We Were Broken From the Start Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 16, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

よかったー！

That was great!

落とし前つけてもらいます、が好きすぎて、こちらも定額をオーバーしてまで買ってしまいましたが買ってよかったです！確かにギャグは少なめでしたが、切ないのと、くすって笑うのと、きゃんっ！てなるのとバランスが絶妙で素晴らしいー！まだまだいっぱい読みたいから、いっぱい作品かいていただきたいです！山田先生の大ファンになりました！！

I was asked to put it on before dropping it, I liked it so much that I even bought this one over the fixed price, but I'm glad I bought it! Certainly, there were few gags, but they were sad and laughed so loud, huh! The balance with Tenaru is exquisite and wonderful! I still want to read a lot more, so I'd like you to read lots of works! I'm now a big fan of Yamada sensei!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

タイトルの通りでした

It was as the title said

This review contains spoilers. 予め言っておくと、設定はサイテーな始まりです。犯罪じゃん！？とご指摘いただくのではないかと思われます。でも、読み進むにつれてエロいだけの流され展開というワケじゃない理由が見えてきて、だんだんと印象が良い方へ変わるんじゃないかなぁ・・・と思います。もともと２人ともちょっと壊れた経験を持つキャラで、そんな２人が出遭ったことでお互いを壊し合うようにエロ展開するうちに関係が変化します。共感はされづらい2人かな、と思いますが、そっと見守ってあげたくなります。あと個人的にはこの年齢差の受攻がかなり好きなもので、☆５つにさせていただきました！ただ、この２人がその後普通に「幸せに暮らしましたとさ」とはならないんじゃないか？という気がして、できれば小冊子でもなんでもいいので続編が読みたいです！

This review contains spoilers. Let me preface it, the settings are a wild start. isn't it a crime!? I think you'll point it out. However, as I read on, I began to see the reason why it wasn't just erotic, and I think it would gradually change to a better impression... Originally, both of them were characters with slightly broken experiences, and the relationship changed as they developed erotically to destroy each other due to the encounter between these two people. I think it's hard for these two people to sympathize with, but it makes me want to watch them softly. Also, personally, I like this age difference attack quite a bit, so I set it to ☆ 5! However, aren't these two people usually “living a happy life” after that? I feel like that, and if possible, a booklet or whatever, so I'd like to read the sequel!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 08, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

「ち○ちがイライラする」がキーワードです

“I'm frustrated” is the keyword

さすがまりお先生。すっとぼけ具合と噛み合わさが癖になります。受け攻めともに傷があるのですが、重くなりすぎず。何がどういいのが、うまく伝えられないのですが、先生の作品って、一回読むと、つい何度もリピートしてしまいます。無意識に手が延びてしまう、スルメみたいな読後感…。

As expected, Mario-sensei. I have a habit of blur and the way it meshes. There are wounds on both attacks, but they don't get too heavy. I can't really convey what is good about it, but once I read the teacher's work, I just repeat it over and over again. A feeling after reading, like surume, that my hands stretch out unknowingly...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 12, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

作家買い

Buy an artist

最初っからぶっ飛んでて、無理矢理から始まって痴漢だったり、とんでもないのに笑っちゃう。２人の会話のテンポもよくギャグ調なのに重い過去があったり…。とにかく飽きさせない面白さです。

They flew by from the beginning, and they started by force, they were molesters, and laughed even though it was ridiculous. The tempo of the conversation between the two was good, and even though they were gagged, they had a heavy past... Anyway, it's fun that won't let you get bored.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

笑ったーー

I laughed

This review contains spoilers. 「ち○ち○がイライラする」という最強で最高なワードに度肝抜かれました。面白すぎる。本当に明るくて楽しくて最高な作品でした！

This review contains spoilers. I was blown away by the strongest and greatest word “Chi○○ is frustrated.” It's too funny. It was a really bright, fun, and amazing work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ぶっ飛んでる‼︎

It's flying ‼ ︎

This review contains spoilers. 就活中の面接官の徹にダメ出しされて、なぜか仕返しに、レ○プに痴漢に…と、ストーカーまで？！最初からぶっ飛んでて面白かったです！

This review contains spoilers. They were screwed by the interviewer Toru during job hunting, and for some reason they got revenge, got molested... and even stalked them?! It was a blast right from the start and it was fun!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 21, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

テンポ良くて楽しい♪

Good tempo and fun ♪

This review contains spoilers. 自暴自棄なやる気ない就活中ボンボン、瀬名×就活先のいけ好かない面接官、椹木。作者様の作品はテンポ良いところが好きですが、この作品も作品名通り、テンポ良すぎです！面接官にイライラしてたつって、なんじゃい？(笑)１話目からのレイプに始まり、２話目のチカン、３、４話目の青カン…未遂？などなど…まだまだありますよ♪あ。全部瀬名×椹木ですからご安心を。いや、ホントクレイジーに勢いあって楽しいです。それにしても、椹木、ちょっと流されすぎでしょ？と思っていたら…そこはちゃんと理由があったんですね、さすがです♪結局のところ、最終的にはラブラブです。ラブラブが１番♪

