The Vessel of a Transparent Love Manga Reviews (P.15)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

なんてなんて優しい物語

What a kind story

hitomi先生3650日からお久しぶりで拝読いたしました。さらにさらに優しい題名の通り、透明感のある物語になっていました。不幸を栄養に生きる人外って？？？あまり人外っぽくない、でもなんだかふわふわした現実感のない存在。ミキは幸せの方がいいのか、シロといるためには不幸の方がいいのか、ミキの幸せとシロの幸せとどっちも願いながら読んでいたら、思わず涙がこぼれました。あああ、このままシロは消えてしまうんだ、、、ネタバレせずにここから先は読んでください。そして最後に先生のあとがきを読んでほしい。全て納得です。不幸は自分で寄せてしまうもの、捉え方一つで変わる。なんだか生き方の指針のようにも感じました。

It's been a while since I read Hitomi sensei since 3650. Furthermore, as the title suggests, which is even more gentle, it was a story with a sense of transparency. Who is someone other than a person who lives by nourishing their misfortune??? They don't seem like outsiders, but they are somehow fluffy and have no sense of reality. When I was reading Miki's happiness or whether it's better to be unhappy to be with Shiro, while wishing for both Miki's happiness and Shiro's happiness, tears unexpectedly spilled out. Oh, Shiro is going to disappear like this... please read from here on without spoilers. And finally, I want you to read the teacher's afterword. I agree with everything. Unhappiness is something we bring ourselves, and it changes depending on how we perceive it. It also felt like a guideline for how to live.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

その後が見たくなります。

I want to watch it after that.

台詞もページ数も多いですが苦になりません。もう一度読み返したいし、画が丁寧で丁寧すぎるのも納得です。是非このお話のスピンオフかその後をお願いいたします。

There are lots of lines and pages, but it's not a pain. I want to reread it again, and I'm convinced that the pictures are so careful and careful. Please do a spin-off of this story or later.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 22, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

無題

Untitled

ファンタジー系BL。お話やキャラクターの心理描写とかも丁寧に扱ってるけど、読み始めから展開が読めてしまうのが何とも。絵はとても綺麗なので星4つ

Fantasy BL. The story and the psychological depiction of the characters are also handled carefully, but no matter what, you can read the development from the beginning. 4 stars because the picture is so beautiful

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 06, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

美しいタイトルに美しい絵

A beautiful picture with a beautiful title

This review contains spoilers. とても細やかで美しい絵を堪能しました。初めはシロって他の人には見えないのかと思っていました。2人の成長物語、シロが主人公みたい。お互い自分より相手の方が大切でハッピーエンドです。独自の設定と長いモノローグと唐突な話の進み方なので、この場面でどう思えば良いの？と戸惑うことが多かったです。

This review contains spoilers. I enjoyed the very detailed and beautiful pictures. At first, I was wondering if Shiro was invisible to other people. Shiro seems to be the main character in the coming-of-age story of two people. We both value each other more than ourselves, and it's a happy ending. It's a unique setting, a long monologue, and an abrupt way of going about the story, so what should I think about this scene? I was often confused.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ラブ面でもう一捻りほしい

I want another twist on the love side

「あかしびと」のコンセプトとその結末は面白かったのですが、何故かはまれせんでした。ラブストーリーの部分がちょっと弱いのかも。そのあたりもう一捻りほしかったです。

The concept of “Akashibito” and its ending were interesting, but for some reason it was rare. Maybe the love story part is a bit weak. I wanted another twist around that point.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 29, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

よいです

That's good

This review contains spoilers. 優しいお話でした。人ならざるものが愛を知るお話。人ではないけど見た目は人とおんなじなんで、こんなイケメンな人外でいいのん？って感じはしました。

This review contains spoilers. That was a kind story. A story about people who aren't human beings who know love. They're not people, but they look just like people, so is it OK to be a good-looking person like this? I felt like that.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 28, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ややご都合ではあるが

It's a bit convenient

リアルかつ繊細なお話なので終盤のご都合展開がちょっと目立ってしまってましたがそれを加味しても読み応えのある素晴らしい話でした！

It's a realistic and delicate story, so the convenient developments at the end were a bit conspicuous, but it was a wonderful story that was worth reading even when that was taken into account!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 10, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

