Koimonogatari Manga Reviews (P.15)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 04, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ゆっくり

slowly

ゆっくりなペースで進んでます。ちょっとゲイに対するいじめ？が2巻で出てくるのでご注意を。

It's progressing at a slow pace. A bit of gay bullying? Please note that it will come out in 2 volumes.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 04, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

青春。すごくいい。

youth. It's really nice.

絵津鼓さんとか好きな方にはハマるかも…？ものすごく、青春です。恋したり、友情を育んだり、悩んだり…。等身大で、美しい。素直に良い子達ばかりで泣ける。どんな形であれ、全力で幸せを願ってしまう、そんな美しいお話です。あとはみんなとにかく育ちが良さそう（笑）。次巻でようやく進展？するようですが、なんかもうオトナな描写が一切無くてもきっと満足してしまうんだろうなあ。そんなBLです。

Maybe you'll be addicted to Ezuko or someone you like...? It's so young. Falling in love, developing friendships, worrying... Life-sized and beautiful. Honestly, there are only good kids and it makes me cry. It's such a beautiful story that makes you wish for happiness with all your might, no matter what form it takes. After that, everyone seemed to be growing up well anyway (laughs). Will progress finally be made in the next volume? It seems, but I'm sure they'll be satisfied even if there aren't any adult depictions at all. That's BL.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 03, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

これはやばい

this is terrible

かなりはまりました。一言で言えばBLだけど、BLっぽくない、かなり深い話、でもぐいぐい入りこめる、そんな読みやすさありの考えさせられる作品でした。エロが好きな方には物足りないでしょうね。これからの進展が楽しみであり、どんなエロが待ってるのかすごく楽しみです。

I'm pretty addicted to it. In a nutshell, it's BL, but it wasn't like BL, it was a pretty deep story, but it was a thought provoking work that was so easy to read. It's probably not enough for those who like erotica. I'm looking forward to future developments, and I'm really excited to see what kind of eroticism awaits.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 03, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

すごくいい

Very good

投稿せずにはいられなかった。私的にはとても良かったです。同性愛の現実ってこういう感じなのかなと思ってしまいました。エロはないけど、とても引き込まれて感情移入してしまいました。早く続き読みたいです。

I couldn't help but post it. Personally, it was very good. It made me wonder if the reality of homosexuality is like this. It wasn't erotic, but I was so drawn in and empathized with it. I want to continue reading soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 02, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

BLではありますが、友情中心の純文学⁈

It's BL, but pure literature centered on friendship

青春にはこんな事あるんだろうな、と感じられる素晴らしい作品です。BL的なシーンはほとんどありませんが、内容重視の方にはオススメです。続きが気になります。

It's a wonderful work that makes me feel like this happens in youth. There are almost no BL scenes, but it is recommended for those who focus on content. I'm worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 02, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

きっとこれがリアル

I'm sure this is real

This review contains spoilers. BLってリアルなようでファンタジーだなと思うけどこの作品は妙にリアル。同性愛に苦しむ子、その友達、同性愛をカミングアウトする子、無意識で相手を傷つける子、同性愛者を嫌悪する子･･･最後の方で笑いながら自分はホモじゃないと言う姿がすごく辛かった。でもきっとそれがリアル。自分も実際同性愛者に会ったら普通でいられる自信が無い。わかっていても差別的になってしまうかもしれない。この話を読んでハッとしたのが正直な気持ち。物語はゆっくり進み、終わったあとはえっ？！？！となるので物凄くイライラする人もいるかもしれません。私がそうです(笑)続き早く読みたいなぁ。

This review contains spoilers. BL seems real and I think it's fantasy, but this work is strangely real. A child suffering from homosexuality, their friends, a child coming out of homosexuality, a child who unknowingly hurts their partner, a child who hates homosexuals... it was very painful to see them laughing towards the end and saying that they are not homosexuals. But I'm sure that's real. I also don't have confidence that I can be normal if I actually meet homosexuals. Even if you know it, it might turn out to be discriminatory. To be honest, I was surprised to read this story. The story progresses slowly, and after it's over, huh?!?! There may be people who are terribly frustrated because of that. That's me (laughs) I want to continue reading soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 01, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

あー！

ahhh!

