23:45 Manga Reviews (P.5)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 05, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

ごちそうさまでした

Thank you for the meal

This review contains spoilers. ちゃんとストーリーがしっかりしてて、切なくて、かつこういうのを読む読者の需要(オブラート)にもちゃんと応えてるものはなかなかないと思うので、私は好きです。絵もすごく綺麗で好きです。時々誰が話してるふきだしかわかんない事があって度々読み返しましたが、甘く評価しときます。

This review contains spoilers. I like it because the story is solid, sad, and I don't think there are many that properly respond to the demand (obblight) of readers who read this kind of thing. The picture is also very beautiful and I like it. Sometimes I only understand who is talking about the bubble, so I reread it often, but I give it a sweet evaluation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

純なお話しで、これから幸せになってほしい

It's a pure story, and I want them to be happy from now on

鼻先がツンとするお話しでした。純真な心同士の出会いが奇跡を起こすのかな。

It was a story that made my nose cringe. I wonder if an encounter between innocent hearts will cause miracles.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 03, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

This review contains spoilers. 絵が好みで買いました。切ないですが綺麗な話で好きです。続編での冷たい未森さんに対して頑張る育くんがかわいい。オススメです。

This review contains spoilers. I bought the picture because I liked it. It's a sad but beautiful story and I like it. Iku-kun, who works hard against the cold Mimori-san in the sequel, is cute. I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 30, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

不思議な感覚の作品

A work with a strange feeling

This review contains spoilers. 生と死の間を描いた感じの不思議な恋の物語。ストーリー重視の作品。ほぼエロシーンはないので、イチャコラBLを見たい人には、向かないと思います。ただ、ストーリーとしてはとても切なくて胸の奥がちくっとする切ない作品です。エロシーンは、最後にちらっとあるくらいです。1度だけ読むより2度読む方が内容にもっと入っていった。

This review contains spoilers. A mysterious love story that feels like it depicts the space between life and death. This work focuses on the story. There are almost no erotic scenes, so I don't think it's suitable for people who want to watch Ichakora BL. However, as a story, it's a very sad work that really boggles my heart. There's only a glimpse of the erotic scene at the end. Reading it twice was more involved in the content than reading it only once.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 28, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

よかったー。

that was great.

一巻だけでも好きでした。きれいに終わってます。ちょっと切ないけれどいいお話。二巻までいくとお話に深みが出ます。なんだかじわーっとしますよ。お話はちょいちょい切ないけれどハッピーエンドです。

I loved it even if it was just one volume. It's finished nicely. It's a bit sad, but it's a good story. The depth of the story comes out when you get to volume 2. Somehow it makes me feel relaxed. The story is a bit sad, but it has a happy ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 26, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

２巻まで読んで。

Read up to volume 2.

This review contains spoilers. 偶然、バイトの帰りの歩道橋で幽霊に出会う育。なぜか育にだけその姿が見え、触れることも出来る。1巻では育の視点で彼が現実の世界に戻るまでが描かれています。 2巻では相手の未森の視点で眠っていたときの記憶が無いため、育との関係がぼんやりでそれによって悩んだり、記憶のなかった頃の幽霊の自分との葛藤など描かれてるので2巻まで読んでこその作品かなと思います。とても良かったです。

This review contains spoilers. By chance, Ikku encounters a ghost on the pedestrian bridge home from work. For some reason, only Iku can see and touch that figure. Volume 1 depicts how he returns to the real world from the perspective of Iku. In volume 2, I have no memory of when I was asleep from my partner Mimori's point of view, so my relationship with Iku is vague and I'm worried about it, and it depicts the ghost's conflict with myself when I had no memory, so I think it's only after reading volume 2. It was very good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 25, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

1.2巻通して

Go through volume 1.2

1巻だけでも感動ですが、2巻読んでより一層面白いです！視点が違う分、読み返すと、この時こう思ってたんだ！っていうところもあって面白いです。オススメです！

Volume 1 alone is impressive, but reading volume 2 makes it even more interesting! When I reread it because my point of view is different, this is what I thought at this time! There is also a place called that, which is interesting. I recommend it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 18, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

