Broken Heart Hall ~Paying the Witch with Lost Love~ Manga Reviews

inficio

Report

Apr 09, 2026 (PST) | Total Reviews: 35

Cute, interconnected stories

The premise is simple, brokenhearted girls get to meet the witch who will grant them a wish in exchange for their heart fragment. Usually they are given some way to achieve their dreams and show their ability to rise back after their breakup to their exes. So far the girls are cute and likeable, looking forward to seeing more characters

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 25, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

良質なファンタジーでストレスなく読める

Good fantasy can be read without stress

This review contains spoilers. ほとんどのキャラが失恋から人生を選び直す物語にもかかわらず、ストレスなく読めるし人生にバリエーションがあって楽しい。貴族や王族、魔法や前世の描き方も無理矢理感がなく古き良き昔の少女漫画の様な丁寧な書き込み。お気に入りです

This review contains spoilers. Despite the fact that it's a story where most of the characters choose their lives again from heartbreak, it's fun because it can be read without stress and there are variations in their lives. There is no sense of force in drawing aristocrats, royalty, magic, or previous lives, and it is carefully written like a good old girl comic. It's my favorite

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 23, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

魔女のサポートがますます冴える！

The witch's support is getting more and more brilliant!

This review contains spoilers. 2巻の続きが気になり、分冊11もポチり。男子勢は立場や現状にあぐらをかいて、婚約者を下に見るね…時代背景をプラスしても、違う言動の男子もいるから、本人の性格や意識の問題だろう。それに反して魔女は、主人公たちに寄り添う言動でどんどん魅力的になるし、今回のヒューゴに思いをぶつけられたソフィア気持ちよかった！もしも勉強が苦手なままだとしても、努力していることや得意なことを認めてくれる心の余裕がある人と人生を歩みたい。ソフィアは能力が開花したから、今後が楽しみ！

This review contains spoilers. I was curious about the continuation of volume 2, and split volume 11 was also burnt out. The boys take a stand and current situation and look down at their fiancee... even if you add the historical background, there are boys with different words and actions, so it's probably a matter of their personality and consciousness. On the other hand, the witch became more and more attractive due to her words and actions that were close to the main characters, and Sophia felt good when her thoughts were thrown at by Hugo this time! Even if I'm still not good at studying, I want to live my life with someone who can afford to recognize my efforts and what I'm good at. Sophia's abilities have blossomed, so I'm looking forward to the future!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 01, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが楽しみです

I'm looking forward to the continuation

数ある漫画の中でも続きを楽しみにしている作品です。よくある悪役令嬢の婚約破棄からの逆転モノ、と見えますが、中身はヒロインを取り巻くいわゆるライバル令嬢たちと婚約者のお話を一組ずつ描いていくオムニバスです。特筆すべきはコミカライズの構成力。数話ごとに入れ変わるメインの令嬢とその胸に抱く思いを、短いページ数で上手くまとめ、読者にするっと感情移入させることができるのは、ただモノローグと棒立ちのキャラを並べただけみたいなコミカライズが量産される今、とても貴重でありがたい。好き嫌いが出るのは絵柄でしょうか。かなり昔の少女漫画風ですが、おとぎ話のようなファンタジーですから、個人的にはしっくりと合っている気がします。

It's a work I'm looking forward to continuing among the many comics. It looks like a common reversal from the annulment of the villain's daughter's engagement, but what's inside is an omnibus that depicts the story of the so-called rival daughters surrounding the heroine and her fiancé, one group at a time. What is noteworthy is the comicalization power of Comicalize. The fact that the main daughter, which changes every few episodes, and the feelings she has in her heart can be successfully summarized in a short number of pages and made readers empathize with it is very valuable now that comicalization, which seems to be just a matter of arranging monologues and stick standing characters, is very valuable and thankful. Is it a pattern that shows likes and dislikes? It's like a girls' manga from quite a long time ago, but since it's a fantasy like a fairy tale, I personally feel like it fits perfectly.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ハッピーエンド好きには良き

Good for happy ending lovers

ネット小説でお気に入りだったものが漫画になっていると知り即購入。それぞれのキャラクターもイメージ通りでテンポ良く読めます。続きが楽しみです。

When I learned that my favorite internet novel was made into a comic, I bought it right away. Each character is just like the image, and you can read it at a good tempo. I'm looking forward to the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

6話まで読みました！毎話楽しみ！

I've read up to 6 episodes! I'm looking forward to every episode!

This review contains spoilers. 一話を試し読みしてからハマってしまい、新刊をいつも心待ちにしております！一話一話の満足感がすごい。次に続く！とはなっても各主人公（？）たちが、魔女に叶えてもらった（プラス少し応援してくれた）事を使いつつも自分の実力で開花していく様は応援したくなります！すぐに勧善懲悪となるわけではないのですが、頑張っている彼女たちを見ると元気が出ます！少しずつ芽吹いていく成果、少しずつ明らかになる謎…とても深くて楽しいです！これからも楽しみにしてます！

This review contains spoilers. After trying out the first episode, I became addicted to it, and I'm always looking forward to the new publication! The satisfaction from episode to episode is amazing. Continued next! Even so, each protagonist (?) I want to support them as they blossom with their own abilities while using what the witch gave them (plus a little bit of support)! It doesn't immediately turn into good, good, and evil, but I feel energized when I see them doing their best! The results that sprout little by little, the mysteries that are revealed little by little... it's so deep and fun! I'm looking forward to it from now on!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 19, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

やり手ルーシー（ネタバレごめん遊ばせ？）

Runner Lucy (sorry spoiler, let me play?)

