23:45 Manga Reviews | MangaPlaza

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 23, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

とても感動的な漫画です……

It's a very moving comic...

This review contains spoilers. 数年前に偶然この漫画を見て、私はとても好きでした。中のいくつかのシナリオはとても私を感動させて、結末は本当にいいですね。しかし、無意識に涙を残します。とにかくこの漫画が大好きです！

This review contains spoilers. I watched this comic by chance a few years ago and I loved it. Some of the scenarios in it really moved me, and the ending was really nice. However, it unwittingly leaves me in tears. Anyway, I love this comic!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 16, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ファンタジーと現実

fantasy vs reality

This review contains spoilers. 1巻は育くんから見た状況で、2巻は未森から見た状況が語られてます。1巻では幽霊？になった未森との奇妙な生活を送りながら、未森がなくなった理由などを解明して行きながら、2人はお互いに惹かれ合う。そして亡くなってないことが分かり、病院で意識不明で眠った状態だったということがわかり、幽霊の未森が体にかえっていって、無事目覚め育とハッピーエンド。そして2巻は目覚めてから日常の生活を始めた未森の状況で、てっきり育とのラブラブな毎日かと思いきや、その時のことはすっかり穴が空いたように忘れてしまっている。育の気持ちを拒みながらも、何故か育の事を考えるし夢で見るが、今の生きている自分ではなく幽霊の自分を好きになったのだと。なんだかむず痒い感じでしたが、最後はきちんとまとまって良かったです。

This review contains spoilers. Volume 1 talks about the situation seen from Iku-kun, and volume 2 talks about the situation seen from Mimori. Is volume 1 a ghost? While living a strange life with Mimori who became one another, the two are attracted to each other while elucidating the reasons why Mimori disappeared. Then it became known that he had not passed away, and it became known that he was unconscious and asleep at the hospital, and the ghost Mimori returned to his body, and woke up safely and had a happy ending. And volume 2 is about the situation of Mimori, who began her daily life after waking up, and even though she clearly thought it was a lovey-dovey day with Iku, she completely forgot about that time. While rejecting Iku's feelings, for some reason, I think about Iku and see it in my dreams, but I think I fell in love with my ghost self instead of who I am living now. It was kind of itchy, but I'm glad it came together properly at the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

序盤からずっと切ない…

It's been sad ever since the beginning...

こういう純愛モノに激弱な自分は知っていましたが、やっぱり泣きながら読んでしまいました。。バッドエンドじゃなくて本当に良かったです……（号泣）

I knew I was extremely weak against this kind of pure love stuff, but after all, I read it while crying.. I'm really glad it wasn't a bad end... (crying)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

良作。純愛。

Good work. pure love.

This review contains spoilers. 最高です。幽霊→死んでませんでした→目が覚める→ハピエン。かと思いきや…まさかの覚えてない…泣ける。クソ泣ける。号泣します。育くんが仄暗い過去持ちなのにピュアッピュアでとにかく可愛いんです。お母さん死んでるオチかと思いきや生きてるんかーい。と突っ込んでしまいましたが。未森さんがまた闇持ちさん。うん、いい。見た目がいいからって皆幸せなわけじゃない。読み進めていくと覚えてないわけではない？幽霊の自分に嫉妬とか…天才ですか？？？泣きました。未森のお友達さんはゲイで実は未森さん好きだったかんじ？最後にはご褒美セッ…誠に有難う御座います。最後には未森さんイケメンスパダリで育くんが無自覚可愛い子ちゃんで最高でした。語彙力崩壊作品です。泣きたい、キュン死したい方にはオススメです。

This review contains spoilers. It's the best. Ghost → I'm not dead → I wake up → Happien. I wonder... I just don't remember... it makes me cry. Damn it makes me cry. I'm crying. Even though Iku-kun has a dark past, he's pure and just so cute. I thought my mom was dead, but I wonder if she's alive. I jumped in, though. Mimori-san is dark again. yeah, good. Just because they look good doesn't mean everyone is happy. Doesn't it mean you don't remember as you read on? are you jealous of your ghost self... a genius??? I cried. Is Mimori's friend gay and actually liked Mimori-san? Finally, there is a reward set... thank you very much. At the end, it was great that Mimori-san grew up on a handsome spadari because she was unaware and cute. It's a work that disrupts vocabulary. Recommended for those who want to cry or die.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

優しい作品

A gentle work

すごく好き。最初は無理と思いました、でも記憶はなくてもけっきょく好きになって、ほんとによかった。優しい作品です。

I really like it. At first I thought it was impossible, but even though I had no memory, I fell in love with it quite a bit, and I'm really glad. It's a gentle work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

