When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! Manga Reviews (P.4)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いです

It's interesting

以前ラノベの方を読んでたんですが、途中になってしまっており、漫画を見つけたので読んでみました。最初の方は、主人公が可哀想で読むのが辛いのですが、前向きな主人公が、これから色々挑戦していく楽しい展開になるはずなので、続きを楽しみに待ってます。絵もとても可愛くて好みなので、そこも嬉しいです。

I was reading the light novel before, but it was halfway through, and I found a comic, so I read it. The first one is difficult to read because the main character is pitiful, but it should be a fun development where the positive protagonist will take on various challenges from now on, so I'm looking forward to the continuation. The pictures are also very cute and I like them, so I'm happy about that too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 20, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

目が印象的

The eyes are impressive

This review contains spoilers. まず最初の印象としては目のタッチが綺麗だなぁと。アニメ化になったりしたら、この作品のタッチに合わせて色を淡い感じにしたらめっちゃ映えそうだな……と思いました。運命のいたずらで入れ替わった主人公。血縁が大事な家族（と思っていた）に突き放されるところはどちゃくそ胸が痛くて、兄貴！おまえ！兄貴ぃ！ってすべての怒りを兄貴にぶつけてました。兄貴も辛いのに、ごめんな…と読み進めながら猛省。どこに着地するのか、完結したらまた一気に読みます。

This review contains spoilers. First of all, my first impression was that the eye touch was beautiful. Once it was made into an animation, I thought it would look great if the colors were pale to match the touch of this work... The main character was replaced due to a fateful mischief. My heart hurts so much when I'm banished by my blood relatives (I thought), big brother! you! big brother! I was putting all my anger on my brother. My older brother is having a hard time too, but I'm sorry... while reading on. Once I'm done, I'll read it all at once again about where it will land.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 19, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

登場人物たちの気持ちがわかってからが良い

It's good to understand the characters' feelings

This review contains spoilers. 面白いところはあると思うし、ストーリーが進んでからようやく登場人物たちの気持ちがわかったので、良かったです。妖精の取り替えは大きな問題ではありますが、この作品のストーリーの中で重要なので、我慢して読み続けました。アンナにとっての嬉しい再会があったことが印象的でした。4巻まででは登場人物たちの気持ちの全てがわかったわけではないので、まだまだ読んでみようと思います。

This review contains spoilers. I think there are interesting points, and I'm glad that I finally understood the characters' feelings after the story progressed. Replacing fairies is a big issue, but it's important in the story of this work, so I put up with it and read on. It was impressive that Anna had a happy reunion. I didn't understand all of the characters' feelings until volume 4, so I think I'll read more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

妖精のせいなのに

Even though it's because of fairies

ヒロインは髪の色など両親や兄と違う事、家族と同じ魔法が使えない事など色々気にしてるのにその事に関して何の反応もしない両親って… まだ、兄は優しかったけど、入れ替わっていたとわかった途端のヒロインに対する態度が酷すぎ。ヒロインは何も悪くなくて、全部、妖精のイタズラのせいなのに。ヒロインとヒロインと入れ替わった女の子、両方がハッピーになりますように。

The heroine is different from her parents and older brother, such as her hair color, etc., and her parents don't have any reaction about that even though they are concerned about various things such as not being able to use the same magic as the family... My older brother was still kind, but as soon as I knew they had been replaced, the attitude towards the heroine was too severe. There's nothing wrong with the heroine, and it's all because of fairy pranks. May both the heroine and the girl who was replaced by the heroine be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 15, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

いろいろ言いたいことはある

There are many things I want to say

This review contains spoilers. 主人公が妖精のイタズラでとりかえ子されてしまうお話です。自分の預かり知らないところで起こったことを攻め立てられてどん底に落とされる主人公がどう幸せになっていくのか、とりあえず元凶の妖精は羽をむしってやりたいですね！

This review contains spoilers. It's a story where the main character is taken over as a child due to fairy pranks. I want to see how the main character, who is attacked and dropped to a rock bottom by something that happened in a place he doesn't know, becomes happy, and for now, I want to pluck the fairy, who is the culprit!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 14, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

既刊読破。

Read it already published.

