Koimonogatari Manga Reviews (P.14)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 24, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

BLとして楽しんではいません。

I'm not enjoying it as a BL.

少女漫画かと思う雰囲気の画面の中に、驚く程しっかりと描かれた、同性愛に対する社会問題。真摯な繋がりと、残酷さと、高校生という、若いけど若過ぎない世代を題材にして描かれる世界が、とても良いです。2巻まで読んでて、これはBLでは無いよな、と思いますが、先がとても気になります。BLとしては今のところ読んでませんが、BL的なキラキラがあってくれても良いのよ？？？

Social issues against homosexuality are depicted surprisingly clearly on a screen that feels like a girls' comic. The world depicted on the subject of sincere connections, cruelty, and high school students, the young but not too young generation, is very good. I've read up to 2 volumes, and I don't think this is BL, but I'm really worried about the future. I haven't read it as BL so far, but it's okay if it has BL-like sparkles???

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 23, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

かわいい

cute

最高にピュアでセンテンスで、ゆっくりゆっくり「まだこいにならないのかー！」って楽しんでおります。かわいい。本当に素敵なお話をありがとうございます。次巻が楽しみです！

With the purest and most intense sentences, slowly and slowly, “Aren't you still here!” I'm enjoying it. cute. Thank you so much for your wonderful story. I'm looking forward to the next volume!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 21, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

学生特有の世界観

Students' unique worldview

まだ完結していないのですが、とにかく先が読みたい作品です。学生の世界だからこそ感じるジレンマや不安など、共感できることばかりです。絶対、読んでほしい作品です。

I haven't finished it yet, but it's a work I'd like to read ahead anyway. There are only things I can sympathize with, such as the dilemmas and insecurities that can only be felt in the student world. Definitely a work I want you to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 10, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

いい意味で裏切ってくれた！

You betrayed me in a good way!

絵柄からほんわかした感じなのかと思ってたけど、心情を丁寧に描いていて、読み応えがあって、なりより、主要な登場人物、1人、1人が魅力的。愛しさがあふれてくる。高校生っていう時期をせつなさや苦しさも含めてこんなに特別に感じさせてくれていいなぁって思う作品。

I was wondering if it was warm and fuzzy from the pattern, but the emotions are carefully drawn, the reading is easy to read, and rather, the main characters, one by one, are fascinating. Loving is overflowing. I think it would be nice if this work made me feel so special, including the hassle and suffering of high school.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 07, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

真剣に向き合ってます

I'm taking it seriously

吉永くんも長谷川くんも、真面目に向き合ってて、とても好感持てます。周りは、いい人ばかりじゃないけど、見守ってくれる人もたくさんいて、話の続きが気になります。

Both Yoshinaga-kun and Hasegawa-kun are serious, and I really like them. There aren't all nice people around me, but there are also a lot of people watching over me, so I'm worried about the continuation of the story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

空気感が好き

I like the feeling of air

少女漫画の方で田倉先生を知り、絵柄や空気感がすごく好みだったので購入してみました。(2巻まで)田倉先生の描く高校生は、男同士でいると子供っぽいところもあるのに、考えてることはちゃんと考えてて、悩んだり、葛藤したり、そういうのがすごく自然に描かれているのが好きです。ＢＬというよりは男同士の友情とか人間関係とかが主なので、ストーリー重視の方におすすめ。今後どうなるか、楽しみです！

I got to know Takura-sensei from the girls' manga, and I really liked the design and feel, so I bought one. (Up to volume 2) I like the fact that Takura-sensei's high school students are depicted very naturally, thinking properly about what they are thinking, worrying, and conflicting, even though there are places where they are childish when they are with each other. Friendships and relationships between men are the main ones rather than BL, so I recommend it for those who focus on the story. I'm excited to see what happens next!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 29, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

