Polaris at Dawn Manga Reviews (P.10)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻の大ボリュームが凄い！

The large volume of volume 2 is amazing!

絵柄に惹かれて購入しましたがもう何度も読み直しているぐらい好きです！生徒教師CPは流され教師が苦手なのですが、由良ちゃんは教師倫理観強くて安心します。押し強い陽キャDKが美人教師に迫るわちゃわちゃラブコメかと思いきや、2巻で全貌がわかり切ない展開に…羽賀の真っ直ぐな一途に泣けます。二人の押問答が好きで、すぐにくっ付かないのがまた良いです。経過がすごくドラマなのでもっと見たい気持ちと、くっ付いて幸せな由良ちゃんを早く見たい気持ちと…1巻出た後も思いましたが早く続きが見たくなる作品です！

I bought it because I was attracted to the design, but I love it so much that I've reread it over and over again! Student Teacher CP has been swept away and teachers aren't good at it, but I'm relieved that Yura has a strong sense of teacher ethics. I thought it was a wacky romantic comedy where the strong Yo-Ka DK approaches a beautiful teacher, but in volume 2, the whole story is unclear... I can't understand the whole story... it makes me cry all over Haga. I like the questions and answers between the two of them, and it's also good that they don't stick together right away. It's a drama with a lot of progress, so the feeling that I want to watch more, and the feeling that I want to watch Yura-chan who sticks together and is happy as soon as possible... I thought even after volume 1 came out, but it's a work that makes me want to watch the continuation soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

1巻から一体誰がこの展開を予想出来たか.

Who on earth was able to predict this development from volume 1...

良い意味で裏切られました。ただ一言、それだけです。自分の中で「突き刺さって消えない」作品になりました。こういう本質的なBLをずっと求めてました。いや、これはガチでやばいって.... 一気に歴代首位レベル...。

I was betrayed in a good way. Just one word, that's all. It has become a work that “pierces and won't disappear” within me. I've been looking for this kind of essential BL for a long time. No, this is ridiculous... the highest level in history all at once...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

まだ続く～⤴⤴⤴

It's still going on ~ ⤴⤴⤴

This review contains spoilers. 1、2巻一気読みして、まだ余韻に浸ってます。いや、続けて読んで良かった。1巻の途中までは煌星の完璧陽キャぶりが好きになれなかったんだけど、大好きな由良ちゃんを暗闇の過去から陽の当たる今へと引っ張りあげようとする真っ直ぐさとか言葉の一つ一つに涙が出そうになった。いいこと言うよね高校生のガキンチョなのに…(だからアオハルが好きなんだ)今のところエロはないけど、大満足です。2巻の終わりは柊真の心の中を覗いて終わって、これからどーなるのか楽しみでしょうがない。

This review contains spoilers. I read volumes 1 and 2 all at once, and I'm still immersed in the afterglow. No, I'm glad I kept reading. Until the middle of volume 1, I didn't fall in love with Korosei's Perfect Sun Caburi, but I almost burst into tears at every one of the words that tried to pull my favorite Yura-chan from her dark past to the present day when the sun shines. Nice thing to say, even though I'm a high school girl... (that's why I like Aoharu) There's no erotica so far, but I'm very satisfied. The end of volume 2 is over with a peek into the heart of Makoto Hiiragi, and I can't help but look forward to seeing what happens in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻

Volume 2

This review contains spoilers. 1巻で何かあるんだな〜とは思っていましたが2巻。2巻やばいです。いやこれゆらちゃんと柊真の気持ちの交錯が凄すぎる。真白が出てきた事で更にぐっと深まる感じが堪らんです。早く続きくださーーーい！！

This review contains spoilers. I thought there would be something in volume 1, but volume 2. Volume 2 is terrible. No, the mixture of feelings between Yura-chan and Makoto Hiiragi is too amazing. Now that True White has come out, I can't stand the feeling that it has deepened even more. please continue soon!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

早く夜明けがきてほしい〜〜！！

I want the dawn to come soon~~!!

煌星の力で照らしてあげてくれ〜〜！！といった終わり方たった、、2巻すごい、、ゆらちゃんがちゃんと自分の中で折り合いを見つけて前に進めますように。それにしても煌星、お前はまっすぐないい男だ！！もう一度抱きしめてあげてくれ！！

Illuminate them with the power of a brilliant star!! That's how it ended... volume 2 is amazing... I hope Yura-chan can properly find an agreement within herself and move forward. Even so, Kōsei, you're a straight, nice guy!! Please give them one more hug!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ぐあぁあぁああぁ

Whoa whoa whoa

めっちゃくちゃ面白い！引き込まれる！1巻の終わりにも2巻の終わりにも続きは！？どこ！？まだ！？ってなったBL苦手な人にも読んで貰いたいくらいストーリーが良い3巻まだですか！？