This review contains spoilers. 1巻だけ読んでみようと思ったのが…もう先が気になりすぎて、4巻一気読み。チェンジリングにより庶民と貴族、異なる家系に生まれついてしまった事から始まる二人の女の子のお話。見た目が親兄弟とは違う事で両親や使用人から冷たい扱いを受けてきたアンナ。同じ理由で親との間に壁を感じながら生きてきたアネット。異なる境遇に生まれついた2人の共通点は”逆境に立ち向かう強さ”前向きな所がとても似ている。アンナの婚約者・エドモンドも第一印象嫌な感じでしたが、本音を知って…なんて純愛なんだぁー！かっこいいよエドモンド！ツンで不器用で甘えただけどアンナへの愛は本物。現時点まだすれ違ってるけど届いて欲しいな。チキンサンドクレープなど作中お料理も登場しますが、そこへなんとマルヒノ王国のうどんや米などもあり完全に日本料理。異国を舞台にした魔法世界と日本(いえ、マルヒノ王国。笑)の融合も楽しい作品です。2人の女の子の数奇な運命に胸が苦しくなるシーンには思わず泣いてしまいますが、今後の展開がとても楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. I thought I'd read only volume 1... but I was too worried about the future, so I read all 4 volumes at once. The story of two girls begins when they were born into different families, a common man and an aristocrat due to changeling. Anna has been treated coldly by her parents and servants because her appearance is different from her parents and siblings. Annette has lived while feeling a wall between her parents for the same reason. What the two people born in different circumstances have in common is their “strength to face adversity” and their positivity is very similar. My first impression of Anna's fiancee Edmond was also disgusting, but now that I know her true intentions... what pure love! That's cool Edmond! She was stubborn, clumsy, and spoiled, but her love for Anna is real. I'm still passing by at the moment, but I want it to arrive. Dishes from the recipe, such as chicken sandwich crepes, will also appear, but there is also udon and rice from the Maruhino Kingdom, which is completely Japanese cuisine. A magical world set in a foreign country and Japan (no, Maruhino Kingdom. The fusion of (lol) is also a fun work. I can't help crying at the scene where the strange fate of the two girls makes me feel heartbroken, but I'm really looking forward to future developments.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

チェンジリング

changeling

This review contains spoilers. 妖精によるチェンジリングで庶民と貴族の子供が入れ替わるお話なんですが、1巻で読みやめると悲しい作品です。でも４巻まで来てやっと救いというか、ワクワク感が出て来たように思います。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story where common people and aristocrat children are replaced due to changeling by fairies, but it's a sad work if you stop reading it in volume 1. But I think it wasn't until volume 4 that a sense of excitement, or rather salvation, came out.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

これも運命なのか

Is this also fate

This review contains spoilers. なぜ妖精はこんなに人間を振り回す悪戯をしたのだろう、という疑問がわくのですが、一応自身の悪戯好きな性格のうえに我を通したからという理由で通ってはいるものの、その真の答えについては恐らくラストのシーンに描かれるのではないかと予測しています。また、ヒロインに着目すると、この作品のなかで一番可哀想な境遇なのは、貴族から庶民に格下げされて苦労しているアンナでしょうか。すべてを失って失望する、と思いきや、ようやく庶民の生活のなかに新たな出会いと発見をするという、ひとすじの光が垣間見えている状況です。これから何が起きるのか。もう一人の庶民育ち→貴族格上げになったヒロイン、アネットの生き方にも目を向けながら、これからの続編を読んでいきたいと思います。

This review contains spoilers. The question arises as to why the fairies played such a prank that swayed humans, but although they went there for the time being because they passed through their own mischievous personality, I'm predicting that the true answer will probably be depicted in the last scene. Also, focusing on the heroine, the most pitiful situation in this work is probably Anna, who is struggling after being downgraded from an aristocrat to a common man. It is a situation where I can catch a glimpse of a glimmer of light, where I think I will lose everything and be disappointed, but at last, new encounters and discoveries are made in the lives of the common people. What's going to happen next? I would like to read future sequels while also looking at the way of life of Annette, the heroine who grew up as a common man → rose to the rank of aristocrat.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

赤ちゃんの時に

When I was a baby

This review contains spoilers. 妖精の悪戯で取り違えられて大きくなってから元の家に戻されて生活していっていますがアンナとエドモンドはどうなるのか続きが気になります。

This review contains spoilers. They were mistaken up due to fairy pranks and have been living back to their original home since they grew up, but I'm worried about the continuation of what will happen to Anna and Edmond.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

切ないお話です

It's a sad story

妖精のイタズラで2人の赤ちゃんが入れ替わり…突拍子もない始まりでファンタジー系なのかなぁと思ってたら、結構境遇や心情がシリアスに描かれてて引き込まれました。2人の女の子が現実を捉えて気を強く持って前に進んでいく勇ましさ？がまたグッときます。次巻が待ち遠しい！しかし…敢えて言うなら、タイトルがアンマッチで惜しいです?

The two babies were replaced in a fairy prank... it started out of nowhere and when I was wondering if it was a fantasy series, the circumstances and feelings were depicted quite seriously, and I was drawn in. How brave are the two girls to seize reality and move forward with a strong sense of strength? It's going to be a surprise again. I can't wait for the next volume! But... dare I say that the title is unmatched and it's a pity?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

はやく続きが読みたい

I want to read the continuation soon

イラストも内容も全てどストライクでした。ふたりとも幸せになって欲しい。はやく続きが読みたいです?