優しい未来

A gentle future

絵もストーリーもとても素敵なお話でした。二人ともかわいらしく、二人の周囲にいる友人たちも、それぞれにいい人たちで、ストレスなく読めました。

Both the pictures and the story were very nice. They were both cute, and the friends around them were all nice people, so I was able to read without stress.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

幽霊と人間と恋の話

A story about ghosts, humans, and love

2巻まで読み終えてしばらく放心状態でした。正直いうと一回読んだだけでは自分の中で上手く消化しきれないところがあって翌日もう一度1巻から読み返しました。で放心状態です。ココロが満たされたというか、すごい作品に出会ってしまったと感じました。1巻でも十分話は完結されています。ですが、2巻のRe:は未森側の視点で語られていく秘密の話。2巻の途中は展開に苦しくなりますが、それも必要な伏線。最後はすべのピースが埋まりハッピーエンドです。何度もいいますが本当に素晴らしい作品です。デビュー作品とは思えない！！作者様は王道の展開と話されていますが、王道だけど王道じゃないてすよ！未森さん、幽霊のときはぽうっとした天然さんだと思っていましたが、恋人同士になったその後の話では、育くんを困らせるくらいイチャラブが好きな25歳児でしたね。そこも最高です。購入を迷われている方がいたら是非読んでほしい。最高の一冊です。

I finished reading up to volume 2 and was in a state of relief for a while. To be honest, there was something in me that I couldn't digest well after just reading it once, so I reread it from volume 1 again the next day. So I'm in a safe state. I felt that my heart was satisfied, or rather, that I had come across an amazing work. Volume 1 is enough to complete the story. However, volume 2 of Re: is a secret story told from Mimori's point of view. It will be difficult to unfold in the middle of volume 2, but that is also a necessary foreshadowing. At the end, all the pieces are filled and it's a happy ending. I've said it many times, but it's a really great work. I don't think it's my debut work!! The author is talking about the development of the royal road, but although it's a royal road, it's not a royal road! When Mimori-san was a ghost, I thought she was a good-nature-san, but in the story after they became lovers, they were 25-year-olds who liked flirtatious love so much that they bothered Iku-kun. That's great too. If anyone is unsure about purchasing, I definitely want you to read it. This is one of the best books.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

作家さん買いです♪

The artist is buying it ♪

絵がとっても好みです(^ー^)丁寧に描かれているストーリーはしっかり心に響いてきました。最後はハッピーエンド!!お互い社会人になった続編も出てくれたらいいなぁ～♪

I really like the pictures (^-^) The carefully drawn story really resonated with my heart. Happy ending at the end!! It would be nice if a sequel where we both became members of society also came out ~ ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 26, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった！

That was great!

けど語彙力なくて感想が難しい…笑言葉の言い回しなどが独特で、繋がりを理解するためストーリーに没頭出来ました。会話の間などもリアルさというか、その場の空気感を感じられて良かったです。絵も綺麗で読みやすいかと思います。特にカラーが好きです！

But my impression is difficult because I don't have vocabulary... The phrases of laughing words are unique, and I was able to immerse myself in the story in order to understand the connections. It was nice to be able to feel the realism of the conversation, or rather the atmosphere of the place. I think the pictures are beautiful and easy to read. I especially love the color!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻

Volume 2

This review contains spoilers. 1巻はファンタジーで2巻は現実のお話という印象です。1巻の『これから』を想像する終わり方も良かったけれど、私は2巻があってよかったなーとおもいました。2巻の後書きで編集担当さんの提案がなければ別の終わり方になってたと書いてあったので『編集担当さんグッジョブ！』とおもいました。

This review contains spoilers. I have the impression that volume 1 is fantasy and volume 2 is a reality story. The way it ended, imagining volume 1 of “The Future” was good, but I thought it was good that there were 2 volumes. It was written in the afterword of volume 2 that it would have ended in a different way if there were no suggestions from the person in charge of editing, so “Good job, Editor-in-charge!” I thought so.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

作者さま買いです。

The author is buying it.

This review contains spoilers. ノットロンググッドバイもこちらも絵が美しいすぎますねー。そしてまたお話も切なくて切なくて。生きててくれて。ハッピーエンドで。ほんと良かったです。ワタシ的には２巻がありで、読み返せば読み返すほどにより一層ぐっとハートを掴まれました。

This review contains spoilers. Both Knot Long Goodbye and this one are too beautiful. And again, the story was so sad, so sad. for being alive. with a happy ending. It was really nice. For me, there were 2 volumes, and the more I reread it, the more it grabbed my heart.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

切なく、優しい…

sad, kind...

