Koimonogatari Manga Reviews (P.8)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 21, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

BLを越えた作品

Works that go beyond BL

エロを求めている方には向いてないですが、この作品はBLを越えたヒューマンストーリーだと思います！田倉トヲル先生は心理描写が飛び抜けて上手すぎます！悩みとか辛さとか人の温かさとか、心にグサグサ刺さり私は大泣きしてます。私が映画監督だったら即映画化ですよ！こんな人間の心の大事な部分がいっぱいつまっている作品を全人類にみて欲しいとさえ思ってしまいました。あーもっとみんなに広めたいー！

It's not suitable for people looking for eroticism, but I think this work is a human story that goes beyond BL! Takura Toworu sensei is so good at depicting psychology by far! I'm crying a lot because my worries, pain, and the warmth of people stuck in my heart. If I were a film director, it would be made into a movie right away! I even wanted all of humanity to see this work, which contains so many important parts of the human heart. Ah, I want to spread the word even more to everyone!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

しっかり読ませてくれる作品です

It's a work that makes me read carefully

高校生の、恋や友情が、しっかり描かれていて、読み応えがあります。若さ故の悩みを抱え、ひとつひとつ乗り越えていく主人公2人に、しあわせな未来がやってきますようにと、願わずにいられません。周りの子達の心模様も、細やかに描かれており、基本的にみんないい子達。3巻完結とのことなので、現段階では最終巻が、とても楽しみな作品です。

The love and friendship of high school students are clearly depicted, and it is worth reading. I can't help but hope that a happy future will come to the two protagonists, who have problems from their youth and overcome them one by one. The heart patterns of the children around them are also drawn in detail, and basically they are all good children. It is said that 3 volumes have been completed, so I'm really looking forward to the final volume at this stage.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 04, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

思ったより爽やかじゃない青春

Youth not as refreshing as I thought

This review contains spoilers. 初めて読む作家さんです。絵が綺麗でみんな個性あって魅力的な男の子たちが出てきます。でも、なかなか恋愛になりません。友情が美しい。難しい年頃で爽やか明るく軽く〜な雰囲気でなく、思ったよりナイーブなお話です。一体この先どうなるのでしょうか、、ら続きが気になります。

This review contains spoilers. This is my first time reading this writer. The pictures are beautiful, and all have their own personalities, and charming boys come out. But it's not easy to fall in love. Friendship is beautiful. It's a more naive story than I thought, with a difficult age and not a fresh, bright, and light atmosphere. What the hell is going to happen in the future, I'm worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 17, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

リアルです(腐男子)

It's real (rotten boy)

えっ俺の事描いてる？って思うシーンが何度も何度もありました。バレてないかな、変じゃないかなって常に気をつけて、学生時代に、お前ってなんか距離感じるって言われ続けてました? 読む度に胸が締め付けられます。早く続きを読みたいです。自分の為にもハッピーエンドで終わらせて欲しいな?

Eh, are you drawing about me? There were scenes over and over again that made me think that. Always be careful if they don't find out or if it's weird, and when you were a student, people kept telling you that you felt some kind of distance? My chest tightens every time I read it. I want to read more soon. you want it to end up with a happy ending for yourself too, right?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 10, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

若さ

youth

高校生が恋と性に対して、悩み考えて自分らしさや、周りとの関わりを手探りで見出だす姿がとても自然に描かれています。

It is a very natural depiction of high school students thinking about love and sex and finding their own personality and relationships with those around them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 03, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

青春！

youth!

This review contains spoilers. 心理描写が繊細で生き生きしていて、読みながら自分も高校時代に戻ったような気分になりました。土井が嫌な奴でめっちゃムカムカしながら読みました。

This review contains spoilers. The psychological depiction was delicate and vivid, and while reading it, I felt like I had gone back to my high school days. I didn't like Doi, so I was really nervous reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 27, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

BLというより青春！

Youth rather than BL!

This review contains spoilers. イチャイチャラブラブはしてません。今のところ。読んでて辛かったりするくらいちゃんとした話。同級生が自分の友達を好きってことに気づいてって設定が新鮮。男の子の友情っていいなぁ。くっつき過ぎず離れずでも大切！ゆるいけど熱い！な青春が眩しいっ！心の声が多いから、クラスでバレちゃうとか親に打ち明けるとかノンケとの恋とか、それぞれの悩みや考え方がリアルでこっちも色々考えさせられる。これからどうなるのかなー。吉永くんは段々長谷川くんを好きになってるよね。わかる、いい男だもんね！でも結局長谷川くんとは結ばれず同じ世界の人との恋愛に向かう、吉永くん的には辛いけどそんなラストがいいです。まぁ2人がラブラブになって、長谷川くんのねこも見てみたい気もするけど笑