The illustrations and content were all a strike. I want them both to be happy. Want to read more soon?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 21, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

新しい生活

A new life

This review contains spoilers. 置いて行かれたときはどうなるのかと思ったけれど新しい家族とも少しずつ打ち解け、町のなかでは思いがけない人との出逢いもあり話がすすんでいき次がたのしみです。主人公が前向きなのがいいですね。

This review contains spoilers. I was wondering what would happen when I was left behind, but little by little, I was able to get along with my new family, and the story progressed due to encounters with unexpected people in the town, and I'm looking forward to the next one. It's nice that the main character is positive.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

けなげな主人公

Naughty protagonist

けなげな主人公が妖精のいたずらに翻弄されつつもたくましく暮らしていく物語。あまりご都合主義が少なくて主人公がとにかく大変なめに遭うのに、ガッツがあって頑張り屋で少し読んでいて胸が痛みます。絵がおとぎ話のように美しいのが気に入りました。

This is a story where the playful protagonist lives a strong life while being at the mercy of fairy mischief. There isn't much expediency, and even though the main character gets in trouble anyway, it hurts my heart when I read it a little bit because he has guts and works hard. I loved how beautiful the picture was as beautiful as in a fairy tale.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 12, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

アンナのこれからが気になる❗️

I'm worried about Anna's future ❗️

一気に読んでしまうくらい、面白い。おすすめの１冊。お兄さんとのこと、婚約者との未来、そして2つの家族。アンナのこれからが楽しみで、不安で、続きが早くでないかないっぱい想像しちゃう‼️

It's so interesting that I read it all at once. One book I recommend. My older brother, my future with my fiancé, and my two families. I'm looking forward to Anna's future, I'm anxious, and I can't help but imagine the continuation isn't quick ‼️

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 12, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

もうだめ

Not anymore

This review contains spoilers. 徹夜して一気に読んでもうた。唯一の味方だった兄に見限られたアンナの気持ちを考えるとページを直視できないくらい辛かった。エドモンドとなんらかの形できっと幸せになって欲しいよ…お願い。

This review contains spoilers. I stayed up all night and read it all at once. It was so painful that I couldn't look directly at the page when I thought about Anna's feelings of being limited by her older brother, who was my only ally. I want Edmond to be happy in some way... please.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

なんだか泣けてくる

Somehow it makes me cry

アンナもアネットもいいこ！本当にいいこ！だからこそ二人が妖精のイタズラで要らぬ苦労をしているのは見ていてつらい。健気に前向きに生きていこうとするから更に泣けてくる。多くの人に読んで欲しい!!

Anna and Annette are good too! This is really good! That's why it's so hard to watch the two go through unnecessary hardships due to fairy pranks. It makes me cry even more because I try to live a healthy and positive life. I want many people to read it!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

感動

touching

これ系のお話って昔からあって、とてもスキなんです。もともとスキなうえにまたこちらのお話は、とても素敵で絵まで素敵。涙涙で3カンまで完読しました。ほんとうにステキ。しばらく本は買わないって決めてたのに…どーしても続きが読みたくてポイント買ってポチポチしてしまいました。最後まで読みたいです。重いお話なので好き嫌いはわかれると思います。おきをつけて。

This type of story has been around for a long time, and I really like it. In addition to being original, this story is also very wonderful, and even the pictures are wonderful. I read up to 3 words with tears in my eyes. It's really nice. I had decided not to buy books for a while... but I wanted to read more no matter what, so I bought points and ended up poking around. I want to read it to the end. It's a heavy story, so I think we can share likes and dislikes. Put on Oki

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

とても良くできたおとぎ話

A very well-made fairy tale

主人公が穏やか健気、賢くて好き。絵が上手で、人物の気持ちもよく伝わってくるし、正統派なおとぎ話を見ている気分。応援してます！

I like the main character because he is calm, healthy, and smart. The picture is good, the feelings of the characters are conveyed very well, and I feel like I'm watching an orthodox fairy tale. I'm rooting for you!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公がけなげで明るくて良い

It's good that the main character is abusive and bright

妖精のイタズラで生活が一変した二人。二人のこれからに目が離せなくなりました。生活の中で使う魔法もファンタジー過ぎず、こんな魔法が使えたらなぁと。貴族の両親は冷たくて、こんな酷い家族いる？と思ったけど、ホントはどんな気持ちでいるんだろう。節約中だけど続きが気になって買ってしまう。

They are two people whose lives have completely changed due to fairy pranks. I couldn't take my eyes off the future of the two of them. The magic I use in my daily life isn't too much fantasy, and I wish I could use this kind of magic. Aristocrat parents are cold, are there such terrible families? I thought, but I wonder how they really feel. I'm saving money, but I'm worried about the continuation and end up buying it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 09, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい妖精との新しい生活は？

How about a new life with a beautiful fairy?

妖精のいたずらで貴族として暮らしていた主人公、美しい妖精と新しい家族、新しい友達、旧知のメイド、・・・とともに、強く生き抜こうとしている。素直な言葉を紡げなかった元婚約者も会うことを考えているのかな？これからの展開が、楽しみです。

Together with the main character, who lived as an aristocrat due to fairy pranks, a beautiful fairy, a new family, new friends, an old maid... they are trying to survive strongly. I wonder if my former fiancé, who couldn't speak honest words, is also thinking about meeting him? I'm looking forward to future developments.

Helpful

Reviews for When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! Manga