A Love That Won't Turn to Foam Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 06, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

三月えみ先生短編集

March Emi sensei short story

This review contains spoilers. 短編集と言いつつも、6話あるうちの4話は「神シリーズ」のオムニバスです。表題作は映画配給会社のお話。お仕事漫画かな？と思ったら、初えちのシチュエーションに大仰天しました。うひょおぉ。最後のページでものすごく綺麗にまとめられていて、素晴らしい一話完結。「神シリーズ」は、最初のお話がすごく切なかった。他にもワンコ攻めや「神」とあだ名のついた個性的キャラ（なのに村役場の土木課というのが良い！）など出てきて、めちゃくちゃ面白かった！ファンタジーっぽくもありつつ、あくまで現実的で大人な男たちの物語で、とても好き。最後の「いい子でごめんね！」は、ヤンキー話としては王道のスカッとするやつでしたが、2人の関係はその始まり方や実際の関係値が、もしかしたら地雷の人がいるかもしれないドキドキなやつです。一冊で色んな感情になれて、大変美味しゅうございました。総218ページでしたが、腹15分目くらいいきました。

This review contains spoilers. Even though it's called a short story, 4 of the 6 episodes are omnibus of the “God Series.” The title film is about a film distribution company. Maybe it's a work comic? When I thought about it, I was amazed at the first time situation. whoa. It was put together extremely neatly on the last page, and a wonderful episode was completed. The first story of the “God Series” was really sad. Other unique characters with dog attacks and the nickname “God” (but the village office's civil engineering department is good!) etc. came up, and it was insanely interesting! It's a fantasy story about realistic, mature men, and I really like it. The last “Sorry for being a good kid!” As a Yankee story, it was a thrilling one, but the way the relationship between the two began and the actual relationship values are exciting, and maybe there are people with landmines. I was able to get a lot of emotions in one book, and it was so delicious. It was a total of 218 pages, but my stomach felt good for about 15 minutes.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 24, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

《予言》38～41頁読んで38頁に戻り〼

Read pages 38-41 of “The Prophecy” and go back to page 38

This review contains spoilers. 映画会社の話。島の役場で働く人たちの話。ざっくり言えばこのふたつのお話で構成されています。映画会社の話は切ないなかにオチもあり。短い中でストーリーが完成されていて良かったです。島の役場で働く人たちの話は、オムニバスで出てくる登場人物入れ替わりながら、お話が進行してゆきます。38頁から41頁まで捲り、『ソゾゾッ』として、38頁に戻るという。(多分、皆さんも同じことやるはず)三月えみ先生、ほんと好き。切なさを生み出す神かも。

This review contains spoilers. A story about a film company. A story about people who work at the island's government office. Roughly speaking, it consists of these two stories. While the story about the film company is sad, it also has a punch line. I'm glad the story was completed in such a short time. The story of the people who work at the island's office progresses while the characters that appear on the omnibus are replaced. It is said that it will roll up from page 38 to page 41, and return to page 38 as “disgusting.” (Probably everyone would do the same thing) I really like Emi March. Maybe it's a god that creates sadness.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 30, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい表紙とタイトル

Beautiful cover and title

まず表紙とタイトルがとても美しいです。その雰囲気からロマンチックな内容かと思いきや、ヒリヒリとした男たちのお話でしたね。そして神シリーズ、せつなかったです。「神」の存在がコミカルであればあるほどそれが浮き彫りになるようでした。もっと見たかったです。

First of all, the cover and title are very beautiful. I thought the content was romantic because of its atmosphere, but it was a story about men who were tingling. And the God series was tough. The more comical the existence of “God,” the more it seemed to come to light. I wanted to see more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 08, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

めっちゃよかったです

That was really good

This review contains spoilers. 表題作後のオムニバスで神様シリーズで役場のお話がすごく全部面白かったです。すごくスピリチュアルな感じで切なくも暖かくじんわりとなりました。

This review contains spoilers. All of the stories about the government office in the Omnibus God series after the title was written were really interesting. It was a very spiritual feeling, and it felt warm and relaxed even though I was sad.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

短編集

short story

だけど！読み応えがあって面白かったです！ええ、思ってた以上に、神様の設定のお話、オムニバスっていうんですか？あれシリーズが特に好きかもです。

BUT! It was a great read and interesting! Well, more than I thought, is the story about God's setting called Omnibus? Maybe I particularly like that series.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 29, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

好きな作家さん

Favorite authors

三月えみさん好きで、何冊か買っていますがその中でも好きな作品です。絵柄が好みなのでそれだけでも読んでて楽しいですが、キャラがちゃんと男性なのにかわいくって好きです。表題作がいちばん印象深いですが、神シリーズもまたいいです。おすすめ！！

