Silver Spoon Manga Reviews (P.4)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

もっと若い頃に読みたかった

I wish I had read it when I was younger

ハガレンからきました。180度違う内容なのにこちらもめちゃくちゃ面白い。素晴らしい内容。紙媒体でもほしい！子供にも読ませたい！

I'm from Hagaren. Even though the content is 180 degrees different, this one is also insanely interesting. Great content. I want it on paper too! I want my kids to read it too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 16, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

楽しく学べる

It's fun to learn

農業高校のリアルな様子を通して、食の大切さが学べる上、登場人物それぞれが成長するところを見守れて楽しめる作品です。そして、美味しそうなピザやベーコンが食べたくなります（笑）

In addition to being able to learn the importance of food through realistic scenes of agricultural high schools, it is a work where you can enjoy watching each of the characters grow. And it makes me want to eat delicious pizza and bacon (laughs)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

読んでよかったと思える作品でした

It was a work I'm glad I read

タイトルを知ってる程度でなんとなく読み始めましたが、最後まで一気に読んでしまいした。どの登場人物たちもキャラが濃く、その中で非農家の八軒くんが悩みに悩んで皆と一緒に進んでいく、一風変わった高校生活にちょっと元気をもらえました。また、みんなの美味しいものに対する飽くなき執念といいますか高いテンションが、「命を育ていただく」ことを重くなりすぎずに読ませてくれます。

Somehow I started reading it when I knew the title, but I read it all at once until the end. All of the characters have strong characters, and among them, Hachiken-kun, a non-farmer, struggles with his worries and progresses with everyone, and I was energized a little bit by an unusual high school life. Also, the high level of tension, which is called everyone's insatiable obsession with delicious food, makes me read “Grow Your Life” without getting too heavy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 25, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

青春

youth

時々これを読みたくなります。高校時代もっと楽しんでおけばよかったな、、、

Sometimes I want to read this. I wish I had more fun in high school...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 26, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

生き物や食品への価値観を変える漫画！

A comic that changes values living things and food!

This review contains spoilers. 生き物の勉強にもなるし、何より食品を見る目が変わりました。消費者側には知られてない生産者側の思いや技術等見られたし、豚の体脂肪が人の平均より低いのにはびっくりしました！これだけ農耕について描けたとしても、やはり作者が農家出身だからこそ学校内での事も描けたんだと思います。何より学校の先生も生徒も、みんなキャラが凄く良かった！重機をチャチャッとアレンジしたり、業者に頼むであろう機械を作っちゃったり…笑。そして、それまで興味なかった馬も、最近は観てるだけで「この馬綺麗だなー」と思うようにもなりました。馬にも種類があった事もこの漫画を見るまで知りませんでした。最終巻は八軒父の笑顔、センターや受験時に細ぉ～くなった八軒と相川に大爆笑し、常磐に子供が2人目産まれそうだったり、みんなそれぞれのその後も見られて良かったです！何より最後の最後に駒場と八軒を見せてくれて嬉しかった！卒業式の時のみんなの叫びが「脱・奴隷」てなのにも笑いました！卒業生が後片付けするとこも(笑)本当に様々な勉強をさせてくれたコミックです。学校内で事あれば焼肉したり、ご飯したり、富士先生がビール持ち寄ってくるとこも大好きでした！ありがとうございました、そして別のコミックの新刊もお待ちしてます♡

This review contains spoilers. It also taught me about living things, and above all, my way of looking at food changed. I was able to see the producers' thoughts and techniques that were unknown to the consumer side, and I was surprised that the body fat of pigs was lower than the average human average! Even if I was able to draw this much about farming, I still think I was able to draw things at school because the author came from a farmhouse. Above all, the school teachers and students all had really good characters! They quickly arranged heavy equipment and made machines they would ask a contractor... lol. Also, I've come to think “this horse is beautiful” just by watching horses that I wasn't interested in until then. I didn't know that there were different types of horses until I watched this comic. The final volume is Hachiken's father's smile, and they burst out laughing at the center and at Hachiken and Aikawa, who became thin during the entrance exam, and it seemed like their second child would be born in Joban, so I'm glad everyone was able to watch it even after that! Above all, I was happy that they showed me Komaba and Hachiken at the very end! I laughed even though everyone's cry at the graduation ceremony was “escape slavery”! It's a comic that really made me study a lot, even though the alumni clean up after themselves (laughs). I loved the fact that Fuji-sensei brought beer for yakiniku and meals if anything happened at school! Thank you and I'm looking forward to the new publication of another comic ♡

