Polaris at Dawn Manga Reviews (P.16)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

先生生徒もの

Teacher student stuff

先生生徒ものは苦手なのですがこれは面白い！嘉島先生はキャラデザがもともと上手な先生だと思っていたけどこのカプの描き方は本当に最高でした！そっちを可愛い感じにするのか！1巻のみのレビューです

I'm not good at teacher student stuff, but this is interesting! I thought Kashima-sensei was originally a good character designer, but this way of drawing capu was really amazing! Does that make it feel cute! This is a review of volume 1 only

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

気づいたら全部読んでた

I had read them all before I knew it

This review contains spoilers. 由良先生あまりにも可愛いんだもん。美人なんだもん。仕方ない。私も羽賀くんの勢いに便乗してしまった気がする。

This review contains spoilers. Yura sensei is too cute. she's beautiful. It can't be helped. I feel like I've piggybacked on Haga-kun's momentum too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 20, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

純愛、一途

Pure love, one way

高校時代先生と生徒から始まってからの音信不通からの再会。長い長い片思いでしたね。生徒と先生だった頃の話が凄く可愛くて好きでした！！元気いっぱいで。そこからの音信不通が、もう切なくて・・・。どうなることかとハラハラしました。煌星の成長っぷりにやられましたね。良い男に成長したなぁ。

A reunion with my high school teacher and student since I was in bad communication. It was a long, long unrequited love. The story from when I was a student and teacher was so cute and I loved it!! Be full of energy. The lack of communication from there made me sad anymore... I was shocked to see what would happen. You've been able to do so much that the brilliant stars have grown. He's grown into a good man.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 13, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

笑

lol

This review contains spoilers. この借り物競争ヤバイ（笑）「ダンディな人」って（笑）で、ヒゲの先生連れてったら、「眼がキュートだから可愛い系なので却下」とか。判断基準が自分目線過ぎて笑える。それは置いといて、チャラくて入れ食い状態だった男子高校生がほぼ一目惚れで美人な先生（♂）を押しまくる。チャラかったのに本気で好きになった人が出来て一途にってお話。

This review contains spoilers. This rental competition is dangerous (laughs), and when I take my bearded teacher, they say “they're cute because they have cute eyes, so they dismiss it.” The criteria for judgment are too much from my own point of view, which makes me laugh. Leave it behind, and the male high school student, who was flustered and fed up, almost falls in love at first sight and pushes over the beautiful teacher (♂). It's a story about someone who I really fell in love with even though it was a joke, and I went all the way to the story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 11, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

最初は

initially

This review contains spoilers. 教師と生徒もの。最初は芳賀くんのチャラい性格と由良センセーあっさりちゅーされちゃってるところですぐ両想いになるのかな～と思っていたのですが、ところがどっこいでした。まさか6年も空白期間があるとは。気がつけばせつない純愛物語になっていて、うわ～どうなるの～と引き込まれます。もだもだが長かったので、ハッピーエンドでほっとしました。絵の雰囲気もすごく好みでよかったです。

This review contains spoilers. Teacher and student stuff. At first, I was wondering if Haga-kun's charismatic personality and Yura Sensei were so easily teased that they would soon fall in love with each other, but that was amazing. I wonder if there is a gap period of 6 years. It's a pure love story where you can't notice it, and I'm drawn in by wow ~ what's going to happen ~. Momodama was a long time, so I was relieved to have a happy ending. I'm glad I really liked the atmosphere of the picture.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 07, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

This review contains spoilers. 最初は自分勝手で子供っぽい高校生がグイグイ攻めててなんだか面倒くさいな…なんて思ったけど、2巻の後半からだんだん面白くなりました。1巻で読むのやめなくてよかった！2巻の柊真メインの描き下ろしが切なかった…てか全体的に柊真は切なかった。いつか柊真も幸せになれますように。

This review contains spoilers. At first, I thought the selfish, childish high school students were attacking so fast that it was kind of bothersome... but it gradually became interesting from the second half of volume 2. I'm glad I didn't stop reading it in volume 1! The drawing of the main novel of volume 2 was sad... Heck, overall, Hiiragi Makoto was sad. I hope one day Hiiragi Makoto will be happy too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

先生と生徒

teacher and student

This review contains spoilers. 禁断の関係だけど一目惚れっぽく軽やかにスタート。からの…なんか重そう（立読みのみ）。高校生ならではの勢いで真っ直ぐ向かっていくのは好印象。受けは超美人教師、攻めは生徒。まあ生徒から攻めるしかありえないよねぇーグイグイいくのが小気味いい。3巻で6年経ってるのにまだ追いかけてるの凄い純愛で良い。たまたま男同士なだけで少女漫画みたいなピュアさ感じる。

This review contains spoilers. It's a forbidden relationship, but it starts off lightly, like love at first sight. From... it seems kind of heavy (standing reading only). Going straight ahead with the momentum unique to high school students is a good impression. The recipient is a super beautiful teacher, and the attackers are the students. Well, there's no choice but to attack from the students, huh, it's creepy to go so fast. It's good that they're still chasing me even though 6 years have passed in volume 3, so pure love. I feel pure like a girls' manga just because they just happen to be men.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ラスト、感動します。

Last one, I'm moved.

