My Beautiful Man Manga Reviews (P.17)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が素敵………

The picture is wonderful...

ドラマを先に見て原作を読み、コミックスが発売とのことで紙媒体を買いましたが、こちらでも購入してしまいました。本当に…清居の「美しさ」が一面に広がっていて読んでいてどんどん引き込まれます。続きが楽しみです。

I watched the drama first, read the original story, and bought the paper version because comics were on sale, but I also bought it here. Really... Kiyoi's “beauty” spreads all over, and I'm drawn in more and more as I read it. I'm looking forward to the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

北野先生の作画だったので

It was Kitano sensei's drawing

This review contains spoilers. 超有名作品ですが、北野先生が描かれてると知って、初めて触れました。北野先生の「最低な男の腕の中」が大好きです。そうですね、1巻ですね。始まったところ、これから続く。次巻は来春だそうで、先は長いですが、楽しみに待ちたいです。カースト頂点と最底辺というフレーズ通り、高校内外で最底辺の平良が体験させられる事が、なかなか胸クソでした。『連む』グールプも、教室のその他も、女子達も、ヒエラルキーなるものが露骨で、人間関係大変そうです。平良がパシリとして行動している事、愛情持って育てている親を思うと痛いです。でも、これは序章なんですよね。客観的に平良が受けている言動と、平良が「美しい清居」へ向ける想いのコントラストが、繊細な絵で余計に映えてます。平良の独白で進んだので、美しい彼が何を思っているのか、とても気になります。原作を読んでいませんので、今後を楽しみに、コミカライズで追っていきます。

This review contains spoilers. It's a super famous work, but I first touched it when I learned that Kitano sensei was drawing it. I love Kitano-sensei's “In the Arms of the Worst Man.” Yes, volume 1. Where it started, it will continue. The next volume seems to be next spring, so there's a long way to go, but I'm looking forward to it. As the phrase “the pinnacle of caste and the bottom” suggests, it was quite heartbreaking to be able to experience Taira at the bottom both inside and outside of high school. The “connecting” ghouls, the rest of the classroom, and the girls all have blatant hierarchies, and relationships seem difficult. It hurts when I think about Taira acting as Pasiri and his parents who raised him with love. But this is a prelude, isn't it? The contrast between Taira's objectively receiving words and actions and Taira's feelings for “beautiful Kiyoi” shines extra brightly in the delicate picture. It progressed with Taira's monologue, so I'm really curious about what his beautiful girlfriend thinks. I haven't read the original story, so I'm looking forward to the future and will follow it in comicalized form.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

待ってました

I've been waiting

This review contains spoilers. コミカライズ化されると発表されてこの日を待ってました?小説が好きすぎて今でも定期的に読んでるし内容も分かっているのに漫画版で読むとまた、違った感じがしてとても良かったです?話が進むにつれて平良に甘えたで嫉妬しちゃう可愛い清居が見れるのが楽しみです?

This review contains spoilers. Have you been waiting for this day since it was announced that it would be comicalized? I liked the novel so much that I still read it regularly, and even though I know the content, when I read it in the comic version, it felt different again, and it was great? I'm looking forward to being able to see the cute Kiyoi who is spoiled by Taira and becomes jealous as the story progresses?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

待ってたよ

I've been waiting

小説版(現在3巻と番外編)が大好きで大好きでコミックスで見たいなぁと思ってました！清居の美しさと平良の目力をゆっくり堪能したい!!

I love the novel version (currently 3 volumes and extra edition), I love it, and I wanted to watch it in comics! I want to slowly enjoy the beauty of Kiyoi and Taira's eyesight!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

美しすぎます

It's too beautiful

小説だけでなく、コミカライズまでなんて✨最高に嬉しいです。絵の美しさにお話の繊細さが相まって、悶え死にそうです。2巻が来年なんて…待ちきれません。小説の続きも切望しています。とにかく、美しい彼大好き□

Not only the novel, but also the comicalization ✨ I'm so happy. The beauty of the picture combined with the subtlety of the story made me feel like I was dying in agony. I can't wait for volume 2 next year... I'm also looking forward to the continuation of the novel. Anyway, I love his beautiful boy□

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良い！！

good!!

