Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time Manga Reviews (P.11)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ボロ泣きです

I'm crying

リアルなすれ違いや心情に感情移入しすぎました。日常のリアルな恋愛を見て泣きたくなったらこれを見るのをオススメします…

I empathized too much into real misunderstandings and feelings. I recommend watching this if you feel like crying when watching everyday real love affairs...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

元サヤと言えばそうだけど

Speaking of former Saya, yes

4年という月日は短いようで長い。所詮他人だし、生まれも育ちも違うし、その中で、仕事柄だったり性格的なものだったりのすれ違いが出てくるのは当然だし。でも相性ってやっぱりあると思う。それは身体だけじゃなくて食べ物の好みとか笑いのツボとか価値観とか。｢尽｣って名前に尽きたなぁ…詳しくは読んでください。すごく感情移入しちゃって、でも最後はほわっとなれます///

The month of 4 years seems short, but it's a long time. After all, they are different people, and they were born and raised differently, and it is natural for differences in work or personality to come up in the midst of that. But I think they are compatible after all. It's not just about the body, but food preferences, laughter pressure points, values, etc. The name “exhaustion” has come to an end... please read for details. I really empathized, but at the end I was relieved///

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

指輪

rings

This review contains spoilers. 別れてからのお話と聞いて読まず嫌いをしていたが、とてもよかった。秀逸なタイトルを始め、小物の使い方やよく練られているストーリー展開に脱帽した。尽のキャップをかぶって桐生がサッカーのチケットを持って現れるあたりから固唾を飲んで見守ったが、ラストまで失速することなく作品に浸ることができた。ロスタイムの間、尽が拗ねていただけに思えた。尽が合鍵を返してもロスタイムが終わっていなくてよかった。流されているように見えるが、心が離れていないから抱き合えた。ずっと左手の薬指に指輪をしていた桐生から何度も歩み寄ってくれてよかった。大切な人の手は離してはいけない。これからもふたりで同じ時間を過ごせますように。尽が桐生の髪を切った誰かに嫉妬するシーンが心に残った。それにしても桐生が魅力的だった。4.7

This review contains spoilers. I didn't like reading it when I heard that it was a story about after we broke up, but it was great. Starting with an excellent title, I took my hat off to how to use small items and a well-crafted story development. I drank my breath and watched from the time Kiryu showed up with a soccer ticket while wearing the cap, but I was able to immerse myself in the work without stalling until the end. It seemed like everything was just being relentless during the lost time. I'm glad the lost time wasn't over even though all of them returned the duplicate keys. They looked like they were being swept away, but since they hadn't left their hearts, they hugged each other. I'm glad Kiryu, who had always worn a ring on the ring finger of his left hand, walked over and over again. Don't let go of someone you love. I hope the two of us can continue to spend the same time together. The scene where Jin was jealous of someone who cut Kiryu's hair stuck in my mind. Even so, Kiryu was fascinating. 4.7

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 13, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ものすごく涙流してしまいました

I shed so many tears

どちらの気持ちも手に取るようにわかりました。言葉少なげなコミックで淡々とすすみますが、静かな表現が切なさと寂しさがものすごく伝わってきて、二人のどちらの気持ちにも共感おぼえました。ここで泣くとかそういった山あり谷ありなお話でもなく、つらつらと自然に泣いてしまいました。ロスタイム、、人には必要ですね。心にしみました。二人が今後とも末長く一緒にいてほしいです。

I understood both feelings as if I could pick them up. It's a comic with few words, and it progresses bluntly, but the quiet expression conveyed so much sadness and loneliness, and I felt sympathy for both of them. It wasn't a story with mountains and valleys like crying here, and it made me cry painfully and naturally. Lost time... people need it, don't they? It stuck in my heart. I hope the two of them will stay together for a long time to come.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 13, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