【まだ立読み中】タイトルが素敵。1巻立ち読みでは、男たちがバカ過ぎて、ガキ過ぎて、失恋というにはあまりにお粗末…。レビューを読みつつ立ち読みを続けると、なるほど女子たちの方も、婚約者という立場を守ろうと自分らしさを見失っているわけね。ただ、学生で婚約者アリがフツーという設定だと、ちょっと酷じゃない？男に浮気されてはじめて、自分を見つめ直すってのが、癪だわね。そんな男にキモチは戻らない。新しい恋の予感が用意されてるのかしらん？

[Still Reading] The title is wonderful. In volume 1 standing reading, the men are too stupid, too bratty, and too lousy to be called heartbroken... If you keep reading while reading the reviews, I see that the girls also lost sight of their individuality in an attempt to protect their position as fiancés. However, wouldn't it be a bit terrible if the setting is a student and her fiancé Ali is futsu? Looking back at yourself for the first time after being cheated on by a man is ridiculous, isn't it? I can't get my feelings back on such a man. I wonder if a premonition of a new love is being prepared?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 05, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

魔女さん最高

Witches are the best

This review contains spoilers. こういう切り口のストーリーは、楽しくて、良いですねただ、やられっぱなしではなく、復讐でもなく、ちゃんと、自分自身の脚で、歩いていけるような手助けをしてくれるのが、素晴らしい面白かったです次のヒロインは、どうなるのか、楽しみですね

This review contains spoilers. The story from this perspective is fun and good, isn't it? However, it was wonderful and interesting that they helped me walk properly on my own feet without being left doing anything, not revenge. I'm looking forward to seeing what happens with the next heroine

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

普通のざまぁじゃないのが良い

It's good that it's not normal

全巻購入しました！ストーリーが良いです。もっと読みたいって思わせる構成でぐいぐい引き込まれます。短編形式なのも読みやすい。ただのざまぁじゃなくて乙女心をたてつつ相手を挫くやり方がスッキリ。バカにすんな！女の子って強いんだぞ！と思える作品です。最新刊が中途半端で終わったので次回更新が待ち遠しいです。

I bought the whole volume! The story is good. It draws me in a lot with a structure that makes you want to read more. The short form is also easy to read. It's not just a joke, it's a refreshing way to frustrate an opponent while setting up a girl's heart. Don't make a fool of me! Girls are strong! It's a work that makes me think. I finished the latest issue halfway, so I can't wait for the next update.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 24, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

こんなお店があるなら行ってみたい

If there is a store like this I want to go

まぁ、簡単には辿り着けないとは思うのですが···。この店に辿り着いたヒロイン達は、みんな良いお嬢さん達で振られるような人達ではないのに、婚約者達が最悪すぎますね。まぁ、婚約破棄できて良かったですが、相手の将来もちょっと気になりますね。続きが気になります。

Well, I don't think it's easy to get there... The heroines who arrived at this store aren't all pretending to be good girls, but their fiancés are just too bad. Well, I'm glad I was able to annul my engagement, but I'm also a little worried about my partner's future. I'm worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 20, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

スカッとざまあー

that's so quick

This review contains spoilers. 早く続きが読みたい！冒頭のシーンはいつになったら読めるのかスカッとするするザマァな展開で軽く読めます

This review contains spoilers. I want to read more soon! The opening scene is easy to read with a messy development that makes you wonder when you can read it

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 10, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

程よくざまぁと強い女の子たち

Girls who are moderately strong

This review contains spoilers. 4話まで読んでー女性たちは強くて魅力的！今のところ程よくざまぁもあるのでスッキリしつつ楽しめますこれから逆ハーの中心にいるあいつとか、一番身分の高いあいつもざまぁされて欲しい！

This review contains spoilers. Read up to 4 episodes - women are strong and charming! So far, there are just a few, so I can enjoy it while feeling refreshed. From now on, I want the guy at the center of the reverse herr to be the one with the highest status!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 05, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

世界観が素敵

The view of the world is wonderful

This review contains spoilers. 1話目は婚約破棄から始まるお約束の…と行きたいところですが、気がつけば魔女の所にいて、砕け散った恋心を取り出してもらうところから始まります。まるでカウンセリングのように、傷ついた人の心を癒やしてくれる魔女の優しいお話です。

This review contains spoilers. The first episode is where I want to go to The Promise... which begins with the annulment of the engagement, but when I notice it, I'm at the witch's place, and it starts with having my shattered love come out. It's a gentle story about a witch who heals the hearts of those who have been hurt, just like counseling.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！早く続きを！！

interesting! continue soon!!