原作既読で内容は知ってるはずなのに続きがすごい気になる！絵が綺麗だから今まで想像してたシーンが脳内でちゃんと補完されていく感じ。1巻の時点でこんなテンション上がっちゃってんのに清居視点が始まったらどうなっちゃうのか。すごいワクワクする。見たいシーンがたくさんあるから早く続きが読みたい。楽しみに待ってます！

I've read the original story and I'm sure you know the content, but I'm really curious about the continuation! The pictures are beautiful, so I feel like the scenes I've imagined until now are being properly complemented in my brain. The tension has risen so much at the time of volume 1, but what happens when Kiyoi's point of view starts? I'm so excited. There are so many scenes I want to watch, so I want to read more soon. I'm looking forward to it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

原作裏切らず

Don't betray the original

原作もドラマも見て心待ちにしていたのですが、期待を裏切らず、素晴らしかったです！2巻発売が2023年春とのことですが、待ちきれないです?

I was looking forward to watching both the original story and the drama, but they didn't disappoint and it was amazing! It is said that volume 2 will go on sale in the spring of 2023, can't wait?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 04, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

原作既読

Original story read

凪良ゆう先生の美しい小説が、クールな線でコミカライズ。夢のようです。不審くんの気持ちがよーく分かりました。

Nagi Ryoyu sensei's beautiful novel is comicalized with cool lines. It's like a dream. I understand Sushi-kun's feelings very well.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 28, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

６巻まで読了

Read up to 6 volumes

スーパーネガティブ根暗とメンタル激強めの正統派イケメンの二人。俺様はそうとも捉える事ができるのか、と納得。見たいモノしか見ない視野の狭さは気になるところ。幸せになって欲しいな。

They are two orthodox handsome men who are super negative and mentally strong. I'm convinced that I can take that as well. I'm worried about the narrow field of view where I can only see what I want to see. I want them to be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 20, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

きれい

beautiful

This review contains spoilers. 小説も読んだけど、漫画になって清居と平良がどう表現されるのか楽しみにしてた。清居は相変わらず素直じゃないけど拗ねたり怒ったり必死になってるのが可愛い。

This review contains spoilers. I also read novels, and I was looking forward to seeing how Kiyoi and Taira would be expressed in comics. Kiyoi is still not honest, but it's cute that he is relentless, angry, and desperate.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 26, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

ドラマで知って

Know about dramas

This review contains spoilers. SNSからドラマでしって気になっていて、とうとうコミックスにも手を出してしまいました。絵がとても綺麗です。特にきよいは綺麗だけど切れ味もあるところが度々出てきて、ドラマを思い出しながら読めました。

This review contains spoilers. I was interested in dramas from SNS, and I finally dabbled in comics as well. The picture is very beautiful. In particular, there were many places where Kiyoi was beautiful but sharp, and I was able to read it while remembering dramas.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 20, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かったです

That was interesting

５巻まで読みました。一応この５巻でちょうど終わりました。なんとドラマチックな２人なんでしょう。純愛でしかない。６巻から新しい章が始まりますが楽しみです。

I've read up to 5 volumes. For the time being, I just finished with these 5 volumes. What a dramatic couple. It's nothing but pure love. A new chapter begins with volume 6, and I'm looking forward to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 16, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい、でもさらに変態感ほしいかも