良き✨✨

good ✨✨

This review contains spoilers. なんてゆーか、それにつきる。小説家の桐生と美容師の尽。好きなのに、尽は言葉で伝えることができずに、一緒にいるのに寂しくて、それに耐えられなくなって、好きだったところも嫌になってきてる自分がまた悲しくて、別れることをきりだし、同棲している家を出て行った尽。いつもの喧嘩だと、その程度とことだと思っていた桐生。1人になってから、ようやく1人でいることが寂しくて、何度も尽にちょっかいを出しにいく桐生。別れた後も何度か体を重ね、お互い気持ちがあることも感じながら、もう最後にしようと行ったサッカー観戦。ロスタイムで手を握りあった瞬間、ほろりと泣けてきた。途中かなりもどかしいけど、最後はきちんと結ばれてくてたから、良き。ストーリー重視な作品。

This review contains spoilers. Wow, that goes for it. The novelist Kiryu and the hairdresser's death. Even though I liked them, they couldn't put it into words, they felt lonely even though they were together, they couldn't stand it, and I didn't like what I liked, and I was sad again, so I ended up breaking up, and they left the house where they lived together. Kiryu thought the usual fights were about that level. After becoming alone, Kiryu finally felt lonely being alone, and went out of his way over and over again. Even after we broke up, we stuck together several times, and while feeling that we had feelings for each other, we went to watch the soccer game for the last time. The moment we held hands in lost time, I started crying bitterly. It was pretty frustrating along the way, but at the end they were properly connected, so that's good. This work focuses on the story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 12, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

心臓がギュッ→続編ありがとうございます！

My heart is tight → thank you so much for the sequel!

This review contains spoilers. BLというジャンルでくくれないというか、ほんと恋愛漫画。生活の端々で思い出してしまう描写。出ていった恋人の好物を買ってしまうところ、返事が来ないことをわかってるのに何度もメッセージを送ってしまうところ、いろんなシーンに心臓がギュッとなりました。ハピエンでよかったです。もう一生離れないで欲しい。泣続編ありがとうございます！描き下ろしで泣きました。自分の母にできなかったことを、恋人の母を通して叶えられるってなんて素敵なんだろう。今回は恋人というよりは家族愛が強く、続編だからこそのストーリーで大変良かったです。

This review contains spoilers. It's really a romance comic that doesn't work in the BL genre. Depictions that make me remember every corner of my life. My heart was strained by the various scenes where I bought my favorite food from my lover who had left, and the place where I sent messages over and over even though I knew I wouldn't get a reply. I'm glad it was Happien. I don't want them to leave for the rest of their lives. Thank you so much for the crying sequel! I cried when I drew it. How wonderful it is to be able to do things that your mother couldn't do through your lover's mother. Family love is stronger than lovers this time around, and it was a very nice story because it was a sequel.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 12, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ずっと涙が出てしまう

I'm in tears all the time

This review contains spoilers. すごくよかったです。不満を伝えたいけど、うまく言えなくてイライラ、ただ、ごめん、と好き、一緒にいて欲しいと言ってほしい尽の気持ちが切なくて、序盤から涙が出ました。言葉にして感謝や愛情を伝えれないけど、ほんとは尽が大好きで、少しでも会えるように馴染みの居酒屋に行ったり、好物を買ってみたり、連絡を待ったりしてる桐生。困った奴だけど、憎めず、可愛くて、切ない。お互いの気持ちをきちんと描いていて、ずっと涙ぐみながら読みました。なかなか本音を言えない桐生の絞り出した胸の内、帰ってきて‥号泣してしまった。はあ‥よかった‥何回でも読み返したくなる作品です。

This review contains spoilers. It was really nice. I wanted to express my dissatisfaction, but I was frustrated because I couldn't say it well, but I was so sad that I wanted them to say sorry and wanted them to be with me, and I burst into tears from the beginning. Kiryu can't express her gratitude or love in words, but she really loves Jin, and she goes to familiar izakayas so they can meet even a little bit, buy her favorite food, and wait to be contacted. He's a troubled guy, but I can't hate him, he's cute, and sad. It was a proper depiction of each other's feelings, and I read it with tears in my eyes the whole time. Kiryu, who couldn't easily say her true intentions, came back and... cried. Huh... great... it's a work I want to reread over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

よその店で「１冊まるごと痴話喧嘩」ってレビューあって、なるほど分かりやすいなぁととても楽しく(泣いたりしながら)読みました

There was a review of “The Whole Book of Idiots” at another store, and I had a lot of fun (while crying) to read that it was so easy to understand

