[Oshi No Ko] Manga Reviews (P.25)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

イチオシ作品?

recommended work?

This review contains spoilers. エンディングが賛否わかれるが、私は結構好き。ある意味ハッピーエンドだと思う。個人的に「愛」とは「生きていく希望」だと伝えたかった作品なのかと解釈。アクアが妹ルビーの未来を守るためにとった行動、深すぎる。他人の幸せの為に身を挺するって凄いと思う。色々な解釈があると思うけれど、私はキャラクターたちがアクアの死をきっかけに人間的に深みが増し、それぞれの道を進んで行く最後好きです。生きている限り立ち止まってはいられない、自分の力で立ち上がっていくしかない！

This review contains spoilers. There are pros and cons to the ending, but I like it quite a bit. I think it's a happy ending in a sense. Personally, I interpreted it as a work that I wanted to convey that “love” is “hope to live.” The actions Aqua took to protect her little sister Ruby's future are too deep. I think it's amazing to stand up for someone else's happiness. I think there are many interpretations, but I like the end where the characters have increased their human depth in the wake of Aqua's death, and they go their separate ways. As long as I'm alive, I can't stop; I have no choice but to stand up with my own strength!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

！！

!!

This review contains spoilers. アニメで見たけどまず、タイトルの意味そう推しの子です、主人公が思ってた人と違いました。地味なおじさんです。

This review contains spoilers. I saw it in the anime, but first of all, the title means that it's a recommended kid; the main character was different from who I thought. He's a plain old man.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

あとは個々人で考察しよう

After that, let's consider it individually

最終巻まで読みました。色んなテーマが語られている漫画ですね。生死、人間の欲、能力や才能、現代特有の問題、、、何をテーマとして捉えるかは個人により違うでしょう。そして、答えもそれぞれ個人で違う。テーマを詰め込み過ぎている印象と、しっかり消化出来ないまま最終回を迎えてしまった印象は拭えません。あとは個々人で考察して消化するしかないですね。とても面白かったし引き込まれたけど、作者さん達は何を言いたかったんだろうか。最後の方は愛という言葉が連発されていて愛がゲシュタルト崩壊してました。それと、幅広いテーマを提供しているのに登場人物の年齢層が若年層に偏っていることも、何か、薄っぺらさを感じた理由だと思いました。

I read until the last volume. It's a comic that talks about various themes. Life and death, human greed, abilities and talents, issues peculiar to the present day... will differ depending on the individual. Also, the answers are different for each individual. I can't erase the impression that the theme was packed too much, and the impression that the final episode was reached without being able to fully digest it. After that, we have no choice but to consider and digest it individually. It was very interesting and drew me in, but what did the authors want to say? At the end, the word love was repeated, and love had collapsed as a gestalt. Also, even though it offers a wide range of themes, I think the fact that the age group of the characters is biased towards younger people is also a reason why I felt that it was flimsy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

好きだけど、、、

I like it, but...

面白かったと素直に言っていいのかわからない作品でした。読み終わってから心がぐるぐるする感じ、スカッとは全然しない終わり方でした。これはこれでいいんだけど、、、ハッピーエンドが好きな方にはおすすめできません。色々な愛の形みたいなものを描いた話だと思います。

It was a work I honestly didn't know if I could say it was interesting. It felt like my mind was spinning round and round after I finished reading it, and it wasn't a quick ending at all. This is fine, but... I don't recommend it to those who like happy endings. I think it's a story depicting things like various forms of love.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

