Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time Manga Reviews (P.3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

続編も大変良かった…！

The sequel was also very good...!

This review contains spoilers. 前作もめちゃくちゃ良かったんですけど、前作で紆余曲折あってまた2人でいる事を選択した2人のその先、が読めてとっても幸せです。語彙力が無いのでこの気持ちを表現するのにやたら文字が必要になるのが歯痒いです。今回は2人の周りの人へのカミングアウトについて。尽の家族がとっても自然体で、そのお友達もあっけらかんとしていて（アウティングと言われたらそれまでですが）、特別な事じゃなく大切な人がいる事はとても尊い事だと感じられるのですが、桐生のお母さんの反応プラスもっと辛辣なものが今の大多数なのかなとも考えてしまいます。だけど、大事なのは全てを理解する事ではなく、そういうのもあるよね、って心に波風立たせず受け入れる事なのかなと思います。この作品読むと色々と考えさせられて、しばらくその余韻に浸っていたくなります。つらつら書き連ねてますが、とてもじんわりする作品なのでぜひ読んでほしいです。

This review contains spoilers. The previous work was also insanely good, but I'm so happy to be able to read Beyond, the two who had twists and turns in the previous work and chose to be together again. I don't have vocabulary, so it's painful that I need so many characters to express this feeling. This time it's about the two coming out to people around them. Jin's family is very natural, and their friends are also easygoing (until then if they say outing), and I feel that having someone important without anything special is a very precious thing, but it also makes me wonder if Kiryu's mother's reaction plus something more painful is the majority now. However, I think the important thing is not to understand everything, and to accept that there are such things without making waves in your heart. Reading this work makes me think about a lot of things, and I want to soak in its afterglow for a while. It's written in a row, but it's a very gentle work, so I definitely want you to read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

取り戻す愛

Reclaiming love

This review contains spoilers. 別れてからより強い関係性を築くことになりました。前よりも愛情深くなります。しんどい時には分け合って、二人で答えを見つけます。より強い絆で結ばれて、いい関係性になります。

This review contains spoilers. We decided to build a stronger relationship after we broke up. I'm more affectionate than before. When it's tough, we share, and the two of us find answers. They are bound by a stronger bond, and it becomes a good relationship.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻ぜんぜん違う人に、超ネタバレレビュー

Volume 2 for completely different people, super spoiler review

This review contains spoilers. 別れてから始まり、くっつくラスト、というストーリー展開な為、重く辛いんですけど……アンニュイな空気感が凄く心地よい作品だった。優しいツクイ君の振り回されっぷりが人間味溢れてて、応援したくなる。ほんと良い子なんだな。桐生も、いるいるこうゆう男！って既視感あって、2人の表現が親近感あった。心理描写が細かくて、没入感あり！桐生は2巻で改心したのか、観念したのか別人に！！？？番外編があるなら、二人のはじめてのエッチでお願したい！！桐生は尽が男は初めて、この場合攻めが多いはずが、受けとはそれいかに！！？？

This review contains spoilers. It's a story development that starts after they break up and ends when they stick together, so it's heavy and painful, but... it was a very comfortable work with an unnuanced atmosphere. The gentle way Tsukui-kun is swayed around is full of humanity, and I want to cheer him on. he's a really good kid. Kiryu is here too, this guy! There was a sense of deja vu, and there was a sense of familiarity between the two expressions. The psychological depiction is detailed, and there is a sense of immersion! Did Kiryu convert in volume 2, or did he think to another person!!?? If there's an extra edition, I'd like to ask for their first sex!! Kiryu is the first to be a man, and in this case, there must have been a lot of attacks, but how is that receiving!??

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

すごくいい作品でした！

It was such a great work!

すごく沁みる作品でした！タイトルに惹かれてなんとなく読んでみました買って損なしのいい作品でした。人間関係、特に恋人との間ではよくある出来事ですが、その表現がすごく好きな作品でした。ここまで細かく表現できる作者さんはほんとにすごいの一言です。とても心揺さぶられる作品でした。ありがとうございました。

It was such a thrilling work! I was drawn to the title and somehow read it. It was a good work without loss when I bought it. It's a common occurrence in human relationships, especially between lovers, and I really liked that expression in the work. The author, who can express it in such detail, is a really amazing statement. It was a very heart-shaking work. Thank you very much.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 20, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

笑顔がいい

It's good to smile

笑顔に癒されて、笑顔に泣かされるお話です。ココミ先生の描かれるキャラの表情は複雑な感情を的確に表していて、それがこちらの感情も揺さぶってくれます。出会えてよかった作品です。二人にはこれからもずっと幸せでいてほしい。

It's a story about being healed by a smile and making you cry with a smile. The expressions of the characters drawn by Kokomi sensei accurately express mixed feelings, and that also shakes my emotions. It's a work I'm glad I came across. I want both of them to stay happy forever.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 19, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