もー気になる！すごくいいです！ただただ夢中になって読んで…感情移入して、泣いて…続きを早くください！先生！！ドラマのような…現実のような…素敵なストーリーです。絵もめっちゃ好きです！個人的に、どのジャンルの方にもオススメです！

I'm curious too! It's really nice! Just get carried away and read it... empathize, cry... please continue quickly! teacher!! It's a drama... like reality... it's a wonderful story. I really like the pictures too! Personally, I recommend it to people of all genres!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ストーリーがいい！

Nice story!

BLですが、多感な時期、ぐるぐると考えてしまう登場人物たちを見てそんな時もあったなぁと思い出しました?青春✨これからどう進んでいくのか3巻が楽しみです～

It's BL, but it was a sensitive period, and when I saw characters that made me think round and round, did you remember that there were times like that too? Seishun ✨ I'm looking forward to volume 3 to see how it progresses from now on ~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 27, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

細やかな心理描写が素晴らしいです。

The detailed psychological depiction is wonderful.

This review contains spoilers. ゲイがマイノリティな性癖という前提で、それに葛藤する大和とそれを支える周囲の人たち。ゲイをすぐ受け入れてハッピーエンド！なんてそんなの現実では難しいし、それよりも嫌悪され迫害される事の方が多い。それでも支えようとするみんなと抗う姿がとても丁寧に描写されていると思います。語りすぎというレビューも見かけますが、単純に結ばれてはい！ハッピーエンド！！がマイノリティの世界で簡単に訪れるわけがないことを分かってるのかな？と素朴な疑問を持ちました。この作者さんは細やかな描写をされるので、そんな単純な作品が読みたいのなら合わないとは思います。私はこの作品がとても好きですし、BLとして一番オススメする作品の1つです。欲を言えば、もっとはやく作品更新をしてほしいです…！続きが出るのをとても、とても待ってました！！

This review contains spoilers. On the premise that homosexuality is a minority sexual habit, Yamato struggles with it, and the people around him who support it. Accept gays right away and have a happy ending! That is difficult in reality, and people are more often disliked and persecuted than that. Nevertheless, I think everyone trying to support them and their resistance is depicted very carefully. There are also reviews that say they talk too much, but they are simply tied together yes! happy ending!! Do you know that there's no easy way to visit in the minority world? I had a simple question. This author is described in detail, so if you want to read such a simple work, I don't think it's right for you. I really like this work, and it's one of my most recommended BL works. Speaking of greed, I want them to update their work sooner...! I've been waiting very, very long for the next one to come out!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 27, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

映画みたいです

It's like a movie

先生ありがとうございます。初めて作者に手紙を出そうと思いました。。文字多くていい。本当に読んで良かったです。

Thank you very much, teacher. I thought I'd write a letter to the author for the first time.. A lot of characters is fine. I'm really glad I read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 26, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

それぞれの葛藤

Each conflict

待ち通しかった２巻がついに！今後の展開が楽しみ！！二人がどうなるのか。このままの関係で終わるのか色々妄想してしまう(笑)次巻で完結とのことなのでどうまとめるのか楽しみ?

The 2 volumes I've been waiting for are finally here! I'm looking forward to future developments! What will happen to the two of them? I have a lot of delusions about whether it will end with this relationship (laughs) it's going to be completed in the next volume, so I'm looking forward to seeing how it will be put together?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 25, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

2巻とも読みました。まだ恋愛要素はほぼ皆無だけど2人の距離が徐々に近付いていくのがほっこりしました。2巻は事件が起きて心が痛かったけど唯司が男前で大和がだんだん強くかっこよくなっていくのが良かったです。2人の周りには素敵な人が多くて安心です。やっぱりこのお話大好きです！早く3巻が読みたいです。

I read both volumes. There is still almost no romance element, but I was relieved to see the distance between the two gradually getting closer. I was heartbroken when the incident happened in volume 2, but it was nice that Yuiji was handsome and Yamato gradually became stronger and cooler. There are so many wonderful people around them, so it's reassuring. After all, I love this story! I want to read volume 3 soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 25, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