幾度も、

over and over,

不器用貧乏な育くんの一生懸命さにときめき、立ち止まっては器用貧乏な未森さんの一瞬の絶望に細やかな息を飲み、そうして繋がる先でグリグリとツボを圧され……！否応なしに生死が絡むお話なので好みが別れると思いますが、決して悲しい終わりではないので私はグッと来てハアッ(良い読了感)となりました。二巻の良くも悪くも正直な未森さんの姿がじわりと沁みて何だか堪りませんでした。追記忘れる前に何度も何度も読み返しています。その度に強かなじわじわ感にグッと来てグッと来てググッと。育くんの芯の雄々しさと未森さんの仄かな女々しさがとても好きで……心の受け攻めは真逆なんじゃなかろうか、と(笑)。

I was thrilled by the hard work of the clumsy poor Iku-kun, and when I stopped, I took a detailed breath by the momentary hopelessness of the dexterous poor Mimori-san, and then I was pressured by griggly and pressure points at the end of the connection...! It's a story where life and death are inevitably involved, so I think our tastes will split, but it's definitely not a sad ending, so I came right in and haha (good sense of reading). For better or worse, the honest appearance of Mimori-san in volume 2 slowly sank in, and it was kind of unbearable. I reread it over and over again before I forget to add it. Every time I did that, I had a strong sense of softness, and it came so fast, it came so fast, and so did. I really like Iku-kun's bravery and Mimori-san's subtle femininity... I wonder if the attack on the heart is the exact opposite (laughs).

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 03, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった

That was interesting

素敵な話でした！育くんかわいいな〜。途中胸がキューっとなる切なさもあったけど、最終的にほっこり。たのしかったです。

That was a wonderful story! Iku-kun is so cute. There was also a sense of sadness that made my heart ache along the way, but in the end I felt relieved. It was fun.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 26, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

This review contains spoilers. 切ない場面で胸が苦しくなったときもあったけど、思いが通じあえてほんとに良かった❤

This review contains spoilers. There were times when my heart ached in sad scenes, but I'm really glad I dared to get through ❤

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 16, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

良かったー

That was great

１巻だけでもキレイにまとまってますが、私は2巻と合わせて大好きになった作品です。ところどころわかりにくいモノローグもあるんですが、行間まで読みたくなって何度もリピ読みしています。受けの育くんは見た目はかわいいけど、中身はちゃんと男の子なのもいいですね。そして２巻の描き下ろしエロ！緒花先生、ありがとうございます！！(笑)

The first volume alone is beautifully organized, but together with volume 2, I fell in love with it. There are also monologues that are hard to understand here and there, but I want to read them even between the lines, so I'm re-reading them over and over again. Kakenoiku-kun looks cute, but it's also nice that the inside is really a boy. And 2 volumes of erotic drawing! Thank you, Professor Obana! (lol)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 15, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

ストーリー重視

Focus on the story

1巻を読んで即2巻目購入しました。エロは少ないけど好きになっていく過程の受けの心情の変化とか可愛くて面白かったです。絵も綺麗で切ないストーリーがしっかりしてて読みごたえあります！1巻目の幽霊でふわふわした先輩と2巻目の現実の先輩とでまたやり直す感じがキュンとしました。ありがとう！良かった。

I read volume 1 and immediately bought volume 2. There isn't much eroticism, but the emotional changes in the process of falling in love with it were cute and interesting. The pictures are beautiful and the sad story is solid, so it's worth reading! The feeling of starting over again with Fuwafuwa Senpai in the ghost volume 1 and the real-life senpai in volume 2 made me excited. thank you! That was great.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 14, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

まってました

I was waiting

書店で一目惚れして１巻を買ったのが去年の秋くらい？お話も絵もなにもかもがきれいでとても好きです。１巻のおわりかたもよかったですが、今こうして育くんと未森さんの未来を見れて本当に嬉しいです。二人にはいつまでも幸せでいてほしい…

