My Beautiful Man Manga Reviews (P.11)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 30, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ひどく純粋で強烈で熱烈な想い

Terribly pure, intense, and fervent feelings

清居「綺麗」は平子にとって特別そんな綺麗な存在への崇拝のような恋清居の優しさや強さに惹かれるにわかるわかりみが深い北野仁先生に感謝です映像じゃ壊れちゃうな

Kiyoi's “Kirei” is special for Hirako, a love that is like adoration for such a beautiful being, thanks to Kitano Hitoshi, who has a deep understanding that can be understood when attracted to Kiyoi's kindness and strength. The video breaks it

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 28, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

原作読破済み

The original story has been read

原作大好きなのでこちらも購入しました。この作品は清居サイドの心情を読んでからが真骨頂だと思ってます。なのでもう少し先が早く読みたいです

I love the original, so I bought this one too. I think the true value of this work came after reading Kiyoi Side's Feelings. So I want to read the one a little bit faster

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

めちゃくちゃ好き。早く続きが読みたい！

I love it so much. I want to read more soon!

1巻を読んですぐ原作に走りました！原作は３巻＋番外編読了済みです。1、2巻は高校生編、3巻は社会人になって再会したところまで、4巻でいよいよ清居くんの抑えきれない感情が表に出てくるターン！待ってました、ここからいよいよ面白さが増してくる！ここまで長く感じたけれど、原作にかなり忠実に進めて下さっている作者さまには感謝感謝です。キャラの描写もとても良い。このままいくと5巻ではちょっとエッチなシーンも入ってきますね。超楽しみ。このままクライマックスに向けて、そして原作2巻、3巻の漫画化もぜひぜひお願いしたいです！！

As soon as I read volume 1, I moved on to the original! I've already read 3 volumes plus extra editions of the original story. Volumes 1 and 2 are for high school students, and volume 3 is the point where they became members of society and reunited, so it's finally Kiyoi-kun's uncontrollable feelings come to the surface in volume 4! I've been waiting for it, the fun will finally increase from here on out! It feels like it's been this long, but I'm grateful to the author who has progressed quite faithfully to the original story. The portrayal of the characters is also very good. If things continue like this, some slightly naughty scenes will come in in volume 5. I'm super excited. As we move towards the climax, I definitely want to ask for comic adaptations of volumes 2 and 3 of the original!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 26, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい

beautiful

小説の世界がマンガに反映されていてとても物語が分かっていてもすぐに美しい彼の世界観へのめり込むことができました！！

The world of the novel was reflected in the manga, and even though I understood the story very well, I was able to immediately immerse myself in his beautiful worldview!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

いい！

That's good!

This review contains spoilers. 凪良ゆうさんのコミカライズということで楽しみにしていました！北野仁さんの絵も言葉も雰囲気もはまっていてわたしは好きです。平良の吃音からの孤独、清居への狂おしい愛・気持ち悪さ（褒め言葉）、清居の孤高の美しさ、唯一無二の存在感…ぐっと物語へと引き込まれます。交わることのない両極端の2人の心の距離が近づいていく様子をじっくり見ていきたいです！3巻が楽しみすぎて…待っています。

This review contains spoilers. I was looking forward to it because it was Nagi Ryoyu's comicalization! I love Hitoshi Kitano's pictures, words, and atmosphere. Taira's loneliness from stuttering, his insane love/disgust (compliment) for Kiyoi, Kiyoi's solitary beauty, and his unique presence... I'm drawn in a lot into the story. I want to take a close look at how the distance between the two hearts of two extremes that never intersect gets closer! I enjoyed volume 3 so much... I'm waiting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

物語に吸い込まれるように読みました

I read it so that I was sucked into the story

ライトノベルのコミカライズ特有の文字の多さがまったく気にならないほどの美麗な文章、美しい絵。2人を取り巻く世界は決して美しくないし、何より2人の関係はまさに歪。なのに「美しい」と思わせる文章と絵、素晴らしいです。2人の関係が今後どのように変わっていくのか目が離せない。

Beautiful sentences and beautiful pictures that I don't care at all about the large number of characters peculiar to the light novel Comicalize. The world surrounding them isn't beautiful at all, and above all, the relationship between them is just distorted. Nevertheless, the sentences and pictures that make you think they are “beautiful” are wonderful. Keep an eye out for how the relationship between the two will change in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