This review contains spoilers. 正直はじめはこのモテイケメンがいきなり先生×男にいかないでしょ…とテンション落ちてましたが、昔の辛い想いを浄化できるまで、自分も先生になり、待ち続けるところに感動！

This review contains spoilers. To be honest, at first I was moved by the fact that this popular guy wouldn't suddenly become a teacher x man... but until I was able to purify my old painful feelings, I became a teacher myself, and I was moved by the fact that they kept waiting!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

初めは遊びから始まった恋だったが

At first, it was a love that began with play

This review contains spoilers. スクールカースト最上位の人気者羽賀に、英語教師の由良はモーションを掛けられ続けている。体育祭の借り物競争では「美人」のお題で、お姫様抱っこされて全校生徒の前でキスされてしまう。初めは単なる遊びだったが、全く相手にされずに何度も告るうちにしだいに本気になっていった羽賀だった。由良は幼馴染の養護教諭の柊真のことが好きらしいが、なんとかして自分に目を向けさせようする羽賀だった。遊びから本気の恋になって…何年にも渡って自分の気持ちを支配するような恋になることもあるのだと、羽賀の恋を見て思いました。

This review contains spoilers. English teacher Yura continues to be moved by Haga, the most popular person in the school caste. In the sports festival rental competition, a princess is hugged and kissed in front of all the students under the theme of “Beautiful Women.” At first, it was just a game, but it was Haga that gradually became serious as she told it over and over again without being dealt with at all. Yura seems to like her childhood friend Makoto Hiiragi, a school teacher, but somehow it was Haga who made her look at herself. From play to serious love... I saw Haga's love and thought that there are times when it becomes a love that controls one's feelings over many years.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 02, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が変わっちゃった

The picture has changed

作者さんの絵がめっちゃ好きなんですが、今回すっごくかわいいというか子供っぽい…残念。。話は悪くなく、攻めが軽すぎる感じはしますが今後期待！

I really like the artist's paintings, but this time they're so cute, or rather childish... too bad... The story isn't bad, and I feel like the attack is too light, but I'm looking forward to the future!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

可愛い絵柄とのギャップが…?

Is there a gap with cute designs...?

This review contains spoilers. 可愛い絵柄からすぐにラブラブになるのかと思いきや、こんなにシリアスだとは思わなかった。一途さが切なくて途中はキツいけど、最後は泣けてしまった。

This review contains spoilers. I thought the cute design would quickly make you fall in love, but I didn't think it was this serious. It was tough along the way because it was too sad, but it made me cry at the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

絵もストーリーもかわいい！1巻読了

The pictures and story are so cute! Read volume 1

This review contains spoilers. The陽キャ1軍男子高校生×美人英語教師生徒×教師っBL作品って距離感がバラバラですが、これは近からず遠からずだと思いました。初っ端の時点でゼロ距離なんですけどね^_‎^;由良は美人系ながらも中身はしっかり者で頼られる先生で、佐賀は「陰とか陽とかどうでもよくね？」と思ってそうな真の1軍。本能のまま動く佐賀に真面目な由良が翻弄されている姿が見所でした。個人的にはもっと教師と生徒には一線を引いてほしいなーと思ったので、展開の早さに置いていかれました?由良の幼なじみや過去が伏線としてすごく気になります！

This review contains spoilers. The sense of distance is mixed in The Yang Kya 1st Army High School Student x Beautiful English Teacher Student x Teacher and Teacher BL film, but I thought this was neither close nor far away. At the beginning, it was zero distance, wasn't it? ^_‎ ^; Yura is a teacher who is beautiful yet has solid content and can be relied upon, and Saga said, “It doesn't matter if it's yin or yang, right?” It seems like I thought it was a true 1st Army. The sight of serious Yura being at the mercy of Saga, who moves according to instincts, was a highlight. Personally, I wanted more teachers and students to draw a line, so they left it up to the speed of development? I'm really curious about Yura's childhood friends and past as foreshadowing!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 28, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

３巻完結、深いお話でした

Volume 3 is complete, it was a deep story

一巻冒頭の明るいテンションでいくのかと思いきや、思ってたよりも重いお話でした。プロットが練り込まれていてオリジナリティがありました。攻めの煌星くんがなかなか報われず可哀想でした。でもいいお話でした。後半泣きました。作画も綺麗。

I thought it would go with the bright tension at the beginning of volume 1, but it was a heavier story than I had anticipated. The plot was well thought out and there was originality. It was a pity that the attacking Kosei-kun wasn't easily rewarded. But it was a good story. I cried in the second half. The drawing is also beautiful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

んー。長い！

huh. long!