This review contains spoilers. Desperate and unmotivated job-hunting bombong, Sena x job-hunting destination's displeased interviewer, Sawaragi. I like the fact that the author's work has a good tempo, but as the title suggests, the tempo is too good! Why are you frustrated with the interviewer? (Laughter) Starting with the rape from episode 1, Chikan from episode 2, Seikan from episode 3 and 4... an attempt? etc... there's more ♪ ah. Don't worry, they're all Sena x Sawaragi. No, it's really crazy, and it's fun. Even so, Sawaragi is being swept away a little too much, isn't he? If you think about it... there was a good reason for that, as expected ♪ After all, it's ultimately lovey-dovey. Lovelove is number 1 ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

中毒性のあるギャグに笑いっぱなしでした

There was a lot of laughter at the addictive gag

面白かったです。不穏な空気感から始まった二人ですが、ラストに向けて一捻りあってのゴールは流石でした。先生の作品は何から何まで独特で…セリフには笑っちゃうし、二人の設定や伏線が地雷のように思いがけない所に、驚きの形であるから「次はどうくる？」とワクワクしながら読み進められました。会話のやり取りもあっちこっち飛びまくって筋が通っていないようでいて、獣道のように実はさりげなくある…みたいな、スベるかウケるかギリギリの所を綱渡りのように進む感じが好きです。あとがきで先生が「今回は、ギャグ成分少なめの少し暗い話でしたが…」と仰っていて、正直笑いっぱなしで「どこが！？」と思いましたし、「ご自身の破壊力を見誤っておられるな」とも思いました。『落とし前つけてもらいます』に近いノリだと思います。ハマる人にはハマる、やや中毒性のあるギャグ多めの作品で面白かったです。

That was interesting. The two started with a sense of unease, but the goal was amazing after twisting towards the end. The teacher's work is unique from what to what... the lines make me laugh, and the settings and foreshadows of the two are in an unexpected place like a landmine, so “what will happen next?” I was excited to read on. The conversation also flew around here and there, and it didn't seem to make sense, and I like the feeling of walking a tightrope at the last minute, like walking a tightrope at the last minute, like being casually like a animal path... In the afterword, the teacher said, “This time, it was a slightly dark story with few gag elements...” and honestly laughed a lot and said, “Where!?” I also thought, “You're misunderstanding your own destructive power.” I think it's close to “I'll ask you to put it on before you drop it.” It was interesting because it was a work with a lot of slightly addictive gags, which are addictive to people who are addicted to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

大好きです！

I love it!

This review contains spoilers. 出ました!!この母性強めの受。大好きです♪︎でも、流されてんのかと思えば、チョット違ったりして。毎話、毎話、とんでもない、いろんな所で致しているというのに、おもしろストーリーが漂うからか、くそエロいのに何だか中和されてしまうと言うか、そこが山田先生ならではですね！デリカシーない執着攻×世話好き流され受かとおもいきや、過去の話があったり、本人も気がついてないような事があったりと…お話もおもしろかったです♪︎山田先生好きな方はもう絶対間違いなく買って下さい！そして、最後まで読んで「天国の鍵」で笑って下さい!!

This review contains spoilers. It came out!! This strong motherly acceptance. I love it ♪ ︎, but when I think it's being played, it's a little different. Every episode, every episode, is ridiculous, and in various places, and yet they say it's somehow neutralized even though it's damn erotic, that is unique to Yamada sensei! The story was also interesting ♪ ︎ If you like Yamada-sensei, you definitely want to buy it because of obsession without delicacy x being swept away by taking care of it, and there are stories from the past that even the person himself wasn't aware of... Then, read to the end and laugh at “The Key to Heaven”!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

尊大な就活生×いけ好かない面接官

An arrogant job hunting student x a displeased interviewer

This review contains spoilers. 連敗中の就活生・瀬名×いけ好かない面接官・椹木。就活で気のないそぶりの面接官・椹木に腹立ちついでにムラムラした瀬名は、街で偶然見かけた椹木に酔って絡む→椹木の服を汚して仕方なく入ったホテルで犯すというとんでもない報復に。どう考えても犯罪…(笑)やることやっても態度がでかくて悪びれない瀬名の肝の据わりっぷりがすごいな。椹木が悪態をつきながらも瀬名のやりたい放題を受け入れるのがなんで？？だったけど、二人の出会いやそれぞれの過去含め、運命的だし相性抜群。実は瀬名より椹木の方が厄介そうだけど、瀬名はむしろ喜びそうだし、ほんとにこれ以上はない割れ鍋に綴じ蓋カップルでした。同僚にバレるのも時間の問題だな。不倫略奪は絶許派なので、瀬名がお母さんと会えてなさそうなのが心残り。

