My Beautiful Man Manga Reviews (P.14)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい

beautiful

第1巻の第一話。実はまだ原作も少ししか読んでいない。理想は原作を読み終えてからコミカライズを読む事だったが待ちきれず。で、すごく良くて涙が出てしまった。ヒラがキヨイの物と思うところ。原作、良いんだなあ。絵も綺麗で良い。

First episode of volume 1. Actually, I haven't read much of the original story yet. The ideal was to read Comicalize after I finished reading the original story, but I couldn't wait. So, it was so good that I burst into tears. I think Hira is Kiyoi's. The original story is good, isn't it? The picture is also beautiful and nice.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

既に

already

続きが待ち遠しい！大好きな漫画家さんが描くと聞いて購入。小説､ドラマとありますが(映画化も)漫画待ってました！既に2巻が待ち遠しいです｡

I can't wait for the continuation! I heard that my favorite manga artist would draw it, so I bought it. There are novels and dramas (including movie adaptations), but I've been waiting for comics! I can't wait for volume 2 already.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 15, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良き

good

小説は読んでいません。ドラマはいまいちハマりませんでしたが、北野仁先生が描かれるとのことで購入しました。こちらはとても良いです！続きも早く読みたいです！

I haven't read a novel. I wasn't really into the drama, but I bought it because it said that Kitano Hitoshi sensei would be drawn. This one is very good! I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 14, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

小説のイメージまんま

Just like the image of the novel

リカコ先生の絵のイメージをそのまま引き継がれてます！漫画だと1シーン1シーンの表情とか見れて最高です。小説一巻の内容だけでも結構な巻数いきそうなんですが、このまま焦らずゆっくり描いてほしいです！原作読まれた方にとてもおすすめです。

The image of Rikako-sensei's painting has been carried over as it is! If it's a comic, it's great to be able to see facial expressions from scene to scene. It seems like there would be quite a few volumes with just the content of one volume of the novel, but I want them to draw slowly without being impatient! I highly recommend it to those who read the original story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

4.5☆

4.5 ☆

さすがに人気作ですね。これは高評価なのが分かります。絵はとても綺麗。あらすじで言うとそんなに珍しいとか目立ったとかいう作品ではないのですが、キャラの個性が濃い、話の入り方が上手い、序盤、クラスの最底辺という立ち位置の主人公の視点からしっかり描かれてて、まるでその位置を経験したような感覚になれます、そっから美しい清居を見て知っていくと、比良の気持ちを共感できたような気がします。自分の事の様に見守ってあげたくなりますね。清居はもちろん美しくて強くて魅力的なのですが、比良の拗らせているようで拗らせてない真っ直ぐな性格が可愛いです。ワンコっぽいのが良い。続きが楽しみな作品。完結したら再評価します、とりあえず4.5☆

As expected, it is a popular work. I can see that this is a high rating. The picture is very beautiful. Speaking of the synopsis, it's not such a rare or conspicuous work, but it's clearly drawn from the viewpoint of the protagonist, who has a strong personality, is good at getting into the story, and you can feel as if you have experienced that position, and when you see and get to know the beautiful Kiyoi from there, I feel like I was able to sympathize with Hira's feelings. It makes me want to keep an eye on them as if they were my own. Of course, Kiyoi is beautiful, strong, and charming, but Hira's relentless, straightforward personality is cute. It's good if it looks like a dog. I'm looking forward to continuing this work. I'll re-evaluate when I'm done, 4.5 for now ☆

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

小説も

Novels too

小説も良かったのですが、やはり漫画になるのも本当によかった。面白いです。読みやすいし、なにより絵がとっても綺麗！

The novel was good, but it was also really nice that it became a comic. It's interesting. It's easy to read, and above all, the pictures are so beautiful!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

キモ＝好きに聞こえてくる！

Kimo = it sounds whatever you want!