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ええ話や

Yeah, that's a story

非農家の主人公を通して描かれていく、育てる命、頂く命に囲まれた世界。彼は悩み、仲間と共に励み、教師や先輩に教えられ、時には体も壊して、体当たりで農・畜産業の大変さ、厳しさ、楽しさ、美しさ、そして有難さを学んでいく。主人公の成長が温かく活き活きとした視点で描かれていて、読んでいて心地の良い作品。

A world surrounded by lives to raise and lives to receive, depicted through the protagonist who is a non-farmer. He struggled, worked hard with his peers, was taught by his teachers and seniors, sometimes broke his body, and learned the difficulties, harshness, fun, beauty, and gratitude of the agriculture and livestock industry. The main character's growth is depicted from a warm and lively perspective, and it is a comfortable work to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

元気が出るリアル学生生活

A real student life that gives you energy

この人たちホントに高校生なの???ってかんじがしますけど面白いです。長いので少しずつ読んでいますが今のところ外れはないです。

are these guys really high school students??? I have a feeling, but it's interesting. It's a long time, so I'm reading it little by little, but so far nothing is off.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 28, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

最後まで面白かった

It was fun until the end

最初から最後まで面白かったですねー。農業高校の現実、農家や酪農家の現実。駒場が幸せそうだったのが良かったです。

It was fun from beginning to end. The reality of agricultural high schools, the reality of farmers and dairy farmers. It was good that Komaba seemed happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

とても面白い

It's very interesting

This review contains spoilers. 連載の終わり方は、少し残念なところもあったけど、農業高校の事や家畜達野菜の勉強も出来て、そうだったんだ！っていうのが沢山ありました。主人公は、鶏の卵が産まれる仕組みを聞いて卵が食べれなくなってたみたいだけど(笑)豚丼ちゃんの回は私も考えてしまいました。可愛がっていた豚を手放すのは、辛い！しかし、美味しいからね、、、。もっと遅くなる産まれてきていたら、この漫画に感化されて農業高校に行っていたかもしれない。ミーハーだから。(笑)

This review contains spoilers. The way the series ended was a bit disappointing, but I was able to study agricultural high schools and livestock and vegetables, and that was it! There were a lot of things like that. The main character heard about the mechanism by which chicken eggs are laid and seems to have become unable to eat eggs (laughs), but I also thought about Butadon-chan's episode. It's hard to let go of a pig you loved! But because it's delicious... If I had been born much later, I might have been inspired by this comic and went to an agricultural high school. Because it's Meeher. (lol)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 12, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

いやー、荒川さんは人格者ですね〜。ハガレンもそうだけど、人生の糧となる作品を生み出してくれてありがとうございます！

Well, Arakawa-san is a person with personality. As is the case with Hagaren, thank you for creating works that will feed my life!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 31, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

出てくる食材が美味しそう

The ingredients that come out look delicious

出てくる食材や料理が美味しそうすぎてやばいです。本当の農林学校？もこんな感じで楽しいのかな？

It's crazy that the ingredients and food that come out look so delicious. A real agricultural and forestry school? I wonder if it's fun like this too?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

農業最高。帯広最高。

Agriculture is the best. Obihiro is the best.