端折って駆け足で雑にムリヤリ終わった感

The feeling that it ended sloppily in a hurry

This review contains spoilers. 伝説のアイドル、アイの妊娠、出産、死。その子どもとして転生した医者吾郎とその患者さりなを描いた物語。吾郎は亡くしてしまった患者の影響でアイを推している。アイが妊娠した状態で自分の病院に来院、アイの出産を直前にして何者かに殺され、前世の記憶をもったままなぜかさりなともども転生するという複雑な設定。読者は誰がどういった理由でアイと吾郎を手にかけたのか、なぜ吾郎とさりなは転生したのか疑問に思いながら読み進める。物語は前世の憧れにして現世では自分の母親のアイのようなアイドルを目指すさりな（現世ではルビー）と母親殺害の犯人探しをする吾郎（現世ではアクア）の二軸で展開される。登場人物たちのキャラがそれぞれよく立っており、とても面白く読み進めてきたのだが、これから話が盛り上がっていって何回かどんでん返しがくるような局面のように思ってたところで突然話が雑にまとめられてうっす〜い感じで終わってしまった。作者さんに何かあったのかもしれないけど、この雑で駆け足な終わり方はそれまではキャラ一人一人が丁寧に描かれてきただけに本当に残念だった。丁寧に最後までいってたら、伝説のマンガになってたように思う。本当に残念。

This review contains spoilers. Pregnancy, childbirth, and death of the legendary idol Ai. A story about doctor Goro, who was reincarnated as that child, and his patient Sarina. Goro is recommending Ai due to the influence of patients who have lost his life. It's a complicated setting where Ai comes to her hospital while pregnant, is killed by someone just before Ai gives birth, and reincarnates for some reason even though she has memories of her previous life. Readers read on while wondering who picked up Ai to Goro and why, and why did Goro and Sarina reincarnate. The story unfolds on two axes: Sarina (Ruby in this world), who admires her previous life and aims to be an idol like her own mother's Ai in this life, and Goro (Aqua in this life), who searches for the culprit of her mother's murder. Each of the characters stood up well, and it was very interesting to read on, but when I was thinking that the story was getting exciting and going back and forth a few times, the story was suddenly put together in a sloppy manner and ended up feeling dull. Something may have happened to the author, but this sloppy and quick ending was really disappointing because each character had been carefully drawn until then. If I had made it all the way to the end, I think it would have become a legendary manga. It's really disappointing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 17, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

楽しかったです！！

It was fun!!

でもここまでの展開を考えるともっと感情がぐわーーっと乱高下してもよかったと思う。なんかあぁそうだよねぇそうなるよねぇーって感じだった。泣いたけど！あぁ～ってなったけど！！面白いは面白かったです！！

But when I think about developments up to this point, I think it would have been nice if my emotions were even more volatile. I felt like, ah, that's right, that's going to happen. I cried though! It turned out to be ahhh!! What was interesting was interesting!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 17, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

全体的には面白いけど最後が駆け足すぎた

Overall it's interesting, but the last one was too quick

最終巻は色々駆け足で尺不足だったのか打ち切りにでもあったのかと疑いたくなる現実としてはあんな感じだろうけど、もっとキャラ事の描写を増やすか視点を絞るべきだった

It's probably like that in reality that makes you wonder if the last volume was running out of scale or if it was even canceled, but I should have narrowed down my point of view on whether to increase the number of depictions of character matters

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 13, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

あ

Ah

友達が好きだから見たら面白いキャラクターが可愛いです。ただキャラクターの描き分けが出来ていないと思います。

I like my friends, so the characters that are interesting to watch are cute. However, I don't think I was able to draw the characters separately.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

良かったです。

That was great.

色々好きですが中でも一番はシリアスでのキャラクターの感情表現です。様々な方法を使ってのそれは中々なものでした。あと芸能界の裏を書く描写もちょっと好きです。

I like a lot of things, but the most of them is the serious emotional expression of the characters. Using a variety of methods, it was all sorts of stuff. Also, I like the depiction of the backstory of the entertainment industry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いです

It's interesting

This review contains spoilers. 勧められて読み始めたばかりですが、面白いです。人気アイドルの主治医と、アイドルの熱狂的ファンが前世の記憶を持ったままアイドルの子供として生まれ変わるという設定も良くて、ここからどうなるのか先の話が気になります。

This review contains spoilers. I just started reading it after being recommended, and it's interesting. The setting where the attending physician of a popular idol and an enthusiastic fan of the idol are reborn as idol children with memories of their previous lives is also good, and I'm curious about what will happen from here on out.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

This review contains spoilers. 1巻から衝撃的で、表紙の通りアイドルになりたい女の子の青春漫画かと思いきや。え？ホラー？サスペンス？な展開に。でも読み進めていくと恋愛要素も入っていたりしてページを進める手が止まらない作品です。

