Silver Spoon Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

肉持ってると男にモテるｗ

they're popular with men when they have meat lol

勉強になりました。農家さんってあんなに大変なんだな。「金持ってると女にモテるが、肉持ってると男にモテる」って名言に笑ったｗ男風呂ヨーグルトもツボった。風呂でヨーグルト作ってるの草ｗ作者先生は天才だと思う。

It's been a learning experience. Farming is so hard, isn't it? I laughed at the quote “If you have money, you're popular with women, but if you have meat, you're popular with men” lol the male bath yogurt also had pressure points. they're making yogurt in the bath lol I think the author is a genius.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

小学生から大人まで是非読んで

Be sure to read it from elementary school students to adults

This review contains spoilers. 大切なことをたくさん学べますねもちろん笑えて楽しく読めるのですが命を育てる頂く考えることもたくさんです小豚はかわいいかわいいですけどね

This review contains spoilers. You can learn a lot of important things, right? Of course, it's funny and fun to read, but they raise lives, and there are a lot of things to think about. Little pigs are cute and cute

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

学校に置くべき

Should I put it in school

命について、しっかり学べて、酪農の大変も学べる。小学生から読むべき漫画。北海道の事も知れるので、すごく為になりました

You can learn about life thoroughly, and you can also learn about the hardships of dairy farming. A comic that should be read by elementary school students. I also learned about Hokkaido, so it was really helpful

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

荒川先生の作品だったので読了。読むと酪農してみたくなりました。八軒の世話焼きなとこ、自分で抱え込んでしまうとこが人間味あって好きです。

It was Arakawa-sensei's work, so I read it. Reading it made me want to try dairy farming. I like the fact that Hachiken takes care of the place where you take care of yourself has a human touch.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

農業について考えさせられる一策

A policy that makes you think about agriculture

鋼の錬金術師で、お馴染みの荒川先生の作品、農業高校の良い所と、現在の農業についての問題などいろいろ考えさせられる作品であった。相変わらずの完成度でとても面白いのでオススメ。巻数もあまり多くないので読みやすいと思う。最後はロシアでの農業うんぬんかんぬんと言う終わりだったので、今やるとちょっとなぁと言う部分もある。

It was a work by Fullmetal Alchemist and the familiar Arakawa-sensei, and it was a work that made me think about various things, such as the good points of agricultural high schools and current issues related to agriculture. I recommend it because it has the same degree of perfection as ever and is very interesting. There aren't many volumes, so I think it's easy to read. At the end, I ended up saying agriculture in Russia is boo boo boo boo, so there is also a part where it's a bit difficult to do now.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

酪農、農業に興味がわいたわ

I'm interested in dairy farming and agriculture

荒川先生の作品といえばバトル！！ってイメージが強いけど、この漫画は残酷農業系よ。でも今まで当たり前のように食べていたものに対して考え方が少し変わった気がする。私達が当たり前のように食べているお肉や野菜、それらを育てる人を知るきっかけになるかもしれないわ。それだけじゃなくて主人公の成長がすごい。逃げる事は誰にだって必要な時があるけど逃げ続けるだけじゃなくて受け止めて前に進んでいる。子供にも読ませたら嫌いだった野菜を食べたり、嫌いだった牛乳も飲むようになった。学校に置いても良いと思えるそんな作品よ。

Speaking of Arakawa-sensei's works, battle! I have a strong image of that, but this comic is based on cruel agriculture. But I feel that my way of thinking about what I had eaten as a matter of course until now has changed slightly. It might be an opportunity to get to know the meats and vegetables we take for granted, and the people who grow them. Not only that, but the growth of the main character is amazing. There are times when everyone needs to run away, but they don't just keep running away, they accept it and move forward. When I read it to my kids, they started eating vegetables they didn't like, and drinking milk, which they didn't like. It's such a work that I think I could put in school.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 12, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公の成長に感激?

Are you thrilled by the hero's growth?