This review contains spoilers. I'm not flirtatious. for now. It's such a proper story that it was hard to read. I noticed that my classmates liked my friend, and the setting was fresh. It's nice to have a boy's friendship. It's important that they don't stick together too much and don't leave! It's loose but hot! My youth is so dazzling! Since there are a lot of voices in my heart, my own worries and ways of thinking, such as finding out in class, confiding in my parents, or falling in love with Nonke, are real, and it makes me think a lot. I wonder what's going to happen in the future. Yoshinaga-kun is gradually falling in love with Hasegawa-kun, isn't he? I know, he's a nice guy! But in the end, he doesn't end up with Hasegawa-kun and heads towards a love affair with someone from the same world, and that's painful for Yoshinaga-kun, but that last one is good. Well, the two have become lovey-dovey, and I feel like I want to see Hasegawa-kun's cat too lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 24, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

DKの、恋に悩む心理描写が素敵

The psychological depiction of struggling with love by DK is wonderful

のみ✖️しばを読んでから、来たのですが、とても丁寧に自分の性的指向に悩むDKの心情が描かれていて、素晴らしい作品でした。次の３巻で最後。そして、内容的には終にBLするかな？という展開です。直接のBL描写が無くても、ノンケDKに恋して、友情と恋の狭間で揺れてる様子が自分のことのように心に響きます。家族へカムアウトするまでの葛藤や勇気、こんな家族や友達、現実に居そう、と思いながら読んでます。

Only ✖️ I came here after reading Shiba, and it was a wonderful work that very carefully depicts the feelings of DK struggling with her own sexual orientation. It will be the last in the next 3 volumes. And I wonder if it will finally be BL in terms of content? That's the development. Even without a direct BL depiction, the sight of falling in love with Nonke DK and swaying between friendship and love resonates with my heart as if it were my own. I'm reading it while thinking about the conflict and courage leading up to coming out to my family, and that this kind of family and friends seem to exist in real life.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 20, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

作者さん買いです。。

The author is buying it..

同性愛の難しい部分を高校生という爽やかな世代にのせてなんともいえないストーリー展開が面白い。。。毎回そんな雰囲気に身悶えながら楽しく読める。。2巻も買ってしまいそう。。。

The indescribable storyline that puts the difficult part of homosexuality on the refreshing generation of high school students is interesting... I enjoy reading it while struggling with that kind of atmosphere every time.. I think I'm going to buy 2 volumes too...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 20, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ゆっくり過ぎて…

it's too slow...

話のテンポはゆっくりでむしろ好きだし、丁寧に進んで欲しいと思いますが、連載が時々で全然先に進まない。なんで！？絵も最初と全然違うし。大好きなんだけど‼️完結してから買えばよかった。ちゃんと最後まで描いてくれるのか不安しかない。

The tempo of the story is slow and I rather like it, and I would like it to proceed carefully, but the serialization is occasional and it doesn't progress at all. why!? The picture is also completely different from the beginning. I love it ‼️ I should have bought it after it was finished. I'm just worried about whether they'll be able to draw until the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

人間ドラマとして素晴らしい！

Great as a human drama!

全くのエロなしですが、これはもう人間ドラマですね。素晴らしい！BL要素は少ないけど、切ないし萌えもある。ほんと良い作品に出会えて嬉しいと感じました。

There's no eroticism at all, but this is already a human drama, isn't it? great! There aren't many BL elements, but it's also sad and exciting. I was happy to come across a really good work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

２巻まで読みました！

I've read up to 2 volumes!

最初BLとは知らずに読んでいて、初心者の私に読めるかもと扉を開けてくれた作品です。やっと購入したんですが。私の現実とは違いますが、これもリアルなんだろうなって思います。隠すか、振り切るか、それぞれに考えがあって、そこで生きていく。学校という閉鎖的な場所では特に難しい。嫌悪する人がいることは分かっていても腹が立つ。そして2巻のラストがどうなるのか気になる。

At first, I read it without knowing it was BL, and it opened the door for me as a beginner that I might be able to read it. I finally bought it. It's different from my reality, but I think this is real too. They each have their own idea of whether to hide it or shake it off, and they live there. It's especially difficult in a closed place called a school. I'm angry even though I know there are people I hate. And I wonder what will happen at the end of volume 2.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らしいです。

It's great.

