Koimonogatari Manga Reviews (P.7)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

すごいドラマだ…

it's an amazing drama...

こんなにも葛藤が描かれてるBLを今まで読んでこなかった！ストーリーがしっかりしてるから満足感(?)がすごい！おかげで次巻をじっくり待てそう！

I haven't read a BL that depicts so much conflict until now! Satisfaction because the story is solid (?) is amazing! Thanks to that, it seems like I'll be able to wait a long time for the next volume!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

勝手に完結だと思い込んでた?

did you think it would end without permission?

つつぎはよー?今まで読んだ高校生BLの中で断トツにリアリティある揺れと仲間との友情とで、読み応えあります！最終的にはあの２人が…と期待してるんだけど、続きが楽しみすぎるっ。

Tsutsugi is OK? It's definitely the most realistic high school student BL I've ever read, and the friendship with my friends, and it's worth reading! I'm hoping those two will eventually... but I'm looking forward too much to the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 15, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

深くて尊い

Deep and precious

This review contains spoilers. BLの重くてエロいものがすきですが、この作品は完全にピュアピュアで登場人物一人ひとりが魅力的なところがとても好きです。続きが早く読みたい！！大和から唯司への感情が、友情から愛情に変わってしまう焦りとかが垣間見えて今後の展開に期待です。

This review contains spoilers. I like heavy and erotic BL, but I really like the fact that this work is completely pure and each and every character is attractive. I want to read more soon!! I can catch a glimpse of Yamato's feelings towards Yuiji and the impatience that changes from friendship to love, and I'm looking forward to future developments.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 15, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

これは、、

This is...

深いですね、、周りでは知らないので想像でしかないですが、リアルにはこんな感じなのかなあって、応援したくなりますね。続きがはやくよみたいです！

It's deep... people around me don't know it, so I can only imagine it, but I wonder if it's like this in real life, and it makes me want to cheer for them. It looks like the continuation is coming soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 14, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

良すぎる

It's too good

This review contains spoilers. これを語るには語彙力が足りなすぎて困る。高校生の心の機微の表現が素晴らしすぎます。長谷川くんめちゃくちゃ良いやつ！こんな友達ほしいよー。吉永くんの心を軽くしてあげることはできるのに、彼女に対しては不器用で。。青春！長谷川くんの親友で吉永くんの好きな人・本郷くんもいいヤツだし、傷つけられてひねくれてしまったかわいこちゃんもいいヤツだし、なっちゃんもいいこ！吉永くんのこと好きになっちゃわないのかなー。それはそれで酷か。吉永くんの親友もイイやつ！イイヤツしか出てこないじゃーんと思ってたら、２巻に出てくるアイツにイライラさせられた！！リアルにいそうだよーーーいつも真面目すぎて考えすぎる吉永くんが繰り出した渾身の一言に拍手を送りたい！って、３巻もあるし、また一波乱ありそうー！次の買います。めちゃくちゃ良い作品！

This review contains spoilers. I'm in trouble because I don't have enough vocabulary to talk about this. The subtle expressions of a high school student's mind are too wonderful. Hasegawa-kun is an insanely good guy! I want a friend like this. I can lighten Yoshinaga-kun's heart, but he's clumsy when it comes to her... youth! Hasegawa-kun's best friend and Yoshinaga-kun's favorite person, Hongo-kun, is a nice guy, the cutie who got hurt and turned perverse is also a nice guy, and Nacchan is good too! I wonder if they'll fall in love with Yoshinaga-kun. is that so bad? Yoshinaga-kun's best friend is nice too! I thought only Iyatsu would come up, but I was frustrated by the guy who appears in volume 2!! Seems real — I want to applaud Yoshinaga-kun, who is always too serious and thinks too much, for his wholehearted words! There are also 3 volumes, and it looks like there's going to be another upheaval! I'll buy the next one. Insanely good work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 14, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

濃密

dense

登場人物達の心情がとっても丁寧に描かれていて、一冊読み終わるのが長く感じました。内容が濃密。お話はゆっくり進むけど、中だるみ感は全く無し。大和も長谷川も友人たちも、まさに手探りしながら少しずつ成長していく姿が爽やかで不器用で眩しいです。今のところあんまりＢがＬしてませんが、大和くんが切なくて健気で幸せになってほしいなー。あと、2巻での親友関くんの男らしさにめっちゃトキメキました。気になる所で続いているので、3巻が楽しみです!

