A Silent Voice Manga Reviews (P.7)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 01, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

感動！

Impressed!

今年映画化した作品です。漫画を読んでみてとても感動し映画も見ました。とても考えさせられる漫画です。是非読んでみて！

This is the film that was made into a movie this year. I was so moved when I read the manga and watched the movie. It's a very thought-provoking comic. Be sure to read it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 04, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

一巻だけ読むと胸糞作品に見える

If you read only one volume, it looks like a heartbreaking work

一巻だけ読んでマイナスレビューしてる方はまぁ一巻だけよんだらマイナスイメージしかないよなと思います。確かに好みはあるかもしれないですが、それぞれの人物の足りないところを見つめ直す作品です。漫画なので、勿論現実的にそんな上手くいかないでしょと思う事もあると思います。それを含めても自分自身の考え方などを振り返る気持ちになれる作品だと思います。少なくとも、綺麗事だとか、登場人物全員終わってるとか、腐った気持ちで見る作品ではないのかなと思います。もしも、そう思うのであればそれこそ自分自身を見つめなおして欲しい作品になるのかなと思いました。

If you read only one volume and have a negative review, well, I think if you read only one volume, you'll only have a negative image. You may certainly like it, but it's a work that takes a fresh look at what each character lacks. It's a comic, so of course I think there are times when I think it won't work that well in reality. Even including that, I think it's a work that makes me feel like I'm looking back on my own way of thinking, etc. At least, I think it's a work to watch with a rotten feeling, with beautiful things or that all the characters have finished. If I thought so, I thought that would be the work I want people to look back at.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 02, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

ストーリーが始まるのは２巻から！

The story starts in volume 2!

最後まで読みました。とてもいい作品です。１巻は主人公の過去の過ちが描かれてます。１巻だけ読んで挫けてしまった方、胸くそ悪くなって読むのを止めてしまった方は、勇気を出して２巻からのストーリーをじっくり読んでみてください。きっと感じるものが変わるはずです。私がそうでしたから！

I read it all the way to the end. It's a very nice work. Volume 1 depicts the protagonist's past mistakes. If you've only read volume 1 and are frustrated, or if you've stopped reading because your heart has gotten so bad, gather your courage and read the story from volume 2 carefully. I'm sure what you feel will change. Because I was like that!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 02, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

最後まで読んで欲しい作品

Works I want you to read until the end

This review contains spoilers. 一巻だけ読んで不快になった方、ぜひ最終巻まで読んでみてください。本当の物語は２巻目から始まります。いじめ、障害など重いテーマを扱う作品で、こんな救われる、希望のあるラストはなかなかないかも。登場人物達の弱さ、醜さ、愚かさがリアルで目を背けたくなる部分もありますが、読み終わった後には清々しさが残る、不思議な作品です。

This review contains spoilers. If you feel uncomfortable reading only one volume, be sure to read the last volume. The real story begins in book 2. It's a work dealing with heavy themes such as bullying and disability, and it may not be easy to have such a saved, hopeful last one. The weakness, ugliness, and foolishness of the characters are real, and there are parts that make you want to turn your eyes away, but it's a mysterious work that leaves a sense of freshness after you've finished reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 01, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

重い想い

Heavy feelings

泣けました。欠損家庭、障害者を抱える家庭、コミュニケーション障害、様々な問題を抱えている特別な人たちと見るより、自分の中にもこんな一面があるのでは？！そんな一面を誇張するとこの人と同じかも！！と思えるのでは？残酷だったり、弱虫だったり、事なかれ主義だったり、負けず嫌いだったり。自分を好きになれ大切にできて人にも同じように接する事ができる。深く重いテーマです。

It made me cry. Rather than looking at families with disabilities, families with people with disabilities, and special people with various problems such as communication disorders, don't we have this side of ourselves?! If you exaggerate that aspect, it might be just like this person!! Don't you think so? They're cruel, they're wimps, they don't care, and they don't like losing. You can love yourself, take care of yourself, and treat others in the same way. It's a deep and heavy subject.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

考えさせられた

It made me think

友達に勧められて読みました最初の方は、何なのこの子たち。すごいモヤモヤした気持ちになったんですけどすごい考えさせられました！よかったです^ ^

A friend recommended it to me and the first one I read was what are these kids. It made me feel so confused, but it made me think so much! I'm glad ^ ^

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

嫌な自分が変わらなくても

Even if my bad self doesn't change

This review contains spoilers. 序盤のいじめが見てて、キツイけど、学校のいじめ現場はもっときつかったりする。作者がそこに向き合って、きっちり描いてくれたのをまず評価したい。主人公がいじめる側から、いじめられる側に転換するのは、学校の空気感からよくわかる話だった。友達のいない孤独な主人公が死を決意し、どぎつく虐めていた西宮と再会し、謝罪して消えようとしたが、主人公を許し、受け入れる西宮は天使過ぎます。（少年漫画を愛読する少年青年男子の心を鷲掴みにするヒロインです。いじめた男なんて、普通は完全無視して終わりでしょうね…）孤独な主人公が贖罪をしているうちに、次々と友達と呼べる人達ができていくのだが、その一人一人に、自分の嫌なところがあって、ぶつかりあって、その輪が崩れてしまうが、ぶつかり合っても、一つになっていくところは素敵でした。また、嫌な自分を変えようと足掻いているうちに、未来が変わっていくのかなと、希望を持たせてくれました。