こいものがたり(２)レビュー

Koi Monogatari (2) review

This review contains spoilers. この漫画を青春と一言で表現するのはお粗末と感じるほどグッときました。内容は、あらすじにもありますが、長谷川唯司が同級生の吉永大和がゲイであることに戸惑いつつ徐々に親睦を深めていく中で、予備校で大和が出会った佐倉彰人は従兄弟にゲイであることがバレ、その従兄弟が無神経に周囲の人へ彰人がゲイであることをカミングアウトし、佐倉彰人の日常が崩れていくさまを見て彰人の従兄弟は腹がよじれるほど笑い転げている。その佐倉彰人を助けようとする大和だが、その佐倉彰人との交流が他に漏れて今度は吉永大和の日常を壊そうとほくそ笑むやつが現れる。いじめを題材にしている漫画は世に多くあるが、ほとんどの作品は≪いじめの原因≫と≪いじめられるという行為・・・無視・暴言・陰口・暴力など≫をクローズアップしていて、いじめの解決までを丁寧に描かない。それは、作者自身がいじめ被害者で自分のつらい経験を吐露しているだけの場合と、作者のサディスティックな内面を表現したい場合が殆どで、その場合、どうやって解決するかは問題ではなく、むしろ解決すると物語が終わってしまうので、どうやったら長引かせられるかに焦点があてられていてむしろ害悪。それが、この作品を見ると、真似できるかはケースバイケースですが、短いページの中で、いかに目の前の人を助けるかということを考えさせられる素晴らしい作品だと私は思いました。

This review contains spoilers. I was so surprised that I felt that it was lousy to describe this comic with youth in one word. The content is also in the synopsis, but as Yuiji Hasegawa is puzzled by the fact that his classmate Yoshinaga Yamato is gay, Sakura Akito, whom Yamato met at the prep school, says that his cousin is gay, and his cousin insensitively comes out that Akito is gay to people around him, and Akito's cousin laughs so much that his stomach twists when they see how Sakura Akito's everyday life falls apart. Yamato is trying to help Sakura Akito, but his interaction with Sakura Akito leaks out to others, and now someone who smiles smiles in an attempt to destroy Yamato Yoshinaga's everyday life appears. There are many comics on the subject of bullying in the world, but most of the works are close-ups of “the cause of bullying” and “the act of being bullied... ignorance, rants, backtalk, violence, etc.” and do not carefully depict the resolution of bullying. There are almost always cases where the author himself is a victim of bullying and only expresses his own painful experiences, and in most cases, when he wants to express the author's sadistic inner world, and in that case, how to solve it is not a problem; rather, the story ends when solved, so the focus is on how to prolong it, which is rather harmful. When I looked at this work, I thought it was a wonderful work that made me think about how to help the person in front of me in a short page, although it is on a case-by-case basis whether it can be imitated.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 29, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

雰囲気が良い

The atmosphere is good

blを読み慣れてしまってるのでエロなかったのが残念ですが、脇キャラ含め主人公の周りにいる人たちの雰囲気が良し。お話もとてもおもしろくて買って損はない作品です。続きが待ち遠しい…

I'm used to reading BL, so it's a pity that it wasn't erotic, but the atmosphere of the people around the main character, including the side characters, is good. The story is also very interesting, and there is no harm in buying it. I can't wait for the continuation...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 14, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が好きです。

I like the picture.

男子高校生って実際の会話とかこんな感じなのかなと思いながら読みました。BLの要素はまだ少ないですが、これから何か起きそうな予感をにおわせている感じで続きぐ気になります。

I read it while wondering if male high school students have actual conversations or something like this. There are still few BL elements, but I feel like it will continue with the feeling that something is about to happen.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 14, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

早く続きが見たい

I want to see the continuation soon

大和の周りで築かれている繋がりが、少しずつ明らかになっていく中で、唯司のポジションが初めからすごくドキドキさせられる。大和だけじゃなく、唯司自身の葛藤の行方も気になって仕方ない。シビアな問題が現実的なシーンで描かれているけど、優しくて静かな強い繋がりを読んでいてジーンとした

As the connections that have been built around Yamato gradually become clear, Yuiji's position is very exciting from the beginning. I can't help but worry not only about Yamato, but also about the whereabouts of Yuiji's own conflict. Serious problems are depicted in realistic scenes, but I read Strong Ties, who are kind and quiet, and it made me feel like Gene

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 14, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

表現が素晴らしい

The expression is wonderful

思春期の友情や悩みがよく伝わってくる作品です。起承転結が上手く組まれてて、読みいってしまいました。

It is a work that often conveys the friendships and worries of adolescence. The beginning, beginning, and end were put together so well that I finished reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 12, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