何回か読み返して

Reread it a few times

This review contains spoilers. まあ。良い話だったな〜と思える、そんなストーリーでした最初から、不幸が必要な人外のシロ、優しい体質のミキ、だから、いやこれお互い雰囲気的に一緒にいて惹かれ合うのは当然で、いやそしたらシロの方生きていけないのでは…と、ずっと思いながら読んでいたので、やはり予想通りの展開、てところで、突如現れた課長wが、言葉選ばず言うと、とても都合よく2人を救うアドバイスをしてくれたと言う感じです。あそこでシロが完全に消えて、人間として生まれ変わるパターンかなとかも思ったんですけど、違った笑。まさかの死ななかったw愛が勝った…！と、いう理解ですが、合ってますでしょうか？絵がとても綺麗で、美しい2人は見ていて癒されました。

This review contains spoilers. well. I thought it was a good story, and right from the beginning, I was reading it while thinking that it was natural that they were attracted to each other by being together in an atmosphere and were attracted to each other, and then Shiro wouldn't be able to live... so after all, it unfolded as expected, and by the way, section chief w, who suddenly appeared, without choosing a word, it feels like they gave advice that would save the two of them very conveniently. I was wondering if it was a pattern where Shiro completely disappeared over there and was reborn as a human being, but that was different lol. I didn't die by accident lol Ai won...! I understand that, but is that correct? The picture was so beautiful, and the two beautiful people were healed to watch.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

あたたかくて透明感のある

Warm and transparent

あたたかくて透明感のある愛の詰まったお話でした。シロとの出会いを通じて主人公はとても頼もしく成長したと感じました。不幸体質も、見方を変えることができたみたい。二人がどうなっていくのかハラハラしながら読みました。一つの物語としてとても美しく、切なく、あたたかみのあるお話でした。

It was a warm, transparent story filled with love. Through my encounter with Shiro, I felt that the main character had grown very reliable. It seems that I was able to change the way I looked at my unhappy constitution. I read it in awe to see what would happen to the two of them. It was a very beautiful, sad, and warm story as a single story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗

The picture is beautiful

特殊な設定です。後半になるにつれて、そういうことね〜。となりました。絵が綺麗なのでお話に引き込まれます。

This is a special setting. As we get to the second half, that's what happened. It became. The picture is beautiful, so I'm drawn into the story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 24, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった

That was interesting

This review contains spoilers. 初読み作者様。ファンタジーなストーリーと絵柄がマッチしていて面白かったです。ずっと結末が不安でソワソワしながら読みましたが、ハピエンで良かったです。自分の好きになった人が消えてしまったら、思い出だけでは満たされないですよね。泣いてしまいました。

This review contains spoilers. First-time reader author. It was interesting that the fantasy story matched the design. I read it all the time while feeling uneasy and fidgety about the ending, but I'm glad it was a happy one. If someone you've fallen in love with disappears, you won't be satisfied with memories alone, right? I cried.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

絵はものすごく上手

Extremely good at painting

陰影とか、他の漫画にはない繊細かつ印象的な絵でした。登場人物がやや魅力がなさ過ぎて、ストーリーもありふれた内容で一回読んで終わりました。

It was a delicate and impressive picture not found in other comics, such as shadows. The characters were a little too unappealing, and I ended up reading the story once with common content.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

薄幸感

Lackluster happiness

This review contains spoilers. 作者自らハピエン厨と言われている通りの結末なんですが、同時に絵柄とかネームから強烈に薄幸さを感じる作風です。このギャップが良いかも。

This review contains spoilers. The ending is just as the artist himself is called Happy Chef, but at the same time, it's a style that makes you feel strongly unhappy from the design and name. Maybe this gap is good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 13, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