It's beautiful, but maybe you want even more perverted

This review contains spoilers. 漫画を数巻読んで面白くて続きが気になり、原作も読みました。BL初心者の自分でも何となくタイトルを知ってたくらい有名な作品だと思うので、今更な感想で恐縮ですが、原作も失速することなく全巻面白くて、思わずファ〜〜〜ッ(高鳴り)ってなりました。もっと早く読むべきだった。。。漫画も繊細で美しくてとても素敵。。なのですが、このお話けっこう途中から雰囲気が変わると言うか。。最初は独特な平良視点なので、シリアスでちょっと狂気的な感じですけど、清居視点が入ったあたりから恋の可愛さが出てきて、その後はオモシロ要素も出てきて、絵の雰囲気の切り替えとかすごく難しい作品なんだろうなと。。★4にしてしまったのは、最新5巻のラストをもっと情熱的にというか、平良の押さえ込んでいた変態感？をもう少し爆発させて欲しかったからです。とってもとっても美しいんですけど、もうちょっとエグみ？とか、グワーっと何か押し寄せてくるような勢いみたいなものがあったら個人的には嬉しかった^^　急に雰囲気変わりすぎても変なのかな…でも本当に美しい。この作家さんの他の作品も気になります。どこまでコミカライズされるのかわかりませんが、原作読んで想像でしか思い描けなかった平良の写真も描かれるといいな。アート作品を白黒平面の漫画で表現するのもまた難しいとは思うのですが、楽しみです！

This review contains spoilers. After reading a few volumes of comics, it was interesting and I was curious about the continuation, and I also read the original story. I think it's such a famous work that even I, a BL beginner, somehow knew the title, so I'm sorry for the further impressions now, but the original story didn't stall, and the whole volume was interesting, and it made me feel unexpectedly fuzzy (loud). I should have read it sooner... The comics are also delicate, beautiful, and very nice.. But do you say that the atmosphere changes quite a bit from the middle of this story... At first, it's a unique Taira point of view, so it's serious and a bit crazy, but the cuteness of love comes out from where Kiyoi's point of view comes in, and funny elements also come out after that, so I think it's a very difficult work to change the atmosphere of the picture... Did you change it to ★ 4 because the last of the latest 5 volumes was more passionate, or rather, the perverted feeling that Taira had held down? That's because I wanted it to explode a little more. It's very, very beautiful, but is it just a little bit more ugly? I was personally happy if there was such a thing as some kind of momentum rushing in ^^ I wonder if it would be strange if the atmosphere changed too much all of a sudden... but it's really beautiful. I'm also interested in other works by this artist. I don't know how comicalized it will be, but it would be nice if pictures of Taira that I could only imagine after reading the original story would also be drawn. I think it's also difficult to express an art work with a flat black and white comic, but I'm looking forward to it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 28, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

かなりのМ

Quite a few M

このふたりが、というよりもキヨイが恋心を認識し、ヒラと想いを共有するまでかなりの時間を要します。ヒラは理解できないほどのМですよね…読んでいて苦しくなるくらい。けれど、ヒラの幸せな顔は少しキュンとしてしまいます…

It takes quite a while for these two, or rather Kiyoi, to recognize their love and share their feelings with Hira. Hira is so much that I can't understand it... it's so painful to read. However, Hira's happy face made me cringe a little...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

完結までには程遠い

It's far from complete

北野先生の大ファン。『最低な〜〜』は何度も、何度も読み返すお気に入り。北野先生の作品を収集したいのに、そもそもコミックを余り出してない。そして『美しい彼』本作。原作が話題になっていたし、タイトル通りの『美しい彼』を描くのは北野先生にピッタリ。。。ですが、この作品は小説が原作。それを忠実に描いているからか、《モノローグ》が多い。多過ぎる。ストーリーは４巻の「キヨイ目線」を読むと、やっと物語の輪郭が見えてきました。今の関係から、どう２人が交わっていくのかは原作を読んでないので分かりませんが、ただ一緒の方向を向く時が来ても２人の中の「歪さ」は無くなることは無いんだろうな～と、思うキヨイとヒラでした。ちなみに４巻の後書きで「やっと折り返し」と北野先生が書いてあったので１０巻ぐらいまでは続くようです。なので完結までは後５〜６年かかるのかな〜～～(泣)

