Hi, I'm a Witch, and My Crush Wants Me to Make a Love Potion Manga Reviews (P.17)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 29, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗

The picture is beautiful

表紙のイラストが好みだったので試し読みしてみました。魔法や魔女モノの作品も好きなので世界観も好みでした。機会があれば続きを読んでみたいです。

I liked the cover illustration, so I tried reading it. I also like works with magic and witch things, so I liked the world view. I'd like to read more if I get a chance.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 29, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

切ないけどいい！

It's sad, but it's good!

惚れ薬がきっかけで失恋したと思い込むヒロインの魔女、くっつくまで時間かかりますが、悶えながら読みました！

The heroine, The Witch, who assumes that she was heartbroken due to love potions, takes time until they stick together, but I read it in agony!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 29, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない系かー

are you sad

This review contains spoilers. おそらくお互いに勘違いとか思い込みとかいろいろあるんだろうけど、女の子がひとりで人々に嫌われてると思って暮らすのはかわいそうなので、なんとかなって欲しいです。

This review contains spoilers. There are probably various misunderstandings and assumptions about each other, but it's a pity for girls to live alone thinking that people don't like them, so I want something to happen.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 26, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

結局この二人はひっつくんだろうなと思いつつも、展開が気になる作品ですね。絵も綺麗だし、話も好きです。

Even though I think these two will eventually get together, I'm worried about the development of this work. The pictures are beautiful, and I like the story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 26, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

タイトルで吹き出してしまいました。が、まだ失恋確定ではないですよね？ね？好きな人が思い人に使うとか一言も言ってないですよね？ね？

It blew up in the title. But the heartbreak hasn't been confirmed yet, is it? right? You haven't even said a word about someone you like using it for others, right? right?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

湖の善き魔女とその庵でのお伽話の様な…

It's like a fairy tale about The Good Witch of the Lake and her hermitage...

This review contains spoilers. 作品が始まった頃はすごく興味を持って続巻を待ち侘びていたのですが、なかなかお話が進行せず、原作2巻の前半の方まで読みそのままにしていた為、コミカライズが少し進んだ事もあって読み返してみました。穏やかに進行するあまり起伏の無い物語なのですが、空気感はとても好きでした。盛り上がったのは3巻での不法侵入者の場面だけで、改めて読み返してみて、「好き〜！」と思っていた印象がしぼんでしまったのはすごく残念！！原作1巻はコミカライズ4巻までです。

This review contains spoilers. When the work began, I was very interested and waited impatiently for the next volume, but the story didn't progress easily, and since I kept reading the first half of the original 2 volumes, I reread it, partly because comicalization progressed a bit. It's a story that progresses smoothly and there aren't many ups and downs, but I really liked the atmosphere. The only thing that made me excited was the Unlawful Intruder scene in volume 3, and I reread it again and said, “I like it!” It's so disappointing that the impression I was thinking about has faded away!! 1 volume of the original story is limited to 4 volumes of Comicalize.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 18, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

親近感の持てる魔女

Familiar witch

魔女、ということにはなっているけれと、どこかにいても不思議ではない、親近感の持てる存在です。無理やり魔女たということで何かをこじつけることもなく、とても読みやすく、応援したくなります。

Although they are called witches, it's no wonder that they are close to them. The fact that I was forced to become a witch doesn't bother me anything, it's very easy to read, and I want to cheer for it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 18, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

読みやすい

readable

This review contains spoilers. 設定とかストーリーに物足りなさはある。めちゃくちゃ盛り上がる展開とかは無いんだけどとにかく読みやすい。

This review contains spoilers. The setting and story are unsatisfactory. There aren't any insanely exciting developments, but it's easy to read anyway.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 17, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

