Polaris at Dawn Manga Reviews (P.9)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

単行本派の方は見ないでください

Please don't look at the book book group

This review contains spoilers. 話の展開が急すぎて何回も読み返してはいたんですが、２巻の続きがどうしても読みたくてコミック誌に手を出してしまいました（バカだ）だってあの終わり方はズルいじゃないですか！早くふたりが再会してるところを見て安心したかったんで…す。でもって煌星が教師になっていたのでそれなりの月日が経っているのはわかりましたが６年もかあ…て考えちゃうとなんかもう彼女をとっかえひっかえしていた初期の煌星の様子からは想像できないです。それだけ由良のことが好きなんだなーて思うのと同時に絶対報われて欲しいってのが正直な気持ちです。煌星は自虐ぽく執着と言っていたけど６年はさすがに長いよ…うん。あとですね、冒頭でちゃんと教師している（？）煌星がとても好印象でした。数学教師になったのも伏線だったのかな。このあとの展開は単行本になるまで待つつもりだけど、うーん我慢できずに追ってしまうかも知れません（笑

This review contains spoilers. The development of the story was so rapid that I reread it over and over again, but I wanted to read the continuation of volume 2 no matter what, so I tried my hand at comic magazines (that's stupid), but that way it ended was misleading! I wanted to feel relieved to see the two reunited as soon as possible... But since Korusei was my teacher, I know that a certain number of months and days have passed, but when I think about it, 6 years... I can't imagine it from the appearance of Kōsei in the early days when she had somehow overtaken her. I think I love Yura that much, and at the same time, I honestly want her to be rewarded. They said that Kosei was obsessed with self-deprecation, but 6 years is really a long time... yeah. Also, they taught properly at the beginning (?) The brilliant star made a very good impression. I wonder if it was a premonition that I became a math teacher. I'm going to wait until it becomes a book for further developments, but hmm, I may not be able to put up with it and follow along (lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる

I'm worried about the continuation

SNSで試しに読んでみて気になったので購入しました。思っていた展開と違う、、！これからが楽しみな作品です！

I tried reading it on SNS and was curious, so I bought it. It's different from what I expected...! It's a work I'm looking forward to from now on!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 30, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

早まった笑

hastened lol

2巻で完結していると思い込み購入。まさかのまだ続いていた…！まだ読める嬉しさと、早く先を読みたいもどかしさで「ウワーーー」となっております。好きな作者さんですが、今までで1番好きかもしれない…各者の感情がきちんと描かれていてみんなに感情移入してしまう。みんな幸せになってくれ…！

I bought it under the assumption that it was completed in 2 volumes. Unexpectedly, it was still going on...! It's “wow” because of the joy of still being able to read it and the frustration of wanting to read ahead quickly. It's my favorite author, but it's probably my favorite until now... the emotions of each person are properly depicted, and I empathize with everyone. May everyone be happy...!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

表紙から想像できないし軽率に読めない

I can't imagine it from the cover and I can't read it carelessly

読み終わって、うわぁ……と軽率に読んだのを後悔しているところです。表紙見て試し読みした時に生徒×先生、関係が邪魔しながらもイチャイチャしてるお話なのかと思いきや……めちゃくちゃ重くて深くて想像もしてない内容でした。由良ちゃんに感情移入してしまって涙涙になってしまい、しまいには2巻最後の描き下ろしであぁ、、とトドメ刺されました。最初の体育祭の感じどこいったの？！？！ずっとあの幸せなページに滞在したかった(笑)どの人物の気持ちになってもつらい。心が元気な時じゃないと読める気がしません、、、続きが気になります！！！頼むから、、、お願いだからみんな幸せになってくれ……

I've finished reading it, and I regret reading it carelessly, wow... When I looked at the cover and tried reading it, I thought it was a story about students and teachers flirting even though the relationship got in the way... it was so heavy and deep that I hadn't even imagined it. I empathized with Yura-chan and ended up in tears, and at the end of the day, it was drawn at the end of volume 2, and I was stabbed so bad... Where was the feeling of the first sports festival?!?! I've always wanted to stay on that happy page (laughs) It's hard no matter who you feel like. I don't feel like I can read it until my mind is fine... I'm worried about the continuation!!! I beg you... please make everyone happy...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

難しいなあ

that's difficult

This review contains spoilers. 1巻からは想像できない深い過去があって今のところ光が見えないけど、煌星が夜明けを意味するならハピエンを期待します、、つらくて見ていられない（ ; ; ）でもストーリーも絵も好きです！

This review contains spoilers. There is a deep past that I can't imagine from volume 1, so I can't see the light so far, but if brilliant stars mean dawn, I expect Happien... it's too hard to watch (;;), but I love the story and pictures!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

思ったより重い話すぎた・・・

It was too heavy a story than I thought...

