Broken Heart Hall ~Paying the Witch with Lost Love~

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  May 25, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English
  良質なファンタジーでストレスなく読める
  Good fantasy can be read without stress
  This review contains spoilers. ほとんどのキャラが失恋から人生を選び直す物語にもかかわらず、ストレスなく読めるし人生にバリエーションがあって楽しい。貴族や王族、魔法や前世の描き方も無理矢理感がなく古き良き昔の少女漫画の様な丁寧な書き込み。お気に入りです

  This review contains spoilers. Despite the fact that it's a story where most of the characters choose their lives again from heartbreak, it's fun because it can be read without stress and there are variations in their lives. There is no sense of force in drawing aristocrats, royalty, magic, or previous lives, and it is carefully written like a good old girl comic. It's my favorite

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Mar 23, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English
  魔女のサポートがますます冴える！
  The witch's support is getting more and more brilliant!
  This review contains spoilers. 2巻の続きが気になり、分冊11もポチり。男子勢は立場や現状にあぐらをかいて、婚約者を下に見るね…時代背景をプラスしても、違う言動の男子もいるから、本人の性格や意識の問題だろう。それに反して魔女は、主人公たちに寄り添う言動でどんどん魅力的になるし、今回のヒューゴに思いをぶつけられたソフィア気持ちよかった！もしも勉強が苦手なままだとしても、努力していることや得意なことを認めてくれる心の余裕がある人と人生を歩みたい。ソフィアは能力が開花したから、今後が楽しみ！

  This review contains spoilers. I was curious about the continuation of volume 2, and split volume 11 was also burnt out. The boys take a stand and current situation and look down at their fiancee... even if you add the historical background, there are boys with different words and actions, so it's probably a matter of their personality and consciousness. On the other hand, the witch became more and more attractive due to her words and actions that were close to the main characters, and Sophia felt good when her thoughts were thrown at by Hugo this time! Even if I'm still not good at studying, I want to live my life with someone who can afford to recognize my efforts and what I'm good at. Sophia's abilities have blossomed, so I'm looking forward to the future!

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Mar 01, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English
  続きが楽しみです
  I'm looking forward to the continuation
  数ある漫画の中でも続きを楽しみにしている作品です。よくある悪役令嬢の婚約破棄からの逆転モノ、と見えますが、中身はヒロインを取り巻くいわゆるライバル令嬢たちと婚約者のお話を一組ずつ描いていくオムニバスです。特筆すべきはコミカライズの構成力。数話ごとに入れ変わるメインの令嬢とその胸に抱く思いを、短いページ数で上手くまとめ、読者にするっと感情移入させることができるのは、ただモノローグと棒立ちのキャラを並べただけみたいなコミカライズが量産される今、とても貴重でありがたい。好き嫌いが出るのは絵柄でしょうか。かなり昔の少女漫画風ですが、おとぎ話のようなファンタジーですから、個人的にはしっくりと合っている気がします。

  It's a work I'm looking forward to continuing among the many comics. It looks like a common reversal from the annulment of the villain's daughter's engagement, but what's inside is an omnibus that depicts the story of the so-called rival daughters surrounding the heroine and her fiancé, one group at a time. What is noteworthy is the comicalization power of Comicalize. The fact that the main daughter, which changes every few episodes, and the feelings she has in her heart can be successfully summarized in a short number of pages and made readers empathize with it is very valuable now that comicalization, which seems to be just a matter of arranging monologues and stick standing characters, is very valuable and thankful. Is it a pattern that shows likes and dislikes? It's like a girls' manga from quite a long time ago, but since it's a fantasy like a fairy tale, I personally feel like it fits perfectly.

  Helpful