This review contains spoilers. 元々は凪良ゆうさんの流浪の月が好きで、BL小説も書いてると知ったので、とりあえず漫画を購入。崇拝している神を自分の性の対象にしてしまった時の罪悪感みたいな感情表現は、さすが凪良ゆう先生って感じがして心がえぐられました!凪良ゆう先生のこういう人間の深層心理みたいなので心をズタズタにしてくる感じがたまらなく好きです!!続きが気になりドラマを見て、小説のシリーズを大人買いしましたw もう清居が可愛い!!!キングがきもうざに振り回されて絆されて、自分が結局折れないといけない状況にさせられてるのが読んでいて快感でしたw 気持ち悪い、が、平良いいぞもっとやれ!!w

This review contains spoilers. Originally, I liked Ryoyu Nagi no Tsuki, and I learned that she also wrote BL novels, so I bought comics for now. The emotional expression, like feeling guilty when I turned the god I worshiped into the object of my sex, really felt like Nagi Ryoyu sensei, and my heart was gouged out! It's like Nagi Ryoyu sensei's deep human psychology, so I irresistibly love the feeling that it shatters my heart!! I was curious about the continuation, watched the drama, and bought the novel series as an adult lol Kiyoi is already cute!!! I was thrilled to read that King was magically swayed and bonded, and eventually made into a situation where I had to break down lol it's disgusting, but it's okay, do more!! w

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 20, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

第一印象は最悪でした。

My first impression was terrible.

This review contains spoilers. 「美しい彼」と言う作品は前々から話題になっており、知ってはいましたが、原作は小説。小説は嫌いではないですが、読むのも時間がかかるし、なんかいいやって感じに後回しにしていました。ですが、今回漫画化したと聞き、漫画なら！と思い迷わず購入しました。最初読んだ時、第一印象は最悪でした。最悪というか、自分にとことん合ってないな感がすごくて、1巻だけじゃ、どっちが攻めか受けかもハッキリせず、(後々攻めになる)暗い男がとにかく気持ち悪くて、受けはとても気が強く、周りを見下してる感じ。1巻はその印象で終わります。いじめとか、孤独感とかがすごくて、そういう雰囲気で漫画の1巻は終わってしまうので、漫画から入った私的には印象が悪いの一言でした。もう買う事はないなと思い、同時になんでこんなに話題になったんだろうかと不思議だったので、小説のレビューを見に行きました。そこにはもう大体のひとが「攻めが気持ち悪い。でもそこがいい！」というレビューがびっしり。私は不思議で仕方なかったです。確かに、攻めであろう男は気持ち悪かった。でも、あれのどこがいいの……？？って世間と私との評価が真逆で当時は困惑してました笑そこまで言うなら……と原作1巻を購入。言うまでもない。最高でした。もう気持ち悪い攻めが最高なの！！！！初めて「気持ち悪い」という言葉を褒め言葉として扱いました。この作品は後々からじわじわとこの作品の良さが来ます。攻めの気持ち悪さと、受けの素直になれなさが絶妙にマッチしていなくて、でもマッチしていない所がうまくいってるというか……、、、まさか自分の最初の「最悪」という評価を覆させられるとは思ってもいなかったです。この作品、攻めの気持ち悪さの良さにハマったら最後です。是非とも、漫画から入って、「なんか合わないな」「気持ち悪いな」と思われたそこの方！！！小説1巻を読んでみていただきたい。是非とも貴方もこの気持ち悪いワールド(褒め言葉)に取り込まれてみて欲しい！！気持ち悪いワールド(褒め言葉)の沼に新たに飛び込む方を我々(入沼済者)はお待ちしております。