This review contains spoilers. It was shocking from volume 1, and as the cover suggests, I thought it was a youth comic about a girl who wants to be an idol. huh? horror? suspense? What kind of development. However, as I read on, it also contains romantic elements, and it's a work where I can't stop moving forward through the pages.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる

I'm worried about the continuation

This review contains spoilers. 初めて1巻を読んだときおもしろすぎて衝撃を受けた！！！すげえ！！！転生したら〇〇だった系は好みじゃないけどこれは好き！続きが楽しみです……！

This review contains spoilers. When I first read volume 1, I was shocked because it was so interesting!!! that's amazing!!! I don't like the series that was 00 when I got reincarnated, but I like this one! I'm looking forward to the continuation...!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

よきよき

Good good

胸がきゅっとなる作品。たいていの漫画は再度読むのが自分の通例であるが、この作品は読み直そうとは思わなかった。それは面白くないからではなく、まあ読んでみれば分かる。

It's a work that makes my heart feel tight. It is my custom to reread most comics, but I didn't think I'd reread this work. It's not because it's not interesting; you can understand it by reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 28, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

芸能界の闇と青春

The darkness and youth of the entertainment industry

This review contains spoilers. 芸能界×転生×復讐×青春と、とにかく面白い要素がつまってます。憎しみや嫉妬も描かれているけれど、主人公の非情になりきれない善性や、周りのキャラたちの暖かさが、重いストーリーにも光を加えていて、ぐいぐい読み進められます。

This review contains spoilers. The entertainment industry x reincarnation x revenge x youth are all packed with interesting elements. Hate and jealousy are also depicted, but the protagonist's ruthless goodness and the warmth of the characters around them add light to the heavy story, and you can proceed with the reading.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

想像と違った

It was different from what I had imagined

アイドルが育っていくとかアイドルメインの話しかなと思っていたけど、そんな単純な話ではなかったです。サスペンス要素も少しありでアイドルの表だけでなく裏側が見えておもしろいです。

I thought it was just about idols growing up or idolmain stories, but it wasn't such a simple story. There's also a bit of suspense, and it's interesting to see not only the front but also the back side of the idol.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

芸能の裏

Behind the performing arts

途中ガラスの仮面みたいだなとは思ったのですがやっぱりイマドキの内容と芸能の裏が細かく書かれてて楽しいいろんなメディアに出てるので食わず嫌いな人もいるかもしれないけど見る価値あり

I thought it was like a glass mask along the way, but after all, the content of Imadoki and the back side of the entertainment are written in detail and appear in a variety of fun media, so there may be people who don't like it without eating it, but it's worth watching

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメを見てたので読んでみた

I was watching an anime, so I read it

転生ものでも最初から衝撃的で読み始めました。現実でも起こりえてるのかなと思いつつ､これからが楽しみです！

I was shocked right from the beginning and started reading even though it was reincarnated. While wondering if it's happening in real life, I'm looking forward to the future!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 23, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

生まれ変わり

reincarnation

This review contains spoilers. 生まれ変わる転生ものですが、異世界でもなく自分の推しの子に生まれ変わってしまうという、嬉しいのかなんだかわからない生まれ変わりをします、凄い展開です。

This review contains spoilers. It's a reincarnation where you're reborn, but it's an amazing development where you're reincarnated not in another world, and you're reincarnated without knowing if you're happy or not.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 23, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

‼

‼

推しの子は、様々な要素にたけており、愛や推し、希望など色々な欲求をまたしてくれる作品だと思います。

I think it's a work that excels at various elements, and I think it's a work that brings back various desires such as love, recommendation, and hope.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

まさかの展開！

Unexpected development!

This review contains spoilers. 第一話からは予想できない展開が続きどんどん引きこまれるストーリーはとても素晴らしい作品だと思う最後はどうなるのか楽しみ

This review contains spoilers. I think the story where unpredictable developments continue from the first episode and I'm drawn in more and more is a very wonderful work, and I'm looking forward to seeing what happens at the end

Helpful

Reviews for [Oshi No Ko] Manga