良い‼️

good ‼️

認める認めない、周りの人たち…同性愛の当事者、その友達、知人、親…悩むよね…

The people around you who acknowledge and disapprove... homosexual partners, their friends, acquaintances, parents... are troubled...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 24, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

完結していない続き物…3巻が待ち遠しい

The unfinished continuation... I can't wait for volume 3

ゲイであることの苦悩とゲイに対して周りがどのように反応するかが描かれています。心理描写が巧みで共感するので「ありえそう」と感じられる説得力があります。2巻の時点で受け攻めが確定していないどころか誰と誰がカップルになるかもほのめかし程度ではっきりとは分かりませんが、友情の延長でハグしたり頰にキスする数少ないBL要素には萌えます。個人的にはキャラに萌えるので大丈夫ですが、そうでないなら物足りないと思います。ストーリーは丁寧に展開していき見せ方もうまいので飽きません。

It depicts the pain of being gay and how people around you react to being gay. The psychological depiction is clever and I sympathize with it, so it has persuasive power that makes you feel “possible.” Far from being confirmed as of volume 2, I don't clearly understand who and who will become a couple at the level of insinuation, but I'm fascinated by the few BL elements where people hug and kiss each other as an extension of friendship. Personally, I love the characters, so it's fine, but if that's not the case, I don't think it's enough. The story is carefully developed, and the way it is shown is so good that I never get tired of it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 24, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

終わらなかった~‼️

It wasn't finished~ ‼️

だいぶ経ってからの２巻でしたので、終わるか⁉️と思っていたら終わりませんでしたー！ラムネのシャララ以来注目していた作家さんです。本作はゲイばれしてからの周りの反応が現実味を帯びて、かなり切ない雰囲気。もう、誰と誰がくっ付くかとか攻め受けどうなるかとか関係無く、幸せになって欲しいと本当に思います。

It was volume 2 after a long time, so when I was wondering if it would end ⁉️, it wasn't over! It's an artist I've been watching since Ramune's Sharara. In this film, the reactions of those around you after becoming gay are realistic, and the atmosphere is pretty sad. I really want them to be happy no longer, regardless of who sticks with who or what happens when attacked.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 23, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

やっと続きが読めた～！！

I was finally able to read the continuation!!

もうだいぶ忘れかけてましたよ～青春フワフワ～キュンキュンな話ではありません！しっかりとしたリアルなお話。実際にそういったマイノリティな類いの悩みを持ってたら…と心がジリジリしてくる内容です。今回大きな事件が起きるけど、なんとか解決。唯司の言うように、大和の人柄からきてるのだろうけど、周りの子達も凄く良い子だなってさらに実感。特に唯司が本領発揮してきましたね！本当にDKかと疑いたくなる達観さ。3巻、ついにラブモード突入でしょうか！次は唯司の番って言うから、この真面目な子達ならそう簡単にはハッピーとはいかないでしょうが。ましてやノンケなわけですし。一回り二回りとさらに成長していくのだろうと思うと次が楽しみです。何年も待とうと思います～

I've already forgotten quite a bit ~ Seishun Fluffy ~ It's not a funny story! A solid, realistic story. The content makes my heart flinch and wonder if they actually have that kind of minority problem... A major incident happened this time, but somehow it was solved. As Yuiji says, it probably comes from Yamato's personality, but I realized even more that the kids around me are also really good kids. Yuiji, in particular, has shown his true form! It's an expert opinion that makes me wonder if it's really DK. Will volume 3 finally enter love mode! They say it's Yuiji's turn next, so it's probably not that easy for these serious kids to be happy. What's more, it's nonsense. I'm looking forward to the next one when I think that it will grow further once or twice. I think I'll wait for years~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 23, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

待ってました！！！

I've been waiting!!!