This review contains spoilers. The work “The Beautiful Guy” has been a hot topic for a long time, and I knew it, but the original is a novel. I don't dislike novels, but they take time to read, and I put them on the back burner because I felt like something was fine. However, I heard that it was made into a comic this time, so if it's a comic! I bought it without hesitation. When I first read it, my first impression was terrible. Worst of all, the feeling that it's not really right for me is amazing, and in volume 1, it's not clear which one is attacking or receiving, and the dark man (who attacks later) is just disgusting, and the reception is very strong, and it feels like he looks down on his surroundings. Volume 1 ends with that impression. There were so many things like bullying and loneliness, and the first volume of the comic ended in that kind of atmosphere, so it was a word that made a bad impression on me personally. I thought I wouldn't buy it anymore, and at the same time I was wondering why it became such a hot topic, so I went to see reviews of the novel. There, almost everyone already said, “Attacking is disgusting. But that's good!” There are plenty of reviews. I couldn't help but wonder. Certainly, the man who would be attacking was disgusting. But what's good about that...?? I was puzzled at the time because the world and my evaluations were the exact opposite lol if I had to go that far... and I bought 1 volume of the original story. Needless to say. It was awesome. Attacks that don't feel comfortable are already the best!!!! For the first time, I treated the word “disgusting” as a compliment. The merits of this work will gradually come later. The disgust of attack and the inability to be honest with the reception didn't match perfectly, but the place where the match didn't go well... I never thought I would be able to reverse my initial evaluation of “the worst.” This is the last time I'm addicted to this work because of how uncomfortable it is to attack. By all means, it's someone from there who started with comics and thought “something doesn't fit” or “it's disgusting”!! I want you to read volume 1 of the novel. By all means, I want you to be taken into this disgusting world (compliments) too! We (Irinuma Seiza) are waiting for new entrants into the swamp of a disgusting world (praise).

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

コミカライズで珍しく当たり！

It's comicalized and it's a rare hit!

コミカライズはハズレが多い&絵師さんが違うという、絶対転びそうな気がするのに、めっちゃ良かった！！小説版の絵が大好きでしたが、全く違和感なく読めました！北野先生バンザイ！惜しむべくは話数が少なく、もっと先まで読みたかったなあーって位です！（小説拝読済みなので）

There are a lot of losses in Comicalize and the painters are different, so I feel like I'm definitely going to fall, but it was really nice!! I loved the novel version of the picture, but I was able to read it without feeling uncomfortable at all! Kitano sensei banzai! Regrettably, the number of episodes is small, and I wish I had read them even further! (Since I've read the novel)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ありがとうございます

Thank you

この作品を読み、続きが気になり過ぎて小説を購入してしまいました。BL小説は読んだことが無かったのですが、こちらのコミカライズがとても良かったお陰で新しい扉を開く事が出来て感謝です。美しい受け、その彼に心酔している攻めの気持ち悪さが2巻以降で爆発するのが楽しみ！

I read this book and bought the novel because I was too worried about the continuation. I hadn't read a BL novel, but I'm grateful that I was able to open a new door thanks to this comicalization so good. I'm looking forward to seeing the beautiful reception, and the unease of attack that he is infatuated with will explode after volume 2!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ドラマから

From dramas

ドラマからです！絵がとても綺麗で購入しました！原作も読みましたが続きが楽しみで仕方ないです！！！

It's from the drama! The picture is very beautiful and I bought it! I also read the original story, but I can't help but look forward to the continuation!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 25, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

最高で最強のタッグだと思う。

I think it's the best and strongest tag team.

「美しい彼」という、レビューの投稿数も高評価も多いこのストーリーを知っていながら、なぜか食わず嫌いしていました。今回、好きな漫画家の北野さんが描くということでポチッとしてみた結果、、、もう感謝しかないです。ありがとうございます！こんな素敵なストーリーに関わってくださって。お陰で大好きな作品が1つ増えました。一気に原作の番外編まで購入して「美しい彼」沼にズブズブです。「美しい彼」のサイドストーリー“金木犀”が読みたくてビジュアルブックにまで手を出す始末…この漫画を含め原作を何度もリピートしてはデュフフフとほくそ笑みしてます。原作には葛西さんの美麗なイラストが入っていますが、それを踏襲(かと言ってコピーでは無い)している2人のキャラの描き方がとても秀逸。平良はいつも清居を見つめてストーカーしているキャラ。だからなのか、平良の瞳の描き方が丁寧にキモい(褒めてます)。それが良い！そしてちゃんとダサい笑。清居も王様感バッチリ。これから平良は清居に散々「キモい」「キモウザ」と罵倒されていくわけですが、言われた時の平良の表情がまたオドオドしているクセに喜んでいて、やっぱりキモいです(褒めてます)。原作まで読んだので展開は知ってしまったわけですが、この先にある清居の渾身の「カッコ悪い」シーンを北野さんがどう描かれるか本当に楽しみです。北野さんには頑張って原作全部を漫画化して欲しい！(余談ですが、北野さんの「最低な男の腕の中」と言う作品の中で、扉絵にアヒル隊長が描かれてて、またしてもデュフフとなりました。。。)