The feelings of the characters were drawn very carefully, and I felt that it was a long time to finish reading one book. The content is intense. The story progresses slowly, but there is no sense of sluggishness at all. The sight of Yamato, Hasegawa, and their friends growing little by little while just fumbling is refreshing, clumsy, and dazzling. There hasn't been much B-L so far, but I want Yamato-kun to be sad, healthy, and happy. Also, I was really excited about the masculinity of my best friend Seki in volume 2. It continues where I'm interested, so I'm looking forward to volume 3!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

深い

deep

こんなに性癖について沢山考えさせられるとは思いませんでした。主要メンバーが男子も女子(母や姉含む)もみんな魅力的に描かれていて、ひとつのドラマとして素晴らしいなぁと思います。友情っていいですね。恋愛っていいですね。毎日がキラキラして青春だなって懐かしい感覚を思いださせてくれる。ゲイに悩む男子校生とその秘密を知ってしまったクラスメイトの心情をじっくり掘り下げた最高の作品です。深すぎて再読するのにエネルギーが必要なので、また暫く置いてから読み直ししたいです。更に続きが早く読みたいです！今後の展開が気になりすぎた、、

I never thought it would make me think so much about sexual habits. The main members, boys and girls (including mother and older sister), are all depicted in an appealing manner, and I think it's wonderful as a single drama. Friendship is nice. Love is good, isn't it? Every day sparkles and reminds me of the nostalgic feeling of youth. This is the best work that carefully delves into the feelings of a schoolboy who suffers from gays and his classmates who have learned their secrets. It's too deep and requires energy to reread it, so I want to wait for a while and then reread it. I want to read more soon! I was too worried about future developments...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

大好き

really like

なんだろうなー。ほんとに大好きな話。どのキャラにも愛着がわく。続きがみたい早く続きがみたい

I wonder what it is. I really love this story. I'm attached to every character. I want to continue it seems like it will continue soon

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

青春です。

It's youth.

純粋でとてもリアルがある様に思います。人間なんだから色々な葛藤があって当然だし改めてLGPを考えさせられます。とってもいい漫画だと思います。続きが楽しみです。

I think it's pure and very real. Since we are human, it is natural that there are various conflicts, and it makes me think about LGP again. I think it's a very good comic. I'm looking forward to the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

良き

good

まず作者さんの絵が好きです。ゆるく流れる時間だけど、その中にいろんな人たちのあらゆる感情が交差して悩みながら過ごしている物語。BLなんだけど、青春群像劇って感じ。もしかしたら、自分も学生の時知らなかっただけでこういう葛藤を抱えてた友だちがいたのかなぁと勝手に想像してしまいました。個人的には好きな人は男女関係ないと思っているので気にしなくてもいいのにって思うんですけど、世の中そう簡単ではないんだなぁと思わされる作品でした。読んでて切ない気持ちになるので、結末はみんながハッピーになれば良いなぁと。

First of all, I like the artist's paintings. It's a story where time flows slowly, but all the emotions of various people intersect in it and they spend time worrying. It's BL, but it feels like a youth group drama. I just imagined that maybe I had a friend who had this kind of conflict just because I didn't know it when I was a student. Personally, I don't think people I like are male or female, so I don't need to worry about it, but it was a work that made me think that the world isn't that easy. It makes me feel sad when I read it, so I hope everyone is happy with the ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

泣いた

wept

もう、泣きました！自分がこの中の一員になってかわりに1人殴りたいくらい、入りこみました。いい話に出会えて幸せです！

I've already cried! I wanted to be part of it and hit 1 person instead, so I went in. I'm happy to have found a good story!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

色んなセクシュアリティの青春物語

A youth story of various sexualities

This review contains spoilers. ただ、泣ける。BLとゆーより、こんな友人関係に憧れます。まだ、誰もちゃんと恋愛してなくて、でも、片思いや、好きだと思って付き合ったけどうまくいかなかったり、、、青春時代の拙い恋と友情物語です。クラスメイトでゲイの子が居ると気づいてしまったけど、ひょんなキッカケで話す様になったら、良い奴で、健気で、幸せを願わずには居られない。バレてる友達も、バレてない友達も、彼を好きだから、守りながら青春してる。３巻が本当に待ち遠しい！！！誰かが恋に落ちるのかな？！

This review contains spoilers. It just makes me cry. More than BL and Yu, I admire this kind of friendship. It's a story of poor love and friendship from the youth, where no one is in a proper relationship yet, but they have unrequited love, or go out with each other because they think they like each other, but things don't go well... I've noticed that some of my classmates are gay, but when they start talking by accident, I can't help but hope for happiness, he's a good guy, healthy, and happy. Both my friend who got caught and my friend who didn't find out like him, so I'm protecting him while protecting him. I really can't wait for volume 3!!! I wonder if anyone will fall in love?!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが読みたい！

I want to read more!