農業従事者な身内が多い私にとって農業の理不尽なところ農業のロマンがあるところ答えのない世界で生きる過酷とやりがいの中をさまよい続けるリアルなこの漫画全国の学校の図書館に寄贈したいレベル笑笑

I have many relatives who are agricultural workers, what is unreasonable for me is that there is the romance of agriculture, living in a world with no answers, this realistic comic that continues to wander through the harshness and rewards I want to donate to school libraries all over the country lol lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 25, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

いい教科書

good textbook

酪農中心ですが、社会に出る前の学生が抱える不安をしっかりと描写していて、それを楽に解決せず、悩み抜いて落とし所を見つけていく、そんな内容の漫画でした。漫画でもその内容から受けとれる部分は多く、現役高校生は一度見ておいた方が良いと思うほどリアル寄りでしたね。ただ、主人公の八軒くんの性格がネガティブスタートな感じなので、ｲﾗｯとするポイントがいくつかありました?

It's centered around dairy farming, but it was a comic with such content that clearly depicts the anxiety students have before they go out into society, and they don't solve it easily, get rid of their worries and find lost places. Even in comics, there are many parts that can be taken from that content, and active high school students were so close to reality that they thought it would be better to watch them once. However, since it feels like the personality of the main character, Hachiken-kun, had a negative start, there were some irritating points?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 17, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

元気出ます

It cheers up

作者買いしました。青春時代はとうに通り越している年齢ですが、登場人物達の情熱に当てられて、頑張らなくては……と言う気持ちにさせてくれます。面白いし、心に残る作品です。

The author bought it. I'm at an age where I've already passed through my youth, but the passion of the characters hits me and makes me feel like I have to work hard... It's an interesting and memorable work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

青春

youth

再読。朝ドラなつぞらをふと思い出しました。自分で手塩にかけて育てた命を自分の手で殺し頂く。かなり衝撃を受けました。身近に酪農家がいないため、遠い話のようでしたが、この漫画を読んで生きるってそういうことだったなーと考えさせられました。主人公を取り巻く仲間たちが個性的でそれぞれの道、思うようにいけない子もいたけど、応援したいです。

reread. I suddenly remembered the morning drama Natsuzora. Have your own hands kill a life you raised on your own. I was quite shocked. There were no dairy farmers close to me, so it seemed like a far away story, but it made me think that's what it was like to live by reading this comic. The friends surrounding the main character are unique, and there were children who didn't go the way they wanted, but I want to support them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 30, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

好きです

I like it

アニメで先に見ました！楽しいです。私も酪農関係の大学行っていたので共感できる部分があったりとても楽しんで読んでます。楽しいだけではなく、食について考える事もあるので食育の入門にも良いかな？

I watched it earlier in the anime! It's fun. I also went to a university related to dairy farming, so I really enjoyed reading it because there are parts I can sympathize with. Not only is it fun, but it also makes you think about food, so is it a good introduction to dietary education?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 22, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

泣ける動物愛

Crying animal love

This review contains spoilers. 見た目はなかなかの主人公ですが、人と動物と関わることで成長していく姿はとても涙なしでは見られない作品ですがそれだけではなく時々出てくる動物の解説などかとても分かりやすくコメディ要素も入っているから笑いながら見れる作品でした

This review contains spoilers. It looks like it's quite the protagonist, but it's a work that can't be seen growing by getting involved with people and animals, but not only that, but it also contains comedic elements that are very easy to understand, such as animal explanations that come up from time to time, so it was a work you can watch while laughing

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

お腹が減る

I'm hungry

面白い上に、勉強になり、食べることが嬉しくなる漫画。この作品に出会えてよかった。

Besides being interesting, it's a comic that makes you learn and makes you happy to eat. I'm glad I came across this work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

お腹が空いた…

I'm hungry...

市販の牛乳を飲んでもチーズを食べても…これ、あの牧場とれたてverならば、どうなんだろう？！ってそればかりを考えちゃう…

Whether you drink commercial milk or eat cheese... what would this be like if it were freshly caught from that farm?! That's all I think about...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

農業高校いいぞ〜

Agricultural high school is good ~

こんなガチガチな農業高校じゃなかったけど、そこでしかない経験ができるという面で、この漫画をよめば農業高校に行きたくなると思います！食のこと命のこと沢山考える事ができますよ！

It wasn't such a crappy agricultural high school, but in terms of being able to have an experience that can only be found there, I think reading this comic will make you want to go to an agricultural high school! You can think a lot about food and life!

Helpful

Reviews for Silver Spoon Manga