[Oshi No Ko] Manga Reviews (P.24)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 16, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

最高

highest

This review contains spoilers. 絵が綺麗だしとても面白いマジで沼るこれからの展開がとても楽しみ

This review contains spoilers. The picture is beautiful and very interesting, I'm really looking forward to the future development of Seriously Swamp

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 28, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

つらい！

that's hard!

This review contains spoilers. ハピエン厨なので辛いです…‼あの方法じゃなくても上手くいく方法きっとあったはずよー！賢いから思いつくはずよー！と思わずにいられない。。。でも芸能界ウンチクも含め、引き込まれて読んだ作品でした。

This review contains spoilers. It's a happy kitchen, so it's painful... ‼ I'm sure there was a method that worked even if it wasn't that method! It's smart, so you should be able to come up with it! I can't help but think... But it was a work I was drawn in to read, including the entertainment industry Unchiku.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 11, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

うまく言葉にできませんが、

I can't put it into words very well,

アイドルという縁遠い存在の辛さや大変さをほんの少しだけ垣間見たような気分になりました。いつもキラキラぴかぴかしている彼ら彼女らが、裏ではどんなに努力をしているのかとかも考えさせられて、私達は彼ら彼女らの表側部分だけしか見れていなかったのかも、と。まあ裏側を見る手段は私達には早々ないわけですが。それでもとても色々なことを考えさせられる作品でした。

I felt like I had caught just a small glimpse of the pain and difficulties of being an idol. It also made me think about how hard they are doing behind the scenes, and I wonder if we were only able to see the front side of them. Well, we don't have a quick way to look at the other side. Even so, it was a work that made me think about so many things.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 29, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

よくできたエンタメ

Well done entertainment

話の縦糸は、母親殺しの犯人探しと復讐に燃える転生者の物語。そこへインフルエンサーやリアリティーショーといった現代のエンタメ業界の仕組みや裏側、芸にかける若者の昔ながらの根性ドラマ、いろんなタイプの美少女との恋の鞘当てなどの横糸を絡める、非常に良くできたエンタメ。個人的にはツクヨミいない方が良かったと思うので⭐️４

The plot of the story is the story of a revenge reincarnator searching for the culprit who murdered his mother. There, the structure and backside of the modern entertainment industry, such as influencers and reality shows, it is a very well-made entertainment that involves weaves such as old-fashioned gutsy dramas of young people involved in performing arts, and scabbards of love with various types of beautiful girls. Personally, I think it would have been better not to have Tsukuyomi ⭐️ 4

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 25, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

復讐ものとして好きです

I like it as revenge

This review contains spoilers. 最終回に対して一時期ネットで色々言われていましたが、復讐ものの最期としては珍しい、むしろ救われた形だと思っています

This review contains spoilers. There was a lot of talk about the final episode on the internet for a while, but I think it's rare for the end of revenge, and I think it's rather a form of being saved

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 18, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いのにもったいない…

It's funny but it's a waste...

ストーリーはよく出来てるし、話も面白いのに話が要所要所で飛ぶし、なんでこんな展開になるのかわかんないってところもあるし、いきなりぽっと出のキャラ(ツクヨミ)の説明もないし。外伝に載せるんじゃなくて本編に組み込んで欲しかった。キャラのブレも激しすぎる。黒川あかねとか最初のキャラから振り切れすぎてる。長期連載でキャラ振れはよくあるけど、そういうのは大抵、キャラの成長とかをちゃんと本編に組み込んでるのに、あかねちゃんはいきなり変わりすぎ。なんか作者目線で面白いものを組み込んだって感じの作品かな。もっと読者目線で書いて欲しかった。

The story is well-made, and even though the story is interesting, the story flies at key points, there are places where I don't understand why it unfolds like this, and there are no explanations for the characters (Tsukuyomi) that suddenly pop up. I wanted it to be incorporated into the main story, not in Gaiden. The character blurring is also too intense. I'm too excited from the first character like Akane Kurokawa. There are many character variations in long-term serialization, but that kind of thing usually involves properly incorporating character growth and the like into the main story, but Akane-chan suddenly changes too much. I think it's a work that incorporates something interesting from the artist's point of view. I wish they had written more from a reader's point of view.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 23, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

