A Silent Voice Manga Reviews (P.9)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 10, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

私はいじめを知らないから良いなと思える気

I don't know bullying, so I feel like it's good

This review contains spoilers. 低評価レビューをみて★５から★４に。確かにご都合主義な一面もあるかなと思ったからです。二度映画を見ました。映画館でやっている時は知らなかったのでテレビで二回。冒頭のいじめシーンや、（主人公が悪い事をした人であるというのを抜きにして）しょうやがゆずに濡れ衣を着せられたりするところはうっとなるけど、それ以上に読みたくなる魅力を感じました。実際、漫画は映画の内容でありつつも、細かな描写や誰がその場面で出張ってくるか（ゆずが女の子なことをしょーこが伝える→映画ではゆず本人が別れ際に手話で）など映画バージョンなところもあり楽しめました。映画は要所をはしょることなくきちんと映画化したんだなという印象です。低評価レビューをみると、しょうこが流され過ぎ、やいじめ加害者を許さないってこと？漫画の存在自体が不愉快、これはないわーなど、この作品の核である「いじめた側といじめられた側」の関係性や双方のふるまいに納得感が無い、そういう許しを得られるみたいな加害者側の擁護を肯定的に描かないでほしいという意見があるようです。恐らく、いじめというものがどれだけ身近にあったかあるかの違いかなと思います。フィクションだと思って読んだわけじゃないですが、筆者はいじめた側はそう簡単には許されない、許されるべきでないということはわかった上で生み出した作品のように思われます。それを踏まえても、やはり「絶対に許すべきではない」という読者の怒りや悲しみが「気持ち悪い・不愉快・許す側（しょうこ）への怒りの転換」に繋がっているのかなと。しょーや・気弱・人の顔がみられない・一生懸命生きている・感情を素直にだすのが苦手・・・しょーこ・人とわかり合いたい、分かり合えると信じているゆず・しょーやは気に食わないやつ、しょうこを守りたい、傷ついてほしくない。徐々にしょうやのことを信頼私は読んでよかったと思いました。

This review contains spoilers. Look at the low rating reviews from ★ 5 to ★ 4. This is because I was wondering if there is certainly an expediency aspect. I watched the movie twice. I didn't know when I was at the movie theater, so I watched it twice on TV. The bullying scene at the beginning and the fact that Shoya Yuzu is dressed in wet clothes (without leaving out the fact that the main character is someone who did bad things) is annoying, but I felt a fascination that made me want to read it even more than that. In fact, even though the manga is about the movie, I was also able to enjoy it because it was a movie version with detailed depictions and who comes on a business trip in that scene (Shoko tells that Yuzu is a girl → in the movie, Yuzu herself uses sign language when they break up). I have the impression that the film was properly made into a film without breaking any key points. If you look at low ratings reviews, does that mean that shoko has been swept away too much and that bullies will not be forgiven? There seems to be an opinion that the existence of comics itself is unpleasant, there is no such thing, etc., and there is no sense of satisfaction with the relationship between the “bullied side and the side that was bullied,” which is the core of this work, and there is no sense of satisfaction with the behavior of both parties, and they don't want them to positively depict the defense of the perpetrator side where such forgiveness can be obtained. I think it's probably a difference between how close or familiar bullying is. I didn't read it thinking it was fiction, but I think it's a work I created after understanding that the bully side is not and should not be forgiven so easily. Even based on that, I wonder if the anger and sadness of readers who say “we should never forgive” is still leading to a “shift in anger towards the disgusting, uncomfortable, and forgiving side (Shoko).” Shoya · timid · can't see people's faces · I'm living hard · I'm not good at showing my emotions honestly... Shoko · I want to understand people, Yuzu Shoya, who believes they can understand each other, I don't like them, I want to protect Shoko, I don't want her to get hurt. I gradually trusted Shoya and thought I was glad I read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 22, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

