Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time Manga Reviews (P.4)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

This review contains spoilers. 何とも言えない切ない感じがヒシヒシと伝わってくる話。相手を尊重できなくなって、自分の感情を優先しがちになる感じも、別れた後で想い出がぶり返して泣ける感じも、切ない。そして、又二人の時間を紡いで行こうと歩み寄る場面が何ともグッとくる。良いお話でした。勿論、絵も良かった！好きです！

This review contains spoilers. It's a story that conveys an indescribable sense of sadness. The feeling that you can no longer respect your partner and tend to prioritize your own feelings, and the feeling that your memories come back and you cry after breaking up are sad. Also, the scene where the two of them walk up to try to carve out their time comes as a surprise. That was a good story. Of course, the picture was great too! I like it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

Home　and　Away

Home and Away

This review contains spoilers. だいぶ前に1巻を購入し、2巻が出るとSNSで知りこちらも購入。Home　and　Awayは、2人の笑顔がたくさん見られます。非常に良いです。私たちは幸せな2人が見たいんだ！！！！よくわかってらっしゃる！台詞回しもすごく独特で良いです。「いかにも漫画のセリフです」って感じじゃなくて、言葉のチョイスとかなんですかね？リアルでいいです。なかなかこういう台詞回しの作家さんはいないように思います。お父さんの話したいことが新しいパソコンなの笑っちゃいました（笑）ちょっと物足りない部分もあるけど、絵も綺麗だし、エッもあるし、頑張ってほしい作家さんなので星5つです。

This review contains spoilers. I bought volume 1 a long time ago, and when volume 2 came out, I found out on SNS and bought this one too. At Home and Away, you can see a lot of smiles between them. It's very good. We want to see two happy people!!! You understand that very well! The line rotation is also very unique and good. It's not like “it really is a comic line,” is it a choice of words or something? It's nice that it's real. I don't think there are many writers with this kind of line. It made me laugh because what my dad wanted to talk about is my new computer (laughs) There are parts that are a bit unsatisfactory, but the pictures are beautiful, and I want them to do their best, so it's 5 stars.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

初めて泣いたわー！

I cried for the first time!

This review contains spoilers. こんな切ない話って。。。あるー！？始まり方がそうだから、そうなんだろうけど、ハピエンで終わって欲しい、お願い、お願い...と思ってたのに、最後のエピソードになっちゃってぇぇぇえ～！えぇぇー(号泣)　もぅ...こっから、モトサヤなんてあり得るぅ...？？？？？　はわわわわぁぁぁ～泣泣....してたら、ツクシ君の熱いポロッ....!!!!!!!!!!!!!意味が....集約されてる意味が.........　to　u　to　i!!!!!!帰って来て出たね、伝えれたね、本当に...　良かったね。eあんなにハピエン諦めモード入って、1コマ毎にすすり泣いていたのに、最後は幸福感にとっぷり。。。深く入り込んでた自分を見つけちゃいました。ふぁぁぁ～　良かった。

This review contains spoilers. such a sad story... it's there!? That's how it started, so that's probably the case, but I wanted it to end with Happien, please... but it ended up being the last episode! Eh (crying) Wow... from here on, Motosaya is possible...???? Whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa... when I was crying... Tsukushi-kun's hot polo...!!!!!!!!! The meaning... the meaning of being aggregated... to u to i!!!!! You came back and came out, you were able to tell it, really... That was great. e I was in such happy give up mode, and even though I was sobbing every frame, I was completely filled with a sense of happiness at the end... I found myself deeply involved. Huh... that was great.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

続編！良き！

sequel! good!

This review contains spoilers. 1巻で最初っからお別れ～このままではセ？レ～しっかり仲直り。尽の愛情が伝わってよかった。桐生が伝えないけど愛が深いのも知ってるよ。続編のHome　and　Away　ふたりの家族も出てきて大きな愛に包まれてました！読んで後悔なし！（221P)

This review contains spoilers. Farewell from the beginning in volume 1 ~ will it stay this way? Re~ make up well. I'm glad my love was conveyed. Kiryu doesn't tell you, but I also know that she is deeply in love. The two families from the sequel Home and Away also came out and were filled with great love! Read it and you won't regret it! (221P)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