手が印象的なおはなし

A story with impressive hands

2巻通して、顔を近付けて笑い合う2人の笑顔がすごくかわいくて印象的なのですが、さらに手の描写が本当にすごい！1巻では桐生の別れてからもずっと指輪を着け続けている手が切なくて印象的で、2巻では尽の桐生を愛で包み込むようなあたたかい手が印象的でした。1巻と2巻では雰囲気というか空気の温度が違うのですが、それぞれどちらも素敵な空気感のお話しです。長く一緒にいると、見えなくなることも見えすぎちゃうことも有耶無耶にしてしまうこともたくさんあって、一度離れてみて分かるそこに残ったただ好きという思い。2人の心情が表情や手、動作などでとても丁寧に描かれていて、でも大袈裟すぎず語りすぎず自然で、だからこの切なくともあたたかい空気感なのかなぁと思いました。2巻での尽と桐生のやりとりを見てから1巻を読み返すと、尽の悩みや葛藤、桐生の後悔や別れたくない気持ちがより感じられて、1巻だけでも素晴らしく好きな作品だったのに2巻でさらに大大大好きになりました！この作品に出会えたことに感謝しています。

Throughout volume 2, the smiles of the two smiling faces close together are so cute and impressive, and what's more, the depiction of their hands is really amazing! In volume 1, Kiryu's hand, who has continued to wear the ring ever since they broke up, was impressive, and in volume 2, the warm hand that envelops Jin's Kiryu with love was impressive. The atmosphere, or rather the temperature of the air, is different between volumes 1 and 2, but they both talk about a wonderful sense of atmosphere. When we've been together for a long time, we can't see, see too much, and there are a lot of things that leave us alone, and once we're apart, we just love each other. The feelings of the two were drawn very carefully with their facial expressions, hands, movements, etc., but they were natural without exaggerating or talking too much, so I was wondering if it was this sad yet warm atmosphere. After watching the exchange between Jin and Kiryu in volume 2, I was able to feel Jin's worries, conflicts, Kiryu's regrets, and feelings of not wanting to break up even more, and even though volume 1 alone was a wonderful work I liked, I fell in love even more with volume 2! I am grateful that I came across this work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 18, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった〜〜〜〜〜

That was good ~~~~~~

This review contains spoilers. なんかもう、こう、すごく良かった。こういうすれ違いあるよね。でもどうやって歩み寄るかお互いが考えられたら素敵だよね。今後も2人に幸あれ〜〜〜〜(泣)

This review contains spoilers. Something was already, really good. There are differences like this, aren't there? But it would be nice if both of us could think about how to get close. Good luck to both of you in the future!!! (crying)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 17, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

内容がしっかりしてておもろい

The content is solid and interesting

This review contains spoilers. 最初別れたところからスタートするので珍しい入り方だなと思いました。が！実はどちらも未練たらたらなんですよね！けどすぐに戻ったらまた同じ繰り返しになってしまうから攻めの方が頑張って引き離して受けが攻めの大切さに気付く感じです別れててもお互い好きが溢れてて尊かったです

This review contains spoilers. It started where we first broke up, so I thought it was an unusual way to get in. but! Actually, I'm sorry for both of them! But as soon as I got back, it was the same repetition again, so I feel like the attackers worked hard and pulled them away and realized the importance of attacking. Even after breaking up, they both liked each other so much that it was precious

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 17, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

切なさの真骨頂

The true essence of sadness

別れても気持ちはあるけど一緒にいれない、お互い言葉足らずだったけど、分かっていても素直になれない、付き合っていたからこそ臆病になってしまう。みたいな言葉にできないモヤモヤや切なさを描くのが本当に上手い。セリフで入れてしまえばチープになるし、長く言葉を使うと情緒がなくなる。その気持ちを表現するためのシーンや表情、言葉…すごい。正直絵はあまりタイプではないし、ストーリー重視だからこそエロも上品だけど買ってよかった〜！！、って思える一冊。読み返しまくってます。マッキーのもう恋なんてしないなんて〜の歌詞を読んだ時に、こいつは恋がよくわかってるじゃねーか（何様？）と思ったのを思い出しました。もう胸がキューとなるほどに苦しい感じ？切ない（すでに言葉を使うほどチープに見える典型的な文だな）まぁ読んでみてほしい。切なさを味わってほしい！！