2巻3巻は260p超え。めちゃくちゃ切ないし多分気持ちは測りしれないけど、、長い。。3巻に至っては別の作品のように感じてきました。もちろん前巻があっての3巻なのですが。。ストーリーは好きだし、切なさも、年月の長さ、それぞれの描写もちゃんと好きだけど完結まで持っていくのに少し長くて途中気持ちが切れてしまった。もう少し短くまとめてくれた方が感動できたかも？

Volume 2 volume 3 is over 260 p. It's insanely sad, and I probably can't measure my feelings, but... it's been a long time... When I reached volume 3, I felt like it was a different work. Of course, it's volume 3 with the first volume... I liked the story, and I really liked the sadness, length of time, and depiction of each one, but it was a bit long and I lost my feelings along the way. Maybe it would have been more impressive if you put it together a little shorter?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 29, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

1巻を読みました

I read volume 1

This review contains spoilers. 先生が可愛くて眼福。主人公は陽キャで人生楽しそう。陰キャが主役はよく見るけど、ここまで周りがチヤホヤしてくれる主人公って、意外とありそうで少ないと思います。青春が眩しくて羨ましいわあ。

This review contains spoilers. The teacher is cute and looks great. The main character is Yo-Ka and seems to enjoy life. I often see Yin Kya in the lead role, but I don't think there are many protagonists who make people laugh this far. My youth is so dazzling that I envy you.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

泣きましたね...

I cried...

2巻まではもうモダモダが過ぎて最早イライラしながら読んでて、コレが後何巻も続くようならもう読まんわ!!と息巻いてからの新刊告知でしたが。泣きました。いや、まさかのこの展開ですか...。重い...重いよどいつもこいつも...。でもね、ぴったりかっちり収まります。純愛と言うなら純愛だし、執着とも紙一重だし。とにかくまぁ気になったら読んでください。汚れた腐女子は心が洗われた気がする逸品です。

Up to volume 2, the moderation was already over and I read it while getting frustrated, and if this continues for many more volumes, I won't read it anymore!! It was a new publication announcement after I had taken a breath. I cried. No, was this development unexpectedly... it's heavy... heavy, but these guys are always... But it fits perfectly and snugly. If you say pure love, it's pure love, and there's a fine line between obsession. Anyway, please read it if you feel like it. The dirty rotten girl is a gem that makes me feel like my heart has been washed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

This review contains spoilers. きつい場面が何度もあるけど続きが気になってしまう漫画で由良ちゃんをいつまでも待てる諦めない心の強さが普通に尊敬レベル。辛い過去から解放されないからむずむずすることも多いけど最高です。

This review contains spoilers. It's a comic where there are many tough scenes but I'm worried about the continuation, and the strength of not giving up that can wait forever for Yura-chan is usually a level of respect. It's often painful because you're not freed from your painful past, but it's awesome.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 27, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

禁断！

Forbidden!

先生と生徒の恋ってこっちまでドキドキしちゃってめっちゃ好きです。しかも先生美人すぎて。まつ毛がもうばっさばさです

I really love the love between a teacher and a student because it's so exciting. What's more, the teacher is too beautiful. My lashes are already big

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

難攻不落

impregnable

美人な先生受け、イケメン生徒攻めの作品ですがどうやら先生には事情があるようで・・・一つ受け入れても更にその先に障壁があり、ある意味BLゲー攻略のような感じも受けました。

It's a work that takes on a beautiful teacher and attacks handsome students, but apparently the teacher has circumstances... even if you accept one, there is a barrier further beyond that, and in a sense, I also received the feeling that it was a BL game capture.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

早く3巻クダサイ。。。

Hurry up, volume 3, Kudasai...

2巻が、、、思いがけず切なかった。。。ちょっとグッと胸が苦しくなってしまった。。。読み易いからすごく内容がストレートに響いてくるのです。。。どうか早く3巻をクダサイ・・・‼

Volume 2... was unexpectedly sad... It made my heart ache a little... It's easy to read, so the content resonates very directly... Please do volume 3 as soon as possible... ‼

Helpful

Reviews for Polaris at Dawn Manga