毎巻主人公の成長に感激させてもらってます。子供っぽいところを残しつつ、成長していく八軒とその仲間たちに爆笑させてもらいながら感動も頂いています。毎巻楽しみにさせてくれる作品です！

I am deeply moved by the growth of the protagonist in every volume. I am also moved by Hachiken and their friends, who are growing up while leaving a childlike place behind. It's a work that makes me look forward to every volume!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

八軒くんの成長に泣ける

I can cry when Hachiken-kun grows

八軒くんの人をほっとけない性格が好きで、個性豊かで正直な仲間たちが好きで、エゾノーの学校生活が面白くてずっと楽しく読んできた漫画でしたが、最後の二巻はもう八軒くんの成長ぶりに泣けてきました…。中学の先生も含めて、八軒くんという生徒をしっかり気にかけてくれる先生方に恵まれて本当に良かった。厳しくも温かい高校生活が眩しい大好きな作品です！

I like Hachiken-kun's personality that doesn't leave people alone, and I like his unique and honest friends, and it was a comic I've enjoyed reading all the time because Ezono's school life was interesting, but the last two volumes have already made me cry because Hachiken-kun has grown up... It was really nice to be blessed with teachers who really cared about the students, Hachiken-kun, including junior high school teachers. It's a work I love, where the harsh yet warm high school life is dazzling!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

サイコー！

awesome!

This review contains spoilers. ずーーーーっと読んでみたかった本です。大人買いしました(笑)。自分は完全な消費者で、消費者目線で食べ物をみて出来るだけ安く買い物をするを繰り返してきました。でも、農家さんの痛みを思い知らされたように思います。特に駒場くん家の離農には心が痛みました。これもまた現実なのだと。クラスの実家の大半は借金が当たり前なのだと。日本人はもっと日本人の事を考えなければならない。もっと農家さんの事を考えなければならない。八軒くんの農家さんがもっと報われる世の中にしたいという考えに賛同です。自分には何が出来るのだろうか？ものすごく考えさせられる作品です。ちなみに私は牛乳が大好きです。毎日飲んでますよ！

This review contains spoilers. This is a book I've always wanted to read. I bought it for adults (laughs). I am a complete consumer, and I have repeatedly looked at food from the consumer's point of view and shopped as cheaply as possible. But I think I was reminded of the farmer's pain. I was particularly heartbroken when the Komaba-kun family left the farm. I think this is also a reality. Debts are commonplace in most of my class's parents. Japanese people should think more about Japanese people. We need to think more about farmers. I agree with Hachiken-kun's idea of creating a world where farmers are more rewarded. What can I do? It's a very thought-provoking work. Incidentally, I love milk. I drink it every day!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 23, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

いい

That's good

作者様の作品はどれも面白くて好きですが、特にこの作品の日常感と青春感は素晴らしいですね。学生時代が懐かしい〜ここまでの実習はなかったものの近いものを感じます。近い学生時代を送った人は絶対ひかれるかと！！

All of the artist's works are interesting and I like them, but in particular, the sense of everyday life and youth in this work is wonderful. I miss my school days ~ I don't have any practical training up to this point, but I feel something close. I think people who have lived close to their school days will definitely be attracted!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

お腹が空く

I'm hungry

連載当時に気になってはいたけれど読む機会が無く、最近思い出したので読んでみました。読み始めると面白すぎて一気に読んでしまいました。農高って未知の世界だったのですが、農業だけじゃなくて畜産とかいろいろ勉強になりますね。動物を育てたり殺したりすることも考えさせられるので、これ小学生の課題図書とかにすれば良い食育になるのでは……とか考えてしまいました。いやしかし漫画内で頻繁に美味しそうなものが出てくるので読んでるとお腹が空きます。めちゃくちゃピザ食べたくなるしベーコンとかソーセージとかも……太るわ！

I was curious at the time it was serialized, but I didn't have a chance to read it, and recently I remembered it, so I read it. When I started reading it, it was so interesting that I read it all at once. Agricultural High School was an unknown world, but I learned not only agriculture but also livestock farming and other things. It also makes me think about raising and killing animals, so I thought that this would be a good dietary education if it were an assignment book for elementary school students... No, but things that look delicious often come up in comics, so I get hungry when I read them. It makes me insanely want to eat pizza, and maybe bacon or sausages... it makes me fat!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

楽しいこともしんどいこともあったね

There were fun things and hard times

こんなに前を向ける作品を読んだのは初めてでした。また読み返すこと間違い無いでしょう。☺️ほんとに大好きな作品です。□

It was the first time I had read such a forward-looking work. There is no doubt that you will be rereading it again. ☺️ I really love this work. □