It's so damn funny! I'm drawn in! What continues at the end of volume 1 and the end of volume 2!? where!? not yet!? There are still 3 volumes with good stories that I want people who don't like BL to read!?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

めちゃくちゃ良い

Insanely good

This review contains spoilers. 始まりはラブコメかなと思ったのですが、２巻まで読んで切ないシリアスな面もあり、、早く2人が思いっきりイチャイチャしてるところが見たいー！羽賀くんも由良ちゃんもイケメン＆美人でめっちゃ良きです！

This review contains spoilers. I thought it was a romantic comedy at the beginning, but after reading volume 2, there is also a sad serious side, so I want to see the two flirting to their heart's content as soon as possible! Both Haga-kun and Yura-chan are so handsome and beautiful!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

良い！

good!

すごく切ない感じで今後の展開がとても気になります！絵もきれいだし、ストーリーも間違いなしなのでおすすめです！

It feels so sad and I'm really worried about future developments! The pictures are beautiful and the story is unmistakable, so I recommend it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

まだまだね…

there's still more...

This review contains spoilers. 切ない…なんか一巻よりもっと切なくなってきたね。柊真くんもずっと辛かったよな。最後に3人の過去と今まで柊真くんの気持ちを知らせてありがとうございます。本当に過去の3人も今の3人も幸せになってほしいですね。

This review contains spoilers. It's sad... something is getting even sadder than volume one. It was always hard for Makoto Hiiragi too. Finally, thank you for sharing the past of the three and how Hiiragi Makoto feels until now. I really want the past 3 people and the 3 people now to be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻からの急展開が神…

The rapid development from volume 2 is divine...

由良先生の止まっていた時間を進め…また歩き出すためには、今まさにその時（高校時代）を生きる羽賀くんじゃなきゃダメだったのかも。。。とにかく、出だしで予想される単なる先生×生徒のわちゃわちゃ恋愛ストーリーではありません。いい意味で読者は裏切られます。。。これは本当に切ない…魂の救済と再生の物語。…気になった方はぜひ本編で確認して下さい！おすすめです♪

Advance through the time Yura sensei had stopped... in order to start walking again, maybe I had to be Haga-kun living right now (high school days)... Anyway, it's not just a messy teacher-student romance story that you might expect at the beginning. Readers are betrayed in a good way... This is really sad... a story of salvation and renewal of souls. ... If you're interested, be sure to check out the main story! I recommend it ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 13, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

泣いたし切ない

I'm crying and I'm sad

1巻はラブコメ的なものだと思っていましたが2巻で急にテイストが変わりました。最近プラネタリウムでAimerの「ポラリス」という歌が流れて良い曲だなと思っていましたが、2巻を読み終えて、この曲の歌詞とこの2巻の話が非常にリンクしました。聴きながら読んだら何だか泣けてきました。続編が早く読みたいです。

I thought volume 1 was a romantic comedy, but volume 2 suddenly changed my taste. The song “Polaris” by Aimer was played at the planetarium recently, and I thought it was a good song, but after reading volume 2, the lyrics of this song and the story of these 2 volumes were very linked. Something made me cry when I read it while listening. I want to read the sequel soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 13, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

悲しいなぁ・・・

that's sad...

This review contains spoilers. なんか試し読みで奥深い内容なのかなって感じがして買ってみました。どーして？って謎めいてたのが段々とわかってくうちに、これは重いって悲しいってどーしよーもないじゃんって、切なくて。

This review contains spoilers. It was a trial reading and I had a feeling that the content was profound, so I bought it. how do you do it? As I gradually came to understand that it was enigmatic, I thought this was heavy, sad, and nothing, so sad, so sad.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 12, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

好き！！！

I like it!!!

This review contains spoilers. こんなに登場人物ひとりひとりに感情移入できるBLないんじゃない？？ってくらい魅力的な人達です！最初はよくあるイケメン生徒と美人教師のアオハルBLかな〜と思って読んだらあれ…？続きあるの？…もしかしてこれ、ただのわちゃわちゃして終わるやつじゃないな〜ってどんどん惹き込まれました〜しかもテンポが良いから暗すぎず、キュンもあり、ギュ〜って苦しくなるのもあり、始めて読む作家さんだったけど、とても展開が上手！読ませ上手！絵も素敵！なにこれ！ってかんじで魅了されまくり…煌星って名前も素敵やん！めっちゃ3巻楽しみです〜〜〜正直、この手の展開ものって今までだいぶ使われてきたネタだと思うんです…それをこんなに新鮮に魅力的に読めるのは感激です。2巻最後の先生のサイドストーリーも滲みた〜良かったよ〜

