I was overwhelmed by the way he abandoned him in the cart. An evil woman who deceived Anna as to why she didn't reveal the truth right away in the first place! Couldn't even think of a millimeter until Annette pointed it out for reasons other than that? and. What's more, it was pointed out, and I wonder if my feelings suddenly came back, even if I was in tears. Rather than my love for my little sister until now, I've made a fool of my poor sister (supposedly a girl with a different coat color) so that she doesn't feel uncomfortable! I don't like the feeling of being drunk on myself, like being kind, being betrayed and having to return the hard work so far of resentment. But when I think this will spice up the story, I want to read volume 3 as soon as possible. Anna is also cute, and I can understand the feeling of not being able to tell the truth to her older brother while feeling from her parents' attitude that they are being neglected. She wasn't a nice person like a saint, nor was she a positive and cheat villain-daughter woman in common stories, and the feeling of being swayed by the balance between weakness and strength was so humane that it hurt my heart. And above all else, I'm glad Annette is a decent woman. I've read this far, and I don't like the blue-haired fairy who set up the prank because she's very sick.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 03, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが楽しみです

I'm looking forward to the continuation

原作は読んでませんが、コミックのみです。絵は綺麗で読みやすいし、アンナとアネットどちらも共感が持てる子なので続きが楽しみです。

I haven't read the original story, but only comics. The pictures are beautiful and easy to read, and both Anna and Annette are empathic kids, so I'm looking forward to continuing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 24, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろいです

It's interesting

絵も綺麗で、設定もよくある転生ものとは一風違い、主人公の境遇に同情でき、おもしろいです。

The picture is beautiful, and the setting is completely different from the common reincarnation one, and I can sympathize with the protagonist's circumstances, which is interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 12, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

小説とは違う

It's different from a novel

小説を読んだことがありますが本当にイライラして良い心地がしなかった。でもコミックは小説とは違うストーリーに見えてとても楽しく読めます。

I've read novels, but I was really frustrated and didn't feel good. But comics look like a different story from novels and are very fun to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 11, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

面白っ！

That's interesting!

アンナ、アネット、どちらも好感がもてる性格で良かった。アンナがこれから本当の家族と仲良くなれるのか、元婚約者との再会やお兄様の動向など気になるところ満載で、次巻が楽しみ！できれば、全員幸せになってほしい。ただし、チェンジリングした女妖精は腹立つから一度痛い目に合えばいいと思う。

I'm glad that Anna and Annette both have likeable personalities. I'm looking forward to the next volume because it's full of concerns about whether Anna will be able to get along well with her real family from now on, a reunion with her former fiancé and older brother's trends! If possible, I want everyone to be happy. However, the changeling female fairy is infuriating, so I think it's good to get in pain once.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 05, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

絵はそこまで好みではないけど。

I don't like pictures that much though.

This review contains spoilers. 話はかなり気になる終わり方をしています。妖精のいたずらによって、貴族と庶民にいれかわってしまう。どうやってストーリーが進んでいくのかすごく気になります。

This review contains spoilers. The end of the story is quite worrisome. They are replaced by the nobility and common people due to the fairy's mischief. I'm really curious to see how the story progresses.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 30, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

原作(アンナ)+原作(アネット)かな？

Original story (Anna) +original story (Annette) maybe?

This review contains spoilers. 去年原作を読んで、コミック化するということでさっそく読んでます(*´艸`)原作はアンナをメインに描かれていて、｢庶民から貴族に〜｣でアネットの話があったので、2巻でアネットと兄さま、ロイドが出てきてびっくりです！！笑きっとなかなか大作の漫画になると思います！原作ではウルッとすることはあっても泣くことなかったけど...同時進行だと時系列が分かって、泣いてしまいました｡ﾟ(PД`q*)ﾟ｡