レビューを見て

Look at the reviews

This review contains spoilers. 試し読みで読める部分であまりいいイメージではなかったので読んでいませんでしたが、割引がついたタイミングでレビューを見て、購入を決めました。いい感じに気持ち悪くて、面白いです。これからの展開が気になります。

This review contains spoilers. I didn't read it because it wasn't a very good image in the part I could read in the trial reading, but I looked at the reviews when the discount was added and decided to buy it. It's nice, disgusting, and funny. I'm curious about future developments.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が

The picture

原作にすごく合ってる私はクールな清居がすきなのでいままさに大好き中wなぜだろう原作より平がキモくない素敵な絵のせいかも長くなっても忠実に細かく描写したコミックになってほしい

I really like the cool Kiyoi, which fits the original story, so I still love it lol I want it to be a comic that faithfully depicts it in detail even if it's longer, probably because of the wonderful pictures that are flat and not gross than the original

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

原作に負けない漫画

Manga that won't lose to the original

小説でよんだものは漫画やドラマになっても全然グッとこないのですが、この漫画は素晴らしいです。北野先生ファンということもあって最高でした。

What I read in a novel isn't great at all, even if it becomes a comic or drama, but this comic is wonderful. I'm also a fan of Kitano-sensei, so that was great.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

いいです

It's good

ドラマからはいりました。小説もよんで、マンガも拝見してます。続きが楽しみです。ずっと応援してます。

I started with the drama. I read novels and read manga. I'm looking forward to the continuation. I've always supported you.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

こちらも良い！

This one is good too!

ノベルからきました！ノベルの挿絵も素敵ですが、こちらもとても素敵で、違和感なく読み始められました！ストーリーは知っていますが、こちらでは絵で楽しむことができて良かったです！

I came from Novell! The illustrations for the novel are also wonderful, but they are also very nice, and I was able to start reading without any sense of incongruity! I know the story, but I'm glad I was able to enjoy it with pictures here!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ドラマ版から

From the drama version

ドラマ版からきました。まだ連載途中とは残念です。平のきもうざい感じがたまりません。早く続きがみたいです

It came from the drama version. It's a pity that it's still being serialized. The annoying feeling of Taira no Kimo is irresistible. I want to continue soon

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

すごい。

That's amazing.

BL作品関係なく小説は好きでよく読んでいるのですが、今まで読んだ全ての小説の中でもかなりの上位にくるくらい大大大好きな作品のコミカライズなので、やっぱり雰囲気壊れてないかなとか色々不安で手を出せませんでした。ですがレビューがよかったのでえいやで購入してみたところ…よかったーー！！すごい。すごい。清居のキラキラを、平良のキモさを、ここまで丁寧に漫画という形にしてくださっていて、嬉しくて感動しながら読んじゃいました。清居の「きも」というセリフが大好きなのですが、それを漫画で読めて幸せいっぱいです。漫画は読むけど小説は読まないという方もきっといらっしゃると思うので、この作品を読んで美しい彼の面白さが伝わって欲しいなと思います。

I like novels and read them a lot regardless of BL works, but it's a comicalization of a work I love so much that it ranks quite high among all the novels I've read so far, so I couldn't get my hands on it due to various concerns about whether the atmosphere would be broken after all. However, the reviews were good, so I bought it at Eiya... great!! That's amazing. That's amazing. They have carefully shaped Kiyoi's Kirakira and Taira's creepy in the form of comics up to this point, and I was happy and moved. I love the line “Kimo” by Kiyoi, and I'm so happy to be able to read it in comics. I'm sure there are people who read comics but don't read novels, so I hope reading this work conveys the fun of his beautiful guy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

歪な恋

Distorted Love

歪んでるような、純愛の物語です！吃音でいじめられキャラが、アイドル志望のクール男子に恋するお話。続きが気になります！

It's a distorted, pure love story! A story about a character who is bullied for stuttering and falls in love with a cool boy who aspires to be an idol. I'm curious about the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

めちゃくちゃいい！

insanely good!