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

辛い、厳しい、でも、夢がある

It's hard, it's tough, but I have a dream

酪農の世界が興味深いし、同級生やら先生やらキャラの濃いメンバーばかりで面白いです。何かと巻き込まれがちな八軒の奮闘も楽しいし、楽しいばかりではない酪農の厳しさもきちんと描かれているところが凄く良かったです。おすすめです

The world of dairy farming is interesting, and it's interesting that there are only classmates, teachers, and other members with strong characters. The struggles of Hachiken, which tend to get involved in something, are also fun, and it was really nice that not only was it fun, but the harshness of dairy farming was also properly depicted. I recommend

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 26, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

なかなか味わえない体験

An experience you can't easily enjoy

犬なら飼ってたので動物の可愛さや愛着の気持ちは何となく分かるのですが、その子を食べるとか売るとかそうなるとやっぱり複雑な心境になりますね…。食育だなー。

If it were a dog, I had one, so I can somehow understand the animal's cuteness and attachment, but it's still a complicated state of mind when it comes to eating or selling that child... it's dietary education.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

6巻まで読了

Read up to 6 volumes

This review contains spoilers. 進学校で学んでいた主人公が、家から離れたいという理由で全寮制の農業高校で過ごします。夢を持っていないとダメな雰囲気…周囲はそんなこと思っていないかもしれないけど、自分だけはウジウジと考えてしまう…主人公の気持ちがわかるような気がした。2巻でのピザ作り大イベントの一体感が、高揚感溢れててすごく良かった。現実や知識を色々と学びながら楽しめる漫画、親子で楽しめそう。馬術についてや、高校生が悩む進路や恋愛、学校生活・私生活など、多岐なテーマが盛り込まれています。

This review contains spoilers. The main character, who was studying at a preparatory school, spends his time at an agricultural high school with a boarding system because he wants to get away from home. It's a bad atmosphere if you don't have a dream... people around you may not think that, but only you think that you're the only one who is ignorant... I felt like I could understand the main character's feelings. The sense of unity at the two-volume pizza making event was full of elation and was really nice. It seems that parents and children can enjoy comics that parents and children can enjoy while learning various things about reality and knowledge. It includes a wide range of themes, such as horsemanship, career paths and romance that high school students struggle with, and school life/private life.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

北海道いいなぁー

Hokkaido is nice

北海道に憧れちゃいます。まあ大変そうですけどねーさらにさらに、最近はリアルに経費が嵩むってききますからね…あわせて作者先生の農業のほうにも手を出したくなりました

I'm longing for Hokkaido. Well, it seems like it's going to be tough, but furthermore, expenses have actually increased recently... at the same time, I wanted to try my hand at agriculture by the author

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 30, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

成長物語

Growth story

主人公やその周りの人々が葛藤しながらも成長していくさまが良いです。葛藤せず愉快に生きている楽しい人物たちもいますがｗｗみんな好きです。

It's nice how the protagonist and the people around him grow while struggling. There are also fun people who live happily without conflict lol lol everyone likes them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

荒川弘の漫画でつまらないものはない

There are no boring comics by Hiroshi Arakawa

ストーリーも面白いし農業の勉強にもなるし、大人から子供まで読んでほしい漫画。ハガレンの時から荒川弘先生のファンですが、何を読んでも間違いがない漫画家さんですね。15巻完結というところも読みやすくて良いです。

The story is interesting, it makes for studying agriculture, and it's a comic I want adults and children to read. I've been a fan of Hiroshi Arakawa since Hagaren, and he's a manga artist who can't go wrong no matter what he reads. The fact that 15 volumes have been completed is also good because it is easy to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

いつ読んでも、最高です！！

No matter when I read it, it's great!!

いつ読んでも、本当に最高です‼特に、八軒くんと御影さんの、すごく、もどかしい恋の話や、離農の現実の話も如実に描かれています。ものすごく、おススメ?

No matter when you read it, it's really great ‼ In particular, it clearly depicts the story of Hachiken-kun and Mikage-san's amazing, frustrating love, and the real-life story of leaving the farm. Terrible, do you recommend it?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

最高でした！

It was awesome!

主人公の悩みと成長をしっかり描き切ったのが素晴らしい。周りの登場人物もいきいきしていて作者様の力量の高さを思い知りました。ご飯もとても美味しそう

It's wonderful that it clearly depicts the protagonist's worries and growth. The characters around me were also lively, and I was aware of the author's high ability. The rice looks very tasty too

Helpful

Reviews for Silver Spoon Manga