This review contains spoilers. I read the original story last year, and since it's going to be made into a comic, I'm reading it right away (*'`) The original story mainly depicts Anna, and there was a story about Annette in “From the Common People to the Aristocrats ~”, so I'm surprised that Annette, her older brother, and Lloyd appeared in volume 2!! lol I'm sure it's going to be a pretty big comic! I didn't cry even though I was nervous in the original story... I understood the time series when it was going on at the same time, and I cried. (p`q*)°.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 30, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

1巻は救われないけど2巻を読んでよかった

Volume 1 can't be saved but I'm glad I read volume 2

1巻が悲しい終わり方をしていたので2巻の発売を心待ちにしていました。ヒロインのことを少し理解してくれた2巻の展開に救われました！まだまだハッピーエンドまでいかないので続きが早く読みたいです。

Volume 1 had a sad ending, so I was looking forward to the release of volume 2. I was saved by the development of volume 2, which gave me a little understanding about the heroine! It's still not a happy ending, so I want to read the continuation soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ファンタジーなのにリアル…

fantasy but real...

This review contains spoilers. 原作も読んでます。庶民と貴族、相容れない関係ですが、少しは家族として同じ時間を過ごしたのでお互いに情というものは感じられました。特に兄。漫画の方でもそこまで読めれば良いな?でも弟たちにはちょっとイラッとしました。

This review contains spoilers. I'm also reading the original story. It's an incompatible relationship between the common people and the nobility, but since we spent a little bit of time together as a family, we felt a sense of affection for each other. Especially my brother. it would be nice if even comics could read that far? But I was a little annoyed with my younger brothers.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 09, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる！

I'm worried about the continuation!

This review contains spoilers. 心根の優しいヒロインと優しいお兄様達に囲まれて、そこまで酷い展開にはならないだろうと思ってたのに。。。まさかです。。。とても気になりすぎるので、ノベルがあるようなのでそっちで続きを読もうと思います！笑一番いい子なのはクリューなのかもしれませんね。。。エドはどうなんでしょう。。！続きが楽しみです♪?

This review contains spoilers. Surrounded by a kind-hearted heroine and kind older brothers, I thought it wouldn't be such a terrible development... No way... It bothers me so much that there seems to be a novel, so I'm going to read more there! lol maybe the best kid is Cru... What about Ed...! I'm looking forward to the continuation ♪?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

これからです！！

It's about to begin!!

今はつらいですが、今後主人公が頑張っていくので2巻以降も是非読んでほしいです話をあまりカットされずに長く続いてほしい……

It's hard right now, but the main character is going to do his best in the future, so I want you to read volume 2 and beyond, and I want the story to continue for a long time without being cut too much...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 05, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる‼︎

I'm worried about the continuation ‼ ︎

絵が綺麗で購入したんですがファンタジー系にしてはあまりにも主人公が可哀想で主人公が幸せになればと応援してます！

The picture was beautiful and I bought it, but for a fantasy series, the main character is too pitiful and I'm rooting for the main character to be happy!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 05, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

えっと。。(追記:ナニコレ面白い！)

huh.. (Additional note: Nanikore is interesting!)

(追記:2025/04/27)序盤は本当に「これはない」ってくらいしんどかった。その中で成長していくヒロインと、変わっていく周りとの関係性がとても丁寧に描かれていて、凄くワクワクします。もっと続きが読みたい。皆がハッピーエンドに向かって進んで欲しいと願います。(---以下は1巻読んだ後の感想です---)序盤だし、これからだし、とは思うけど。。もっとキラキラした楽しいお話かと思ってたので、この入り方はちょっとしんどい。物語がある程度進むまでは買います。展開が気になるから。

(Update: 2025/04/27) The beginning was really tough, like “this isn't there.” The relationship between the heroine, who grows in the midst of it, and her changing surroundings is very carefully depicted, and I'm really excited. I want to read more. I want everyone to move towards a happy ending. (---Below are my impressions after reading volume 1---) It's the beginning, and I think it's the beginning... I thought it would be a more sparkling and fun story, so this way of getting into it is a bit tough. I'll buy it until the story progresses to a certain extent. Because I'm worried about developments.

Helpful

Reviews for When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! Manga