原作者のファンで既に読破！めちゃくちゃいいお話なのを、なんとこれまた作画が大好きな北野先生♡購入するしかないじゃありませんか！私の脳内イメージそのまんまでした。ありがとうございます。

I'm a fan of the original author and have already read it! It's an insanely good story, but Kitano sensei loves drawing again ♡ isn't there no choice but to buy it! The image in my brain remained the same. Thank you very much.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

本当に最高です

It's really awesome

最初は実写版から入ったんですけど、本当にハマってしまって原作を読みたくなって今回やっと読めました。原作も本当に最高で美しかったです

At first, I started with the live-action version, but I was really addicted to it and wanted to read the original story, so I was finally able to read it this time. The original story was also really awesome and beautiful

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

何度も読んでいます。

I've read it many times.

ドラマも好きですが、この漫画はより原作に近いのでドラマとは別角度から見ているような感覚で楽しみにしています。人物の表情が丁寧に描かれているので何度も読んでしまいます。

I also like dramas, but since this comic is closer to the original, I'm looking forward to it as if I were watching it from a different angle from the drama. The facial expressions of the characters are carefully drawn, so I read it over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

4巻が面白すぎて前レビュー消した

Volume 4 was so interesting that I deleted the previous review

4巻が・・4巻から大変なことになっちょった・・。あまりに面白展開すぎて前回のレビューを削除して書き直しています。セリフ及びモノローグ（セリフ以外の心の声的なやつ）が多めなのに全く負担にならず・・いやモノローグがあるお陰で世界観にズイズイと引き込まれ吸い込まれ蒸発し・・あっ違う・・とにかくあの清居が、振り回されてるとですよ！平良に！！それはもうブンブンと！！これ次の5巻出たらもう昇天するんではなかろうか（無論私が）・・。3巻以下で読むの止まってる人全員に4巻を買ってあげたい・・そんな4巻でした。

Volume 4... it's been a bit of a big deal since volume 4... The development was so interesting that I deleted the previous review and rewrote it. Even though there are so many lines and monologues (voice of the heart other than dialogue), it's not a burden at all... no, thanks to the monologue, it's drawn in by the worldview, sucked in, and evaporated... oh no... that's wrong... anyway, that Kiyoi is being swayed around! To Hirara!! That's already booming!! If the next 5 volumes of this come out, I wonder if they'll ascend to heaven (of course I)... I want to buy 4 volumes for everyone who has stopped reading 3 volumes or less... it was 4 volumes like that.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻も最あんど高！！！

Volume 2 is also the most expensive!!!

■試し読みのアヒル隊長でガッツリ心捕まれ(何ならそこでもー泣きそうになった)そのままハマってすぐ、番外編含め原作の小説即買いしました！めちゃくちゃ面白くて一気読み。小説読んでコミックは原作のイメージを全く損なってない。凄い！絵も自分の想像するひらきよ！小説読んだ後コミック読み返したらニヤけてしまいます。■2巻買いました！はぁ〜〜2巻も最高でした！！3巻秋に発売予定らしいですが、待ちきれない！でも、小説再読→コミックのループで気長に待ちます！楽しみです！！

■As soon as I got hooked on the trial reading Captain Duck and got hooked on it, I immediately bought the original novel, including the extra edition! It was insanely interesting and I read it all at once. Reading the novel, the comic didn't damage the image of the original at all. that's amazing! Pictures are also free to imagine yourself! It makes me grin when I reread the comic after reading the novel. ■I bought 2 volumes! Huh... volume 2 was great too!! It seems that volume 3 will be released in the fall, but I can't wait! But I'll wait patiently in the comic loop after rereading the novel! I'm looking forward to it!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 08, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ゆっくり進んでください…

Please proceed slowly...

原作の作者様追いから来ておりますが、ドラマもコミカライズもこの作品ホントにすごいと思います。BLはファンタジーのはずだったのにな。もしやこのまま怪物のような作品になっていくのではないだろうか？社会の認識を変換させる的な。ともあれ、ずーっと楽しみたいので、ゆっくりゆっくり進んでほしいです。

I'm coming after the author of the original story, and I think both the drama and comicalization are really amazing. BL was supposed to be fantasy. Wouldn't it be if the work continued to look like a monster? It's like changing society's perception. Anyway, I want you to enjoy it all the time, so I want it to go slowly and slowly.

Helpful

Reviews for My Beautiful Man Manga