We have feelings even if we break up, but we can't get together, we both didn't have enough words, but even though we understood, we couldn't be honest, and we became timid only because we were in a relationship. I'm really good at drawing fuzzy and sad feelings that can't be put into words like that. If you put it in words, it becomes cheap, and if you use words for a long time, you lose your emotions. The scenes, expressions, words to express that feeling... amazing. To be honest, pictures aren't really my type, and since they focus on the story, the erotic ones are elegant, but I'm glad I bought them!! A book that makes me think,. I've been rereading it. When you read the lyrics to Mackie's No Longer in Love, this guy knows love very well (who?) I remembered what I thought. Does it feel so painful that your heart is already queuing? It's sad (it's a typical sentence that already seems cheap enough to use words) Well, I want you to read it. I want you to enjoy the sadness!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

泣ける

I can cry

1巻も泣けたけど、2巻も泣ける…！続編出ないのかなー、と思っていたので、とても嬉しいです。ありがとうございます！

Volume 1 made me cry, but volume 2 also made me cry...! I was wondering if there would be a sequel, so I'm very happy. Thank you so much!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

幸せしかない

There is nothing but happiness

あ～～続編読めて幸せ～～(*^O^*)そして恋人作って同棲したくなる笑分かち合うってこういう事なんだなって教えてもらった！

Ahhh... I'm happy to read the sequel ~ (*^O^*) and I was told that this is what it means to make a lover and want to live together lol sharing!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ホントにもっと早く読めば良かった！

I really wish I had read it sooner!

This review contains spoilers. 人気作品で前から気になっていて、何度も試し読み、購入にいたらず。桐生の髪型、あまり好きじゃなく。あと始まりから別れてるっていうのが、ハピエン派なので。でも、もっと早く読むべきだった！これは高評価なのわかる。同棲して4年、当たり前に一緒にいたのに、尽が突然出ていく。近すぎてずっと一緒にいると、わからなくなる時がある。好きだったハズの所も全部嫌に見えて。痛いほどわかりすぎる気持ち。尽と桐生の気持ちが丁寧に描かれていて、良かった。ゲイとバイのCPはありがちだけど、驚いたのは桐生の過去。バイだけど、男は尽が初めて、でも女性は両手以上に付き合ってるって。ひゃーっっ！！だけど、元カノカレは出てこないので、そこは安心。気になった桐生の髪型も中盤には短くなり、そうなるとカッコ良い！笑。お互い気持ちがあって離れたので（尽が一方的）、なかなか踏ん切り付かなかったけど、戻って良かった。離れてた時期があったからこそ、よりお互いの大切さがわかりそれまで以上に絆が深まり。2巻が出たタイミングで安定のハピエンなのがわかり、ようやく1巻を購入。長い道のりでした。笑。迷ってるかた、お勧めです　是非！ロスタイムの大切さが沁みます。

This review contains spoilers. It's a popular work and I've been interested in it for a long time, tried reading it over and over again, and didn't even buy it. I don't really like Kiryu's hairstyle. After that, the fact that they broke up from the beginning is because they are in the Happien faction. But I should have read it sooner! This is a high rating, I understand. We lived together for 4 years, and even though we were together as a matter of course, everything suddenly came out. There are times when we don't understand when we're together too close. Everything I loved looked disgusting. A feeling that is painfully too understandable. I'm glad that the feelings of Jin and Kiryu were carefully depicted. There tend to be gay and bi CPs, but what surprised me was Kiryu's past. Bye, but this is the first time a man runs out, but they say they're hanging out with women more than two hands. huh!! However, my ex-girlfriend hasn't come up, so I don't worry about that. Kiryu's hairstyle, which I was interested in, was also shortened in the middle, so that's cool! lol. We both had feelings for each other and left (everything was one-sided), so it wasn't easy to get through, but I'm glad we went back. It was precisely because we were apart that we understood the importance of each other more and our bond deepened more than ever before. When volume 2 came out, I found out that it was a stable Happien, so I finally bought volume 1. It's been a long journey. lol. If you are unsure, I recommend it! The importance of lost time is evident.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

★★★★★

★★★★★

This review contains spoilers. 久しぶりにBL読んでうるっ(;_;)となりました。好きな人でも他人だもん。一緒に住むって好きだけじゃ乗り越えられないことってあります！わかりみがすぎる。こんなにもせつなくて、苦しくて、優しくて、愛おしい物語…この作品に出会えてよかった！

This review contains spoilers. It's been a long time since I read BL and it became amazing (; _;). Even if it's someone you like, it's someone else. There are things you can't overcome if you just love living together! It's too easy to understand. It's such a troubling, painful, kind, and adorable story... I'm glad I came across this work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

2人が成長してる！

They're both growing up!