This review contains spoilers. 最初絵が可愛いし展開も楽しく見てたんだけど、2巻からの重さがやばいやばい。まさかのこんな展開だとは思わなかったから結構しんどい。みんながみんな救われたらって思うけど無理なのかもなと諦めてるけど、前に進んでハッピーエンドになってくれたらいいなぁ

This review contains spoilers. At first, the pictures were cute and I enjoyed watching the development, but the weight from volume 2 onwards was awful. I didn't think it would unexpectedly unfold like this, so it's pretty tough. I wish everyone could be saved, but I've given up wondering if it's impossible, but it would be nice if they moved forward and had a happy ending

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 08, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

想像以上に重たい話だった

It was a heavier story than I had imagined

美人な生徒だと思ったら、男の先生だった。って感じから始まるからそんな重たい話だと思わず買っちゃいました。そしてまだ続きそうだし先の展開がめちゃくちゃ気になる。気持ちの揺れとか表情とか言葉遣いで読者側もガンガン気持ちが揺さぶられて、感情が大暴走でした！

I thought he was a beautiful student, but he was a male teacher. It starts with that feeling, so I bought it without thinking it was such a heavy story. And it seems like it's still going on, and I'm really worried about future developments. The readers' feelings were also shaken by the shaking feelings, facial expressions, and wording, and their emotions went wild!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ハマった。。。

I'm addicted to it...

This review contains spoilers. 2巻からグイグイ引き込まれて、なんかもー、心臓持たないです。。。正直絵の雰囲気は好みじゃなかったけど、ストーリーに引き込まれて、何度も読み返しました。せつない。それはもうせつない。それでも前に進もうと、懸命にもがく3人の気持ちに、次号も寄り添いたいと思いました。

This review contains spoilers. I was so drawn in from volume 2, and somehow... I don't have a heart... To be honest, I didn't like the atmosphere of the picture, but I was drawn into the story and reread it over and over again. That's annoying. That's no longer bothersome. Nevertheless, I wanted the next issue to be close to the feelings of the three people struggling so hard to move forward.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ぎゅうぎゅうで切ない。流石嘉島先生。。?

It's so tight that it's sad. As a matter of fact, Kashima sensei...?

2巻を読み終えてもう白旗。1巻から通して3回繰り返し読んで、次巻が出るまであと1年ほど待たないといけないと知り絶望してます。今すぐ続きをください。単話売りの検討をお願いします。

I've finished reading volume 2 and it's already Shirahata. I read it over and over again 3 times starting with volume 1, and I'm in despair when I know that I'll have to wait about 1 year until the next volume comes out. Please continue right now. Please consider selling a single episode.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

がんばってーー！

good luck!

This review contains spoilers. ２巻でレビューしちゃいます。めちゃくちゃハマりました。羽賀くんがチャラくて、先生と出会って本当の恋を知って上手くまとまる話かなー？と思っていたら、、、。続きが楽しみな作品に出会えて嬉しいです。羽賀君がこの話の世界を変えてくれるんだろうなと思うけど、こんなに応援したくなるなんて、、、羽賀くん！頑張って！！

This review contains spoilers. I'm going to review it in volume 2. I'm insanely addicted to it. I wonder if it's a story where Haga-kun is playful, meets his teacher, knows his true love, and comes together well? If you were thinking... I'm happy to come across a work that I'm looking forward to continuing. I think Haga-kun is going to change the world of this story, but I can't help but... Haga-kun! Good luck!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

つ、続き読みたいです?

Do you want to read more?

良かったです！！！切なくて、でも、綺麗で。ドキドキしました。続きが早く読みたい、とか、推理小説バリです笑ほんとによかったなぁ。。。

That was great!!! It's sad, but it's beautiful. It was exciting. I want to read the continuation as soon as possible, it's a mystery novel Bali lol I'm really glad...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

うわあ…切ない…

wow... sad...

This review contains spoilers. 先生と生徒と先生と…えええ？プライベートなことを何も教えてくれないのは、ただの生徒としか思ってないから？それでも暴こうとするのは、執着？恋？過去を知った上での言動と、決断と、そしてそれぞれの揺れる心…どれも切ない。程良いテンポと情報量で、置き去りになった気持ちと、時間の流れと、向き合おうとすることが、読む者のことも置き去りにしないギリギリのところで進んでいて、それがさらに切なさを増幅する。特に、2巻の後半の書き下ろし？がまた切ない。なんとも言えない切なさと寂しさで、胸がギュッとなった。ああもう、語彙が無くて、うまく説明できないけど、みんな可愛いんだよな。切ないんだよな。絵がとにかく好き。で、早く続きが読みたい。

This review contains spoilers. teacher, student, teacher... huh? Why don't you tell me anything private is because they only think they're just students? Still trying to uncover it is obsession? love? The words and actions after knowing the past, the decisions made, and their respective shaky hearts... all are sad. With just the right tempo and amount of information, trying to face the feeling of being left behind and the flow of time progresses at the last minute without leaving the reader behind, which further amplifies the sadness. In particular, the latter half of volume 2 was written down? It's sad again. My heart was tight because of the indescribable sadness and loneliness. Oh, I don't have any vocabulary anymore, so I can't explain it well, but they're all cute. it's sad, isn't it? I love the picture anyway. So, I want to read more soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

