A Love That Won't Turn to Foam Manga Reviews (P.10)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

表題作もっと読みたい

I want to read more of the title work

表題作は主人公の仕事でのテーマとストーリーとがうまく合わさっていて、短いながらも良くできていると思いました。というのを2回読んで理解できました。こんなに短いのがもったいない。あとの神様シリーズはカプが3組も出てきてすげぇなこの役場はって感じです。私はあまり刺さりませんでしたが、話はしっかりできていると思います。

The title work was a good combination of the main character's work theme and story, and I thought it was short yet well-made. I was able to understand it after reading it twice. It would be a waste for it to be this short. There are 3 groups of capes in the After God series, and it feels like this is an amazing government office. It didn't really stick to me, but I think the story is well made.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

よかったです！

That was great!

値下げで初めて購入の作家さん。表題作が印象に残らなかったので⭐減らしましたが、後の作品はストーリーもとてもよかったです。続編があれば買います。買ってよかったです。

The artist bought it for the first time due to a price reduction. The title work didn't leave an impression on me, so ⭐ I reduced it, but the story of the later works was also very good. If there's a sequel, I'll buy it. I'm glad I bought it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 03, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

すごくお気に入りです！

I really like it!

表題作より、神様の出てくるお話が好きです。村の役場に神が！ポスターも噴き出しました！コミカルなお話を描ける方とは思っていなかったので意外な驚きです。ただ、土木課の先生と生徒の話は受け入れられなかった。やはり先生が生徒に手を出すのは・・拒否感があります。ところで、神様の恋は成就したということでしょうか？ワタクシには読み解けませんでした・・。

I like the story in which God appears more than the title work. God is at the village office! Posters have spewed out too! I wasn't expecting someone who could draw comical stories, so I was surprised. However, the conversation between the teachers and students in the Civil Engineering Division was not accepted. After all, when teachers touch students... there is a sense of rejection. By the way, does it mean that God's love has been fulfilled? I couldn't decipher it...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

作者さん買いです。

The author is buying it.

短編集ですね。表題作品と紙シリーズ3作品と短編１つ。実は個人的には一番最後の短編が一番好みだったかな。

It's a short story. The title work, 3 works in the paper series, and 1 short story. Actually, I personally liked the very last short story the most.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

テンポよし

Good tempo

表題作と神さまのシリーズ3作と短編ひとつ。表題作はテンポ良くドキッとさせられました。神さまシリーズは続き読みたい。

The title work, 3 works in the God series, and 1 short film. The title work had a good tempo and made me feel excited. I want to continue reading the God series.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 02, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

作者さんが好きで色々な作品を読ませていただいていますがそのなかでも面白かったです。短編集ですが読みごたえがありみんな美男で萌えました。

I like the author, and I've read a lot of his works, but it was particularly interesting. It's a short story, but it was worth reading, and everyone was beautiful and I fell in love with it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 30, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買いです

I'm buying the author

三月さんの作品、すごく好きです。絵も好みですし、ストーリーにも引き込まれる。神シリーズのオムニバスがとても良かったです。初めはちょっとあやしく思えた神さま(笑)も、人とはちょっと違う体質を持ったふつうの男なんだなぁと。しかしゲイ率高めの多田野村。どこにあるんだろう…行ってみたい。

I really like March's work. I like pictures, and I'm drawn into the story. The Omnibus from the God series was really good. God, who seemed a bit suspicious at first (laughs), is also a normal man with a slightly different constitution from humans. However, Tadano Village has a high gay rate. I wonder where it is... I want to go.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 25, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

短編集

short story

This review contains spoilers. この作者さんはいつも世界観とタイトルが美しいですね。個人的には役場の神さまのお話がヒットしました。気持が顔に出る荒島と解り難い赤石、その質ゆえに彼らの関係が今に至るのだろうな…という気がして想像が広がります。大変魅力的な2人、丸々1冊彼らのお話を読んでみたいです。

This review contains spoilers. This author always has a beautiful worldview and title. Personally, the story of God at the Government Office was a hit. I have a feeling that their relationship will reach the present due to the quality of Arashima, whose feelings come out on their faces, and Akaishi, who is difficult to understand... my imagination expands. I want to read the whole story of these two very charming people in one book.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 17, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

盛りだくさんだけど

There are a lot of them

表題作とシリーズもの3作と短編1作。表題作はさらっとしてて、読み応えには欠けてたかな。最後の短編が好みでした。

3 title works and a series, and 1 short film. The title work was empty, and I think it lacked readability. I liked the last short story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

いい

That's good

複数カップリングの複雑で切ないラブストーリーです。でもちゃんと全部ハッピーエンドになります。

It's a complicated and painful love story with multiple couplings. But it all has a happy ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

表紙からの中表紙が素敵！

The middle cover from cover to cover is wonderful!