This review contains spoilers. のみしばを読んでとても好きになった作家さんです。他の方のレビューにもありましたが本当にいいです。まだ恋愛モードではないですが、BLを超えて物語として十二分に楽しめます。ただただ付き合って・・・というのも好きですが、恋愛ってこういう悩みとか葛藤があるよねとか思い出しながら（笑）一気に読みました。のみしばとは違った視点での男子校生の友情や恋模様、これからも楽しみにしてます。青春いいね。

This review contains spoilers. This is an author I fell in love with after reading Mishiba. It was also in other people's reviews, and it's really nice. It's not in romance mode yet, but you can fully enjoy it as a story beyond BL. I also like just hanging out... but I read it all at once while remembering that romance has these kinds of worries and conflicts (laughs). I'm looking forward to the friendships and love patterns of male school students from a different point of view from Mishiba. Youth is good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

青春最高

Youth is the best

This review contains spoilers. めちゃ良かった！ボリュームも凄いし皆んないい子。土井以外！続き読みたい！

This review contains spoilers. That was really good! The volume is amazing and they're all nice kids. Other than Doi! I want to keep reading!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

読んで！

read it!

読んでない人は読んで欲しい。完結するまで待とうと思ったけど半額だったので手を出してしまった。もう、人の心の動きが丁寧に描かれていて、出てくる人達の気持ちに寄り添って改めて自分の考えとか感じ方とか、もー色々考えちゃう。考えたり想像したり読むのが好きな人にはお勧めです。

I want people who haven't read it to read it. I thought I'd wait until it was finished, but since it was half price, I got my hands on it. The movements of people's minds have already been carefully drawn, and I'm close to the feelings of the people that come up and think about my own thoughts and feelings again. I recommend it to anyone who likes to think, imagine, and read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 08, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

いいです！

That's good!

切ない話ながら、格好いいキャラクターがたくさん出てきて、とてもいい話だと思います。続きが待てない！

While it's a sad story, a lot of cool characters have appeared, and I think it's a very nice story. I can't wait for the next one!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

最高すぎる！

It's too awesome!

出てくる登場人物がみんな魅力的。一括りにBLな物語じゃなく人の繋がりとか人間くささが感じれるストーリー。綺麗事だけですませたりしないとこも面白い！続きが早く読みたいーー！最高です！

All of the characters that appear are fascinating. It's not a BL story all at once; it's a story where you can feel the connection and humanity between people. It's also interesting that you don't just do things that are pretty! I want to read the rest soon! It's awesome!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 16, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

人間関係が素敵！

The relationships are wonderful!

とても読み応えがあるお話です。男の友情っていいな〜と思いました。3巻も待ち遠しいです！きれいな形で終わってほしい！

It's a very readable story. I thought it would be nice to have a man's friendship. I can't wait for volume 3! I want it to end up in a beautiful way!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 16, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

マイノリティを真剣に描いた作品

A work that seriously depicts minorities

「のみしば」がとても良かったので作者買いです。セリフの長さや画に若干の荒削り感があるのは否めないんですが、めちゃくちゃ真摯な姿勢でマイノリティを描いた良作だと思います。泣きました・・・

“Mishiba” was very good, so I bought it from the author. There is no denying the length of the lines and the slight roughness in the pictures, but I think it's a good work depicting minorities with an insanely sincere attitude. I cried...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

最高です。

It's the best.

This review contains spoilers. この作品、めちゃくちゃ大好きな作品です。レビュー評価が高く、絵柄きれいで購入しました。結果、最高でした。エロはありません。が、身近にゲイの男の子がいて自分の友人を好きだったら……というストーリー。本当に丁寧に描かれ続きが気になる素敵な、作品だと思います。

This review contains spoilers. I really love this work. I bought it because the reviews were high and the design was beautiful. The results were great. There is no eroticism. But it's a story about if there's a gay boy close to you and you like your friend... I think it's a wonderful work that has been drawn really carefully and I'm worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Reviews for Koimonogatari Manga