The Vessel of a Transparent Love Manga Reviews (P.16)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 22, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

美しいけど難しい

Beautiful but difficult

This review contains spoilers. 私の理解力のなさで何度もページを行ったり来たりで、読むのにかなり時間がかかってしまい、感情移入できず泣けませんでした。素敵なお話なのはわかります。身体という器と心、空っぽから少しずつ満たされる様子はとてもいいです。わりと言葉ではっきり言わず、表情や間や絵の雰囲気で状況を伝える場面があり、それが私には難しくて考えてしまい、もう少しだけ説明があれば良かったなと。でもやはり私の理解力のなさが原因ですね。あかしびとはどうやって生まれたのかも気になります。感情むき出しのシロさんもみてみたいですね。切なさはありますが、優しくてキレイなお話でした。

This review contains spoilers. I went back and forth through the pages over and over due to my lack of comprehension, and it took quite a while to read, and I couldn't empathize and couldn't cry. I know it's a wonderful story. It's so nice to see your body and mind being filled little by little from the emptiness. There was a scene where I couldn't say it clearly in words, and conveyed the situation with facial expressions, spaces, and the atmosphere of the picture, and it was difficult for me to think about it, and it would have been nice if there were just a few more explanations. But it's still because of my lack of understanding. I'm also curious about how Akashibi came about. I'd also like to see Shiro-san, who shows off her emotions. It was a sad story, but it was a kind and beautiful story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 22, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

感動

touching

素直とか純粋とかそんな忘れてたものが愛おしくかんじられるそんな作品です。よんだあとふわふわしました。試し読みで好きだなって感じたらぜひ。

It's such a work where you can lovingly feel things you've forgotten, such as honesty and purity. After that, it became fluffy. If you feel that you like the trial reading, be sure to check it out.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

じんわりやさしい

Gentle and gentle

This review contains spoilers. 優しい話です。人外のしろさんが感情を一つ一つ教えられて、2人で幸せになっていくお話です。じんわり優しい。2人が出会ってほんとに良かった。

This review contains spoilers. It's a kind story. It's a story where the outsider Shiro-san is taught her emotions one by one, and the two of them become happy. Gentle and gentle. I'm really glad the two met.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

深い愛のお話

A story of deep love

This review contains spoilers. レビューが高かったので気になり購入しました。不幸体質な受けと、その受けのマイナスの感情を糧に生きる人外の攻めのお話で最初の導入は「なるほどなるほど〜」と軽く受け止めて読んでいてのですが関係性の矛盾？みたいなものがどんどん重くのしかかり、そして愛とは何か、大事なものを守るためにというお話になっていき、とても切なく深いお話だったんだと気づきました。最後はハピエンでよかったです！！2人のイチャイチャが可愛かったです♡

This review contains spoilers. The reviews were high, so I was curious and bought it. It's a story about receiving an unhappy constitution and attacking people who live off the negative feelings of that reception, and the first introduction was read by taking it lightly as “I see, I see ~”, but is there a contradiction in the relationship? Something like that weighed more and more, and it became a story about what love is and to protect what is important, and I realized that it was a very sad and deep story. I'm glad it was Happien at the end!! The flirting between the two was cute ♡

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がタイトル通りの透明感ある美しさ

The picture is transparent and beautiful as the title suggests

初読み作家様。高評価と泣いたという数々のレビューを見て購入。結果、泣きはしませんでしたが、2度、3度と読むうちにじんわりときたし色んな気付きがありました。作家様があとがきでもっと描きたいものがあったと書かれてたので、もう少し巻数増やしてじっくり描いて下さってたらもっと引き込まれて泣けたのかもと思うと残念です。でも、とにかく絵が綺麗でシロがめちゃくちゃ格好良くて素敵でした。

First-time reader writer. I bought it after seeing high ratings and numerous reviews that made me cry. As a result, I didn't cry, but as I read it 2 or 3 times, I slowly realized a lot of things. It was written that the artist had something more to draw in the afterword, so it's a pity to think that if they had increased the number of volumes a little more and drew carefully, they might have been drawn even more in and cried. But anyway, the picture was beautiful and the white was insanely cool and wonderful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

いい意味で裏切られた。

I was betrayed in a good way.

This review contains spoilers. 絵が綺麗で購入したもののあまりに暗い始まりで読むのダルって思ってましたが読んでるうちに引き込まれてしまいました。悲しい結末なのかと思い涙しましたが最後まさかのハピエンでよかったです。主人公がめちゃくちゃ素直でいい子なので幸せになってくれて嬉しいです。

This review contains spoilers. The picture was beautiful and I bought it, but I thought it would be Dal to read it because it started so dark, but as I read it, I was drawn in. I was in tears thinking it would be a sad ending, but I'm glad it was a surprise happy event at the end. I'm happy that the main character is an insanely honest and nice kid, so I'm happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

期待していたものとは

What was expected

This review contains spoilers. 元々涙もろいのでもっと泣いてしまうくらい期待していましたが、そうでもなかったかな。作品がどうか、というわけではなく。ハッピーエンドだと確認してから読んだので安心して読んだから？でも二人の思いの描写が丁寧に描かれていて絵もきれいで良かった！また読み返そう?