2巻がなかなかでなくて、ここ数年長かった…(;_;)！！忘れかけたころに新刊通知！！嬉しすぎて興奮気味に1巻見返していざ2巻を見たら、涙涙涙！！！こんなに涙出るとは思わなかった…！！！大和の周りのみんなが良い奴で、ほんとよかった(;_;)あ、土井くんはあれですが…。(土井くんも何か訳があるのかな…?それともただの嫌な奴なのか?)また3巻が出るまで、頑張って耐えようと思います！！3巻楽しみに待ってます！！！！！！！

Volume 2 wasn't easy, and it's been a long time for the past few years... (; _;)! Just when I almost forgot it, I was notified of the new publication!! I was so happy that I looked back at volume 1 feeling excited, and when I saw volume 2, tears, tears!! I never thought I'd burst into so many tears...!! Everyone around Yamato is a nice guy, and I'm really glad (; _;) Ah, Doi-kun is like that... (I wonder if Doi-kun also has any translation...? or is he just a bad guy?) I'm going to do my best and endure until volume 3 comes out again!! I'm looking forward to volume 3!!!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 23, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

！

!

すごい良かった！！続きが気になる！ストーリーもいいし、現実みがあって面白い！

That was really good!! I'm worried about the continuation! The story is good, and it's realistic and interesting!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 23, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ホントにホントに、お待ちしておりました?

really, really, have you been waiting for it?

This review contains spoilers. 1巻から３年…。2巻発売予定の書影を見て、もう、嬉しくて即買いです?高校生ゲイ大和と唯司。《１巻》偶然、大和がゲイであり、自分の友人を好きなことを知る唯司。友人に対する気持ちへの嫌悪感はあるものの、ゲイであることへの偏見はなく、理解し受け入れてくれる唯司。大和にとって、ゲイであることを知る唯一の同性の友人として、とても良い友人関係が構築されていく様が描かれています。《2巻》大和にとって、とても苦しく、考えさせられる2巻でした。普通に過ごす日常の中で、突然向けられた悪意あふれる現実問題。ホントに、胸糞の悪い出来事でしたが、これがリアルなのかな。と感じました。ゲイであるということを、唯司達のように受け入れてくれる人もいる。でも、そうじゃない人が大半であろうマイノリティであるということ。突きつけられた現実問題に打ちのめされるも、大和は一人ではなかった。彼の側に、唯司がいて良かった。彼の人となりを信じ側にいてくれる人達がいて良かった。この出来事を通して、大和の心の成長を感じると共に、唯司への心境の変化が見られました。そして、又、気になるところでの続き…?そして、SNSでの休載のお知らせ…3巻の発売はいつになることやら?早く、わたしの望んでいる結末が見たいところです?

This review contains spoilers. 3 years since volume 1... Looking at the calligraphy that is scheduled to be released in volume 2, are you already happy and bought it right away? High school gay Yamato and Yuji. “Volume 1” Coincidentally, Yamato is gay, and Yuji learns that he likes his friend. Although there is disgust for feelings towards friends, there is no prejudice against being gay, and Yuiji understands and accepts. It depicts how a very good friendship relationship is built for Yamato as the only friend of the same sex who knows that they are gay. “Volume 2” was a very painful and thought-provoking volume 2 for Yamato. A real problem full of malice that is suddenly directed at us in our everyday lives. Really, it was a horrible incident, but I wonder if this is real. I felt it. There are also people who accept that they are gay, just like Yuji and the others. But that's probably the majority of people who aren't in the minority. Yamato was not alone, even though he was overcome by the real problems he faced. It was good to have Yuiji by his side. I'm glad there are people who believe in his personality and are on his side. Through this event, I felt the growth of Yamato's heart, and I saw a change in my state of mind about Yuji. And again, continuation where I'm worried...? Also, the announcement of the suspension of use on SNS... I wonder when volume 3 will be released? Would you like to see the ending I want soon?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 18, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

^ ^

^ ^

1巻ではあまり進展はないものそれぞれの感情と悩みがわかりやすくて話は好きでした(*ﾟ∀ﾟ*)次巻とても期待です！おすすめです♪

There wasn't much progress in volume 1, but I liked the story because it was easy to understand each emotion and worry (**) I'm really looking forward to the next volume! I recommend it ♪

Helpful

Reviews for Koimonogatari Manga