A Silent Voice Manga Reviews (P.12)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 15, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かったがありえない

It was funny, but it's impossible

面白く読みました。ですが、いじめたヒトをいじめられたひとは、絶対に許さないと思う。いじめたヒトは生涯その罪を背負う

It was an interesting read. However, I don't think people who have been bullied will ever forgive bullied people. People who bully carry that crime for the rest of their lives

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

これが現実であれば、こんなに綺麗ではないんだろうなとは思う。しかし、あくまで漫画。テーマを生かしながも、フィクションの良さがあります。ラスト、もうちょっと先まで見たかったなあ、、と個人的には思いましたが、読みたさに負けて久々に全巻買して、良かったです。しょうこたん、、、かわいすぎるぜ、、

If this were real, I don't think it would be this pretty. However, it's just a comic. While making use of the theme, it has the merit of fiction. I personally thought I wanted to watch the last one a little bit further, but I'm glad I lost in reading it and bought the whole volume for the first time in a while. Shokotan... is too cute...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 13, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

今まで感じたことの無い気持ちになりました

It made me feel like I've never felt before

This review contains spoilers. 初めてレビューさせて頂きます。「聲の形」全巻読みました。いじめる側、いじめられる側、皆どちら側にでもなる可能性があって、そしてどちら側にもキズは残る。それはその時だけでは無く、一生の問題で、思い出す度に嫌に気持ちになって、自分の事を嫌いになって行く。この話しを全て読み終わった時に私は、今まで感じたことの無いモヤモヤしたような、言葉では表せられない気持ちになりました。そして自分が自分を好きでいるか考えさせられました。この漫画は学校に通う全ての人達に読んで、自分が好きな自分になれるように努力し変わり続けられるようになってほしいと思います。本当に勉強になりました。ありがとうございます。これからも頑張って下さい。

This review contains spoilers. I'm reviewing this for the first time. I read the entire volume of “The Shape of Voice.” There is a possibility that everyone will be on either side, the bully side or the side being bullied, and scratches will remain on either side. It's not just that time; it's a lifelong problem, and every time I think about it, I don't like it, and I dislike myself. When I finished reading all of these stories, I felt a fuzzy feeling that I had never felt before, and I couldn't express it in words. And it made me think about whether I liked myself. I want everyone who goes to school to read this comic so they can continue to make an effort and change so that they can become who they like. It was a real learning experience. Thank you very much. Please keep up the good work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 04, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

良作

Good work

This review contains spoilers. 言葉では言い表せないです。子供特有のいじめ理論、そこから生まれた消えない心の傷や成長する姿は、本当に胸にくるものがありました。かつてのメンバーと、新たなメンバーを加えて高校生になってから改めて対峙し(語弊があるかもですが)、関係を少しずつでも変えていく様が良かったです。主人公に対し最初はざまあみろと思いましたが、両者の親の気持ちを考えるとやるせない。大人だけでなく、高校生くらいまでの子供たちにも是非読んで欲しい作品です。しかし、黒髪ロングの女の子に対してだけはずっともやもやしっぱなしでした。ヤキモチから始まるのは分かりますが、成長が全く微塵も見られない。挙句に、自分に非があるくせに勢いのまま人の母親を叩き返すわ、口は悪いわ···本当にク〇ですね。彼女を許してる主人公やヒロイン達の懐の深さには尊敬します。正月、黒髪ロングの子に「ざまあみろ」なことが起こって改心するなりしていたら読後かなりスッキリしたのになぁと思いました。

This review contains spoilers. It's indescribable. The bullying theory peculiar to children, and the indelible heartbreak and growth that were born from it really stuck in my heart. After adding new members and becoming a high school student, they confronted each other again (although there may be a misnomer), and it was nice that they changed the relationship little by little. At first, I thought it was amiro to the main character, but when I think about the feelings of both parents, I can't let it go. This is a work I definitely want not only adults, but also children up to high school age to read. However, I was always haunted only when it came to girls with long black hair. I understand that it starts with a feeling of excitement, but I can't see the slightest speck of growth at all. At the end of the day, they knock back at people's mothers with momentum even though they have their own fault, and that's really bad at speaking... it's really bad. I respect the depth of love of the protagonist and heroines who have forgiven her. On New Year's, when something “amiro” happened to a girl with long black hair and she was converted, I thought I felt pretty refreshed after reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 04, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

涙が・・・

tears...

読んでいて涙が溢れてくる場面が多かったです。人の心の醜いところまでしっかり描かれていて、妙に現実的です。だからこそ、人の優しさに重みが感じられるんだと思います。絵も丁寧ですごく引き込まれます。

There were many scenes where tears overflowed while reading it. Even the ugly parts of a person's heart are clearly depicted, and it is strangely realistic. I think that's why I can feel the weight of people's kindness. The pictures are also careful and very engaging.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 04, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい！

It's interesting!

けっこうグサリとくる漫画。読んでいて辛かったけど、主人公の強さったら。

It's a comic that's pretty messy. It was hard to read, but what about the strength of the main character.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 27, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

子どもだって自分なりに考えて、想いがあっての言動で…でもいろんな人がいるからなーと読んでていろいろ考えさせられました。

Even children think in their own way, with words and actions... but since there are all kinds of people, it made me think about a lot of things.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 25, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！引き込まれる！

interesting! I'm drawn in!