I'm a big fan of Kitano sensei. “Worst ~ ~” is my favorite that I reread over and over again. I want to collect Kitano-sensei's works, but I haven't published too many comics in the first place. And the book “The Beautiful Guy.” The original story was a hot topic, and drawing “The Beautiful Guy,” as the title suggests, is perfect for Kitano sensei... However, this work is based on a novel. There are a lot of “monologues,” probably because they faithfully depict it. That's too much. As for the story, when I read volume 4 of “Kiyoi's Perspective,” I was finally able to see the outline of the story. From their current relationship, I haven't read the original story, so I don't know how the two will interact, but it was Kiyoi and Hira who thought that the “distortion” within the two would not go away even when they just turned in the same direction. Incidentally, Kitano-sensei wrote “I'm finally back” in the afterword of volume 4, so it seems like it will continue until about 10 volumes. So I wonder if it will take 5 to 6 years until it's completed ~~~ (crying)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい彼

A beautiful guy

孤高で、確固たる自分があって、口数少なくて美しい彼が、こんなにも人間くさく、悩みや葛藤や恋心もあって、何だかとても可愛いし、とても好感が持てます。気弱だと思っていたひら君の方がとても頑固な気がします。それがとても心地よい。これからどうなっていくのか楽しみです。

He is lonely, has a firm self, and is beautiful with few words, but he is so humane, has worries, conflicts, and love, and is somehow very cute, and I am very likable. I feel that Hira-kun, who I thought was weak, is very stubborn. It's so comfortable. I'm looking forward to seeing what happens in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

じれったい

I want to do my best

実写化で知り、ドラマも映画も観れてないので、陰キャ✕陽キャの話がどう進んでいくのか気になったので小説が原作との事ですが、活字が苦手なのでマンガを購入しました。3巻までの感想としては「じれったい」の一言です。なかなか進展しない2人の関係にムズムズします。けどこの先ラブラブハッピーエンドが待っていると期待して読み続けたいと思います。

I know it was a live-action adaptation, and I haven't been able to watch the drama or movie, so I was curious about how the story of Yin Kya ✕ Yang Kya would progress, so I said it was based on a novel, but I'm not good at print, so I bought the manga. As for my impression up to volume 3, it's just one word “I get lost.” I'm upset by the relationship between the two that hasn't progressed easily. However, I would like to keep reading hoping that a love-love happy ending awaits in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 14, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

作品タグキング

Artwork tag King

原作が小説なので言葉1つ1つが綺麗で、うっとりしました。漫画家さんの他の作品もちょこちょこ読んでいて、また違った良さが有り、絵の美しさも画角の使い方も素敵です。blの実写今すごく多くて流行ってるのだろうけど…何か見れなくて、私には漫画が丁度良いです。何処までも純愛で、すれ違ってどっちも美しい彼美しい物語です。

Since the original story is a novel, every word was beautiful, and I was fascinated. I also read the manga artist's other works here and there, and they have different merits, and the beauty of the pictures and the way they use the angle of view are wonderful. There are so many live effects of BL now that they're probably popular, but... I can't watch anything, and comics are just right for me. It's a beautiful story about him who is pure love everywhere, and they're both beautiful when they pass each other.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 09, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ドラマから

From dramas

This review contains spoilers. ドラマはシーズン1？だけさらっと見てからのコミック版購入です。小説は未読です。ドラマ版の時はさほどでしたが、コミック版の清居の横柄な王様感が清居目線を読んでも、あんまり好きになれませんでした。清居も平良も両方とも私にはあんまり合わないキャラでした。しかし文句を言いながらも最新刊までちゃんと購入してしまう。

This review contains spoilers. Is the drama season 1? I just took a quick look and then bought the comic version. I haven't read the novel. That was so bad when it was in the drama version, but I didn't really like Kiyoi's arrogant sense of the king in the comic version, even when I read it from Kiyoi's point of view. Both Kiyoi and Taira were characters that didn't really suit me. However, even though they complained, they bought the latest edition properly.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 15, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

1巻のみ読了

Read only volume 1

友人に勧められて読みました。1巻のみ読了。結構特殊で複雑な心理描写です。パシリくんとクラスのキング、どう変化していくのか、楽しみです。続きも読みます。

I read it on the recommendation of a friend. I've only read volume 1. It's a pretty special and complicated psychological depiction. I'm looking forward to seeing how Pasili-kun and the King of Class will change. I'll read more.

Helpful

Reviews for My Beautiful Man Manga