元サヤカプのその後。めちゃくちゃ良かったです！個人的には、前作を上回るほど良かった…。尽と桐生が2人でやってくためのルールを取り決めて、同じ失敗を繰り返さないという思いが強く感じられました。固い絆で結ばれた2人は最強です！桐生ママ、尽の家族も登場し、盛りだくさん。大満足です。

After the original Sayakap. It was insanely good! Personally, it was so good that it surpassed the previous game... Jin and Kiryu agreed on rules for the two of them to come, and I felt strongly that they wouldn't make the same mistakes over and over again. The two people who are bound by a strong bond are the strongest! Kiryu Mama and Jin's family also appeared, and there were plenty of them. I am very satisfied.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

泣いた

wept

これ、ほとんどの女子に刺さりまくるお話だと思う。旦那さんのことちょっと大切にしてあげようと思った。大切なものって無くなってから気づくからラストはハッピーエンドになって良かったね。

I think this is a story that sticks to most girls. I thought I'd take good care of my husband. I notice important things after they're gone, so I'm glad the last one had a happy ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

出逢えて良かった。

I'm glad we met.

This review contains spoilers. 試し読みで気になって購入。めちゃくちゃ良い！！！なんて言うんだろう、同棲とか同居とか誰かと一緒に居ればいるほど関係は深くなってるけも、それでいいのか不安になる。内容がリアルすぎて考えさせられた。今後2人が幸せに暮らしてくれたら嬉しいな〜本当に自分見てるみたいでドキドしたけど、自分自身きっかけもらえた作品。この作品に出会えて良かった。続きも読みたい！！！

This review contains spoilers. It was a trial reading and I was curious and bought it. insanely good!!! I wonder what they say, the more people live together, or live together, the deeper the relationship becomes, but I'm worried about whether that's OK. The content was so real that it made me think. I would be happy if the two of them live a happy life in the future ~ It was exciting because it really seemed like they were watching themselves, but I was inspired by myself. I'm glad I came across this work. I want to read more!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

続編ありがとうございます

Thank you for the sequel

This review contains spoilers. 1巻の切なくて切なくてどうしようもないところが大好きでした。2巻の幸せで幸せでどうしようもないところが大好きです。

This review contains spoilers. I loved the sad, sad, and helpless part of volume 1. I love volume 2: Happy, Happy, and Helpless.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

じーん

Gene

This review contains spoilers. 気になると全部嫌になってくるしそうなるといつもは伝わってることも間違って伝わったり全然伝わんなかったりするよね〜お互い大好きじゃん！！！って思いながら見てました続編楽しみに読みます！

This review contains spoilers. If it bothers you, everything becomes disgusting, and when that happens, things that are always conveyed are misunderstood or not conveyed at all ~ we love each other!!! I was watching while thinking, and I'm looking forward to reading the sequel!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

んァ〜〜！！！(言葉にならない)

huh!!! (unspeakable)

This review contains spoilers. 2巻発売おめでとうございます！！！！1巻が出た時から本当に大好きな作品で、1巻発売日にたまたまロスタイムに餞を手に取った自分によくやったと言ってあげれるぐらいの気持ちです。そして2巻も読むことが出来て幸せです。2人の関係がメインだった1巻と違い2巻は成長した二人とその身内を巻き込むような展開で、否定とか肯定とかどちらの意見も当たり前にある世で怖くても独りじゃなくてふたりで喜怒哀楽を分かち合って新しい未来の1歩を踏み出すような素敵な話で……お互いがお互いをだいすきすぎる〜って顔するのほんとに堪らん。し…尽くんさまじでほんとにどれだけスパダリなんだよこんな人間愛さずにはいられないよな…！！！とういは甘え方が上手だしふとした時に尽の心にすっと入ってくようなそんな唯一無二の2人がだいすきです。幸せだ……そして先生のあとがきがすごく素敵な言葉でだいすきです……ありがとうございます?

This review contains spoilers. Congratulations on releasing volume 2!!! It's a work I've really loved since volume 1 came out, and I feel like I could tell myself that I did a good job when I happened to pick up the sword in lost time on the day volume 1 was released. Also, I'm happy to be able to read 2 volumes. Unlike volume 1, where the relationship between the two was the main thing, volume 2 is a development involving two people who have grown up and their relatives, and it's a wonderful story where both opinions such as denial and affirmation are commonplace, and it's a wonderful story where the two share their joys, anger, sorrow, and take a step forward in a new future... it's really unbearable that they both love each other too much. And... you've done so much, how spadary you really are, I can't help but love this kind of person...!!! I love these two unique people who are good at spoiling and seem to come right into my heart when I'm done. I'm happy... and I love the teacher's afterword with such wonderful words... thank you?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

一気読みです

I'm reading it all at once

This review contains spoilers. 好きな所が嫌いになってく描写のわかりみが深過ぎました…別れてる期間にもお互いを思ってる所が胸がギュッとなります2巻の幸せそうな2人を見ているだけでジワジワと幸せを分けてもらえた気がします！！

This review contains spoilers. The depiction of what you like becomes disliked was too deep... I feel like I was able to share my happiness just by watching the two happy people in volume 2, even during the period they were separated from each other!!

Helpful

Reviews for Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time Manga