This review contains spoilers. Isn't there a BL where you can empathize with each of the characters this much?? They are such charming people! At first, I thought it might be Aoharu BL by a common good-looking student and beautiful teacher, and read that...? Is there more? ... I was drawn more and more by the fact that it wasn't just a mess and ended up being drawn into it~ Moreover, the tempo was good, so it wasn't too dark, there were also gaps, and it was difficult, so I was a writer who read it for the first time, but it developed really well! Let me read it well! The picture is wonderful too! what is this! I was so fascinated... the name Kōsei is wonderful too! I'm really looking forward to volume 3 ~ ~ To be honest, I think this kind of development is a story that has been used quite a bit until now... I'm thrilled to be able to read it in such a fresh and appealing way. The side story of the teacher at the end of volume 2 also blew up ~ I'm glad ~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 12, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻が最高

Volume 2 is the best

1巻の2人の攻防もめちゃめちゃ可愛くて好きだったのですが、2巻で一気に惹き込まれました...最近読んだ中で1番好みです...次巻も楽しみにしています

I liked the battle between the two in volume 1 because it was so cute, but volume 2 drew me in all at once... it's my favorite among those I've read recently... I'm looking forward to the next volume too

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻の破壊力！

Volume 2: Destructive Power!

完全に2巻で心を鷲掴みにされた。軽くて明るい学園恋愛ストーリーかと思ったら2巻で本気出してきた。なんだこのストーリー展開…重くて切なくて心臓痛い。一巻のキラキラした出だしからは想像付かない。煌星はもっとチャラいかと思ってたし由良先生ももっとちょろいかと思ってた。煌星真面目だし未だにキス止まりだし由良先生は強気だし固いし未だに過去引きずりまくってるしで二人とも意外性があってキャラが魅力的すぎる。過去に閉じ込められてる由良先生に掛けた煌星の言葉がど直球でびびった。「忘れなくていいよ」とかいう良くある慰めの優しい言葉じゃなくて意外性があって良かった。それを受けた由良先生が学校を辞める＝閉じ込められていた過去からようやく一歩踏み出せたのかな。時が経って煌星教師になってるし髪色変わっててイケメン度増してるし由良ちゃん髪伸びて美人度増してるし二人の再会が待ち遠しい。チャラ男だったはずの煌星が数年経っても由良ちゃんにメッセージ送り続けて思い続けてるの純情すぎないか。ギャップに萌える。そのメッセージを開かずともちゃんと見てる由良ちゃんもたまらない。帰国決めたのは大人になって生徒じゃなくなった煌星と過去から前にようやく進めた自分が再会してもいいかなと思えたからなのかな。煌星＝ポラリスって名前もすごく好き。煌星のおかげで由良先生に夜明けが来て欲しい。

Volume 2 completely grabbed my heart. When I thought it was a light and bright school romance story, it really came out in volume 2. What is this storyline... it's heavy, sad, and heartbreaking. I can't imagine it from the glittering start of volume one. I thought Kosei would be more charismatic, and Yura sensei was also wondering if she was a little bit more playful. Kōsei is serious, they've still stopped kissing, and Yura sensei is bullish and stiff, and they're still dragging on with the past, so both of them are unexpected, and the characters are too attractive. Kōsei's words to Yura sensei, who is trapped in the past, made me freak out. I'm glad that it's unexpected, and it's not a common, comforting, kind word like “you don't have to forget it.” I wonder if Yura sensei, who received it, quit school = was finally able to take a step forward from the past where she was confined. Time has passed and she has become a Kosei teacher, her hair color has changed, her handsome level has increased, and Yura's hair has grown and she is more beautiful, and I can't wait for the two to meet again. Isn't it too pure that Kosei, who is supposed to be a crazy man, continues to send messages to Yura-chan even after a few years have passed and continues to think about it? I'm fascinated by the gap. Even if she doesn't open that message, Yura is watching it properly is also irresistible. I think the reason I decided to return to Japan was because I thought it would be okay to reunite with Kosei, who had finally moved forward from the past. I also really like the name Kosei = Polaris. Thanks to Kōsei, I want Yura sensei to see dawn.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

好きっっっ

I like it

待ってました泣泣泣待ちに待った2巻、、！！2人がどうなるのか気になります。切なすぎます3人とも幸せになってほしい！

I've been waiting, crying, crying, I've been waiting for volume 2...!! I'm curious what will happen to the two of them. It's so sad, I want all 3 of them to be happy!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

わーー

wow

This review contains spoilers. 他の作品が好きなので、期待ハズレだなと思ってました。が！皆さんの2巻のレビューで読まないわけにはいかなくなり、読みました。うぅーん、救われない悲しさは苦手なのですが、気になります。少しでも救われてほしい。もちろん2人とも。嘉島先生の作品、やはり好きです。