無知は罪

Ignorance is a sin

実際に経験したことはないけど、登場人物の言動や心の動きがリアルだなと感じた。無知は罪だな…。障害もいじめも、いつまで経っても解決できない難問ですね。

I've never actually experienced it, but I felt that the characters' words, actions, and movements of mind were real. ignorance is a sin... Disability and bullying are difficult questions that cannot be solved no matter how long it has passed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

考えさせられる

It makes me think

アニメ映画が話題で、そちらをみてから原作を読みました。登場人物たちの人間関係とか心情にリアリティがあり、単なる良い話とか感動ものにしてないところが深いです。

The animated film was a hot topic, and I read the original after watching it. There is reality in the relationships and feelings of the characters, and it's deep that it's not just a good story or something moving.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

めっちゃ好き

I really like it

映画で面白すぎて何回も見させていただきました。耳が聞こえないこともあって少し勉強になる部分もあるのでとても気に入っています

The movie was so interesting that I watched it over and over again. I really like it because I'm deaf and there are parts where it's a bit of a learning experience

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

石田

Ishida

人と人が互いの気持ちを伝えることの難しさを教えていますが、綺麗ごとが多いので自分は苦手な作品です。親子だって、夫婦だって気持ちが伝わらないんです。

It teaches me how difficult it is for people to express their feelings to each other, but since there are so many beautiful things, it's a work I'm not good at. Both parents and children, and married couples can't convey their feelings.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

いい作品

Good work

絵が上手い。セリフや心理描写がかなりリアル。デフォルメとリアルさのバランスの取り方が上手い。かなりきつい内容を扱っているので、描くのも大変だったと思うけど、できればもっと続いてほしかった。中身をもっと伸ばすこともできたと思うけど、大変だったのかな。硝子たちのこれからも見たいと思った。

Good at painting. The lines and psychological depictions are pretty realistic. It's a good way to strike a balance between deformation and realism. It deals with pretty tough content, so I think it was hard to draw, but if possible, I would have liked it to continue longer. I think it was possible to expand the contents even more, but I wonder if it was difficult. I wanted to see the glass ones from now on.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

心に響く作品です

It's a work that resonates with the heart

最初の小学校時代のお話では、胸が苦しくなるくらいの描写で、とても引き込まれます。泣ける作品です。そして、耳が聞こえない方がどんな事で困るのか、悩むのか、勉強になります。

In the first elementary school story, the depiction is heartbreaking, and I am very drawn in. It's a work that makes you cry. Also, I will learn about what kind of problems and worries people who are deaf are.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

映画もみました

I also watched a movie

マンガの方がちょっと、絵がリアルですね。映画はもっと絵がキレイで話のえぐさとのギャップに困惑しましたね。耳聞こえない人のつらさ、いじめ、後悔、切なかった。

The pictures in the manga are a bit more realistic, aren't they? The pictures in the movie were even more beautiful, and I was puzzled by the gap with the story. The pain, bullying, regret, and sadness of a deaf person.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良き

good

こんな良い話が書けるなんて素晴らしいです！感動しました！1巻はハラハラドキドキムカムカしますが、後々ジワジワ来ますね！

It's great to be able to write such a good story! I'm impressed! Volume 1 is really exciting, but it will start to creak later!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

考えました

I thought about it

This review contains spoilers. 私の身近には無いけど、もし今後自分の周りに主人公やヒロインのように悩み、苦しんでいる人がいたら、って考えました。二人だけでなく、周囲の人たちの悩み、苦しみは、共感できるものでした。障害との向き合い方の難しさを考えさせられた、素晴らしい作品でした。

This review contains spoilers. I'm not close to me, but I thought if there were people around me who were worried and suffering like the main character or heroine in the future. I was able to sympathize not only with the two of them, but also with the worries and suffering of those around them. It was a wonderful work that made me think about how difficult it is to deal with disabilities.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 02, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

引き込まれるストーリー❗

A story that draws you in ❗

映画で途中まで観てたので、続きが知りたくて購入。最初はつらい場面もありますが、主人公が自業自得な部分もある中で、自分と向き合い悩みながらも少しずつ成長していく様子がグッと胸にくるものがありました?主人公へのいじめのきっかけは誰にでも起こるような些細な出来事ですよね…。考えさせられました。