最高オブ最高

The best of the best

This review contains spoilers. 1巻を買った時に、別れから始まる物語というのが新しくてすぐ世界観に引き込まれました。読み進めるうちに泣けてきて泣けてきて、私の読んだBLの中で多分1番泣いた作品です。2巻もこれまた涙が止まらなくて、2人ともの家族にカミングアウトしてその反応で〜というのがもう涙腺が崩壊しました。絵もほんっとに綺麗で話をすごく入ってきやすいし、ほんとにほんとに大好きな作品です。この2人の幸せな続きがまた見れたら嬉しいなと思います。

This review contains spoilers. When I bought volume 1, the story that begins with parting ways was new, and I was immediately drawn into the worldview. It made me cry and cry as I read on, and it's probably the work that made me cry the most in BL I've read. I couldn't stop my tears in volume 2, and when I came out to the family of 2 people, my lacrimal gland had already collapsed due to that reaction... The pictures are also really beautiful, and it's really easy to get into the story, and it's a work I really, really love. I think I would be happy if I could see the happy continuation of these two people again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

なんて幸福感！！！

What a feeling of happiness!!!

まずは、続編嬉しいです！有り難うございます。大好きなカップルの元サヤ後のお話！男とか女とか関係なく、最後は人間同士の付き合いなんだなぁとじんわり心が温まりました。喧嘩してもがいて、でも嫌いになれなくて。愛おしいって言葉がしっくりくる大好きなお話です。

First of all, I'm happy with the sequel! Thank you very much. A story about a couple I love after their ex! It didn't matter if it was a man or a woman, and it slowly warmed my heart that it was a relationship between humans at the end. They fought and struggled, but they didn't like it. It's a story I love that fits perfectly with the word adorable.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 09, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

乗り越える愛が人を強くする

Overcoming love makes people stronger

恋愛漫画を読んでも普段は自分の恋愛と重ねたりしないタイプなのですが、この作品はあまりにもリアルで、思わず自分に置き換えて読んでしまいました。過去に苦い経験をした人や、復縁を経験したことがある人には特に刺さると思います。それくらい登場人物の気持ちが生々しく描かれていて、どちらにも強く共感できました。別れたくて別れているわけじゃない。その葛藤や揺れる心情が痛々しいほどに伝わってきて、けれど確かにそこには愛がある。言葉にしきれない想いが詰まっていて、こうした困難を乗り越える恋愛は人を強くするのだと、続巻を読みながら改めて感じました。

Even when I read romance comics, I'm the type that doesn't usually overlap with my own romance, but this work was so realistic that I unintentionally replaced it with my own. I think it's particularly painful for people who have had bitter experiences in the past or people who have experienced reunion. The feelings of the characters were depicted so vividly, and I was able to strongly sympathize with both of them. It's not like we broke up because we wanted to break up. That conflict and shaking feelings have been painfully conveyed, yet there is certainly love there. It was filled with indescribable feelings, and I felt once again while reading the next volume that romance that overcomes such difficulties strengthens people.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 08, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

欲しい言葉はたった一つ

There is only one word I want

This review contains spoilers. 4年の歳月がすでに経った状態でのスタート。間に何があったのか詳しくは書かれていないけど、ご飯屋さんの夫婦に名前を覚えられ、関係性も知っている。編集の方も尽を知っていて、二人が過ごした日々にいろんな人が関わっていて、二人が一緒にいる事を当然のように知っていてそうだと思っている。それだけ二人が周囲から見ても良い関係性に見えているのは間違いないし、仲も良かった。それでもほんの些細な引っかかる事が積もってしまうのは一緒に生活していく以上感じてしまうもので…。今までだったら何とも思わなかった事が気になったりと、何というか…リアリティが高い。嫌になって別れを告げたはずなのに、何気ない日常の思い出の中に常に現れる桐生の存在が、尽にとってどれだけ大きな存在なのかを如実に語っている。桐生もまたどうにかしたい気持ちはあるのに、言葉ではなく体でそれを表そうとするの不器用すぎません？小説家だからこそいろんな言葉を知っているはずなのに、言葉ではなく体でって…。自分の中でうまく言語化できないのが悔しくて仕方ない！！よりを戻せた二人はこれからも些細な事で喧嘩したりしちゃうのかな、とか考えていたら続編が出るとのこと！！！二人のその後を見れると思うと嬉しくて仕方ないのと同時に心がぎゅっとなるんだろうな…と少し覚悟をして読みたいと思います。