This review contains spoilers. I like other works, so I thought my expectations were missed. but! I couldn't help but read it after everyone's review of volume 2, so I read it. Hmm, I don't like the sadness of not being saved, but it bothers me. I want them to be saved even a little bit. Of course, both of them. I really like Kashima-sensei's work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

こんなにピュアで一途なのに

Even though it's so pure and one-of-a-kind

なかなか相手に届かず実らない恋の物語も珍しい！だけどそこが良い！ピュアで一途だからこそ実らない恋！何だかハラハラドキドキモヤモヤさせられる！3巻、早く続きが読みたい！

Stories of love that don't easily reach their partner and don't come to fruition are also rare! But that's good! A love that doesn't come true only because it's pure and unbelievable! Somehow it makes me feel so excited and fidgety! I want to read volume 3 and more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻…

Volume 2...

This review contains spoilers. 二律背反痺れた、、、、当て馬だと思ってた柊真に焦点を当てた書き下ろしですが、ほんとうに良かった。本編ではゆらちゃんの繋ぎ止めたい過去の思い出や、煌星の好きな人を自分が助けてあげたいという強い思いに焦点が当てられてるわけですが、その裏で進行してた柊真のどろどろとした感情。同じ顔をした双子の片割れと、その恋人と、自分。3人組でひとり後ろを歩く。恋人になった2人への優しさゆえについた嘘で傷ついてる自分にも受け入れ難い。正直、1巻の最初あたりからゆらちゃんの想い人はもう亡くなってて、煌星がゆらちゃんを追って教師になるところまでは予想通りでしたが、2巻の巻末にこんな（いい意味で）人間臭さ溢れた痺れる作品が来ると思ってませんでした！絵が綺麗で可愛いということで読み始めた作品でしたが、3巻も絶対購入します！！！首をながーーくして待ってます！！！！！

This review contains spoilers. It was written focusing on Makoto Hiiragi, who I thought was a hit horse, and it was really good. In the main story, the focus is on Yura-chan's memories of the past that she wants to keep them connected and her strong desire to help people who love Kosei, but the murky feelings of Hiiragi Makoto progressed behind that. A split of twins with the same face, their lover, and myself. A group of 3 people walk behind each other alone. It's hard for me to accept that I'm hurt by lies told because of kindness to the two people who became lovers. To be honest, from around the beginning of volume 1, Yura-chan's lover had already passed away, and it was as expected until Kōsei followed Yura-chan and became her teacher, but I didn't expect such a numbing work full of human smell (in a good sense) to come to the end of volume 2! I started reading this book because the pictures are beautiful and cute, but I will definitely buy 3 volumes!! I've been waiting for a long time!!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻からが真骨頂(個人的見解)だった！！

Starting with volume 2 was the true essence (personal opinion)!!

This review contains spoilers. 1巻は学園物かな？と軽い気持ちで読んでいたが、2巻からグイグイと重い話がキタキタキター！！ヤバいっ！由良ちゃんの心が揺れ動く描写が良かった、、、。羽賀がどこまでも前を向いていて、由良ちゃんへ真っ直ぐに気持ちをぶつけてくる。本当は羽賀に惹かれ始めているのに真白への気持ちを捨てきれずどこかブレーキをかける由良ちゃん、、、。うわあ！！キュンです！！ズキズキしますっ！そして羽賀は時間を止めていた由良ちゃんの世界を壊してくれた。止まっていま時間を進めてくれた！これは羽賀にしか出来なかったことだ。残酷だけれど由良や柊真には必要だったはず。そして世界を壊された由良は、、、？！どうなる？！どうする？！あああーー！続きが待ち遠しい、、、！！ヒューマンドラマもBLも楽しみたい人にめちゃくちゃ押します！オススメ！

This review contains spoilers. Is volume 1 a school thing? I was reading it with a light feeling, but from volume 2, the story is so loud and heavy!! that's dangerous! The depiction of Yura's heart shaking was good... Haga is looking forward all the way, and her feelings go straight to Yura-chan. Actually, Yura-chan is starting to be attracted to Haga, but she can't give up her feelings for Mashiro and puts the brakes somewhere... wow!! It's Kyun!! It makes me throb! And Haga destroyed the world of Yura, who had stopped time. It stopped and now it's moving forward in time! This was something only Haga could do. It's cruel, but it must have been necessary for Yura and Hiiragi Makoto. And Yura, who destroyed the world...?! What's going to happen?! what to do?! Ahhhh! I can't wait for the continuation...!! I really recommend it to people who want to enjoy both human dramas and BL! I recommend it!

Helpful

Reviews for Polaris at Dawn Manga