23:45 Manga Reviews (P.7)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 01, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

２巻切ない

Volume 2 is too short

This review contains spoilers. 一巻のラストですでに付き合ってる2人がちょこっとあったのですが　その間のお話が2巻で出てます　みかんでも切なくて　ジーンとしちゃいました　最後　ハッピーエンドで本当に良かった

This review contains spoilers. There were a little bit of 2 people who were already dating at the end of volume 1, but the story between them came out in volume 2, and I was sad even tangerines and ended up with Gene. I'm really glad it had a happy ending at the end

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 09, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

◎

◎

微妙だという口コミもあって迷ったけど、読んで良かったです。キレイな絵と、繊細な心理描写。エロ全面に出した作品が好みな人には向かないと思うけど、そこに重点置いてない方は楽しめるかなと思います。

There were also reviews that said it was subtle, so I was at a loss, but I'm glad I read it. Beautiful pictures and delicate psychological depictions. I don't think it's suitable for people who like works that show full eroticism, but I think those who don't focus on that can enjoy it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

1巻の終わりの時系列が

The time series at the end of volume 1

This review contains spoilers. 全体的に良かったのですが何度読んでも1巻の最後の時系列だけがわかんない。霊体じゃなくなって付き合ってない時の話よね？2巻では付き合うまでに行き来してるかんじではなかったのであれはどこの時系列だろうとモヤモヤ。読み逃しかな。それとも1巻発売時点では続編の予定がなかったので1巻で完結て感じでかいたものだったのかなー？

This review contains spoilers. Overall, it was good, but no matter how many times I read it, I didn't understand only the time series at the end of volume 1. It's a story about when they're no longer spiritual bodies and aren't dating, right? In volume 2, I didn't feel like I was going back and forth until we started dating, so I was confused about where the time series was. I probably missed reading it. Or were there no plans for a sequel when volume 1 was released, so I wonder if it was something that was amazing when it was completed in volume 1?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

せっつな！

I'm so busy!

This review contains spoilers. 新しいBL。幽霊系は読んだ事ありますが。。こんな切ないパターンは初めて。一巻終わってRe:でさらに切なくなった。ケド！最後はちゃんと幸せになてよかった〜。途中ちょっとキャラの気持ちに熱入りすぎてわかりづらかったところがちょいちょいあって。。そんな詩人みたいな人いるかな〜って思ってしまって感情移入がしづらかったかな。。でも嫌いじゃないです！切ない作品！好き〜٩( ᐛ )و

This review contains spoilers. The new BL. I've read about ghosts... This is the first time I've seen such a sad pattern. I was even saddened by Re: when I finished volume one. Ked! I'm glad I was really happy at the end. There were a few things along the way that were a little bit too enthusiastic about the characters' feelings and it was hard to understand... I wonder if there are people like such poets, and it was hard for me to empathize... But I don't hate it! A sad work! I like it~()

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

良かったです

That was great

This review contains spoilers. 作者さんの元ネタとしては幽霊のほうだったのか。生霊のほうがハピエンあるし王道だと思いましたが、２巻では記憶がなくて最終的にも完全に思い出せてない？感じで、全体的になんだか切ない雰囲気が最後まで漂ってたなー。テーマがテーマなだけに、明るいハピエンではなかったので、しんみりしちゃった。

This review contains spoilers. Was the author's original story about ghosts? I thought Ghosts were happy and the royal road, but I don't have any memory in volume 2, so I can't fully remember it even in the end? It felt like, the overall atmosphere was somewhat sad until the end. Just because the theme was a theme, it wasn't a bright happy person, so I felt relaxed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 21, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いんだけど…

It's interesting, but...

すみません…。多分私の理解力不足です。話の流れが分かりづらいところが度々あり、その都度何度か戻って繰り返し読んだり…だんだん疲れてきて途中眠くなったりを繰り返してしまいました。理解すると内容は面白いので読めましたが、キュンキュンできる場面であるはずが、内容確認の作業が多くてもったいなかったように思います。多分理解してから繰り返し読むことで面白く読めると思います。内容と設定はとても面白いので、入っていけるまで何度も読んでみようと思います。

sorry... Maybe my comprehension is lacking. There were many places where it was difficult to understand the flow of the story, and each time I went back several times and read it over and over again... I gradually got tired and fell sleepy along the way. Once I understood it, the content was interesting, so I was able to read it, but I think it was a waste because there was a lot of work to check the content. I think you can probably enjoy reading it by reading it over and over again after understanding it. The content and settings are very interesting, so I think I'll read it over and over until I get in.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

かわいい

cute

This review contains spoilers. 育が女の子より可愛いです。内容はなかなかじれったいのが長かったので、私的には2巻のほうが面白かったですw

This review contains spoilers. Ikugi is cuter than girls. The content was quite confusing for a long time, so personally volume 2 was more interesting lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 05, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

萌える！

I'm furious!