This review contains spoilers. すぐくっつくBLやエロを求めてるBLが見たい人にはおすすめできません。この話をBLというジャンルに括っていいのかも分かりません。同性愛者の男の子の成長過程を見守らせて頂く作品です。ただそれだけでなく、主人公や登場人物、皆が皆人との付き合い方や、自分との向き合い方に誠実だからこそ何度も何度も悩む姿がとても眩しく、それでいて目が離せません。登場人物の言葉が、相手を思ってるからこそ出た言葉が多くて、読んでてとても優しい気持ちになるし、温かくなります。2巻の段階で、恋愛らしい恋愛はまだ起きてませんが、彼らが幸せになることを心から祈ってます。

This review contains spoilers. I don't recommend it to people who want to watch BL that stick together quickly or BL looking for erotica. I don't know if it's okay to group this story in the BL genre. It is a work where you can watch over the growth process of a homosexual boy. Not only that, the main character, and characters are all sincere in how they deal with people and how they deal with themselves, so dazzling that they worry over and over again, yet I can't take my eyes off them. Many of the characters' words come out because they think of the other person, and it makes me feel very kind and warm when I read them. At the stage of volume 2, a romantic romance hasn't happened yet, but I sincerely pray that they will be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻

Volume 2

やっと読みました。ゆっくり続いていく日常、楽しさも重苦しさもリアルに伝わってきました。３巻待ち遠しいです。

I finally read it. The fun and heavy pain of everyday life, which continues slowly, has been conveyed realistically. I can't wait for volume 3.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 17, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

BLというより…

rather than BL...

「ゲイ」に焦点を当てた、男子高校生の恋愛がテーマ。少女漫画に近い気が。残念ながら（今のところ）誰もラブラブになりません（笑）…なので「男の子のらぶらぶえっちが見たい！」て人には正直物足りない感はあるかもしれませんが…男の子たちが無邪気にじゃれ合っててそれはそれでとてもよいものです…（眼福）。マイノリティに悩む男子高校生のリアルな心情描写、不安、切なさ、自己否定…だけど恋をする、葛藤が繊細に描かれていてとても読み応えあります。恋愛じゃない、男の子の友情もいいもんだなー…てみていたら、2巻の最後で不穏な空気…？！！続きが気になります！！

The theme is the romance of male high school students, focusing on “gays.” I feel like it's close to a girls' manga. Unfortunately (so far) no one has become lovey-dovey (lol)... so “I want to see boys hanging out!” To be honest, there may be a feeling that it's not enough for people... the boys are playing with each other innocently, and that's really good... (eye blessing). It delicately depicts the realistic feelings of a male high school student suffering from minorities, anxiety, sadness, self-denial... but the conflict of falling in love, and it is very readable. It's not love, boys' friendships are good too... and when I was watching it, there was a disturbing atmosphere at the end of volume 2...?!! I'm curious about the continuation!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 17, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

泣いた…

I cried...

泣きました〜！主人公達の気持ちが丁寧に描かれています。BLって展開早くて、あれ？って思うことも多々ありですが、これは違うなー。ゆっくりゆっくりって感じで、良いですね〜。早く続きが読みたい！

I cried! The feelings of the main characters are carefully depicted. BL is developing fast, huh? There are many things I think, but this is different. It feels like it's slow and slow, which is nice. I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 17, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

早く！！

quickly!!

とにかく早く続きをお願いします！こんなに気になると思わなかった。引き込まれました。良かった。

Anyway, please continue as soon as possible! I didn't expect it to be this bothersome. I was drawn in. That was great.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 17, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

良い良い！

good good!

This review contains spoilers. すっごく丁寧に進んでいくお話しで、友情と恋心の切ない感じがたまりません。これからどうなるのか？？とっても気になります。私的には、やまととゆうじのハッピーエンドで終わって欲しいところ。。。。はやく続巻読みたいです。田倉トヲルさん大好きです。応援してます。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story that progresses so carefully, and the sad feeling of friendship and love is irresistible. What's going to happen now?? I'm really curious. Personally, I want it to end with Yamato and Yuji's happy ending... I want to read the next volume soon. I love Toru Takura. I'm rooting for you.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 09, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

丁寧なものがたり

A polite story

登場人物がとても多いけど、主役の2人をはじめ、どの人物の心理描写も丁寧で違和感なく描かれていてすごい！応援したくなる。ものがたりの進み方はゆっくりですが、それはすごく自然で良い意味で重みがあり、読後の満足度が高いです。続きが気になる！本当に素敵な作品です！

There are so many characters, but it's amazing that the psychological depictions of every character, including the 2 leading actors, are carefully drawn without any sense of incongruity! It makes me want to cheer. The story progresses slowly, but it is very natural and has weight in a good sense, and there is a high level of satisfaction after reading it. I'm worried about the continuation! It's a really nice piece!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 03, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ゆっくりな…

slowly...

まだ葛藤が続くんですね！読みごたえあって、時間かけて読みました！

The conflict is still going on! It was a great read, and I took the time to read it!

Helpful

Reviews for Koimonogatari Manga