4巻まで

Up to 4 volumes

This review contains spoilers. 「湖の善き魔女」ロゼと、王宮の近衛騎士ハリージュのお話。タイトルが物語のすべてを言い表しています。魔女であるロゼが、王都に出た際一目惚れしていたハリージュから惚れ薬の調合を依頼されることから始まります。何だかんだで惚れ薬が完成し、効果の確認のためにロゼが少量の惚れ薬を試しに飲んでみるのですが、このシーンがとても素敵。ここまで比較的淡々としていたストーリーが急にキュンキュンしだします。ロゼが可愛すぎます。元々片想いしてるのに、惚れ薬…。惚れ薬を言い訳にちょっと自分の気持ちに素直になるところ、可愛いけれど切ないです。そして同じシーンのハリージュ視点の小説が収録されているのが、これまた良かった！いつも付き合う女性とは違うロゼに戸惑うところが可愛い。4巻ではとうとう！とうとう両想いに！冒頭ハリージュが自覚したところからキュンキュンきていましたが、惚れ薬事件その2が起こり、薬が切れたところでプロポーズ！これが萌えずにいられるでしょうか？（いや、無理ｗ）ただ、盛り上がりはここまで。ロゼが恥ずかしがり屋過ぎて距離が縮まる速度が遅すぎます。好きも言えないし（言ってるようなものですが）手をつなぐのも素直になれない。一緒に住むのもウダウダ悩んで、夜だけハリージュのお家にお邪魔する。モダモダも過ぎればイライラの素。とりあえずこの巻で原作小説1巻部分が終了とのことで、次巻からもこの調子だとちょっと微妙かな。今後の動向が非常に気になります。ところで、この作品で一番好きなのが主役カプではなくビッラウラ様。こういう王族の矜持を持った王女様…切ないけれど素晴らしいですね。異世界ものを読んでいると、色々王族としてあり得ない人物が登場しますが、彼らに彼女の生き様を見て欲しい。彼女が幸せになったという描写があって本当に良かったです。ロゼも彼女くらい思い切りが良ければなぁ…と思ってしまいました。

This review contains spoilers. A story about “The Good Witch of the Lake” Rose and Harry Rege, the Knight Guards at the Royal Palace. The title says everything about the story. It starts when Rose, the witch, is asked to prepare love potions by Haliju, whom she had fallen in love with at first sight when she went to the royal capital. Somehow the love potion was completed, and Rose tried taking a small amount of love potion to confirm the effects, and this scene was very nice. The story, which had been relatively dull up to this point, suddenly starts to creep in. Rose is too cute. I originally had an unrequited love, but love medicine... The place where you can be a little honest with your feelings using love medicine as an excuse is cute yet sad. Also, it was great that a novel from Khaleej's point of view with the same scene was recorded! The fact that I'm confused by Rose, who is different from the woman I always go out with, is cute. Finally in volume 4! At last, we have both feelings! At the beginning, Haliju was thrilled from where she became aware, but the love drug incident part 2 happened, and when the medicine ran out, they proposed! Is it possible to keep this from happening? (No, that's impossible lol) However, the excitement has reached this point. Rose is too shy and the speed at which the distance shrinks is too slow. I can't say I like it (it's like I'm saying it), and I can't honestly hold hands. I'm worried about living together, so I only visit Haliju's house at night. Too much moda is a source of frustration. Anyway, the first volume part of the original novel is over with this volume, so it's probably a bit subtle if it continues like this from the next volume. I'm very concerned about future trends. By the way, what I like the most about this film is Villaura, not the lead actor cap. A princess with this kind of royal pride... sad but wonderful. When I'm reading Isekai Monogatari, various people from the royal family appear, but I want them to see her way of life. I'm really glad there was a depiction of her becoming happy. I wish Rose was as bold as her...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 15, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

私も欲しい

I want it too

ほれ薬、私も欲しい…と、思いながら読みました。男女問わず、誰か私に惚れて等と思いながら笑。ストーリーですが、じわじわと距離を縮めていく二人が微笑ましい。魔女ヒロインは、男性慣れしていないわりに、自分の要求をカレにできていて感心！

I read it while thinking, “Hey, medicine, I want it too...” Regardless of gender, I thought someone would fall in love with me lol. As for the story, the two people who are slowly shortening their distance make me smile. I'm impressed that the witch heroine was able to make her own demands on her boyfriend even though she wasn't used to men!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 09, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になります