This review contains spoilers. Originally, my tears were fragile, so I was expecting to cry even more, but I wonder if that wasn't the case. It's not about how the work is. I read it after confirming that it had a happy ending, so I read it with peace of mind? But it was nice that the depiction of their thoughts was carefully drawn and the picture was beautiful! Should I reread it again?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

優しい

kindest

少し難しい部分もありましたが、とても優しくて切なくて…なんだか心にジーンとくるお話でした。絵も丁寧で素敵でした。

There were some difficult parts, but it was so kind and sad... it was a story that somehow stuck in my heart. The pictures were also careful and wonderful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

いい話だとは思うけど難しい...

I think it's a good story, but it's difficult...

ストーリー重視の作品でおすすめされたので読んでみましたが、正直完全に理解するのは難しいお話だなと感じました。ストーリー自体は斬新で奥深くとても面白いですし、絵も綺麗なので読みやすいです。ただ、ちょっと抽象的というか、分かるんだけど分からないって感じのセリフや展開が多くて、読後は余韻よりも「う〜ん」と唸ってしまいそうになりました。あと2、3回読めば理解出来るのかもしれないけど、そんなに何度も読みたいかと聞かれると、ぶっちゃけＮＯですね…

It was recommended as a story focused work, so I read it, but to be honest, I felt that it was a difficult story to fully understand. The story itself is novel, deep, and very interesting, and the pictures are beautiful, so it's easy to read. However, there were many lines and developments that were a bit abstract, or felt like I understood but didn't understand, and after reading them, I almost groaned “hmm” rather than the afterglow. If you read it 2 or 3 more times, you might be able to understand it, but when asked if you want to read it that many times, it's totally NO...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 29, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ファンタジー

fantasy

This review contains spoilers. 涙なくしては読めません。空っぽの不幸だけで満たされていくシロの身体がミキに会ってどんどん変わります。喫茶店のまりあちゃんが生まれたての赤ん坊のようだとシロのことを言っていたけど、ミキと過ごすうちに愛や嫉妬、欲も生まれミキからの愛で満たされ死を選ぶ。号泣ですね。ネタバレはハピエンですので、泣いちゃうけど安心してください。

This review contains spoilers. I can't read without tears. Shiro's body, which is filled with nothing but empty misfortune, changes steadily when she meets Miki. She said that Maria at the coffee shop looked like a newborn baby, but while spending time with Miki, love, jealousy, and greed were born, filled with love from Miki, and she chose death. crying, isn't it? The spoiler is Happien, so don't worry, I'll cry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

愛で人は生まれる

People are born with love

This review contains spoilers. 人の姿をしてる人でない者が「シロ」と名付けられ純粋な愛を注ぎこまれて本当の人になるというちょっと不思議な話だと思う。ミキとの出逢いが偶然なのか必然なのかはわからないが、シロとミキにとっては漠然としてた愛と言う感情をお互いに感じ注ぎ育てる事が出来た唯一無二の番なのではないかと思う。不幸体質と思い込んでいたミキの幸せはシロがいる事ならこの先幸せしかないでしょう。

This review contains spoilers. I think it's a bit strange story where a person who isn't a person in human form is named “Shiro,” pure love is poured in, and becomes a real person. I don't know if the encounter with Miki was a coincidence or inevitable, but I think it's the one and only turn for Shiro and Miki, where they were able to feel and nurture the vague feeling of love into each other. Miki's happiness, which she thought was unhappy because of her unhappy constitution, is that if Shiro were around, she would have no choice but to be happy in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

3.6☆

3.6 ☆

美しいファンタジー。絵はすごく儚い感じが出てる綺麗な絵。不思議で珍しい設定。うつわのシロ...人間界を徘徊してる見習い天使みたいなイメージで読んでたけど、もっと何だろう、中身のない、まさに透明なうつわか。ガチっとしたストーリーではなくて全体的にふわっとした近代的なおとぎ話と言った感じかな。美しさを楽しむには良い作品ですが、さらっと読んでたらちょっとわかり辛いかも。評価は3.6☆

A beautiful fantasy. The picture is a beautiful picture with a very ephemeral feeling. A mysterious and unusual setting. Shiro in a container... I read it with the image of an apprentice angel wandering around the human world, but I wonder what more, it's just a transparent container with no content. It's not a crappy story; it's like an overall fluffy modern fairy tale. It's a great work to enjoy its beauty, but it might be a bit difficult to understand if you read it quickly. The rating is 3.6 ☆

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 11, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

惜しい

It's a pity

This review contains spoilers. とても絵が綺麗で内容も面白く心が暖かくなるんだけど、、、惜しいです。あともう一歩何かが足りない気がします。。作者さんは多分すごく優しい人なんだと思う。だからキャラもみんなどこか優しくて理性的で、ストーリー自体も優しく落ち着いている雰囲気だから物足りなく感じちゃうんだと思います。