I watched it halfway through the movie, so I bought it because I wanted to know the continuation. There are also difficult scenes at first, but while there are parts where the main character is self-reliant, there was something that really stuck in my mind about how he faced himself and grew little by little while worrying? The reason for bullying against the protagonist is a trivial event that can happen to anyone... It made me think.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 30, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

いい話

Nice story

This review contains spoilers. 難しいテーマですがいい話でした。タイトルだけ知っていたのですが、読めて良かったです。映画はまだ見ていないので、見てみたくなりました！

This review contains spoilers. It was a difficult subject, but it was a good story. I only knew the title, but I'm glad I was able to read it. I haven't seen the movie yet, so I wanted to watch it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 02, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

良き

good

映画でも見たけど、とっても面白かった。是非読んで欲しい！！

I also saw it in the movie, and it was really interesting. I definitely want you to read it!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

リアルなイジメ

Real bullying

イジメがリアルに描いています。ヒロインが可愛い絵です。障害者をいじめるシーンが残酷でした。

The bully is drawing realistically. This is a cute picture of the heroine. The scenes of bullying people with disabilities were cruel.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 19, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

感動

touching

映画を観て原作を読みたくて全巻購入しちゃいました。何度読んでもいい話でした。

I bought the entire volume because I wanted to watch the movie and read the original story. It was a great story no matter how many times I read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 09, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

まあまあです

It's OK

声の形はいいのはなしがあります。オーストラリア人の高校生で読むと、「きれいなはなし」と思った。チャプター１から、面白いのはなしになる、と思いました。漫画を読んだ後にええがを見ました。どっちでも好きでした。けど、時々、はなしはつまらなくなりました。簡単に言いうと、面白いはなしが読みたい奈多、声の形は読むといいと思います。

There are some good forms of voice. When I read it to an Australian high school student, I thought it was a “pretty story.” From chapter 1, I thought there would be nothing interesting. After reading the comic, I looked at the picture. I liked either of them. But sometimes, talking became boring. Simply put, I want to read Nata, who wants to read an interesting story, and I think it's a good idea to read the form of voice.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 21, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

読み切り

Read through

雑誌に読み切りが掲載されたときから好きな作品です読み切り時よりも広がりがあるぶん、メッセージ性はややぼやけてしまったかな？という印象ですが、描きたいことが描かれているんでしょうね

It's a work I've liked since the one-off was published in magazines. It's wider than the one-off period, so I wonder if the message is slightly blurry? I have the impression, but it probably depicts what I want to draw

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

1度読んでほしい

I want you to read it once

良い人も嫌な人もいるけど、登場人物それぞれの気持ちに共感できる部分がありました。皆それぞれ思うことも違うし誰が間違ってて、この人が正しいとは言えないなと思いました。

There are good people and bad people, but there was a part where I could sympathize with the feelings of each character. Everyone had different ideas, who was wrong, and I thought it was impossible to say that this person was right.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 03, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

成長物語

Growth story

映画化が話題になっていたので気になっていました！主人公2人の変化が見どころです。

The film adaptation was a hot topic, so I was curious! The highlight is the change between the two main characters.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 18, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

重い、でも…

heavy, but...

イジメとか陰口とか、暗い部分がリアルで重い…。正直、目を背けたくなる描写がいっぱいで、読むのがキツい。でも、だからこそ、失敗を繰り返しながらも前に進もうとする主人公たちに頑張れと声をかけたくなる。再読する気はまだおきそうにないけど、読んで良かったと思える作品。

The dark parts, such as bullying and backtalk, are real and heavy... To be honest, there are so many depictions that make me want to turn my eyes away, and it's hard to read. But that's why I want to call out to the protagonists, who are trying to move forward despite repeated failures, to do their best. I still don't feel like rereading it, but I'm glad I read it.

Helpful

Reviews for A Silent Voice Manga