I'm worried about the continuation

１巻まで読みました。ヒロインのずぼらなとこが少し気になるけど、おもしろかったです。騎士は外見も中身も良い人で好感が持てました。

I've read up to volume 1. I'm a little worried about the heroine's sloppiness, but it was interesting. I liked the knight because he was a good-looking and good-looking person.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 08, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

タイトル通り

As the title says

タイトル通りのストーリーです。以前に読んだことがあり、失恋感情から始まっていく切ない展開、儚げヒロインと記憶していたけど、読み返したら割とヒロイン、ヒーローおちょくってるな！？想い人が親しい仲って設定なら好意の裏返し的な感じで揶揄うパターンって割とあるけど、ほぼ初対面の想い人に対しておちょくれる神経、結構図太い笑ヒーローもこんなに隠しもせず不機嫌顔連発してたっけ？？と記憶との差異にちょっと戸惑いました笑あと前読んだ時も思ったけど、王宮騎士、ヒマなの？笑そんなに時間あるんか？？笑街外れに一人ひっそりと暮らすずぼらな魔女と意外と面倒見の良い王宮騎士のすれ違い、交流を通してじわりじわり恋になるお話です。

This is the story as the title says. I've read it before, and I remember it as an ephemeral heroine, a sad development that begins with feelings of heartbreak, but when I reread it, I'm making fun of the heroine and hero quite a bit!? There are quite a few patterns where the lover is set to be on a close relationship, and ridicule them with the opposite feeling of favor, but the nerves that make fun of the person they have almost met for the first time, the big lol hero didn't hide it so much and had a series of grumpy faces?? I was a little puzzled by the difference between my memory lol and I also thought when I read it before, but is The Royal Knight free time? lol do you have that much time?? lol it's a story about a sloppy witch who lives quietly alone on the outskirts of town and a royal knight who is surprisingly easy to take care of each other, and they slowly fall in love through interaction.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 08, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ほっこり

Relaxed

This review contains spoilers. 一人暮らしでちょっと危なっかしい魔女のロゼと、騎士のハリージュのお話です。惚れ薬の素材をわざと1個ずつ伝えて会える機会を増やすロゼちゃんなかなかいい性格してておもしろい。お菓子を持ってきてくれるようになるハリージュとのやり取りが微笑ましいです。ロゼのピンチの時も助けてくれて、お屋敷で暮らすようになって…とふたりの仲が進展していくのににまにまします。

This review contains spoilers. This is a story about Rose, a witch who lives alone and is a little dangerous, and Khaleige, a knight. Rose-chan, who deliberately conveys the ingredients of love potions one by one to increase opportunities to meet, has a pretty nice personality and is interesting. The interaction with Haliju, who starts bringing me sweets, makes me smile. They helped Rose even when she was in a pinch, and now they live in a mansion... and the relationship between the two progresses even as it progresses.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 08, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

魔女がかわいい。ほんとは素直な性格なのが餌付けされてる所に出てるのが良い。急展開というより、ゆっくり進んでいくストーリーで読みやすい。

Witches are cute. It's good to show up where they are being fed because they really have an honest personality. Rather than a sudden development, the story progresses slowly and is easy to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 08, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

少しづつ二人の間が縮まっていって

Little by little, the space between the two is shrinking

This review contains spoilers. 森に囲まれた湖の中にある小島に暮らす湖の魔女ロゼ。彼女の家に行くには、船で湖を渡らなければならない。外部との接触をできる限り排除し穏やかな生活をおくってきたのだが、ある日騎士が訪ねて来て、彼女に惚れ薬を作ってほしいと依頼する。その日から彼女の生活ががらっと変わってしまうのだ。ロゼは魔女の祖母と二人で暮らしてきたが、その祖母が4年前に亡くなり一人になった彼女は薬の材料を買いに街にでた。そこで祖母の悪口を聞くがそれを庇ってくれた騎士に一目惚れをしたロゼだったが、まさにその彼が自分を訪ねてきて惚れ薬を作ってほしいと言っているのだ。私の失恋が決まってしまった……。惚れ薬の材料をあれやこれやと彼に小出しで頼むロゼに若干切れそうになりながら、その要求に応えるために、ロゼのもとに通い続ける騎士ハリージュ。二人の仲が少しづつ縮まっていく様子が微笑ましい。惚れ薬は妹の様に思っているお姫様に頼まれたものだったというのがいいいですね。なんだか読んだことがあるような気がしたのですが…「小説家になろう」のコミカライズ作品でした。