This review contains spoilers. The pictures are so beautiful, the content is interesting, and it warms my heart, but... it's a pity. I feel like something is missing one more step.. I think the author is probably a very kind person. That's why all of the characters are kind and rational, and the story itself has a gentle and calm atmosphere, so I think it's unsatisfactory.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ファンタジー

fantasy

This review contains spoilers. 不幸体質のために『あかしびと』を引き寄せ、一緒に生活することとなる。あかしびとは、契約した人間の不幸を糧として生きていく。そんな中で、今まで契約した人間と違った感覚の持ち主との生活することで、気持ちに変化が生まれ、不幸を感じて欲しいのに感じて欲しくないというちぐはぐな気持ちに戸惑う。人間ではなかった者が人間の感覚を得ることで変化していく過程を読むことが出来ました。

This review contains spoilers. They attracted “Akashi Bito” due to their unhappy constitution, and they ended up living together. With Akashibi, they live their lives using the misfortunes of people who have signed contracts as food. Under such circumstances, by living with someone who has a different sense from the person I have signed a contract with until now, a change in my feelings has occurred, and I am puzzled by the insignificant feeling that I want them to feel unhappy but I don't want them to feel it. I was able to read the process by which people who were not human beings changed as they gained human senses.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 15, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

幸せは共に築くもの

Happiness is something we build together

This review contains spoilers. 人と人ならざる者の奇妙な契約から始まる現代風ファンタジー。美麗な絵で描かれる淡々と進むストーリーの醸し出す空気からハピエンのイメージが浮かびにくかったのですが、運びも丁寧で良かったです。この主人公の場合、不幸体質というよりも無意識な自己否定感の方が強いのかなと思いましたが、そもそも「不幸」の基準が明確でなく、感じ方は人それぞれ。キッカケひとつで自分を形どる何かが変わる。身体的な空腹は食事を摂る事で満たされますが、空っぽの心を満たしてくれるのはやっぱり愛なんだと思える美しく綺麗な物語でした。

This review contains spoilers. A modern fantasy that begins with a strange contract between people and non-human beings. It was hard for me to imagine Happien from the atmosphere created by the slowly progressing story drawn with beautiful pictures, but it was nice that the delivery was also careful. In the case of this protagonist, I thought that an unconscious sense of self-denial was stronger rather than an unhappy constitution, but in the first place, the standard for “unhappiness” was not clear, and each person had a different way of feeling it. Something that shapes me changes with just one trigger. Physical hunger is satisfied by eating a meal, but it was a beautiful and beautiful story that made me think that what fills an empty heart is love after all.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

健気…

Good health...

This review contains spoilers. 人外物で、受けが不幸体質の上性格良くて健気…絵はとても綺麗で好き。個人的にちょっと、物語が分かり辛い所あって入り込めず。読み込むと面白いのかな？

This review contains spoilers. They are foreign objects, unhappy, and have a good personality and are healthy... the pictures are so beautiful and I like them. Personally, there are places where the story is a bit difficult to understand, so I can't get in. Would it be interesting to load it?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買い

Buy the artist

作者買いです。美しいおはなしですね。人を愛する事で始まるお話し。ただ静かに進んでいきます。泣けますね。

I'm buying the author. It's a beautiful story. It's a story that starts with loving people. It just progresses quietly. It makes me cry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 25, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい愛の物語

A beautiful love story

This review contains spoilers. 初めの方はもしかしてメリバかもしれないと途中不安がたくさん募ってきたけど、「人を愛することによって本当の人間になれた」というこのストーリーがとても美しく描かれていて最高でした。そして絵がとても綺麗で大好きです

This review contains spoilers. There was a lot of anxiety along the way that the beginning might be Meriba, but this story “I was able to become a real person by loving people” was drawn so beautifully and it was amazing. And the picture is so beautiful and I love it

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

画力が凄い‼

The drawing power is amazing ‼

凄く好みの絵ではないのですが画力が凄くて引き込まれました。さーっと1回だけ読むだけだと解りづらいかな?最後どーなるのかドキドキして読んだ結果?]他の作品も気になり即購入?これは・・・ハマってしまったのか？?

I don't really like this picture, but the drawing power was amazing and I was drawn in. well, wouldn't it be hard to understand if you only read it once? I was excited to read what would happen at the end?] Curious about other works and bought them right away? Has this... become addicted to it?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ピュアなファンタジーストーリーです。

It's a pure fantasy story.

海外映画の世界から飛び出てきました？？のようなあの有名俳優にそっくりなおしゃれイケおじ様。そんなイケおじ様を受け止める受けも透明なぐらいのピュア。こんなに素敵な作品なのに、この先戸籍とかどうするんだろうなと意味不明な考えが過ぎった。この2人は幸せに過ごすんだろうな。

Did you jump out of the world of foreign movies?? A stylish, good-looking old man who looks just like that famous actor. The reception for such a good-looking old man is so pure that he is transparent. Even though it's such a wonderful work, I had too many meaningless thoughts about what to do with the family register in the future. I wonder if these two are going to have a happy time.

Helpful

Reviews for The Vessel of a Transparent Love Manga