単純に面白い

It's simply interesting

アニメ化されて有名なので読んでみましたが、サスペンス要素ありで確かに面白いです。絵は好みでないものの、キャラとストーリーがしっかりしているので読み応えあります。

It was made into an anime and is famous, so I read it, but it certainly is interesting because it has suspense elements. I don't like the pictures, but the characters and story are solid, so it's worth reading.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 22, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

心が決まった

My heart has been decided

This review contains spoilers. 紙のコミックスを読了。（1～6巻のみ）元から恋愛リアリティーショーは悪趣味だと思っていましたが、今作を読んで絶対にそのような番組は絶対に観ないことを心に決めました。

This review contains spoilers. I've read the paper comic. (Volume 1 to 6 only) From the beginning, I thought romance reality shows were bad taste, but after reading this film, I made up my mind that I would never watch such shows.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 19, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

終わり方が

The way it ends

芸能界の闇がよくわかった作品でした。現実的で、時には残酷でした。終わり方が納得できなかった。アクアの生まれ変わりの意味それがはっきりしたのは分かった。ただ、もう少し夢を見せてくれてもいいじゃないか。重曹ちゃんとの明るい未来を描いてくれてもいいじゃないか。本当に辛かった。

It was a film that clearly understood the darkness of the entertainment industry. It was realistic, and at times cruel. I wasn't convinced how it ended. I understand that the meaning of Aqua's reincarnation was clear. However, wouldn't it be nice if you showed me some more dreams? Wouldn't it be nice if you could draw a bright future with Juso-chan? It was really painful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 18, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

初めを我慢すると展開が面白い

The development is interesting if you put up with the beginning

This review contains spoilers. 初めの方は若干キモッと感じたところもあったのですが、そこを乗り越えてミステリ要素が入ってきてからはストーリーの続きが知りたくてどんどん読み進めてしまいました！全体の流れには影響ないのですが、アイがベビーシッターも雇っていないのに寝不足・ストレスゼロっぽいのと、さりなちゃんのの母親だけが悪者に描かれていて、父親については無罪放免的な扱いなのは、違和感があったので星一つマイナスで。

This review contains spoilers. There were places where I felt a bit creepy at the beginning, but after overcoming that, the mystery element came in, I wanted to know the continuation of the story, so I read on and on! It doesn't affect the overall flow, but the fact that Ai doesn't have a babysitter but lacks sleep and seems to have zero stress, and that only Sarina-chan's mother is depicted as the bad guy, and the fact that her father is treated in an acquittal manner is one star negative because there was a sense of incongruity.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 14, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が好き過ぎました！

I loved the picture too much!

This review contains spoilers. キャラクターのデザイン特に目の描き方がやっぱり凄く好きです！お話は設定が入りにくい所があるので、個人的には⭐️マイナス1って感じです！

This review contains spoilers. After all, I really like the character design, especially the way the eyes are drawn! There are places where it's hard to set up the story, so personally I feel like ⭐️ minus 1!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 14, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

東京ブレイドのキザミ覚醒シーンが好き♡

I like the Kizami Awakening scene in Tokyo Blade ♡

This review contains spoilers. 双子の兄妹の話。大分前に読んだのにも関わらず、レビューを忘れていました。アニメ3期スタートするのを受けて、書いてみようかと。。。もう乗っけから釘付けになる話の作りで、双子が産まれてアイさんが逝く前までの話と、アクアがドラマに出たり舞台に出るところが、大好きでした。そこだけ何度も読み返したいくらい。でもそのあと、生まれ変わってからの最大の目的、『復讐』『敵討ち』をする話は正直、辛くて悲しくてきつかった。もう読みたくないくらいです。だから最後はなんであんなことになるのかと、今でもどうにか夢であって欲しいと思うくらいです。しかし、これだけ人の心に傷を植え付けてくる物語、読むのを後悔させる話の展開はないかもしれない。それが赤坂先生と横槍先生の作戦なら、大成功ですよ、ここに、アクアのあの場面で、呼吸が苦しくなった読者います。