This review contains spoilers. I watched the bullying in the early stages, and it's tough, but the school bullying scene is even tougher. First, I would like to evaluate the fact that the author faced it and drew it so well. The main character's transition from the side where he is bullied to the side where he is bullied was a story I could understand very well from the atmosphere of the school. The lonely protagonist with no friends decides to die, reunites with Nishinomiya, who was being harshly bullied, apologized, and tried to disappear, but Nishinomiya, who forgives and accepts the protagonist, is too much of an angel. (This is a heroine who captures the hearts of boys and young boys who love to read shonen comics. (The man who bullied him would usually end up completely ignoring it...) While the lonely protagonist was making an atonement, people formed one after another, and each of them had something they didn't like, and they collided, and that circle fell apart, but even when they collided, it was wonderful that they became one. Also, while I was scratching my feet to change my bad self, it gave me hope that the future would change.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

後がある

There's a back

今、自分が嫌いで価値がなくみんなと同じように普通になれないただ生きていることが苦しい人は、後10年頑張って生きて欲しい。そうしたら、全く違う人達に囲まれて別の環境にいて笑っているあなたがいます。変わる過程は苦しい、逃げても閉じこもるのもいい、がむしゃらにぶつかるのもいい、いつもそのままのあなたのままでいいんだよ。じわじわと大人になっていき、過去を反省できることは幸せなのかもしれない…と読んでいて思いました。

I want people who don't like themselves, have no value, and just suffer from living a normal life like everyone else, to work hard for another 10 years. Then, you're in a different environment, surrounded by completely different people and laughing. The process of change is painful; it's okay to run away or stay locked up, it's good to bump into each other, and you can always just be who you are. As I read, I gradually became an adult, and being able to reflect on the past might be happiness...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 19, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

意外な内容

Surprising content

続けて読みたくなりました、興味が出たのは後は映画化ですかね？

It made me want to keep reading it; what got me interested was the movie adaptation after that, right?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 19, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らしい作品

Great work

いじめに関する作品で友情、恋愛、親子関係などいろいろと考えさせられる漫画でした！

It was a comic about bullying that made me think about friendship, romance, parent-child relationships, etc.!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けた

I was able to cry

聴覚障がい者がどのように生きて、苦しんできたか。とても目頭が熱くなるお話でした。耳が聞こえなくても、手話や口話で伝える術はある。だからこそ、その言葉を聞くことだって出来る。そして。向き合うことだって出来る。人と違うことは、そんなに異端なことなのか？違ったって、こうやって互いを知っていくことはできるのだから。主人公たちを取り巻く環境の中で、思春期ながらの葛藤や熱い思い、そして、ぶつかり合う心の叫び色々と考えさせられました。

How have hearing-impaired people lived and suffered. It was a story that made my eyes feel very hot. Even if you're deaf, there are ways to communicate in sign language or spoken language. That's why I can even hear those words. and. We can even face each other. Is being different from others such a heresy thing? Other than that, we can get to know each other this way. The environment surrounding the main characters made me think about various conflicts, passion, and cries of conflicting hearts just like in adolescence.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 15, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

明日ママ

Tomorrow mom

レビューを見るとかなり評価が分かれてますが、以前ドラマであった明日ママを思い出しました。冒頭だけをみて低評価する人が多数いるということ。。

When I looked at the reviews, the ratings were quite divided, but it reminded me of Tomorrow's Mama, which used to be a drama. It means that there are many people who only look at the beginning and give it a low evaluation..

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 15, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

久しぶりに涙がでました

Tears for the first time in a long time

いろんな感情が出てくる漫画だと思いました。漫画の話ですが、誰もが一度は経験したことがあるのではないでしょうか。イジメは駄目だと正義論ばかりな話より共感できました。

I thought it was a comic where all kinds of emotions came out. It's a comic story, but I think everyone has experienced it at least once. I was able to sympathize with the fact that bullying is bad rather than a story full of arguments about justice.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 14, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

すごいリアル

So real

週マガの方で読み切りを初めて読んだ時、涙が止まりませんでした。わたしも小学生の時、同じクラスに聴覚障害ではありませんが、身体に障害のある子がいました。この漫画のような直接的ないじめはありませんでしたが、その子を疎んでいる子は確かにいて、私もそ内の1人でした。そして、その子に対してではありませんが、私自身いじめを受け、いじめをしたことがあります。中学に上がってからあることをきっかけに、自分がどれだけ小さく弱い人間かと思い知り、深く反省しました。その矢先、中学2年の時に読んだこの作品。いろんなことを思い出し、重ね、登場人物どの人の気持ちも私にはわかりました。恐らく、一つのクラスにこれほどの感情をそれぞれ持った子が集まるのはありえないと思います。でも漫画ですんで←少しオーバーで、極端に描いているところもあると思います。でもそんな事言ったらグダグダグダグダ、いつまでたっても話なんて進みません。このくらいでいいと思います。一巻だけを読んでどうこういう前に、最後までよんでから文句言ってもらいたいですね笑笑本当にリアルで考えさせられる作品だと思います。