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

涙ポロリします

I'm going to burst into tears

This review contains spoilers. レビューを見てると、泣いた、涙が出る、などの言葉を見て興味をひかれ買ってみました。途中まではん？泣ける要素はまだ感じないなぁと思っていたものの終盤での試合のシーン､､､あそこで自然と涙が零れました、そこからはもう2人の幸せそうな顔が沢山見れて満足です！

This review contains spoilers. When I was looking at reviews, I was intrigued when I saw words such as crying and crying, so I bought it. halfway through? I thought I hadn't felt the element of crying yet, but in the final game scene... tears naturally fell over there, and I'm happy to see so many happy faces from there!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

良い味わいの作品〜

A work with a good taste~

別れから始まるさくひん。すでぬ、そこですれ違いや不満や惰性が起こってるわけです。どんなカプにもありますよねー。一度、別れるという行動を取ったことで、思ってることは口にださないと伝わらないよねって、風通しが良くなった二人の関係が羨ましいです。

Sakuhin begins with a break up. That's where misunderstandings, dissatisfaction, and inertia have already occurred. Every type of cap has it, right? Once they have taken the action of breaking up, what they think won't be conveyed until they say it, and I envy the relationship between the two, which has improved their circulation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 28, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

泣ける。

It makes me cry.

This review contains spoilers. ツクシ、桐生どちらの想いにも共感でき泣けました。ありがちって言えばそうなんだけど、恋愛てこんなだったよね..とかこんな経験されてる方も多いのでは？離れてみて感じた気持ち、“思いやり”って大事よなって改めて思わせてくれた作品でした。気持ちを言葉にするのが苦手な桐生の「帰ってきて。」に涙腺崩壊。ここ最近読んだBLで本当に大好きな作品です。全力でオススメします！

This review contains spoilers. I was able to sympathize with the feelings of both Tsukushi and Kiryu, and it made me cry. Speaking of common, yes, but I think there are many people who have experienced things like this when it comes to love... It was a work that made me think once again about the feeling I felt when I left, that “compassion” was important. Kiryu's “Come back.” by Kiryu, who isn't good at putting her feelings into words Lacrimal gland collapse. It's a BL book I've read recently and I really love it. I recommend it with all my might!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

別れた時間は大事

Time we broke up is important

試し読みで別れた場面から始まる設定が気になって購入しました。最初はつくしの流されてしまう所にイライラしましたが2人共まだ全然忘れられずにいるし、桐生が帰って来てって言った所で何だかもう許してあげようよーって思いました。つくしの桐生に対する要求が細かい事まで凄く共感出来たしそれに対する桐生の想いも共感出来たし、作者さん凄いなーと思いました。

I bought it because I was curious about the setting starting from the scene where we broke up in the trial reading. At first, I was frustrated that Tsukushi was swept away, but both of them still haven't forgotten at all, and when Kiryu said she'd come back, I thought I'd somehow forgive them already. I was able to really sympathize with Tsukushi's demands on Kiryu, down to the details, and I was able to sympathize with Kiryu's feelings about it, and I thought the author was amazing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 20, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ビタースイート

bitter sweet

別れからはじまる話。読み心地が優しい。よりもどしなよ〜とか思いながら見てました。主人公が攻めだったのが意外。（ごめんなさい）

It's a story that begins with a break up. The reading comfort is gentle. I was watching it while thinking that it was better than that. Surprisingly, the main character was attacking. (sorry)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

涙腺崩壊

lacrimal gland collapse

すごく良かった！！！！評価が高くていつか読もうと思っていた作品。眠れない夜に手に取ってみた。もどかしい2人の想いに気持ちが高まり、ほんの一言や微かな表情で涙腺崩壊。BLならではの良い作品。最高でした。

It was so good!!! It was highly rated and I thought I'd read it someday. I picked it up on a sleepless night. Feelings were heightened by the frustrated feelings of the two, and the lacrimal gland collapsed with just one word or a faint expression. A good work unique to BL. It was awesome.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

リアル！

real!