This review contains spoilers. A story about twin brothers and sisters. I forgot to review it even though I read it a long time ago. In response to the start of the 3rd season of the anime, I thought I'd write it... It's a story that you'll be glued to right from the start, and I loved the story from when the twins were born until Ai passed away, and the fact that Aqua appeared in dramas and appeared on stage. I just want to reread that over and over again. But after that, to be honest, the story of “revenge” and “enemy attack,” the biggest purpose since being reborn, was painful, sad, and tough. I don't even want to read it anymore. So I wonder why it happened at the end, and I still want it to be a dream somehow. However, there may be no development of a story that instills so much hurt in people's hearts or that makes them regret reading it. If that was Akasaka-sensei and Yokoyari-sensei's strategy, it would be a huge success; here is a reader who had trouble breathing during that scene in Aqua.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 25, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

一気読み

Read it all at once

This review contains spoilers. お薦めされて読み始めたけど、読み出したら止まらず一気に読みました。読むほどストーリーに引き込まれました。ただ、アクアには生きてて欲しかったので☆マイナス1にしました。アクアが生き残ったうえでのラストを考えることは出来なかったのかなーって、そこが残念でたまりません。

This review contains spoilers. It was recommended and I started reading it, but once I read it, I couldn't stop and read it all at once. The more I read, the more I was drawn into the story. However, I wanted Aqua to live, so I set it to ☆ minus 1. I wonder if I wasn't able to think about the last time Aqua survived, and that's unfortunate and irresistible.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

最終話だけ、マジでどうした？？

Just the last episode, seriously what happened??

This review contains spoilers. ストーリーもイラストも本当に面白かった。アクアの結末に納得できないという意見もあるだろうが、ひっかかったのはそこじゃない。なんで最終話がほぼモノローグ？？しかもルビーじゃなくて黒川あかねの？それだけがすごくモヤモヤする。なんの効果狙ったのか知らないけど……アクアが居なくなった後に必死で頑張っているキャラクター達の描写は沢山あったのに、それをモノローグで終わらせるのか？キャラのセリフじゃだめなのかな？モノローグというより文章での説明って感じで、なんか安っぽい印象に落ちてしまっている気がする。ページの都合上、巻きで終わらせないといけなかったのか？最終話の内容は、2、3話かけてゆっくりやれば良かったんじゃないかと思う。最終話は酷いけど、直前まではすごく良かったから星4つです。

This review contains spoilers. The story and illustrations were really interesting. There may be opinions that they aren't satisfied with the outcome of Aqua, but that's not where I got caught. Why is the final episode almost a monologue?? What's more, it's Kurokawa Akane instead of Ruby? That alone makes me really confused. I don't know what effects they were aiming for, but... there were a lot of depictions of characters who were desperately trying their best after Aqua disappeared, so are you going to end it with a monologue? I wonder if the character's lines aren't good? It feels like an explanation in sentences rather than a monologue, and I feel like I've fallen into a cheesy impression. Did I have to end it with a roll due to page reasons? As for the content of the final episode, I think it would have been better if I spent 2 or 3 episodes slowly. The final episode was terrible, but it was really good until just before, so it's 4 stars.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 15, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

タイトルとは裏腹

Contrary to the title

タイトルや華やかな物語の大筋とは全然違う、登場人物の背景が複雑に重なり合う、ある意味サスペンス的なお話だった。登場人物が場面場面で物語の中心になり、特にメインのキャラは誰として見たらいいのかわからなくなる複雑さもあった。最後の選択は意外でもありアクアらしくもあり…誰も救われない終わり方だった様に感じた。それでも物語を通して人それぞれの悩み苦しみや様々な想いを抱えながら、光を求めて光を道標それが何かしらの推しである人もいて生きる意味や力になる可能性を秘めているというメッセージ性のある話で深い内容だった。

It was a suspenseful story in a sense where the backgrounds of the characters overlapped intricately, which was completely different from the title and the general outline of the glamorous story. The characters became the center of the story in scene scenes, and in particular, there was also the complexity of not knowing who to watch as the main character. The final choice was both surprising and aqua-like... I felt like it was an end where no one was saved. Nevertheless, it was a deep story with a message that while each person has their own worries, suffering, and various feelings throughout the story, it is a story with a message that it has the potential to be a meaning and power for life in search of light, and there are people who have some kind of recommendation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 29, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