丸々表題作ではなかったのでちょっと残念でした。後日談とかほしかったな。神様シリーズもなかなかでした。

It wasn't a complete title work, so it was a bit disappointing. I wanted to talk about it at a later date. The God series was pretty good too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 28, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

どれも良かった

All of them were good

短編集の詰め合わせです。表題作と最後の短編以外は舞台が繋がっています。表題作も良かったですが、それ以上に「神は役場にいる」シリーズが気に入りました。切なかったりキュンキュンしたりで面白かったです。特にこのシリーズの主役の赤石と荒島のやり取りが好きです。片想いをこじらせてる受けと、どこか天然？な攻めの会話にニヤニヤしてしまいます。みんな末永くお幸せに。

This is an assortment of short stories. Other than the title work and the final short film, the stage is connected. The title work was good, but more than that, I liked the “God Is in the Government Office” series. It was so sad and funny. I especially like the interaction between Akaishi, the protagonist of this series, and Arashima. Is it something natural between the reception that is bothering unrequited love? It makes me grin at such an aggressive conversation. May everyone be happy for a long time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 22, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

表紙に惹かれて

Attracted by the cover

雰囲気あるタイトルと表紙イラストに惹かれて購入。期待値が高すぎたのか、ハマりきれず、でした。

I was attracted to the atmospheric title and cover illustration and bought it. Maybe my expectations were too high, and I wasn't fully addicted to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

どれもいい！

Any one is good!

短編はあまり読まないけど、ずーっと気になっていたので。なんか良かったなー。もっと読みたい感じもするけど、これで終わってるからいい気もする。

I don't read many short stories, but I've always been interested in them. Something was good. I also feel like I want to read more, but now that it's over, I also feel good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

高濃度！

High concentration!

どの話も濃くて面白い。表題作はもうちょっと続きが読みたいし、結局神はどっちなのだろう？という疑問を残しつつ、ヤンキーカップルもかわいいし、お得感満載の短編集でした。

Every story is intense and interesting. I want to continue reading the title work, but which one is God after all? While leaving the question, the Yankee couple were cute, and it was a short story full of great value.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 30, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

短編集ですが各話すごく密度が高くて話もよくまとまっていて絵も綺麗ですごく読みやすいです。表題作のモノローグの入り方が好きです。

Although it is a short story, the density of each story is very high, the stories are well organized, and the pictures are beautiful and very easy to read. I like the way the title monologue is included.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 26, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった。

That was interesting.

表題作は好みでなかった。「～役場にいる」は赤石が良いキャラでシリアスの中で面白かった。３CPの話でどれも良かったけど、先生と生徒CPの話が１番好き。先生は可愛いし生徒はワンコでいい奴でよかった。最後の作品は面白かったけど二人がするところまでは到らず残念。翠の受見たかったな～。

I didn't like the title work. “I'm at the government office...” is a good character for Akaishi, and it was interesting in serious situations. All of the 3CP stories were good, but I liked the teacher and student CP story the most. I'm glad the teachers are cute and the students are nice dogs. The last work was interesting, but it's a pity they didn't get to the point where the two of them did it. I wanted to see Midori receive it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 31, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

オムニバス

omnibus

ちょっとしっかり読み込まないとストーリーに辿りつけない感じ柔らかな優しい雰囲気が好き

I like the soft, gentle atmosphere where I feel like I can't reach the story until I read it a little bit carefully

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 16, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった！

That was great!

何編かお話がありますが、表題作がお気に入りです。三月先生の独特の世界観というかわかりやすくない感じが好きなのですごく良かったです。もっと続きが読みたかったな。神様シリーズも良かった。色々な形の恋があって全編通して楽しく読めました。

There are several stories, but the title work is my favorite. I like Mitsuki-sensei's unique view of the world and the feeling that it's not easy to understand, so it was really nice. I wanted to read more. The God series was good too. There are many forms of love, and I enjoyed reading the whole story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 07, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

表題作は少しだけ、後は神シリーズ

The title work is just a little bit, and the rest is the God series

表題作はあっちゅーまに終わります！いい話だけどね！意地っ張りのロマンチストはこじらせてるよねーー！って話です（笑笑）でも、上手くまとまってて、表現とか進み方とかが秀逸。ネタ的にはそんな変わったこともないんだけど、かなり演出が上手い！と思う作品です。表題作の後はほぼ神シリーズです。神シリーズって何？！？！ってなりますよね。死者と通じ合えるという特殊能力を持っているとされる他称「神」の周りの人たちの恋愛シリーズです。神本人のもあります？！基本的にノンケくんとゲイくんの話ですが、、、BLあるあるで、狭い交遊範囲にゲイカップルがわんさかパターンです（笑笑）読んでほっこりするお話たちです。

The title work comes to an end right away! Nice story though! mean romantics are freaking out! It's a story (lol lol), but it's well-organized, and the way it's expressed and progressed are excellent. The story hasn't changed that much, but they're pretty good at directing! It's a work I think. After the title work, it's almost the God series. What is the God series?!?! It's going to be, isn't it? It is a romance series about people around the other name “God,” who is said to have a special ability to communicate with the dead. God himself is there too?! Basically, it's a story about Nonke-kun and Gay-kun, but... there is BL, and gay couples have a wacky pattern in a narrow circle of interaction (lol lol) and these are stories that make me feel relaxed when I read them.

Helpful

Reviews for A Love That Won't Turn to Foam Manga