付き合って４年、美容師の尽が「別れる」と告げ、小説家の桐生の元を出て行ってからはじまる、ふたりのお話です。なぜこうなったのか、何が気に入らないのか、リアルに想像できるふたりの恋愛に、感情移入できます。ちょっと最後のワールドカップのくだりは出来すぎだけど、素直に気持ちを言えた桐生に拍手。絵はかわいすぎてあまり好みではなかったんだけど、ストーリーがよかった！

It's a story about the two, which begins after being in a relationship for 4 years, the hairdresser Jin says they are “breaking up,” and leaves the novelist Kiryu. You can empathize with the love between the two that you can realistically imagine why this happened and what you don't like. The final World Cup story was a bit too much, but I applauded Kiryu for being able to honestly express his feelings. The picture was so cute that I didn't really like it, but the story was great!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

高レビュー

High reviews

と、表紙と題名に惹かれて購入！ほんと、レビュー信じてよかったです。一気読みでした。途中、涙がこぼれましたわ。大オススメです！

I was attracted to the cover and title and bought it! I'm really glad I believed the reviews. I read it all at once. Tears spilled along the way. I highly recommend it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

リアルな感情

Real emotions

相手が何かにのめり込んでいると、自分の気持ちまで蔑ろにされたように感じて孤独だったり許せなかったり。でも後から考えたら、許せたことだったんじゃないかとか、自分のほうが勝手だったんじゃないかと自分を責めたり。何度同じ気持ちになっても、諦めない２人でいてほしいです。

When my partner is immersed in something, I feel that even my own feelings have been despised, and I feel alone or unforgivable. But when I think about it later, I blamed myself for thinking that it was something I could forgive, or that I was selfish. I want them to be two people who don't give up no matter how many times they feel the same way.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

勝負は最後までわからない

You don't know the game until the end

同居生活に鬱憤がたまって恋人である桐生と別れることにした尽。自分の不満をわからせたい、とヘソをまげている尽の気持ちもわかるが、一生懸命に尽の気を引こうとすがってくる桐生の想いが切なくて。お互いまだ好きなのに、どうやってもうまく噛み合わない。このまま終わってしまうのか、終盤までもどかしくてたまらないのだが、最後、2人の堰を切ったような感情の爆発が一気に流れを変えて良かった。なるほど、ロスタイムとはよく考えたなー。こういうモダモダはストレスがたまることが多いのだが、こちらの作品はそれを感じさせない絶妙な匙加減。

I was so frustrated by living together that I decided to break up with Kiryu, my lover. I also understand Kiryu's feeling that she wants to understand her dissatisfaction, but Kiryu's feelings of trying so hard to get Dane's attention are sad. Even though they still like each other, they don't mesh well no matter what. I wonder if it will end like this, and I'm so frustrated and unbearable until the end, but at the end, I'm glad that the emotional explosion that seemed to have cut the weir between the two changed the tide all at once. I see, I thought a lot about lost time. This kind of moda is often stressful, but this work has an exquisite balance of key that doesn't make you feel that.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

別れから始まるストーリー

A story that begins with a break up

This review contains spoilers. いろいろなbl読んできたけど、別れてから別の相手にいく話がほとんどなのに、そこからの二人の幸せとは何か、相手がどんなに大事だったか、ふりかえって、またはじめていく過程の機微が書き込まれていて、いいいみで裏切って来る素敵なお話でした。ここみ先生のほかのさくひんも今読みあさっています。でもやはりどの作品も、機微が書き込まれていて、小説のようです

This review contains spoilers. I've read a lot of BL, and even though most of them are stories about going to different people after breaking up, it was a wonderful story about how happy the two people were from there, how important their partner was, and the subtleties of the process of looking back or starting, were written, and they betrayed them with good intentions. I'm reading Kokomi sensei's other Sakuhin right now. But after all, every work has subtlety written in it, and it's like a novel

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

酸いも甘いもの味わえる！

You can enjoy both sour and sweet things!

ちるちるアワードでランキングに入っていたため購入！読んでみるとさすが受賞作だと思った。身近な設定だけど、感情の描き方がめっちゃよかった！！

I bought it because it was ranked in the Chiru Chiru Awards! When I read it, I really thought it was an award-winning work. It's a familiar setting, but the way it depicts emotions was really good!!

Helpful

Reviews for Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time Manga