芸能界ってこんな感じなんだろうなぁ

I wonder if the entertainment industry is like this

This review contains spoilers. 芸能界に興味無いけどこんな感じなんだろうなぁと思いながら読み進めました。有馬カナ推しとしては幸せになって欲しかったなぁ。終わり方に否定的なコメント多いけどオレ的には嫌いじゃないかな。でも少しでも良いからアクアとカナちゃんは付き合って欲しかったなぁ。カナちゃん可哀想過ぎでしょ。こんなヒロインいますか？オレは白いサイリウムを振り続けるよ！

This review contains spoilers. I'm not interested in the entertainment industry, but I read on while wondering what it would be like. As Arima Kana's recommendation, I wanted her to be happy. There are a lot of negative comments about how it ended, but I don't think I like it. But even a little bit is fine, so I wanted Aqua and Kana-chan to go out with each other. Kana-chan is too pitiful, isn't she? Is there a heroine like this? I'll keep waving white psyllium!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 23, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

最初から怒涛の面白さ

Furious fun from the beginning

This review contains spoilers. 1巻からめちゃめちゃ面白いです主人公死んで生まれ変わりますえええっと何度思ったことでしょうかそこからの仕上がっていく過程その過程もかなり面白い

This review contains spoilers. It's really interesting from volume 1, the main character dies and is reincarnated, huh, how many times did you think? The process of finishing from there on that process is also pretty interesting

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 05, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ようやく完結読了

Finally finished reading

This review contains spoilers. ブームが来ていた時に中盤まで読んでいましたが、だんだん芸能関係の相関図が飲み込めなくなってきてしまい一時中断していました。ようやく、今になって読了。ところどころ前半の伏線？は朧げになってしまったところはありましたが収まるところに落ち着いたのかなという感想。壮大な風呂敷を全部畳もうとはしなかったのかな？にしても最後まであかねの理解者っぷりはすごかった。かなやルビーにとっては突然の出来事であまりに酷い結果になってしまったけど。ルビーが立ち直ったのは良かったけど、優しい愛(嘘)で固められたアイドルなのだとしたらその後は少し心配。何はともあれ、連載お疲れ様でした。楽しみました！

This review contains spoilers. I was reading it until the middle when the boom was coming, but I gradually became unable to swallow the correlation chart related to entertainment, so I stopped for a while. At last, I finished reading it now. A foreshadowing of the first half here and there? There were places where it became blurry, but I have the impression that it has settled down where it fits. I wonder if they didn't try to fold up all the magnificent furoshiki? Even so, it was amazing how many people understood Akane until the end. Kanaya, it was a sudden event and the results were too bad for Ruby. It was great that Ruby got back on her feet, but if she's an idol solidified by gentle love (lies), I'm a little worried after that. Anyway, thank you for the serialization. I enjoyed it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 30, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

芸能界の闇と光

The darkness and light of the entertainment industry

This review contains spoilers. アニメを見て漫画を読もうと思いました芸能界の裏側について描かれていて面白いなと思いましたまた絵が可愛くて目の表現が凄い！アイドルに幻想を抱いていたりアイドルの裏側を見たくないとか思う人は読まない方がいい気がします結構ドロドロしてると思います

This review contains spoilers. I thought I'd watch anime and read comics. I thought it was interesting because it was drawn about the other side of the entertainment industry. Also, the pictures are cute and the expression of the eyes is amazing! I feel like people who have fantasies about idols or don't want to see the other side of idols should not read it; I think it's pretty muddy

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 15, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

好みの問題？

A matter of taste?

This review contains spoilers. ただの転生でなく、推理あり演技あり恋愛ありで面白い。けど感情移入しただけに、最後は好みが分かれるかと…。ハッピーエンドが好きなので、、読み返したくなくなった…。主人公自信の夢はかなわず、転生の意義が虚しい…。それでも奇跡的に助かった…であってほしかった…

This review contains spoilers. It's not just reincarnation, it's interesting with reasoning, acting, and romance. But just because I empathized, I wonder if their tastes will split at the end... I like happy endings, so I don't want to reread them... The protagonist's dream of confidence doesn't come true, and the meaning of reincarnation is futile... Still, it miraculously saved me... I wanted it to be...

Helpful

Reviews for [Oshi No Ko] Manga