読んでるとどんどん引き込まれていきました！！ただ一巻読んだだけだとただの胸糞漫画なので二巻を購入しようかなと思っています！幸せになれる展開だといいなと思います。

As I read it, I was drawn in more and more!! If I just read one volume, it's just a heartbreaking comic, so I'm thinking of buying volume 2! I think it would be nice if it was a development that would make you happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 23, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

幼いがゆえに

Because I'm young

聴覚障害をもつ子を標的にしてしまった過去。幼いがゆえに、悪意とは言い難く、でも確かに悪意ととられる。難しいけれど、考えさせられる。

A past where children with hearing impairment have been targeted. Since he is young, it is difficult to say that it is malicious, but it is certainly regarded as malicious. It's difficult, but it makes me think.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 15, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

深い

deep

絵の可愛さに反して、話の内容はとても深いと思います。小学生時代は本当にリアルで痛々しかったです。それを背負うことにした主人公がどうしていくのか、先が楽しみです。

Contrary to the cuteness of the picture, I think the story is very deep. My elementary school days were really real and painful. I'm looking forward to seeing what the protagonist, who has decided to carry it on his back, will do.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 22, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

７巻まで一気に読んだ

I read up to 7 volumes at once

朝日新聞で取り上げられていただので、一巻だけ読んでみたが、その奥深さに夢中になり、気が付けば、７巻まで一気に読んでしまった。続きが気になります。聴覚障害の少女と、彼女を小学生時代に苛めていた少年を中心に、彼らを取り巻く人たちを描いています。誰もが「悪意」を持ち得る。だからといって、悪人ではない。この難しいテーマに正面から取り組んでいます。

It was featured in the Asahi Shimbun, so I read only one volume, but I was obsessed with its depth, and before I knew it, I read up to 7 volumes at once. I'm worried about the continuation. It depicts a deaf girl and the people surrounding her, centering on a boy who harassed her when she was in elementary school. Anyone can have “bad intentions.” But that doesn't mean he's a bad person. We're tackling this difficult subject head-on.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 11, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

難しい

difficult

耳が聞こえない、上手く話せないからコミュニケーションが取れなくていじめの標的になる。小学生くらいの年の子は正直ですから読んでいて胸が痛くなるような描写もありました。でもかわいそうの一言で済ませられる問題でもない。7巻という短さですが考えさせられる作品だと思います。

Since they are deaf and can't speak well, they can't communicate and become targets of bullying. Children of elementary school age are honest, so there were also depictions that made my heart ache when reading them. But it's not a problem that can be solved with just one poor word. It's a short 7-volume work, but I think it's a thought-provoking work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 03, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

いろいろなことを考えさせられる

It makes me think about a lot of things

やったらやられる。そんな世界観がとてもでていてあー昔はこうだったなと思い返していました。それでも昔をどうにかしたいと今を変えたいと思っているキャラ達がとてもよかったです。今まで考えてないようなことを考えさせられる作品でした。

If you do it, you can do it. There was such a view of the world, and I thought back to myself that, ah, it used to be like this. Even so, the characters that want to do something about the past and want to change the present were very good. It was a work that made me think about things I hadn't thought about until now.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 01, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

続編希望！

Hope for a sequel!

続編希望！切に、願う。いじめの話は、多々あれどもっと読んでみたいと思いました。

Hope for a sequel! I really hope. There are a lot of bullying stories, but I wanted to read more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 20, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

引き込まれます

I'm drawn in

明るい話ではないです‼︎イジメを通じて色々な人が変化していく話です。引き込まれるように1巻読み終わりました。2巻目も気になるところです

It's not a bright story ‼ ︎ It's a story where various people change through bullying. I finished reading volume 1 so that I was drawn in. I'm also worried about volume 2

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

こわいです、

I'm scared,

現実で普通にありえる話だったので怖かったです、みて学ぶことがたくさんあります

It was scary because it was a story that could happen normally in real life, so there's a lot to learn by watching

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 11, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

読み進めるごとに

as I read on

この漫画の主人公は、最初耳の聞こえない少女のことを苛めます。その結果、クラスメートから見放され孤立し、昔苛めた少女に会って報いたいと考えます。この話を読んで、自分は主人公と一緒になって苛めたりしないまでも、苛められている子に手を差し伸べられるだろうかと考えさせられました。

The main character of this comic annoys a girl who is deaf at first. As a result, she was abandoned and isolated by her classmates, and she wants to repay her by meeting a girl who was irritated in the past. Reading this story made me wonder if I could reach out to a child who is being harassed even if I'm with the main character and not being harassed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 05, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

ちょっと辛い

It's a bit painful

気になって読んでみました。１巻はほんとに辛いです。読むのをやめたくなるくらい。自分の子供がこんな状況になったらどうしようと怖くなりました。失った時間は戻ってこない。主人公がこの後どう行動し、進んでいくのか、一つの答えとして見届けたいと思いました。

I was curious and read it. Volume 1 is really hard. It makes me want to stop reading. I was afraid of what to do if my child were in this situation. Lost time won't come back. I wanted to see how the protagonist will act and progress after this as one answer.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 23, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

いじめだけじゃない

It's not just bullying

いじめに関する描写がリアルで、やってること自体よりまわりのクラスメイトや大人たちの言動がすごく辛いです。でもそれがあっての主人公の償いの始まりなので、嫌な気持ちにはなりませんでした。終始暗い話ではなく、ヒロインの笑顔やウザい親友（？）にふっと癒されます。

The depiction of bullying is realistic, and the words and actions of my classmates and adults around me are much more painful than what they are doing. But that was the beginning of the protagonist's atonement, so I didn't feel bad about it. It's not a dark story from beginning to end, but the heroine's smile and annoying best friend (?) I am so healed.

Helpful

Reviews for A Silent Voice Manga