どちらもカワイイ

They're both cute

This review contains spoilers. 生徒であるハガ君も一途でカワイイ。先生の由良ちゃんも文句無しにカワイイでどっちも応援したくなります。早くくっ付くといいのに〜

This review contains spoilers. Haga, who is a student, is also extremely cute. My teacher, Yura, is also so cute and I want to cheer for both of them. I hope they stick together soon~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

わ〜

wow

This review contains spoilers. まさかのまだ終わってないだった?先生が可愛くてぐいぐい読まされました。話の流れはこうなるだろうなぁ、って思うのが当たってしまう期待を裏切らない物でしたがこっから先はどうなるのかな。切ない系ですが、なんとなく安心して読める作品でありましは

This review contains spoilers. it really isn't over yet? The teacher was so cute that it made me read it a lot. It didn't disappoint my expectations when I thought the flow of the story would be like this, but I wonder what will happen from here on out. It's a sad series, but somehow it's a work I can read with peace of mind

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 30, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

良きっ(*´ー｀*)

That's good (*'-`*)

まさか続きものと思わずに購入ー。さらりと読めますー◎２巻に進むといろいろ納得。続きが気になりますー( *´艸｀)

I bought it without thinking it would be a continuation. I can read it without hesitation — ◎ I was convinced of many things when I moved on to volume 2. I'm worried about the continuation (*'`)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 30, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

とりあえず続きを早く読みたい作品。キラキラしたストーリーからのギャップが凄かった。レビューを読んで気になった方は是非。オススメです。

Anyway, I want to read the continuation as soon as possible. The gap from the sparkling story was amazing. If you read the reviews and are interested, don't miss it. I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 25, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻……！！！

volume 2...!!!

This review contains spoilers. 2巻まで読了。先生に恋した生徒くんの可愛い話かな？とか、養護教諭との三角関係かな？とかるんるんで1巻読んでたのですが、とんでもない。2巻最初から最後までずっとトラップしかなくて心臓ギュッと鷲掴み状態でした……。おおう……。2巻描き下ろしの柊真(養護教諭)の心にまたも心臓ギュッとなりました……。みんな幸せになってほしい……。続刊お待ちしております……。早く読みたい……。

This review contains spoilers. I've read up to 2 volumes. Is this a cute story about a student who falls in love with his teacher? Or maybe a triangular relationship with a school nurse? I was reading volume 1 of Karunrun, and it was ridiculous. From the beginning to the end of volume 2, there were only traps, and I was in a state where I was gripping the eagle tightly... ooh... My heart was once again tight in the heart of Makoto Hiiragi (school nurse), who drew volume 2... I want everyone to be happy... I'm looking forward to the next issue... I want to read it soon...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

え、、、えぐりとられた心.ぞう

Eh... gouged heart... elephant

This review contains spoilers. えぐい重たい辛いむり悲しいすごいスートリーがしっかりしすぎててやばい幸せになって欲しい全員がつらい幸せになって欲しい表紙に騙されたこんなもっとハピハピHappyーーーー！！！！！かな思っておもったらえっっっっっぐぅぅぅぁ！！！！！！！！やないの！！！心臓痛かった痛かった面白かった羽賀頑張って頑張って由良ちゃん乗り越えられるといいな

This review contains spoilers. so heavy, painful, sad, so amazing, so solid that I want them to be so happy that everyone wants to be so happy I was fooled by the cover that I want them to be so happy, so much happier!!!! when I thought about it, huh huh!!!!!! I'm not going to do it!!! My heart hurt it was painful it was funny Haga I hope Yura can do my best and overcome it

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

こうきたか！

this is it!

This review contains spoilers. 思ってた感じと違うストーリー展開で、深く重い気持ちになりました。ここで終わってしまうのか…と。それぞれの抱えてたものが、それぞれでしか解決出来ないですよね。どんなに言葉尽くしても高校生の言葉は先生に届かなかった。そして、大人になった彼。これからですよね。みんな前へ進むんだとは思いますがどのように進めていくのかとても楽しみです。早く3巻読みたいです。

This review contains spoilers. The story unfolding was different from what I had anticipated, and it made me feel deep and heavy. I wonder if it's going to end here... What they each have can only be solved with their own, right? No matter how many words I tried, the words of the high school students didn't reach their teachers. Then, he became an adult. From now on, right? I think everyone is moving forward, but I'm really excited to see how it progresses. I want to read volume 3 soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

This review contains spoilers. 胸がギュッと張り裂ける気持ちです。泣けました。続きがが気になりすぎて夜しか寝れませんがそれまで何度も読み返そうと思います！！早くくっついて幸せになれる未来がきますように！！

This review contains spoilers. It's a feeling that makes my heart feel tight and torn. It made me cry. I'm so worried about the continuation that I can only sleep at night, but I think I'll reread it over and over until then! May the future come where we can quickly stick together and be happy!!

Helpful

Reviews for Polaris at Dawn Manga