We Were Broken From the Start

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jan 16, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English
  よかったー！
  That was great!
  落とし前つけてもらいます、が好きすぎて、こちらも定額をオーバーしてまで買ってしまいましたが買ってよかったです！確かにギャグは少なめでしたが、切ないのと、くすって笑うのと、きゃんっ！てなるのとバランスが絶妙で素晴らしいー！まだまだいっぱい読みたいから、いっぱい作品かいていただきたいです！山田先生の大ファンになりました！！

  I was asked to put it on before dropping it, I liked it so much that I even bought this one over the fixed price, but I'm glad I bought it! Certainly, there were few gags, but they were sad and laughed so loud, huh! The balance with Tenaru is exquisite and wonderful! I still want to read a lot more, so I'd like you to read lots of works! I'm now a big fan of Yamada sensei!!

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jul 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  タイトルの通りでした
  It was as the title said
  This review contains spoilers. 予め言っておくと、設定はサイテーな始まりです。犯罪じゃん！？とご指摘いただくのではないかと思われます。でも、読み進むにつれてエロいだけの流され展開というワケじゃない理由が見えてきて、だんだんと印象が良い方へ変わるんじゃないかなぁ・・・と思います。もともと２人ともちょっと壊れた経験を持つキャラで、そんな２人が出遭ったことでお互いを壊し合うようにエロ展開するうちに関係が変化します。共感はされづらい2人かな、と思いますが、そっと見守ってあげたくなります。あと個人的にはこの年齢差の受攻がかなり好きなもので、☆５つにさせていただきました！ただ、この２人がその後普通に「幸せに暮らしましたとさ」とはならないんじゃないか？という気がして、できれば小冊子でもなんでもいいので続編が読みたいです！

  This review contains spoilers. Let me preface it, the settings are a wild start. isn't it a crime!? I think you'll point it out. However, as I read on, I began to see the reason why it wasn't just erotic, and I think it would gradually change to a better impression... Originally, both of them were characters with slightly broken experiences, and the relationship changed as they developed erotically to destroy each other due to the encounter between these two people. I think it's hard for these two people to sympathize with, but it makes me want to watch them softly. Also, personally, I like this age difference attack quite a bit, so I set it to ☆ 5! However, aren't these two people usually “living a happy life” after that? I feel like that, and if possible, a booklet or whatever, so I'd like to read the sequel!

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jul 08, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  「ち○ちがイライラする」がキーワードです
  “I'm frustrated” is the keyword
  さすがまりお先生。すっとぼけ具合と噛み合わさが癖になります。受け攻めともに傷があるのですが、重くなりすぎず。何がどういいのが、うまく伝えられないのですが、先生の作品って、一回読むと、つい何度もリピートしてしまいます。無意識に手が延びてしまう、スルメみたいな読後感…。

  As expected, Mario-sensei. I have a habit of blur and the way it meshes. There are wounds on both attacks, but they don't get too heavy. I can't really convey what is good about it, but once I read the teacher's work, I just repeat it over and over again. A feeling after reading, like surume, that my hands stretch out unknowingly...

  Helpful