This review contains spoilers. It started when 4 years had already passed. The details of what happened between them are not written, but the couple at the restaurant remember their names, and they also know the relationship. The editors also know everything, and various people are involved in the days they spent, and I think it's natural that they know that they are together. There is no doubt that the two seem to have a good relationship even when viewed from their surroundings, and they were on good terms. Even so, the fact that only trivial snags pile up is something I feel even more than we live together... I'm worried about things I wouldn't have thought of until now, and I mean... it's very realistic. They should have said goodbye because they didn't like it, but Kiryu's presence, which always appears in casual everyday memories, clearly talks about how big a presence he is for Jin. Kiryu also has a feeling he wants to do something about it, but isn't it too clumsy to try to express it with his body instead of words? Since I'm a novelist, I'm supposed to know a lot of words, but with my body, not words... I can't help but be frustrated that I can't verbalize it well within myself!! The two who were able to get back together were thinking about whether they would continue to fight over trivial matters, and it was said that a sequel would come out!!! I want to read it with a little bit of preparation, thinking that I can't help but be happy when I think I can watch the two of them later, and at the same time it probably makes my heart feel tight...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

すごくリアルだった、、、

It was so real...

内容がとてもリアルだなあ、、と。好きだったところを時間が経つにつれて嫌になってくる、好きだけど離れたい、でも好きみたいなそんな少し苦しいストーリーでした。全体的に明るいストーリーではないですが、また読み返したい！と思える大好きな作品になりました！

The content is so realistic... It was a slightly painful story where things I liked became disliked over time, and I liked them but I wanted to get away from them, but I loved them. Overall, it's not a bright story, but I want to read it again! I think it's my favorite work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

不器用な受け

Clumsy reception

This review contains spoilers. 最初2人が別れるところから始まります。一度離れてみて気付くこともありますよね…。2人で一緒にいる時の笑顔が素敵過ぎて、1人でいるときとかすれ違うところは見ていて辛かったです。同居においてやっぱりコミュニケーションって大事で、不満は抱え込まずに言った方がいいなと。相手を想うばかり遠慮してしまいがちだけど、言ってみてお互い気付くこともある。復縁してからの2人のイチャイチャ最高でした…！

This review contains spoilers. It starts with the first two people breaking up. There are times when you walk away once and notice it... The smiles when the two of them were together were so nice, and it was hard to see how they were so different from when they were alone. After all, communication is important when living together, and I think it's better to talk about it without harboring complaints. It's easy to just think about the other person and hold back, but there are times when we both notice when we say it. The flirting between the two of them since they got back together was amazing...!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 17, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

まるで小説を読んでいるような漫画

A comic that makes you feel like you're reading a novel

This review contains spoilers. 別れから始まるお話。なんて切ない。ずっと心がギュッとなってた。好きが嫌いになっていく感覚、長く付き合っていれば本当にある。桐生の上手く言葉にできないのもすごくわかる。小説家にとして感情や情景を言語化して伝えることをずっと突き詰めて考えている。だからこそ、言葉にできてしまう感情ではないとか、その枠にはめてしまいたくないとか、そんな気持ちもあるのかなと感じた。結局お互い大好きなのにうまく言葉にできなくて、相手の嫌なことばかりが見えてきて。でも、離れようとしても嫌なところが見えていても、長く一緒にいたからこそ噛み合ってしまうことが多くて、それがまた苦しいしリアルだった。そして、4年って長さが中途半端な気がしていて、大抵3年とか3ヶ月とか『3』であることが多い気がしたけどW杯出てきて、そういうことかーーーってなった。スタジアムの高揚と対比するような心情とか、逆にロスタイムの「試合がこのまま終わってしまう」という焦りと、試合が終われば関係も終わるという想いが重なって、もう本当に見ていて苦しくて、ホイッスルと共に私も涙腺崩壊でした。そしてここまで涙腺崩壊させたのは、ご本人たちの語り多めなストーリー展開。丁寧に彼らの心情が描かれていて、まるで小説を読んでいるようでした。何度でも読み返しています。素敵なお話でした。

This review contains spoilers. A story that begins with a break up. How sad. My heart was tight the whole time. There really is a feeling that likes and dislikes become if you've been in a relationship for a long time. I also really understand Kiryu's inability to put it into good words. As a novelist, I've always been thoroughly thinking about verbalizing and conveying emotions and scenes. That's why I felt that there was also a feeling that it wasn't an emotion that could be put into words, or that I didn't want to put it in that frame. In the end, even though we both loved each other, we couldn't put it into words, and we could only see what the other person didn't like. However, even when they tried to leave, they often meshed because they had been together for a long time, and that was also painful and real. Also, I felt like 4 years was half-hearted in length, and I felt like it was usually 3 years or 3 months or “3,” but the World Cup came out, and I was wondering... The feeling that contrasts with the excitement of the stadium, or conversely, the impatience that “the game will end like this” in lost time overlapped with the feeling that the relationship would end once the game was over, and it was really painful to watch, and along with the whistle, my lacrimal gland collapsed. And what caused the lacrimal gland to collapse up to this point was the story development that the people themselves talked about a lot. Their feelings were carefully depicted, and it was as if they were reading a novel. I reread it over and over again. That was a wonderful story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