I like Emi March, and I've bought several books, but this is my favorite work among them. I like the design, so it's fun to read that alone, but I like that the characters are cute even though they are really male. The title work is the most impressive, but the God series is also good. I recommend it!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

大満足な短編集

Very satisfying short story

This review contains spoilers. 大人の恋愛を描いた表題作の他、神様シリーズのオムニバス短編集とその他1編が入った盛り合わせ作品。全部で5本の短編が入った短編集です。どの作品も短いのに、それを感じさせないストーリーが盛り込まれていて、とても満足度の高い作品だと思います。テイストも大人の切ない恋愛だったり、ちょっと不思議な神様が出てきたり、叔父と甥っ子という親族同士だったりと全く異なる世界観のもので構成されていて飽きることがありません。この短さにキャラたちの心情を上手く混ぜ、一つのお話として上手くまとめられるのは三月先生ならではの魅力だと思います。一番恋愛っぽくないですが、神様が荒島と付き合うお話が何故か一番印象に残りました。不思議な力を持つ人にとって、言葉では説明出来ない陽の力を持つ人に側にいて欲しい気持ちは十分特別な想いに感じたからです。神様も癒されたい時があるよね、とほんわかした気持ちになりました。

This review contains spoilers. In addition to the title work depicting adult romance, this is an omnibus short story from the God Series and 1 other part in an assortment. This short story contains a total of 5 short stories. Even though every work is short, it contains stories that don't make you feel that, and I think it's a very satisfying work. The taste is also composed of things with completely different worldviews, such as sad love between adults, a slightly strange god appearing, and relatives called an uncle and nephew, so I never get tired of it. I think the appeal unique to March sensei is that it is so short that the feelings of the characters are well mixed and put together well as a single story. It's not like love at all, but for some reason the story of God's relationship with a deserted island left the biggest impression on me. This is because I felt that for people with mysterious powers, the feeling of wanting someone with positive powers to be by their side, which cannot be explained in words, was a special enough feeling. It made me really understand that there are times when God also wants to be healed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

表紙から何から大好き！

I love it from the cover!

This review contains spoilers. 三月先生の短編集。表題作は独立していて、他3篇は町役場を通じて繋がっているオムニバス形式、最後にまた独立した短編という構成。初めて読んだ時に、表題作の攻めをなんて嫌なヤツと思ったけれど読み返したらそんな事なく、思慮深い男前。２人の路地裏でのキスシーンがとても良かった。タイトルは悲しげだけど、雰囲気があって好き!！町役場繋がりの短編も、すごく良かったです。特に神様と呼ばれる彼にとっての神様は、、、切ないながら心があったかくなるお話で大変好みでした。つまり、お話全部好き～。ピリッとしたり、切なかったり、ちょっと不思議(ファンタジー科学!最高)だったり、もちろんキュンあり、大充実の短編集です。ここまで満足度の高い短編集はなかなかないのでは。

This review contains spoilers. A short story by Mr. March. The title work is independent, and the other 3 chapters are composed of an omnibus format connected through the town hall, and finally an independent short story. When I first read it, I thought the attack in the title work was disgusting, but when I reread it, that wasn't the case, and he was a thoughtful handsome man. The kiss scene between the two of them in the back alley was really nice. The title is sad, but I like it because it has an atmosphere!! The short story about connecting to the town hall was also really good. In particular, God for him, who is called God, was a sad yet heart-warming story, and I really liked it. In other words, I like all the stories. It's tangy, sad, and a little strange (fantasy science! It's an amazing), and of course, it's a very fulfilling short story. I don't think there are many short stories with such a high level of satisfaction.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

神様…

god...

This review contains spoilers. ＊どのお話も全部良かったのですが、私は神様シリーズが1番刺さりました。序盤の蓼科さんからすでに泣かされ、中盤旭くんに泣かされ、終盤はいよいよ…嗚呼！そうか、そうだったのか。神様は確かに役場にいたね…そう思った時にまた溢れるものが込み上げてきちゃって。さすがさすがの三月先生作品でした。なんやかやで後回しにしてしまっていたのですが、ようやく読めて感涙。なんでこんなに後回しにしてたんやジブン、さっさと購読しとけや！ってなりました（笑）ありがとうございました、星5つ！！

This review contains spoilers. *Every story was good, but the God series stuck with me the most. I was already made to cry by Mr. Tateshina at the beginning, made me cry by Asahi in the middle, and the final stage is finally here... oh my! I see, was that so? God was certainly at the government office... just when I thought so, an overflow of things started pouring in again. As expected, it was a March teacher's work. I had put it on the back burner for some reason, but I was in tears when I finally read it. Why were you putting it on the back burner so much, Jibun, so quickly subscribe! That's it (laughs) thank you, 5 stars!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