リアリティ

reality

主人公が自分の性癖に悩みながらも、理解ある友達に支えられ、でも親友には大切であるからこそ、性癖を告白できずにいる。ストーリーの進みはとても遅いけれども、それがかえってリアルな感じで好感がもてます。オススメです。

While the main character is struggling with his own sexual habits, he is supported by understanding friends, but he is unable to confess his sexual habits precisely because he is important to his best friend. The story progresses very slowly, but it feels rather real and I like it. I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

いいわー♡

That's great ♡

自分が高校生の頃って恋愛についてこんなに真剣に悩むなんて事あったかな？と凄い考えさせられました｡もっと友達とかも大事にしとくべきだったのでは？とかいろいろと反省点が…｡苛める方も苛められる方も問題が有ると思ってたけどそうじゃない場合もあるのね｡土居君のグズっぷり半端無いわ｡重森君みたいな子１人いると雰囲気全然変わってくるのわかるわ｡私的にはもぉ吉永君と唯司君がくっついて幸せになってほしいです｡素晴らしい作品だと思います｡続きは3年も待たずに出てほしいです｡おばあさんになってしまいます(笑)

When I was in high school, was there ever a time when I was in high school that I seriously worried about romance? It really made me think. Shouldn't I have taken more care of my friends? There are a lot of points to reflect on... I think there are problems with those who annoy and those who are being harassed, but there are also cases where that isn't the case. I know that when there is one child like Shigemori-kun, the atmosphere completely changes. Personally, I want Yoshinaga-kun and Yuiji to stick together and be happy. I think it's a great work. I want the rest to come out without waiting 3 years. I think it's a great work. I want the rest to come out without waiting 3 years. I'm going to become an old woman (laughs)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

すごい心にズンとくる

It really comes to my heart

それぞれの心理描写がすごい刺さる。楽しいし、辛いし、超リアルなような、美しい話。初めて読んでどっぷりハマって、でも、１巻から２巻って出版までにそんなにかかってるの？！続き待つのつら。

Each psychological depiction is really stinging. A beautiful story that is fun, painful, and super realistic. I read it for the first time and was totally addicted to it, but did it take so long for volume 1 to 2 to be published?! It's hard to wait for more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ヤバイな、これは

this is dangerous

心理描写凄すぎる。男性女性を超えて、人生だわ。一巻しか読んでなくてエロも全く無いけど、二巻も買います。映画化されても良いぐらい、ストーリーが素晴らしい。それにしても、登場人物皆が穏やかで優しくて、世界はこうも優しいのか。あー、こんな人達に囲まれて悩めるなんて、羨ましい。

The psychological depiction is too amazing. Beyond men and women, it's life. I've only read one volume and there's no eroticism at all, but I'm buying two volumes. The story is so wonderful that it could be made into a movie. Even so, all the characters are calm and kind, and is the world so kind? Oh, I'm envious of being surrounded by people like this and being bothered.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 07, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻を心待ちにしてました〜

I've been looking forward to volume 2~

いつでるんだ？？と首を長ーくして待ってました！紙媒体で購入してます。2巻はとっても分厚くてウキウキ倍増！私の中では文乃ゆき先生のひだまり…と同じところにいます。3巻完結は寂しいですが、2巻は攻めの大和の巻、3巻は受けになっちゃうの？！唯司の巻になるらしいので、どんな風にくっつくのか…どんな風にクライマックスに持っていってくれるのか期待大！田倉トヲル先生の本では一番好きです。

when is it coming out?? I've been waiting for a long time! I bought it on paper. Volume 2 is so thick that it's twice as exciting! Inside me, I'm in the same place as Fumino Yuki sensei's Hidamari... It's sad to finish volume 3, but volume 2 is volume of attacking Yamato, and volume 3 is going to be taken?! It seems like it's going to be Yuji's volume, so I'm excited to see how they stick together... how they'll bring it to the climax! I like Toru Takura's book the most.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 07, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

高校生の頃が懐かしく感じる

I feel nostalgic about when I was in high school

高校生男子が、恋や友情について真剣に考えて葛藤しているストーリー。マイノリティである自分をどう受け止めるか？マイノリティの友達をどう受け止めるか？など、夫々が自分のアイデンティティを獲得するために一生懸命感じて、考えて、もがいているところが甘酸っぱく、心が熱くなります。大和がイケメンなだけじゃなく真面目でいいやつすぎて、相当ひねくれ者じゃなければ大好きで応援したくなる！！主人公との関係がもどかしいですが、今後の展開を楽しみにしています○