I knew about the story “The Beautiful Guy,” which had many reviews and high ratings, but for some reason I didn't like it. My favorite manga artist Kitano drew it this time, and as a result, I have nothing but gratitude... Thank you so much! They said they were involved in such a wonderful story. Thanks to that, my favorite work has increased by 1. I bought even the extra edition of the original story all at once, and I'm in the “beautiful guy” swamp. I wanted to read the side story “The Beautiful Guy,” so I even dabbled in a visual book... I've repeated the original story over and over again, including this comic, and I'm smiling softly. There are beautiful illustrations of Kasai in the original story, and the way they draw the two characters that follow (but not copies) is very excellent. Taira is a character who always stares at Kiyoi and stalks him. Maybe that's why the way Taira's eyes are drawn is carefully creepy (I'm praising him). That's good! and it's really lame lol. Kiyoi also has a perfect sense of being a king. From now on, Taira will be taunted a lot by Kiyoi for being “gross” and “gross,” but he is delighted with the fact that Taira's expression when told to it is once again ridiculous, and it's still creepy (I'm praising him). I've read the original story, so I know the development, but I'm really excited to see how Kitano-san will draw the “uncool” scene of Kiyoi's full body that lies ahead. I want Kitano-san to do his best to make all of the original comics! (As an aside, in Kitano-san's work called “In the Arms of the Worst Man,” Captain Duck was depicted on the door painting, and it became Dufufu once again...)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

すごい小出し！！漫画ってそうなるよね…

Great small release!! Manga is like that...

話の進みは、牛歩のような一歩で歯痒い！！でも、背が高くて手足も長い、長髪黒髪イケメンが、吃音でオドオドしてるだけで、こんなにも気持ち悪くなるんだと、実感させてもらった。きもうざ平良と孤高のキング清居が、眼前に現れて苦しい。自分の干からびた想像では見れなかった2人を見れて嬉しすぎる。この2人が、これから、あんななって、こんななってしちゃうの？？でも、2巻2023年春って言い切られてしまってるし…乙女清居や雄味増し増し平良を拝めるのはいつになるんだろう…。楽しみが増えてありがたいが、待つ苦しさも増えてしまったよ。

The story progresses in one step like walking a cow, and it's itchy!! But it made me realize that this tall, long-haired, dark-haired handsome guy with long arms and legs just stutters and stutters makes me feel so uncomfortable. Kimoza Taira and the lonely King Kiyoi appear in front of me and it's painful. I'm so happy to be able to see these two people that I couldn't have seen in my own dry imagination. Are these 2 people going to be like that or this from now on?? But it has been said that volume 2 is spring 2023... I wonder when we will be able to worship Otome Kiyoi and Omi Masashi Taira... I'm thankful that the fun has increased, but so has the pain of waiting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

尊い…(合掌)

Precious... (Gassho)

This review contains spoilers. 好きすぎました。空気感、小説原作ならではの言葉選びの美しさ、キャラ、絵柄、全てに惹かれました。どうしても続きが読みたくて原作も全て買いました。普段小説が大の苦手で絶対買わない私が買いました。個人的に大事件です。それくらい虜です。もう、どちらも全部ほんっっと最高です。現時点ではクラスメイトや周囲の人間がクソすぎて辛いのですが、高校生時代のそういう事が２人の進展に繋がると言いますか…そこが苦手な方、もうちょっと頑張って読んで欲しい…！

This review contains spoilers. I liked it too much. I was attracted to the atmosphere, the beauty of choosing words unique to the original novel, the characters, and the pattern. I really wanted to read more, so I bought all of the original books. I usually don't like novels so much that I never buy them, so I bought it. It's a major incident for me personally. I'm so captivated. They're all really great already. At the moment, my classmates and people around me are so bad that it's painful, but do you think that kind of thing when you were in high school will lead to progress for the two... if you don't like that, I want you to try a little harder to read it...!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

待ってました！

I've been waiting!