甘い！とにかくかわいい！すれ違いもだけど、お互いの本音が言えない。キュンキュンします！ずっと気になってた話だけど、買ってよかった。

sweet! It's just so cute! We have passed each other, but we can't say our true intentions. I'm going to cringe! It's a story I've always been interested in, but I'm glad I bought it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

？?? 混乱…(*_*)

??? Confused... (*_*)

This review contains spoilers. 幽霊の時の２人の関係のほうがわかりやすくてよかったです。肉体に戻ってからの２人の関係がわかるようで、よくわからなかった。未森の会社の同僚の男の人はなにがしたかったのか。当馬役なんだろうけど、展開なかったのでわかりませんでした。作者さまはもっと話を長く設定してたのではないでしょうか(¯―¯٥)。ページの都合上、もしくは締切の都合上か大人の都合上で長くかけなかった気がしてなりません。しかし、ほかの方のレビューを読んでみたら、伏線を回収していないのは、この作者様の作風な気もしてきました。また読み直しして自分なりに話を膨らまして解釈して読んでいこうと思います。

This review contains spoilers. I'm glad the relationship between the two was easier to understand when they were ghosts. It seemed like they understood the relationship between the two after returning to their bodies, and I didn't really understand it. What did the male colleague at Mimori's company want to do? It was probably the role of the horse in question, but since it wasn't developed, I didn't understand. I think the author had set the story even longer (-). I don't feel like it didn't take long due to page reasons, or due to deadlines, or due to adult circumstances. However, when I read other people's reviews, I also felt that the fact that they haven't collected foreshadowing is the author's style. I'm going to reread it again, expand the story in my own way, interpret it, and read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

優しいお話

A kind story

絵が可愛くて読み始めました。全体的を通しての感想として優しいお話でした。でもその中に切なさや人を想う熱さもあって良かったです。エッチシーンはあまりなくストーリー重視の作品でした！

The picture was so cute that I started reading it. It was a kind story as an overall impression. But I'm glad that there was also a sense of sadness and passion for others in it. There weren't many sex scenes, and it was a story focused work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が好き

I like painting

This review contains spoilers. 絵が綺麗。こういう設定の場合、目が覚めても覚えてるとかなのに忘れてるのは辛い。人と関わらないようにしてた育が変わっていく感じが良かった。

This review contains spoilers. The picture is beautiful. In the case of this kind of setting, it's hard to forget even though you remember it even when you wake up. It was nice to feel that my upbringing, which I had tried not to get involved with people, was changing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 25, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

うーーーん

Hmm

This review contains spoilers. 1巻は物凄く好きでした。号泣しました。が…2巻の「Re;」の途中が納得いかなかった。未森さんが目を覚ましたのは育くんのおかげなんです。未森のためにもう会えなくなる事も覚悟して手放したんです。なのに眠っていた時の記憶がないからと欠けた記憶を探そうとも知ろうともせず感謝もなく育に「今の自分を見ていない！」と怒って拒絶するのは如何なものかと。いい人スタンプ集める人の行動じゃないよ（やめたのかもしれないけど）。気味悪がるのは仕方ないとしても後からでも嘘でも「ありがとう」とかなんかないんでしょうか。それに記憶に抜けがあると思ったら普通知りたいと思うものでは？そこら辺のもやもやがなければ星5でした。あと未森の友人やら同僚との関係性とかもよく分かんなくて中途半端なのが残念。お話は全体的にはとても好きだし絵も好みなので他の作品も機会があれば読んでみたいです。

This review contains spoilers. I really liked volume 1. I cried. But... I wasn't convinced about the middle of volume 2 of “Re;.” It was thanks to Iku-kun that Mimori-san woke up. I was prepared that I wouldn't be able to meet him anymore because of Mimori, so I let go. But since I don't have any memories from when I was asleep, I didn't try to find or know my missing memories, and I had no appreciation, and I said, “I'm not looking at who I am now!” I wonder what it would be like to get angry and reject it. It's not the act of someone who collects good people stamps (maybe they stopped). Even if it's unavoidable to be creepy, even if it's a lie later, isn't there such a thing as “thank you” or something? Also, if you think there's a memory gap, don't you just want to let them know? It would have been 5 stars if there wasn't any haze around here. Also, I don't really understand Mimori's relationships with his friends and colleagues, so it's a pity that they're half-hearted. Overall, I really like the story, and I like the pictures, so I'd like to read other works if I get a chance.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 25, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

たしかに

Certainly

たしかに…話がわかりにくい^^;。詩のような叙情的なモノローグ(かな？)が、展開の合間合間に挟まれるので、お話の進みが何度も分断されます。こちらは感情の動きや(この中での)現実世界の進みを追いかけつつ読んでるので、そこで切られると、あれっ？となってしまう。そしてそういうのが何回もやってくる。しっかり集中して読み込まないと置いてかれてしまうなーと思いました。それも楽しみ方の一つかもしれない。もしくは、この詩的な文章が散りばめられた情景のような雰囲気をふわっと楽しむか。どちらでもいいんですけど、それを楽しめるならこの作品はおすすめだと思います。