This is a story about a high school boy who seriously thinks about love and friendship and is in conflict. How do we accept ourselves as a minority? How do we treat our minority friends? It is sweet and sour, and the fact that they each work so hard to acquire their own identity is sweet and sour, and my heart is heated. Not only is Yamato a good-looking guy, he's also a serious and nice guy, and if he's not a pretty perverse person, I love him and want to support him!! My relationship with the main character is frustrating, but I'm looking forward to future development○

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 07, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

すごく良かったです

It was really good

This review contains spoilers. 一巻のみ読了の感想です。ストーリーがとても良い！エロなし、まだ恋愛にも発展してませんが、同性愛の葛藤とか、理解とか悩み友情などが詰まってます。ただ、文字が多くて絵付きの小説読んでるみたいです。BLコミックに求めてるものが足りない！読んでも読んでも進まない関係、コマ割りが細かく文字が多いので時間がかかり疲れる、萌えがない（かわいい子がいない）。自分は小説も読むので、その感覚でなら星5なんですが、BLコミックとしては楽しめてるか疑問なので星4かなー？？と思いつつ、評価下げるのも心苦しいので5にしてます。2巻はいまいち食指が動かないのでまだ購入予定無しです。

This review contains spoilers. This is my impression of only reading one volume. Very good story! There's no eroticism, and it hasn't developed into a romance yet, but it's filled with homosexual conflicts, understanding, trouble, friendship, etc. However, it's like reading a novel with lots of characters and pictures. What I'm looking for in BL comics is missing! Relationships that don't progress whether you read or not, the frame is detailed and there are many characters, so it takes time, it's exhausting, and there's no anger (there are no cute kids). I also read novels, so it's 5 stars for that feeling, but I'm wondering if I enjoy it as a BL comic, so I wonder if it's 4 stars?? While thinking about it, it's also painful to lower the rating, so I set it to 5. My index finger doesn't move much in volume 2, so I don't have any plans to buy it yet.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 06, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

めっちゃ好き

I really like it

2巻までもだいぶしんどかったけどわりと日常系だなぁきっとこれがリアルなんだなぁと思ってたのに、こっから更に踏み込んでしんどくなりそう……って2巻出るのに3年かかってるの！？続きはいつ出るの！？！？みたいな状態。嘘だろしんどいーすきー……っ

It was pretty tough until volume 2, but it's pretty everyday; I'm sure this is real, but it took 3 years for volume 2 to come out by going even further from here on out and it seems like it's going to be tough...!? When will the next one come out!?!? It's in a state like that. that's not true, it's tough, I like it... huh

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 04, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ツボです

It's a pressure point

This review contains spoilers. くどく感じる人がいるのもわかるのですが、わたしは好きです。正直待ってるのも忘れてたレベルでしたが続きが読めて嬉しいです。レビュー見て迷ったんですが、随分前に買った1巻を読み返したら買わずにはいられませんでした。主要キャラ女の子二人も含めみんな誠実でいい子なのですが、唯司の格好良さがたまらなくツボです。右左の解釈違いが苦手な自分でも全く気にならないお話ですが、吉永がタチだと断言してることに安心感はあります。笑他の友人とはまた違う大事な存在をそういう対象に見てしまった吉永の苦悩が今から楽しみです。3巻完結がさみしいような嬉しいような、まただいぶ待つことになるんだろうな…。

This review contains spoilers. I know there are people who feel bad, but I like it. Honestly, it was a level I had forgotten to wait for, but I'm happy to be able to read the continuation. I was at a loss when I saw the reviews, but when I reread the first volume I bought a long time ago, I couldn't help but buy it. Everyone, including the two main characters, is honest and nice, but Yuiji's good looks is irresistible. It's a story that doesn't bother me at all, even if I'm not good at misinterpretations between right and left, but there's a sense of security that Yoshinaga asserts that it's Tachi. lol I'm looking forward to the anguish of Yoshinaga, who saw an important person that was different from his other friends as such an object. I'm so sad and happy that volume 3 is completed, and I wonder if I'll have to wait a long time again...

Helpful

Reviews for Koimonogatari Manga