Hi, I'm a Witch, and My Crush Wants Me to Make a Love Potion Manga Reviews (P.16)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 05, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

小説も

Novels too

先に小説を読んでいた作品のコミカライズってことで購入しました。話は勿論大好きですが、絵もとても綺麗で買って正解でした。小説も漫画もどっちもお気に入りの作品です！

I bought it because it was a comicalization of the work I had read earlier. Of course I love the story, but the picture was also very beautiful and I bought it, which was the correct answer. Both novels and comics are my favorite works!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 05, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった！！！

That was interesting!!!

漫画の絵がとても可愛く、物語も好みで面白かったです！小説の方も気になって読みましたが、二人の絡みが可愛くて楽しめました！漫画続編待ってます*

The manga pictures were so cute, and I liked the story, so it was interesting! I was also interested in reading the novel, but the entanglement between the two was so cute that I enjoyed it! I'm waiting for the manga sequel*

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 03, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

はまってしまいました。

I'm addicted to it.

立ち読みで気になり購入。その後も気になりノベルの方も購入してしまいました。コミックの方の絵も好みなので、続きも購入すると思います

I bought it because I was interested in standing reading. Even after that, I was curious and bought a novel too. I also like pictures from comics, so I think I'll buy more

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 01, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

魔女がかわいい

Witches are cute

絵がとてもきれいで読みやすい。あと魔女殿がとてもかわいい。これからどんな展開になるのかとても楽しみです。

The pictures are very beautiful and easy to read. Also, the witch hall is so cute. I'm really excited to see what developments will take place in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 31, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

小説が良くて買いました！

The novel was good and I bought it!

先に小説の方を読んで、好きな話だったので漫画も気になって買っちゃいました。絵がとても綺麗できゅんきゅんしてるロゼの表情がすごく可愛いです！！

I read the novel first, and since it was a story I liked, I was interested in comics and bought them. The picture is so beautiful and Rose's jaw-dropping expression is so cute!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 31, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

良かったです！

That was great!

絵がとても綺麗で、背景や景色も素敵で読みやすいです。お話しもテンポが良く、主人公も可愛く応援したくなります…続きが早く読みたい！

The pictures are very beautiful, and the background and scenery are nice and easy to read. The story has a good tempo, and the main character is cute and makes me want to cheer... I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 31, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

いいです

It's good

テンポも良く、絵も良く、すごく入り込めます。割引のクーポンを獲得したら小説も読みたいとワクワクしています。

The tempo is good, the pictures are good, and it's really immersive. I'm excited to read novels once I get a discount coupon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 30, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

いいですね〜

That's great ~

This review contains spoilers. 顔がいい、に毎回にこにこさせてもらってます！これからも頑張ってください！

This review contains spoilers. I have a nice face and make me smile every time! Please keep up the good work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 29, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

可愛いらしくて素敵

It looks cute and nice

絵もストーリーも最高に可愛いです。1巻では少しずつ打ち解けていく感じがコミカルに描かれています。続き早く読みたい！

The pictures and story are so cute. Volume 1 comically depicts the feeling of getting along little by little. I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 29, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

最高に良い

The best

小説からとっても好きなお話しでした発売されたのに気づいた時は嬉しくて思わず息を飲みました笑マンガも最高に良い！ロゼ可愛い！ハリージュもかっこいい！続きがとってもとっても待ち遠しいです！

It was a story I really liked from the novel, and I was so happy that I took my breath when I noticed it was on sale lol the manga is so good too! Rose is cute! Haliju is cool too! I really, really can't wait for the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ラノベファンも納得のコミカライズ!

Comica rise that even light novel fans are convinced of!

小説で読んで、ホントに大好きすぎで。こういう時、コミックになって絵がイメージと違ってたりするとガッカリしてしまうのですが、キャラも風景も、ロゼのお家もイメージを超えてました!ロゼの表情が可愛い。森の風景も素敵で早くも2巻が楽しみです!おすすめです!

I read it as a novel, and I really loved it so much. At times like this, I'm disappointed when it becomes a comic and the picture is different from the image, but the characters, scenery, and Rose's house all surpassed the image! Rose's expression is cute. The forest scenery is also wonderful, and I'm looking forward to volume 2 as early as possible! I recommend it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 27, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ティエン推し！

I recommend Tien!

小説から入りましたが、その時からティエン推し‼漫画で読むと動きがあってさらに良い〜?4年前から気になってた騎士様から惚れ薬を頼まれて内心イヤながらもお仕事として引き伸ばしながらもちゃんと惚れ薬を作るように頑張る魔女ちゃんのお話?ほのぼので落ち着く?

I started with novels, and I recommend Tien from then on ‼ If you read it in comics, there's movement and it's even better ~? A story about a witch who is asked for love potion by a knight she has been interested in since 4 years ago and works hard to make love potion properly even though she doesn't like it but stretches it out as a job even though she doesn't like it? so heartwarming that calms you down?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 27, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

無愛想紳士✖️無表情魔女

unfriendly gentleman ✖️ expressionless witch

ときめきすぎて原作小説も読破してしまいました！２巻も楽しみにしています。

I was so excited that I read through the original novel too! I'm also looking forward to volume 2.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 27, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

すごくオススメです！

I highly recommend it!