良き〜

good~

別れから始まる作品はあまり読んだことが無かったので新鮮で面白かったし、2人のキャラがしっかり出来ててブレることもなく読み通せて良かったです。アレの描写が意外にリアルでギャップをくらいました。

I hadn't read many works beginning with the break up, so it was fresh and interesting, and I'm glad the two characters were well made and I was able to read through without blurring. The depiction of it was surprisingly realistic, and there was a gap.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 27, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

すごく‥なんかわかるなー‥って。

That's amazing... I don't understand something...

もう、どちらの思いも行動も。キチンとしたい性格で、好きな人のお世話も苦じゃなかった筈の尽くん。大好きだから、しょうがないなーなんて出来ていた事も、積もり積もってそれが苛立ちに感じてしまうと、ふとした時に爆発しちゃう。「もう無理！」ってなるのわかります‥。マイペースで甘え上手でモテるのに、何故かいつも振られてしまう桐生くん。「あ、ヤバイ‥」と思ってあの手この手で何とかしようとするけど、戻ってきての一言が言えない‥。肝心な一言って、なかなか言えないかも‥。どうしたって嫌いになれない尽くんの葛藤が切ないです。自業自得な桐生くんの、もう無理かも‥と気づいた時の表情が切ないです。ほんと、桐生くん‥身勝手で不器用すぎて、なのに可哀想で可愛いと思ってしまう‥大好きだから嫌いになりきれない尽くんと、大好きだから別れるなんて認められない桐生くん。一度別の方向に行きかけて、でも歩み寄ってまた同じ道を進んで行く‥そんな素敵なラブストーリーでした。とっても良かったです！ありがとうございました！！

Both thoughts and actions are already there. He has a temperamental personality, and he shouldn't have been a pain taking care of the people he likes. I love it, so when things that can't be helped pile up and I feel irritated, they suddenly explode. “I can't do it anymore!” I understand it becomes... Kiryu-kun is popular for being spoiled at his own pace, but for some reason he always gets swayed. I thought, “Oh, that's dangerous...” and tried to do something with that method, but after coming back, I couldn't say a word... It may not be easy to say the most important thing... No matter what happened, I can't hate it, and it's sad to have an exhaustive conflict. Kiryu, who is self-reliant, looks sad when he realizes that he may not be able to do it anymore... Really, Kiryu-kun... is so selfish and clumsy, yet she thinks it's pathetic and cute... Kiryu-kun is not allowed to do everything she doesn't like because she loves her, and to break up because she loves her. It was such a wonderful love story where they almost went in a different direction once, but then walked up and followed the same path again. It was very nice! thank you!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 23, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

もともとがケンカ？？

was it originally a fight??

初読み作者さん買い。最初から『別れ』では無く一方的な言い分？？だったような⋯。ツクシは名前の通りお母さんみたいな尽くし方。トウイは作家でマイペース。自由業だから執筆中は籠もる、飲みに誘われればふらっと出掛ける。たぶん、付き合うor同棲or結婚、全部のパターンに当てはまると思うけど『何で自分だけ！！』って思い出しちゃうんですよね〜〜〜。そしてケンカ！同棲を解消したのにまだトウイの家の鍵を持ってるとか、「寝れないよ～」の連絡だけで家に行ってあげるとか、ツクシの想いは、まだソコにあるって感じでしたね。ただ、こういうケンカを何回もしてお互いに分かり合って、妥協して、妥協して(あえての２回！)話し合って何十年も一緒に暮らして行くんだろうな～と思いますよ。そして恋人同士、新婚あるある話しを上手く作者さんが描いてるので、とっても素敵なラストになってました。ちょっと作者さんの作品をコンプリートしてみたくなりました。