ドラマにはまり、小説は全く読まないのでハードルが高かったので読まず、漫画になったら速攻買いました(^^)清居と平良のイメージもそのまま期待を裏切らない作品で凄い！嬉しいです！一巻は中途半端で終わったので早く2巻が読みたいです〜

I'm addicted to dramas, and since I don't read novels at all, the hurdles were high, and when it became a comic, I quickly bought it (^^) The images of Kiyoi and Taira are amazing works that don't disappoint! I'm happy! I finished volume 1 halfway, so I want to read volume 2 as soon as possible~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい

beautiful

原作未読ですが、北野先生ファンなので購入しました。清居、美しいです。ただ、平良がスクールカースト底辺でパシられてたり、からかわれてたりするのがちょっと、読んでいて辛い。これからどうなっていくのでしょうか。何も知らないので、楽しみ！

I haven't read the original story, but I'm a Kitano-sensei fan, so I bought it. Kiyoi is beautiful. However, it's a bit painful to read that Taira is at the bottom of the school caste and is being made fun of. What's going to happen in the future? I don't know anything, so I'm looking forward to it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

心が苦しい〜

My heart is pain~

試し読みでアヒル隊長の表現力に魅了され読み止まらなくなりそのまま購入。高校生だとこういうことする人いますよね…いろんな意味で幸せになってほしい。次巻発売まで結構先なので待ち遠しい。

I was fascinated by Captain Duck's expressive power in the trial reading and couldn't stop reading it, so I bought it as it was. There are people who do things like this when they're in high school... I want them to be happy in many ways. It's quite a while until the next volume goes on sale, so I can't wait.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

いやぁ、美しいのよ

Well, it's beautiful

This review contains spoilers. ずっと小説版はお見かけしていてなんて美しいんだろうと気になっていたのが漫画が発売されたのを知り即購入。小説版と作画違う方らしいのですが、気にならず美しい…尊い…。なかなか進みが漫画だとスローペースに感じるので2人のラブラブがみれるのは当分先なんだと覚悟しつつ最後まで楽しみにしてます?

This review contains spoilers. I've always seen the novel version and was curious how beautiful it was, but when I learned that the comic was on sale, I bought it right away. It seems that the drawing is different from the novel version, but it doesn't bother me and it's beautiful... precious... I feel like the progress is pretty slow if it's a comic, so I'm looking forward to the end while being prepared that I can see the two in love for a while?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 12, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが早くみたい

I want to see the continuation soon

原作が小説ということもあって、ストーリーが深いかんじがしました。二人はどうなってくの！？早く続きが読みたいです！

There is also the fact that the original story is a novel, so I felt that the story was deep. What's going to happen to the two of them!? I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

続き〜！

Continued~!

This review contains spoilers. 活字が苦手で未読。ドラマから入ったのでコミカライズになるとどんなだろうと少し躊躇ってましたが…北野先生が大好きなので読んでみました。透明感のある絵とストーリーがマッチしていてもっと早く読めばよかった。まだまだ2人の恋はこれからみたいですが2巻が今から待ち遠しいです！

This review contains spoilers. I'm not good at print, so I haven't read it. I started with the drama, so I was a little hesitant about what it would be like to comicalize it... I love Kitano-sensei, so I read it. The transparent picture matched the story, and I wish I had read it sooner. Looks like their love is still around the corner, but I can't wait for volume 2!

Helpful

Reviews for My Beautiful Man Manga