絵柄も繊細なタッチでとても綺麗で、少女漫画好きの方は好きだと思います。続きが気になる作品です！

The design is also very beautiful with a delicate touch, and I think those who like girls' manga will like it. I'm worried about the continuation of this work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 13, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

進み具合が遅いかな

I wonder if progress is slow

This review contains spoilers. 話の内容は楽しいけれどなかなか進まないのが歯がゆい6巻まで読んでいるのですがまだ完結まではかかりそう？ストーリーはとてもいいと思う魔女に秘薬を依頼しに来た王宮騎士その王宮騎士に4年間片思いしていた魔女魔女(ロゼ)は少しでも彼といたくてわざと時間をかけて秘薬を作るその間にお互いの愛が深まる(特にヒーローの方がおちてしまいましたね)でもヒロインの気持ちがなかなか前進しなくて進行速度はかなり遅い(魔女殿素直になって欲しい…マジで)ここまでテンポ良かったし内容も楽しかった中盤から速度が遅くなったからうーんって感じ…ストーリーはいいと思う軽く説明すると前半に事件がありヒーローと結婚する事に(絶対読んだ方がいいから内容9.5割端折りまくってます)もっとテンポが良ければ最高なのになぁヒーローの素直でヒロインの気持ちを最優先で考える優しさ「魔女」という立場も守ろうとしている行動とても素敵だと思うただ…魔女殿を「あんた」って呼ぶのだけはやめて欲しいよ「ロゼ」でいいじゃん(泣)

This review contains spoilers. The content of the story is fun, but it doesn't progress easily because I've read up to 6 volumes of Itchy Teeth, but it seems like it will still take until it's over? I think the story is very good, the royal knight who came to ask the witch for an elixir for 4 years, and the witch witch (rose), who had a crush on that royal knight for 4 years, their love for each other deepens during that time (the hero in particular fell down), but the heroine's feelings didn't advance easily, and the progression speed was pretty slow (I want the witch to be honest... seriously) the tempo was good up to this point and the content was fun I feel like hmm because I think the story is good... I think the story is good because there was an incident in the first half and I ended up getting married to the hero (the content is broken up by 9.5 percent) it would be great if the tempo was better, the hero's honesty and kindness, putting the heroine's feelings first, and I think the act of trying to protect the position of a “witch” is very wonderful, but... I want you to stop just calling the witch “you” That's right (crying)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

穏やかでいい

It's nice to be calm

派手なバトルや嫌がらせの応酬とかありませんが、それが逆にいい感じです。人馴れしない主人公が　もどかしい！と思うこともあるけど、丁度いいテンポで話しが進むのでイライラすることもなく穏やかで可愛い恋愛感がいいと思います。応援したくなりますね。

There are no flashy battles or harassment exchanges, but on the contrary, it's a nice feeling. The unfamiliar protagonist is frustrating! There are times when I think, but since the conversation progresses at just the right tempo, I think it would be nice to have a calm and cute sense of romance without getting frustrated. It makes me want to cheer them on.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 18, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

雰囲気がとても良い

The atmosphere is very good

This review contains spoilers. とある騎士に4年前から片思いしている若い魔女。ある日、惚れ薬を作ってほしいと片思い中の騎士がやってきて…。両片思いっぽい雰囲気の物語です。切ない空気を描くのが抜群に上手い作家さん。

This review contains spoilers. A young witch who has had a crush on a certain knight since 4 years ago. One day, a knight I have an unrequited love for me comes and wants me to make love potions... It's a story with an atmosphere similar to two unrequited love. An artist who is extremely good at drawing sad air.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ちゃんと魔女と騎士

Properly witches and knights

魔女も騎士もしっかり仕事している中でリアルな距離の縮め方と言いますか、好感の持てる漫画だなと思いました。進みが遅いので打ち切りになるかもと不安ですが、続きが楽しみです。ロゼ、かわいい。

While both the witch and the knight are doing their job well, I thought it was a comic that I liked because it was a realistic way to shorten the distance. Progress is slow, so I'm worried that it might be canceled, but I'm looking forward to the continuation. Rose is cute.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

魔女様と騎士様のピュアな恋愛模様を堪能

Enjoy the pure love pattern between a witch and a knight

世間ずれしていない、というか世間知らず過ぎる魔女様と騎士様のお話。もう初々しいし、恋愛に向かっていく過程のもどかしさについては、ぜひ作品を読んでじっくり堪能していただきたいです。

A story about a witch and a knight who isn't out of touch, or rather too naive. It's already fresh, and I want you to thoroughly enjoy the frustration of the process of moving towards love by reading the work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

惚れ薬を作り中

Making love potion

This review contains spoilers. 魔女として惚れ薬を作るように好きな人から依頼された令嬢の物語。色んな薬草など材料が出てきて面白い。主人公はイケメン好きなんだなと思った。二人の恋がうまくいって欲しい。

This review contains spoilers. This is the story of a young girl who is asked by her favorite person to make love potions as a witch. It's interesting that ingredients such as various medicinal herbs have come out. I thought the main character likes good-looking guys. I want their love to go well.

Helpful

Reviews for Hi, I'm a Witch, and My Crush Wants Me to Make a Love Potion Manga