Certainly... the story is hard to understand ^^;. A lyrical monologue like a poem (maybe?) Since it is sandwiched between developments, the progress of the story is divided over and over again. I'm reading this while chasing emotional movements and progress in the real world (within here), so if I get cut there, huh? It's going to become. And that kind of thing comes over and over again. I thought it would be left behind if I didn't concentrate and read it. That might be one way to enjoy it. Or, why don't you just enjoy the atmosphere of this scene interspersed with poetic sentences? Either one is fine, but if you enjoy it, I think this work is recommended.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 22, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

デビュー作と思えない

I don't think it's my debut work

イケメンの幽霊とコンビニ店員のBL。2巻の方が主人公たちの切なさがより伝わって良かったです。デビュー作と思えない絵の完成度です。粗さがなくてビックリ。細かいことですが……タブレットで横置きで読むと、若干コマ割りが見辛かったです。縦で読んだ方がいいと思います。

BL between a handsome ghost and a convenience store clerk. I'm glad that volume 2 conveyed the seriousness of the main characters even more. It's the degree of perfection of the picture that I don't think it was my debut work. I was surprised that it wasn't rough. It's a small detail... when I read it horizontally on my tablet, it was a bit difficult to see the frame breaks. I think it's better to read it vertically.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 06, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

いいお話

Good story

This review contains spoilers. 途中切ないところもあったけど、ハッピーエンドで終わります‼︎良かった。絵がとても綺麗。☆4.5

This review contains spoilers. There were also places that were cut along the way, but it ended with a happy ending ‼ ︎ I'm glad. The picture is very beautiful. ☆ 4.5

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 17, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった～

That was good ~

This review contains spoilers. 途中からなんか切なくなってきて…でも読み進めるとちょっとしたすれ違いって言うのがわかって…最後良かった～エロはそんな沢山ないけど読んで良かった

This review contains spoilers. Something became sad halfway through... but as I read on, I understood that it was a slight misunderstanding... I'm glad at the end ~ I'm glad I read it even though there aren't that many erotic

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 06, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ロマンチック

romantic

面白いストーリーでした。言葉選びが詩的過ぎてちょっと分かりにくい部分があったのが残念ですが、それがまた同時に独特の雰囲気を作っていると思いました。

It was an interesting story. Unfortunately, there was a part where the choice of words was too poetic and a bit difficult to understand, but at the same time, I thought it also created a unique atmosphere.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

This review contains spoilers. ファンタジー寄りの不思議な雰囲気のお話でした。BLとしてでなくても成立する面白いストーリーだと思います。

This review contains spoilers. It was a story with a strange atmosphere close to fantasy. I think it's an interesting story that works even if it's not a BL.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 12, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

2冊に渡って

Over 2 books

重体で意識不明のままな未森は幽体離脱してるんだよねコレ、そして過去に母親との気持ちのスレ違いを残したままな育には何故か見えて触れるーっていう設定で始まる１巻から目覚めた未森からの視点で育に再会する2巻、と長編並みにゆっくりとふたりの心の変化が分かり感情移入し易いです。両巻共に盛り上がりシーンが有りキューン度高かったです。

It's easy to understand that Mimori, who is seriously ill and remains unconscious, has left her astral body, and volume 2, which begins with a setting where you can see and touch Iku, who left a thread of feelings with her mother in the past, and volume 2, where she reunites with nuru from the perspective of Mimori who woke up from volume 1, which begins with a setting where she left a thread of feelings with her mother in the past, slowly changes in their minds as long stories, and it's easy to empathize with them. There were exciting scenes in both volumes, and the level of queue was high.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 04, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

是非2冊続けて読んでください

Please read 2 books in a row

1巻も十分素敵な話ですが、2巻目でぐっと奥行きが出るというか、切ないなさがつのって涙が出そうになりました。一瞬未盛りが嫌なキャラになりかけたところがあって、育がかわいそうで、イラッとしましたが、やっぱりいい子だった。元の絵も綺麗だし、時々現れるチビバージョンもかわいいです。それにセリフも泣けたり、笑えたりして、話に引き込まれます。特に２巻がいいです。

Volume 1 is also a wonderful enough story, but the second volume has a lot more depth, or rather, I almost burst into tears when I feel sad. There was a place where he almost became a character I didn't like when he was underdeveloped for a moment, and I felt sorry for his upbringing, and I was frustrated, but after all, he was a good kid. The original picture is beautiful, and the little version that appears from time to time is also cute. Also, the lines make me cry and laugh, and I'm drawn into the story. Volume 2 is particularly good.

Helpful

Reviews for 23:45 Manga