This review contains spoilers. Rose, the lake witch, lives on a small island in a lake surrounded by woods. To get to her house, you have to cross the lake by boat. They have been living a peaceful life by eliminating contact with the outside world as much as possible, but one day a knight visits and asks her to make love potions. From that day on, her life changed drastically. Rose has lived with her grandmother, who is a witch, but when her grandmother died 4 years ago and she was alone, she went to town to buy ingredients for medicine. I heard her grandmother speak ill of it there, but Rose fell in love at first sight with the knight who sheltered her, and that is exactly what she wants is to visit her and make love potions. My heartbreak has been decided... Knight Harry Joo continues to go to Rose in order to respond to that demand, while almost running out of rose to ask him for this and that ingredients for love potion in small portions. The way the relationship between the two shrinks little by little makes me smile. It's nice that the love potion was requested by a princess who thought like her little sister. I felt like I had read it before... it was a comicalized work of “Let's Be a Novelist.”

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 07, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

4巻まで最高

Up to 4 volumes maximum

This review contains spoilers. 絵も綺麗でじれったいやり取りが好きな方にはとてもおすすめです！4巻までで大体一区切りしてるんですが、5巻からは第二章スタートって感じです。4巻まで本当に楽しめましたが、私には人気だから無理に続いてる様に思えてしまいました。次巻はないかなー。ハリージュさん5巻からキャラもデザインも崩壊ぎみ…顔が変で内容も変。

This review contains spoilers. I highly recommend it to those who like beautiful pictures and casual communication! There is roughly one section up to volume 4, but it feels like chapter 2 starts with volume 5. I really enjoyed up to volume 4, but since it was popular to me, it seemed impossible for me to continue. I wonder if there will be a next volume. The characters and design have collapsed since Harry Ju-san volume 5... the face is strange and the content is also different.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 07, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

配分がいい

The allocation is good

魔女の子テンションがちょうどいい、読んでいてこちら迄安定してくるし惚れ薬を作る過程は美しく楽しい。こういう世界にゆっくり浸るのは癒されます。

Demon Girl's tension is just right, it stabilizes up to this point while reading, and the process of making love potions is beautiful and fun. Slowly immersing yourself in this kind of world is healing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

雰囲気が最高に好き

I like the atmosphere the best

最初から相思相愛で溺愛っていう作品では無いです。しかしその分しっかりと過程を楽しめるような物語で、徐々に近づく2人の距離と、焦れったい雰囲気が最高に素敵です。ふんわりとした絵柄も相まって、ゆったりと楽しめます。

It's not a work of mutual love and doting from the beginning. However, it's a story where you can enjoy the process so well, and the distance between the two gradually getting closer and the impatient atmosphere are so wonderful. Coupled with the fluffy pattern, you can relax and enjoy it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

良い

good

タイトルがやっぱりおかしいだろ!と突っ込みたくなるやつは、やっぱり読んでて面白いので、結果、気になり全部読む。

the title is really strange isn't it! After all, the ones that make you want to dive in are interesting to read, so I read them all because I was curious about the results.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 01, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

乙女ごころ

Otome Gokoro

This review contains spoilers. 森の外れに住む魔女ロゼ。一目惚れした彼に惚れ薬をつくって欲しいと依頼される。それと同時に失恋してしまいます。でも恋しいひとの顔を見るために、小出しに薬の材料を求めます。乙女心です。

This review contains spoilers. Rose is a witch who lives on the outskirts of the forest. The guy I fell in love with at first sight asks me to make love medicine. At the same time, I'm heartbroken. But in order to see the face of the person I miss, I ask for medicine ingredients in small doses. It's a maiden heart.

Helpful

Reviews for Hi, I'm a Witch, and My Crush Wants Me to Make a Love Potion Manga