じんわりと

Slowly

心が浄化されるような作品でした。読み終わってタイトルがしっくり来ました。自分の中にはドス黒い感情ばかりなので、彼らのように透明でキレイな感情が眩しくて仕方なかったですよ。途中ちょっと泣いちゃいました。攻めの“赤ちゃん発言”は、本当に今この瞬間に新しい感情を目の当たりにして覚えていくんだなぁと思うと愛しくてたまらなくなる。おとぎ話・ファンタジーでしたが、たまにはいいかも。エッチはエロさよりも相手へのリスペクトと愛情で溢れてました。

It was a work that purified the mind. I finished reading it and the title came right. I have only dark feelings inside of me, so I couldn't help but be dazzled by their transparent and beautiful feelings. I cried a little bit along the way. The offensive “baby statement” is adorable and unbearable when I think that I'm really going to witness new emotions at this moment and remember them. It was a fairy tale fantasy, but it might be good once in a while. Sex was full of respect and love for the other person rather than eroticism.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

人外✕人間

Outsider ✕ Human

設定が面白い！不幸が栄養で愛は毒。段々と感情が芽生える感じも絵も素敵です。受けの身体が華奢過ぎて好みじゃなかったのでそこだけマイナス。

The setting is interesting! Misfortune is nourishment; love is poison. The feeling of gradually developing emotions and the pictures are wonderful. The recipient's body was too delicate and I didn't like it, so that was the only negative.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絵うま

The picture is beautiful

This review contains spoilers. 絵がめっちゃうまくて読みやすかったです。漫画よりもリアルに近い絵で、シロのボディがとてもセクシーだった。あかしびとがミステリアスでお話も面白かった。最後が救われる話で安心した。

This review contains spoilers. The pictures were really nice and easy to read. The picture was closer to reality than the manga, and Shiro's body was so sexy. Akashibito was mysterious and the story was interesting. I was relieved to hear the story where the last one was saved.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

タイトル通り

As the title says

This review contains spoilers. タイトル通りでちょっと不思議でファンタジーなお話でしたけど、｢人の負の感情｣が糧で「愛」が毒なんて。無機質な人の形だった｢シロ｣がミキとの生活の中で少しずつ色んな感情を持って行く。不幸体質なミキも、シロによって負の感情を感じなくなっていくのに、それではシロにとって栄養失調なんて。何とももどかしい。でも、それでも｢愛｣を捨てれず。｢透明な器｣は究極の愛によって満たされる事で、意味のあるものになるんですね。と、訳の分からないレビュー担ってしまいました。

This review contains spoilers. As the title suggests, it was a bit strange and fantasy story, but I can't believe “love” is toxic because “people's negative emotions” feed on it. Little by little, “Shiro,” who was in the form of an inorganic person, carries various emotions in her life with Miki. Miki, who is unhappy, also stopped feeling negative emotions due to Shiro, so that's why Shiro is malnourished. It's so frustrating. But even so, I couldn't give up “love.” When a “transparent vessel” is filled with ultimate love, it becomes meaningful, doesn't it? I was responsible for a review I didn't understand.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 20, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

美しく透明

Beautifully transparent

まず絵が綺麗。静かで透明な画風。ストーリーにピッタリです。聖母のような受けの愛で満たされて、二人が幸せになれて良かった～

First, the picture is beautiful. Quiet and transparent painting style. Perfect for the story. I'm glad they were filled with receiving love like Our Lady, and the two of them were happy~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

感動しました。

I'm moved.

とにかくイラストが美しい。世界観があります。話的には他の作家さんがした話のほうが良いのがありましたが、それでも題名にあった内容で良かった。

Anyway, the illustrations are beautiful. I have a view of the world. In terms of story, there were stories told by other writers that were better, but even so, I'm glad the content matched the title.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 31, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ファンタジーの世界

fantasy world

人外攻めの聖母受け。人の悲しみや絶望などの負の感情を糧に生きるシロと、シロの宿主として自分の不運さから生じる負の感情を提供することで、少しでも誰かの為になればと思う聖母のようなミキ。絵がキレイでした。

Receive Our Lady of Outer Attacks. Shiro, who lives on negative emotions such as human sorrow and hopelessness, and Miki is like Our Lady who hopes to benefit someone even a little by providing negative emotions arising from her own misfortune as Shiro's host. The picture was beautiful.

Helpful

Reviews for The Vessel of a Transparent Love Manga