Did you fall in love at first sight at a bookstore and bought the first volume around last fall? The story, pictures, everything are beautiful and I really like it. The way volume 1 ended was great, but I'm really happy to be able to see the future of growing up like this now and Mimori-san. I want them both to stay happy forever...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 02, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

続編出てなお良し

It's even better that the sequel came out

１巻だけ出ていた頃から好きでしたが、続編が出てとても嬉しいです！１巻だけだと切ないけれど、ぜひ２巻まで読んで欲しいです。主人公のお母さんのエピソードも好きでした。

I've loved it since the first volume came out, but I'm so happy that the sequel is out! It would be sad if it was only volume 1, but I definitely want you to read up to 2 volumes. I also liked the episode about the main character's mom.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 20, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

読んでいてグッとくる、セリフと絵がいい

Reading it makes me happy, the lines and pictures are good

一つ一つのセリフがとても綺麗な絵の表情とあわさると、本当に読んでてぎゅっと心臓にきますね。何だか映画とかみてるようで素敵だなと思いました。もっともっと緒花さんのオリジナル作がみたいです。

When you mix each line with the very beautiful expression in the picture, it really comes to my heart when I read it. It looked like they were watching a movie or something, and I thought it was wonderful. I want to see more and more of Ohana's original works.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 18, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

私は好きでした?

I loved it?

This review contains spoilers. 幽霊と人間の話がここまで広がるかと思うと素敵でした??空白の記憶が引っかかる攻めと体も心も全部覚えてる受け?あの時のあの時間は偽りじゃないけど、あってはいけない時間?読み応えありました?

This review contains spoilers. It was wonderful to think that the story of ghosts and humans would unfold this far?? an attack where a blank memory gets caught and you remember everything in your body and mind, take it? That time at that time isn't a lie, but is it a time that shouldn't have happened? was it worth reading?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 11, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

あー…好きかも

ah... maybe you like it

初めて緒花さんの作品を読みました。今までに、あまりない設定だったので、なんとなく興味をひかれ読み出しました。繊細なストーリーに引き込まれていきました。23:45 REも読みます。

I read Ohana's work for the first time. Until now, there weren't many settings, so I was somehow intrigued and started reading it. I was drawn into a delicate story. I also read 23:45 RE.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 11, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

This review contains spoilers. 生きてて良かった！１巻ではどっちなんだろうな？って感じでだったので、二人が生きて会うことができて良かったです。本当に絵が素敵で透明感があります。

This review contains spoilers. I'm glad I'm alive! Which one is it in volume 1? It was like that, so I'm glad the two of them were able to meet alive. The picture is really nice and has a sense of transparency.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 08, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

続いていたのね・・・

it was going on...

てっきり１巻で終わりかとおもっていたんだけど、まだ続いていたんですね・・・。内容は１巻の方が好きでした。もう少し見たいって思っていたのでうれしいんですけどね。REってつけるだけあって、内容が１巻と２巻で同じような違うような感じ。

I definitely thought it would end with volume 1, but it was still going on... I liked the content of volume 1 better. I wanted to see a little more, so I'm happy. I just added RE, and it feels like the contents are just as different between volume 1 and volume 2.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 07, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

すごくいい話しです

That's a really good story

待ってました2巻が出て、２人の続きが描かれていてまた感動しました。２人の感情や考えもよくわかったし、きゅんとします。切なさもあるけど最後はハピエンでよかった… 意外とHシーンもドキドキしてよかったです‼︎（描かれない方なのかとおもってました笑）

Volume 2, which I've been waiting for, came out, and I was moved again by the fact that the continuation of the two was depicted. I understand their feelings and thoughts very well, and I'm amazed. It's sad, but I'm glad it was Happien at the end... Surprisingly, I'm glad the H scene was exciting too ‼ ︎ (I thought it was the one that wasn't drawn lol)

Helpful

Reviews for 23:45 Manga