I couldn't stop crying when I first read the one-off in the weekly magazine. When I was in elementary school, there was a child in the same class who was not deaf, but was physically disabled. There was no direct bullying like in this comic, but there were certainly children who despised that child, and I was one of them. Also, although not against that child, I myself have been bullied and bullied. Since I was in junior high school, I realized how small and weak I was, and I deeply reflected on it. Just after that, I read this work when I was in the 2nd year of middle school. I remembered and repeated a lot of things, and I understood the feelings of every character. I think it's probably impossible for children with such feelings to gather in one class. But since it's a comic, ← it's slightly over, and I think there are places that are extremely drawn. But if I say such a thing, it's ridiculous, the story won't progress no matter how long it's been. I think this is enough. I want people to read only one volume and complain before and after reading it all the way to the end lol lol I think it's a really real and thought-provoking work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 11, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

私もいじめにあっていました

I was being bullied too

This review contains spoilers. 障害を持った子は私の学年にはいませんでしたが、小学校の時、クラスであったいじめで一人の男の子が転校しました。私もそれを見て見ぬふりをした一人です。そして、中学に入ると、私自身がいじめにあうようになりました。それ以降、主人公と同じように、自分が悪いと考えるようになりました。もう40歳にもなりますが、いまも友達がいません。結婚もしていません。人との距離のとり方が全然分からないんです。昨日まで仲がいい友達と思っていた人が急に手のひらを返すあの光景は未だに忘れる事は出来ません。忘れようとするほど、鮮明に思い出します。そんな自分のこれまでの人生と本当に多くのことが被る作品でした。謝れる相手がいるのは幸せな事です。自分の人生にもこんな瞬間が来るのかなぁと思うと、本当に自分自身も情けなくなり、私みたいな人がこれ以上増えない事を祈ってしまいます。主人公が未来に希望を感じて終わる描写は、私みたいな人間からすると、救われる気持ちになりました。

This review contains spoilers. There were no children with disabilities in my grade, but when I was in elementary school, one boy was transferred due to bullying in my class. I was one of those people who pretended not to see it. Then, when I entered junior high school, I myself began to be bullied. After that, like the main character, I began to think that I was bad. I'm already 40 years old, and I still don't have any friends. I'm not even married. I don't know how to keep a distance from people at all. I still can't forget that scene where people I thought were close friends until yesterday suddenly return their palm. The more I try to forget it, the more vividly I remember it. It was a work where so many things intersected with my life up until now. It's a happy thing to have someone to apologize to. When I wonder if a moment like this will come in my life, I really feel sorry for myself, and I pray that there won't be any more people like me. The depiction where the main character ends feeling hopeful for the future made me feel saved from the point of view of a person like me.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 11, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

めちゃくちゃ感動した！

I was so moved!

This review contains spoilers. 最終回に石田が西宮を手を繋ぎながら西宮をエスコートする姿を見て涙が出てきて本当に感動した映画も楽しみだな

This review contains spoilers. I'm also looking forward to the movie where I was really moved when I saw Ishida escorting Nishinomiya while holding hands in the final episode, and I was really moved

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 23, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

泣きました

I cried

この先が気になりました。最近読んだ中でも最高に心をかき乱す作品でした。読んだ後に残る、なんとも言えない高揚感は溺れるナイフと似ていました。

I was worried about the future. It was one of the most disturbing works I've read recently. The indescribable feeling of elation that remained after reading it was similar to a drowning knife.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 21, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けた

I was able to cry

This review contains spoilers. 主人公にとっては興味がある相手へののちょっかいのつもりだったのかな。でもやり方が酷すぎる。そして、仕返しされても仕方ない気もしたけど、少し可哀想に思えた。(彼だけが悪いわけではないようにも)いじめられることをきっかけに人の痛みがよりわかる人になってよかった。主人公は、「助ける」ってとても勇気がいる行動ができて凄いと思いました。感動です！！

This review contains spoilers. I wonder if the main character meant it was a little bit about someone he was interested in. But it's too bad to do it. Also, I felt that it was unavoidable even if they were retaliated against, but it seemed a little pitiful. I'm glad he became a person who understood people's pain better after being bullied (even though he wasn't the only one to blame). I thought it was amazing that the main character was able to do an act that required so much courage to “help.” I'm impressed!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 16, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

おすすめです！

I recommend it!

読んでよかった！久々に感動しました！一人一人の視点から、それぞれの心情が伝わってきました。

I'm glad I read it! I was moved after a long time! Each person's feelings were conveyed from each person's point of view.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 03, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

聲の形

The shape of a voice

色々な意見があるけど俺はすごくいい作品だと思う。障害やいじめについて考えるきっかけになると思う。

There are a lot of opinions, but I think it's a really good work. I think it will be an opportunity to think about disability and bullying.

Helpful

Reviews for A Silent Voice Manga