短編の魅力について考えさせられる

Makes me think about the appeal of short stories

「拒まない男」がすごく良かったので三月えみ先生の2作目。あ、短編集か…とちょっと残念に思ったのに、読んでみたら素晴らしかった。表題作が、短いが故に隅々まで情感が行き届いていて、気持ちが完全に持っていかれました。お話も驚きに満ちて読み応えたっぷりな上、主人公二人が魅力的。三月先生の描く男の人は、見た目も中身も不思議にセクシーで、存在感があって、短編をしっかり支えています。もっと読みたいけど、でもこのままで完璧だと思ってしまう、短編という形の魅力すら見直してしまうような作品でした。その後で表紙から続く三枚の絵を見ると、胸がギュッとして見惚れてしまう。こんな恋をしてしまったら、大変だな…。神のオムニバスも素晴らしかったし、本当に贅沢な一冊です！

“The Man Who Doesn't Reject” was so good that it was March Emi Sensei's second film. Ah, I thought it was a short story... but it was wonderful when I read it. Since the title work was short, the emotion was thorough in every corner, and the feeling was completely carried away. The story is also full of surprises and is easy to read, and the two main characters are fascinating. The man drawn by Mitsuki sensei is strangely sexy in appearance and content, has a strong presence, and supports the short story well. It was a work that made me want to read more, but it made me think it was perfect as it is, and it even made me review the appeal of the short form. After that, when I look at the three pictures that continue from the cover, my heart is tight and I fall in love with them. it would be hard to fall in love like this... God's Omnibus was also amazing, and it's a really luxurious book!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買い

Buy the artist

This review contains spoilers. 表題作と神シリーズ短編集。作者様も後書きで書いてますが受けが全員拗らせてる笑。それがさ、とっても愛おしくなってくるんですよ。全編通して一筋縄ではいかない恋なので、一つの恋を読み終わるたびに、報われてよかったとか前を向けてよかったとか切ないため息をついてました。個人的にはどれも凄く好きなCPばかり。神シリーズの通称神さまは亡くなった人の声を聞ける特殊な力を持ってる人間で、周りの恋路を少し手助けしてる設定。短編だからこそ無駄なシーンがなくてそれぞれの恋をギュッと凝縮してある感じ。甘さは少ないですが色んな感情が見れて買ってよかったです。

This review contains spoilers. The title work and the God series short story. The author also wrote it in the afterword, but everyone was relentless lol. Well, that makes me so adorable. It's a love that isn't straightforward throughout the entire story, so every time I finished reading One Love, I sighed sad that I was glad I was rewarded or that I was glad I was able to look forward. Personally, all of them are just CPs that I really like. God, commonly known as God in the God series, is a person who has a special power to hear the voices of people who have died, and the setting helps people around them a little bit with their love paths. Because it's a short film, there are no useless scenes, and it feels like each love is tightly condensed. There is little sweetness, but I'm glad I was able to see so many emotions.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

オムニバス最高

Omnibus is the best

This review contains spoilers. 全部いいね！3作あります。だからこそ、短編で終わらずたくさん読みたい！！表題作、攻めが好みです。神シリーズ、もっと背景も含み、神様と荒島の先もみたい！あ、ワンコ好きなので、旭推しです。「いい子〜」の翠もいいね〜、受けらしいけど。あとがきの三月先生の設定解説と麗人仕様よかったです（笑）

This review contains spoilers. It's all good! There are 3 works. That's why I want to read a lot without ending with a short story!! I like the title work, Attack. The God series includes more background, and it also looks like God and the other side of the desert island! Oh, I like dogs, so I recommend Asahi. Midori from “The Good Kid” is good too, but she seems to have received it. The set-up explanation and beauty specifications for the afterword by Mr. March were good (laughs)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

シリーズもあるから短編集のような

There's also a series, so it's like a short story

This review contains spoilers. 表題作+2タイトル(1つはシリーズ)、全218P。表題作は、一緒に転職するはずだった元同僚のお話。小林くんが泣きながら好きだって言うの可愛かったし、余裕ある石原さんかっこよかった。もう1タイトルはシリーズになってて1番長い。霊能力がある役場職員、神様が全部に出てくる3CPのお話。測量士、教師と生徒、神様自身と同僚で昔からの友人荒島さん。ラブラブカップルというよりは、背負ってる事があって神様のお陰でいい方向に向かっていくお話たち。144Pの離して、やだ、やだよね！！わかる！！の2人のやり取り可愛すぎたなぁ。もう1タイトルは叔父、甥っ子もの。叔父さんは伝説のヤンキー、甥っ子は叔父さんのせいでグレちゃった。可愛い。グレちゃう理由が可愛い。修正は白抜き