がんばっていく主人公たちがすてき！こちらも励まされます！あ～～早く続きが読みたいです！元婚約者たちも、まぁせいぜいがんばってくれ！

The main characters who do their best are wonderful! This is encouraging too! Ahhh... I want to read more soon! Ex-fiancés, well, do their best!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろかった！

That was interesting!

This review contains spoilers. よくある婚約破棄ものかと思いきや、ちょっと違った感じで面白い。いわゆる悪役令嬢といわれる令嬢たち視点でのオムニバス形式の物語っぽいけれど、全部が繋がっている世界で、ヒロインポジションの子が狭い交友関係の中（学園内）で攻略相手を乗り換えていくことで、次の物語が始まる感じ。まだ二人目までしか読んでいませんが、ざまあとハッピーエンドの気配が濃厚で、楽しく読み進められました。

This review contains spoilers. I thought it might be a common engagement annulment, but it's interesting because it feels a little different. It's like an omnibus-style story from the viewpoint of young daughters called so-called villain daughters, but it feels like the next story begins when a child in the heroine position switches enemies in a narrow friendship relationship (within the school) in a world where everything is connected. I've only read it for the second time yet, but there was a strong sign of a happy ending after a while, so I enjoyed reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 01, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

すごく好き

I really like it

This review contains spoilers. こういうのすごく好きルーシーが次々男を変えているのか、ルーシーはその気はないのに男が寄ってきているのかまだわからないけど、きっぱり捨てられていく男がどんどん見られるのは楽しい

This review contains spoilers. I really like this kind of thing. I still don't know if Lucy is changing men one after another, or if Lucy doesn't feel like that, but it's fun to see more and more men being thrown away once and for all

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

なかなか面白い

It's pretty interesting

This review contains spoilers. オススメで表示された作品。表紙の魔女に惹かれてページをめくりましたが、一応令嬢物ではあるのかな？何だかちょっと懐かしい感じのホッとする絵柄です。婚約破棄された令嬢によって、相手の男が…、というよくある展開だけどスカッとするお話。主人公は毎回変わるオムニバス形式のようです。他の令嬢物とちょっと違うのは、“失恋堂”の魔女の存在。令嬢たちの砕けた恋の欠片を集めています。彼女は狂言回しの役どころでもあるのでしょうか。そして１組目のカップルを壊したルーシーが２組目にも登場。お前またやる気か！と思ったんですが、他の方のレビューにあるように、このルーシーって実は魔女の使い魔が化けた姿なんじゃ？と私も一瞬思った。“失恋堂”の魔女は恋の欠片を集めているので、使い魔をルーシーという少女に変身させて毎回カップルを破局させ…、のような。現時点で配信されている３話まで読了済ですが、もっと読み進めていかないと、魔女に関してはまだまだ謎が多いですね…。

This review contains spoilers. This work was displayed as recommended. I was drawn to the witch on the cover and turned the pages, but I wonder if it's a young lady for the time being? The pattern is somewhat nostalgic and makes you feel relieved. It's a common development where the other man... is due to a daughter whose engagement has been annulled, but it's a refreshing story. The main character seems to be in an omnibus format that changes every time. What is slightly different from other young girls is the presence of a witch from “Shukondo.” We are collecting Fragments of the Daughters' Broken Love. Is she also a part of Kyogen Kaishi? Also, Lucy, who broke up the first couple, appeared in the second group. Are you motivated again! I thought, but as you can see in other people's reviews, isn't this Lucy actually transformed into a witch's servant? I also thought for a moment. The witch in “Shikondo” is collecting fragments of love, so it's like turning the messenger into a girl named Lucy and causing the couple to break up every time... I've read up to 3 episodes that have been distributed so far, but if I don't read further, there are still many mysteries about witches...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 23, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

はやく～

soon~

はやく続きが読みたい！これに尽きる。宰相のアホ息子、泣け、泣け、泣け～って感じで、こいつは幸せになっちゃいかん！

I want to read more soon! That's all there is to it. The prime minister's idiot son feels like cry, cry, cry, and this guy won't be happy!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 21, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

かわいい

cute

絵がすごく！！かわいい！！(*^_^*)　ストーリーも、おもしろいです。失恋をした人にだけ、魔女のお店に入ることが出来るなんて、おもしろすぎる設定でした。

The picture is amazing!! cute!! (*^_^*) The story is also interesting. It was such an interesting setting that only people with a broken heart could enter the witch's shop.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 10, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

おも不思議な話

Mainly a mysterious story

いきなりの魔法使いとか　有りがちな婚約解消とかあっても、軽い感じで読めます。昔の少女コミックスとかこんなカンジだったなぁ　って感じがしました

I can read it with a light feeling, even if there are things like Sudden Wizards or dissolution of engagements that tend to happen. I felt like old girls' comics and stuff were like this

Helpful

Reviews for Broken Heart Hall ~Paying the Witch with Lost Love~ Manga