This review contains spoilers. 作者さん買いです。絵柄もストーリーも優しくて引き込まれます。独特な言葉が少々難解でじっくり読み返しその意味(表現)を自分なりに解釈しましたが、正直不安です…?2巻の方がよりじっくりと読まないと難しく感じましたが、優しい気持ちになったり、切なかったりと心が揺れ動かされる素敵な作品でした。幽霊だった時から現実の世界に戻った未森さんの記憶の中にいる不思議な男の子。それが育くんだと辿りついた時…夢やあいまいな記憶に未森さんの葛藤や苛立ち。そして育くんは忘れられてしまった辛さに耐えて。思い出せない過去の事にどうしたらいいのかわからない切なさに胸が締め付けられました。それでも未森さんを一途に想い続けている育くんに涙がでました。そしてこれからの事が大切だと2人の距離が少しずつ縮まっていくのがとてもよかったです。それから「未来の話をしにきた」…と未森さんの言葉が素敵でした。2人で未来に向かって幸せになってほしいです。最後は未森さんの可愛らしいさに笑っちゃいました。そして2人の笑顔にとてもほっこりしました。

This review contains spoilers. The author is buying it. The design and story are gentle and drawing me in. The unique words are a bit difficult to understand, and I carefully reread them and interpreted their meaning (expression) in my own way, but to be honest, I'm uneasy...? I felt that volume 2 was more difficult if I didn't read it more carefully, but it was a wonderful work that shook my heart by making me feel kind and sad. A mysterious boy in Mimori-san's memory who has returned to the real world since he was a ghost. When I arrived at it growing up... Mimori-san was conflicted and frustrated by dreams and vague memories. And Iku-kun endured the pain of being forgotten. My heart was strained by the sadness of not knowing what to do about things from the past that I couldn't remember. Even so, Iku-kun, who continues to have feelings for Mimori-san, burst into tears. And it was great that the distance between the two gradually shrinks when the future is important. Then, “I'm here to talk about the future”... Mimori-san's words were wonderful. I want the two of them to be happy for the future. At the end, I laughed at how cute Mimori was. And I was so relieved by their smiles.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

優しくて

Be kind

切ないやら優しいやらいろんな感情になりました。作者さんの絵もとても優しくて素敵だなと思いました。辛かった分二人で幸せに！

It made me feel all kinds of feelings, sad and kind. I thought the artist's paintings were also very kind and wonderful. It was hard, so happy for the two of us!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

変わりゆく23:45という時間

The changing time 23:45

「ノットロンググッドバイ」が良かったのでこちらも購入。緒花さんの美しく繊細な絵が、このくらいの年齢の眩さや危うさをより巧く表現されていて好感が持てます。実態がある幽霊って辺りはとても不思議な感じがしましたが、ストーリーを読み進めていくうちにあまり違和感なく受け入れられました。恐らく、この特異な環境でなければ出会わなかったであろう全く違うタイプの2人だと思いますが、互いに心通わせていく様はなかなか読み応えがありました。タイトルの23:45も1-2巻を通して、キーになっている時間の仕掛けの変化はとても上手いなと思いしました。

“Not Long Goodbye” was good, so I bought this one too. I like Obana's beautiful and delicate paintings that more skillfully express the glare and danger at this age. I felt very strange about ghosts that actually exist, but as I read the story, I was accepted without much sense of incongruity. I think they are two completely different types of people who probably wouldn't have met unless they were in this unique environment, but the way they communicate with each other was quite worth reading. The 23:45 title also went through volume 1-2, and I thought that the change in the time mechanism that is the key was very good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 31, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

すべてが好きすぎる

I like everything too much

絵が好き、ストーリーが好き、萌え感が好き、キャラクターが魅力的、セリフが好き。非の打ち所がない作品です。何度も読み返した・・・。作者さんの作画って、角度が素晴らしくいいですよね。この角度から描けちゃうか～という感激と、どれもめちゃくちゃ美しいのでもう、、、なんでもないシーンでうっとり見つめてしまいます。切なく甘いストーリーも大好きです。

I like pictures, I like the story, I like the sense of emotion, the characters are attractive, and I like the lines. It's an impeccable work. I reread it over and over again... The angle of the artist's drawing is wonderful, isn't it? I was so moved that I was able to draw from this angle, and they were all so beautiful that I stared fascinated at scenes where there was nothing anymore... I also love the sad and sweet story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 06, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