Bought it for the first time reading the author. It wasn't a “break up” from the beginning, but a one-sided statement?? Seems like it was... As the name suggests, Tsukushi acts like a mother. Toi is a writer and self-paced. Since it's a freelance job, I get stuck while writing, and when invited out for a drink, I go out casually. I think it probably applies to all patterns of dating or cohabitation or marriage, but “why only me!!” It reminds me of that, doesn't it? And then a fight! It felt like Tsukushi's feelings were still there, like they still had the keys to Towi's house even though they had resolved their cohabitation, or that they would go home just by contacting them “I can't sleep!” However, after fighting like this over and over, they understood each other, made compromises, and made compromises (twice!) I think we'll talk about it and live together for decades. Also, since the author is good at drawing a story about lovers and newlyweds, it was a very nice end. I just wanted to complete the author's work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 20, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

他者を理解することの難しさ

The difficulty of understanding others

This review contains spoilers. BL作品で過去一泣きました。。。BLに限らない関係に当てはまるテーマを含む作品だと思います。何年間も一人の人間と愛し合う関係を継続するには、お互いの努力や思いやりが必要だと改めて感じさせられました。素晴らしい作品をありがとうございます。

This review contains spoilers. It was a BL film that made me cry once in the past... I think it's a work that includes themes that apply to relationships not limited to BL. It made me feel once again that in order to continue a loving relationship with one person for many years, mutual effort and compassion are necessary. Thank you so much for your wonderful work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

切なさいっぱいの良作！

A great work full of sadness!

長く付き合ったカップルに普遍の悩みの描写が切ない良作です！恋の始まりは男同士ならではのじゃれ合う2人が伸びやかでとっても楽しそうなだけに、ちょっとしたことが許せなかったり、ごめんの一言が言えなかったり、自分の気持ちでいっぱいいっぱいになったり、わかるんだけど思わず声をかけたくなります…。ストーリーもとてもいいんですが、絵がすごく好みで、可愛い感じの2人なのに時々すごく色気を感じる場面があって、それが作品の魅力をさらに増している気がしました。やっぱりマンガは絵も大事！

It's a good work with a sad depiction of common worries for couples who have been in a relationship for a long time! At the beginning of love, two people who play with each other unique to men are relaxed and seem to be having so much fun, so I can't forgive little things, I can't say a single word of sorry, I'm filled with my own feelings, and it makes me want to call out even though I understand it... The story is also very good, but I really like the pictures, and even though they are two cute people, there are scenes where I sometimes feel a lot of sex appeal, and I felt that this further increased the appeal of the work. After all, pictures are also important in manga!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

せつない…

that's annoying...

恋愛中って相手の嫌なとこも好きだったし、多少のワガママとかも聞いてたけど、長くなればなるほど微妙にずれてくるのよね…この作者さん、きっと大恋愛したのちの別れを経験なさった方かな…別れへの心情がめちゃくちゃリアルで、すごく丁寧。読後感もいい。そしてすごく切なくなる。

When I was in a relationship, I also liked the other person's bad points, and I've heard things like being somewhat selfish, but the longer it gets, the slightly off... I'm sure this author is someone who experienced a breakup after a big relationship... the feelings about breaking up are insanely real, and they are very polite. The feeling after reading is also good. And it makes me really sad.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 30, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

苦しい。。。

It's painful...

男女問わず経験したことがあるような胸の痛みが蘇ります。つくしくんの不器用だけど伝えようと頑張ってる姿にキュンとします。

Chest pain that both men and women have experienced comes back to life. I'm amazed at how clumsy Tsuku-kun is but trying his best to convey it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 15, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

気持ちわかるわ〜

I know how you feel~

This review contains spoilers. 別れてからスパッとなんてなかなか無理ですよねごめん、戻ってきてって言われたら戻るのにって私も何度思った事やら…すごく感情移入して読めました(　*ˊᵕˋ*)絵も見やすく、感情移入もしやすくだいすきー！の一言に尽きます<(^o^)>

This review contains spoilers. It's not easy to do anything quickly after breaking up, isn't it? Sorry, I wonder how many times I thought I'd go back if I was told to come back... I was able to read it with great empathy (**) The pictures are easy to read, and it's easy to empathize with, I love it! It's all in one word< (^o^) >

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

大泣きしました

I cried a lot

好きな理由も嫌いなった理由も自分が一番わかってる様でわかってないんだよね…。ストーリーが最高すぎて大泣きしながらレビューしてます。最高だからみんな読んで。

I don't understand why I liked it or why I didn't like it because it seemed like I knew the most... The story was so great that I cried while reviewing it. It's awesome, so everyone read it.

Helpful

Reviews for Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time Manga