This review contains spoilers. A job hunting student on a losing streak, Sena x an unhappy interviewer, Sawaragi. Sena, who was angry with the careless interviewer Sawaragi during job hunting, got drunk and got involved with Sawaragi she happened to see in the city → soiled Sawaragi's clothes and committed a crime at the hotel she had no choice but to enter. No matter how you think about it, it's a crime... (laughs) Sena has a huge attitude and doesn't get offended no matter what she does, it's amazing how careful she is. Why is Sawaragi acting evil and accepting whatever Sena does whatever he wants?? But, including their encounters and their respective pasts, they are fateful and go great together. Actually, Sawaragi seems more troublesome than Sena, but Sena seemed rather happy, and they really were a couple bound to a broken pot that couldn't be better. it's only a matter of time before a colleague finds out. Adulterous robbers are unforgivable, so it's a pity that Sena doesn't seem to be able to meet her mom.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

終始ニヤニヤしながら読んだ

I read it while smirking from beginning to end

エロいし面白いし最高でした！！内容はまぁまぁハードなはずなのになぜか笑えてしまえるの山田まりお先生らしくて最強だと思いました！好き！

It was erotic, funny, and awesome!! The content is supposed to be pretty hard, but for some reason it makes me laugh, I thought Yamada Mario sensei was the best! I like it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

なんておばかな攻めなの

What a stupid attack

無理矢理系の攻めは最後までイライラしてなんだか許せないまま終わることが多いけど、この話の攻めは頭が残念すぎる子だからか途中から笑ってしまいかわいいと思い始めた。どこまでも器の大きい受けだと思ってたけど、結局受けも攻めに救われてたと分かって良かった。続編見たい。

Forcible attacks are frustrating until the end and often end up being somewhat unforgivable, but I began to think that the attacks in this story were cute and I laughed in the middle, probably because they were kids with too bad brains. I thought it was an extremely powerful reception, but in the end, I'm glad to know that the receiver was saved by the attack. I want to see the sequel.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

なかなかな壊れよう

Looks like it's going to break quite a bit

This review contains spoilers. 山田まりおさん大好きです。ほぼほぼの作品を読んでます。今回もさすがでした。攻めがなかなかな壊れ方でやべぇやつでしたが、過去の思い出があるにしても、なかなかなあれこれを許しちゃう受けもかなり壊れてました。今回も絶妙にシュールな笑いと、ちゃんとエロしてくれて最高でした。大好きです。

This review contains spoilers. I love Mario Yamada. I've read almost all of the works. It was amazing this time too. The attack was pretty broken, and it was a terrible thing, but even if I had memories from the past, the reception that would allow this and that was pretty broken. This time, too, they had an exquisitely surreal laugh and were really erotic, which was great. I love it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

壊れてましたが、のち活性化

It was broken, but later activated

This review contains spoilers. 一話目で苦手だと思う人も居るかも。最後まで読むと、少し印象が変わるとは思いますが、妙な縁がある2人という感じでした。エチは無理矢理感がありますね´д` ;

This review contains spoilers. There may be people who don't like the first episode. If you read it to the end, I think the impression will change slightly, but it felt like they were two people with a strange relationship. There's a sense that Echi was forced to do it'`;

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 23, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

執着×5000

Obsession x 5000

嫉妬、執着凄すぎて、楽しめます。暗くなく、明るめ？恋愛系で、奪うから始まるから、どんなに暗いねんと思ってたら、攻がポジティブ過ぎて楽しめたです！

The jealousy and obsession are so great that I enjoy it. Light, not dark? It's a romance type, and it starts with stealing, so no matter how dark I thought it would be, the attack was so positive that I enjoyed it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 23, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

独特なテンポの就活生×面接官

A job hunting student with a unique tempo x interviewer

This review contains spoilers. 初めは瀬名が本当にクズでひどい事ばかりしてきますが、読んでるうちに素直なおバカ度がアップしてきて大丈夫に。親とは仲直りしてほしかったが、自分で就職先を見つけて自立するのは成長が見え良かった。トールも過去はどうあれ戒めを持って生きる姿に好感が持てた。二人はお似合いの似た者同士で、人間味のある失敗はあれど反省しているし、幸せになってほしいと思えた。独特の「間」や静かだけどテンポの良いセリフも秀逸で、シリアスな展開の中にもちょっとシュールで笑える部分もあり面白かった。

This review contains spoilers. At first, Sena is really scum and only does terrible things, but as I read, my honest stupidity level increased, and I'm fine. I wanted them to make up with my parents, but it was nice to see growth when I found my own employment and became independent. I was impressed by the way Thor lives with commandments no matter what in the past. The two are similar people who are a good match, and they are reflecting on their humane mistakes, and they wanted them to be happy. The unique “space” and quiet yet well-paced lines were excellent, and there were also parts that were a bit surreal and laughable in the serious developments, which were interesting.

Helpful

Reviews for We Were Broken From the Start Manga