せつない

It's annoying

うー、よかった。せつなくて何度も涙してしまうところが。胸痛かった…。好きな人に覚えられてないってこんなにツライことってないもん。絵もきれいで話の流れもすごくよくて浸りました。

Wow, that was great. There is a place where it makes me cry over and over again because it's so annoying. my chest hurt... It's never this hard not to be remembered by someone you like. The pictures were beautiful and the flow of the story was so good that I was immersed in it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 16, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

隠れオタとリア充

Hidden otaku and rear charge

２人とも穏やかな性格なのに、静かな情景の中に熱が広がる不思議な話でした。幽霊とのひとときから、育くんの変化もあって凄く頑張ってた。難しい言葉に葛藤が含まれてる感じもあって、考えさせられます。性格や家族との過去もあり、今の自分がある意味とか、頑張る姿に涙も自然にでてきます。何度読んでもホントいい話で、大好きです。何と言っても、絵が好き。育ちゃん可愛いです。２人のイチャイチャも良かったです。

It was a strange story where the heat spread in a quiet scene, even though they both had calm personalities. I've been working really hard since I was with ghosts, and there were changes in Iku-kun. There is also a feeling that conflict is included in difficult words, and it makes me think. I also have a personality and a past with my family, and tears naturally come out when I see myself doing my best now, in a sense. It's a really good story no matter how many times I read it, and I love it. After all, I love painting. Iku-chan is cute. The flirtation between the two was good too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

肩越しに見つめるのはドーナツの穴

What I stare over my shoulder is a hole in a doughnut

This review contains spoilers. 作者さん買いです。フォローしてる方オススメ。作者さんの「ノットロンググッドバイ」が少々難解でも読めば読むほど隠された意味が出てくるイチオシものだったので、この作品も期待して読みました。この作品もすっごく好きです！歩道橋から23：45に毎晩飛び降りている幽霊の未森(未森といったらハルモニオデオンの遊佐未森世代ですが、作者さんはもっと若そう)と、そんな未森を見つけて放っておけなくて自宅に住まわせてしまった育のお話。ネタバレなしで読んだら、どちらに転ぶか最後までドキドキしたので、ネタバレなし推奨です。続編にre: が描かれたことで、一筋縄では全くいかないその後が違って視点でとらえられてこれもまた切ない。ぜひ2冊続けて読むことオススメです。挿絵やキャラデザインを多くされている方なので、絵が洗練されてて素晴らしく綺麗で、繊細なモノローグと一緒にずっと眺めていたくなります！レビュータイトルは、ドーナツの穴はあるかどうかっていう作品内の命題です。トポロジーですね。

This review contains spoilers. The author is buying it. Recommended for those who follow. The author's “Not Long Goodbye” was a bit difficult to understand, but the more I read it, the more hidden meaning came out, so I was expecting this work as well. I really like this work too! It's a story about the ghost Mimori (Mimori is the Yusa Mimori generation of Harmoniodeon, but the author seems to be younger) who jumps down from the pedestrian bridge every night at 23:45, and Ikku, who found Mimori and couldn't leave them alone and made them live at home. If I read it without spoilers, I was excited until the end about which one I would fall, so I recommend it without spoilers. Since re: was drawn in the sequel, the aftermath, which was not straightforward at all, was taken from a different point of view, which is also sad. I definitely recommend reading 2 books in a row. They do a lot of illustrations and character designs, so the pictures are sophisticated, wonderfully beautiful, and I want to look at them all the time along with their delicate monologues! The title of the review is a proposition in the work about whether there is a hole in a doughnut. It's topology.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ちょっと難しい…？

a little difficult...?

This review contains spoilers. わたしには少し難しく感じましたが、絵が好きだし、ハッピーエンドだからもうなんでも良きです。育くんの片想いから両思いになれてよかった。

This review contains spoilers. It felt a little difficult for me, but I love painting, and since it has a happy ending, anything is fine. I'm glad I went from Iku-kun's unrequited love to mutual love.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 10, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

透明感

Transparency

この作者さん、絵もお話しも透明感があって、せつないけどあったかくて読了後になんとも言えない優しい気持ちが。ストーリー重視の方にはおすすめです。

There is a sense of transparency in both the pictures and the story by this author, and I have a gentle feeling that I can't say anything after reading them, even though they are sad but warm. Recommended for those who focus on the story.

Helpful

Reviews for 23:45 Manga