This review contains spoilers. Title work+2 titles (1 in a series), 218P in total. The title story is about a former colleague who was supposed to change jobs together. Kobayashi-kun crying and saying he likes him was cute, and Ishihara-san, who had time to spare, was cool. The other title is the longest in the series. A 3CP story where God, a government office employee with psychic powers, appears in all of them. A surveyor, teacher and student, God himself and his old friend Arashima. Rather than being a lovey-dovey couple, these are stories where they have things on their backs and go in a good direction thanks to God. Release the 144P, no, no! Understood!! The interaction between the two was too cute. The other title is for my uncle and nephew. My uncle is a legendary Yankee, and my nephew went crazy because of his uncle. cute. Glee's reason is cute. Corrections are blank

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

内容の濃い短編集

Short stories with a lot of content

あまり短編ものは好きではないのですが、さすがの三月先生、ひとつひとつのクオリティが高いです。とっても切ないのに暗くなり過ぎずドライ過ぎない。その匙加減が素晴らしくていつも魅了されています。

I don't really like short stories, but as expected, the quality of each one, Mr. March is high. Even though it's so sad, it's not too dark and not too dry. I am always fascinated by how well it is done.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

好き～！

I like it~!

作家買いです！表紙がステキ！ストーリーの引き出しの多さとお話の展開の面白さは三月さんならではです！！大好きです！短編とは思えないストーリーのボリュームです。“神様”シリーズが好きです。三月さんの作品好きな方なら読むことをオススメします！

I'm buying an artist! The cover is wonderful! The large number of story drawers and the fun of the story development are unique to March!! I love it! It's a volume of stories that don't seem like a short story. I like the “God” series. If you like March's work, I recommend reading it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 13, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

心臓を鷲掴みにされる。

My heart is taken by an eagle.

作者様買い。上手く言葉で表現できないけど、読んでると、剥き出しの心臓を鷲掴みにされているような感覚に陥る。本心が暴かれる、剥き出しになる、上手く取り繕えず溢れ出る想い、そんなものに心打たれる。私にとって、そんな作品達。

Buy the author. I can't express it well in words, but when I read it, I feel like my bare heart is being grabbed by an eagle. I am struck by the feeling that my true heart is revealed, that it is revealed, that it can't be repaired well and that it overflows. For me, these are works like that.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

短編集とは思えない濃さ

Unbelievably intense as a short story

特に表題作よかった。表紙めくると、あと2枚続き絵になってます。これが作品読んだ後見返すともう胸ギュンです。最高です。三月えみ先生のお話は行間読ませる感じなので、私はサラサラっと読み進めないのですが、それがまたよく、短編なのにストーリーが詰まってて物足りなさ感ゼロです。今回も登場人物の名字遊びあって楽しかった。

The title work was particularly good. When I turn the cover, there are 2 more pictures in a row. When I look back after reading this work, it's already heart-wrenching. It's the best. The story by Emi March feels like it makes me read between the lines, so I can't read it smoothly, but it's also good, and even though it's a short story, it's full of stories, so I have zero sense of unsatisfaction. This time, too, it was fun to play around with the characters' surnames.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

何度でも読み返したくなる本(^_^)

A book you'll want to reread over and over again (^_^)

好きです、三月えみ先生(^_^)先が見えない物語、想像を超えてくる物語、そして不思議な物語、大好きです(^_^)人物も魅力的です(^_^)何度でも読み返したくなる本です。大満足でした(^_^)

I like it, Mitsuki Emi Sensei (^_^), a story where you can't see the future, a story that goes beyond imagination, and a mysterious story, I love it (^_^) The characters are also fascinating (^_^) It's a book I want to reread over and over again. I was very satisfied (^_^)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

凄く好き

I really like it

ツボ過ぎて何度も読み返してます。真面目で一途でロマンチスト、ホントに可愛い〜！そして神様、ちょっと狡い位良いです。心に刺さる短編ばかり、超オススメです！

There are so many pressure points that I reread it over and over again. Serious and unwavering romantic, really cute! And god, I'm a little bit cunning, so good. I highly recommend all the short stories that stick to my heart!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 07, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

短編、オムニバスだけなのに満足感すご

I'm satisfied even though it's only a short film and omnibus

物語重視だと巻数重ねるものでないと満足できなくなってきているのですが、三月えみ先生の作品は短編でも十分に読み応えがあって流石です！しかもエッチ。表題作の甘々の続きとか神シリーズの各カプ続き見たい〜！あとがきの（続きがあるなら優等生攻め）に期待してるんですがもうどこかで読めたりするのでしょうか？？？オススメです！

If the emphasis is on the story, I'm no longer satisfied unless it's a series of volumes, but it's amazing that Mitsuki Emi sensei's works are easy enough to read, even in short stories! What's more, it's naughty. I want to watch the continuation of the title work, and the continuation of each capsule in the God series! I'm looking forward to the afterword (if there's a continuation, attack the honor student), but can I read it somewhere already??? I recommend it!

Helpful

Reviews for A Love That Won't Turn to Foam Manga