Haru's Curse Manga Reviews (P.16)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 25, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

独特の絵ですが、とても深い内容でした。姉の心の葛藤、現実、亡くなった妹の知られざる裏の気持ち。読み応えのある作品でした。

It was a unique picture, but the content was very deep. My older sister's emotional conflict, reality, and my deceased sister's unknown feelings behind her. It was a well-read work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 22, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

セリフがすごい

The lines are amazing

文字数が多くてちゃんと読むのにかなり時間がかかるけど、セリフまわしとかすごい。何度読んでも読み応えがある。

There are so many characters that it takes quite a while to read it properly, but the line changes are amazing. It's worth reading no matter how many times I read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

なんか難しい！

Something difficult!

来世は他人がいいが大好きでこちらも読みました。やっぱりありきたりな感じじゃなくて小西先生らしい作品だと思います！でもちょっと難しい

I read this too because I love that others are good in the next life. After all, it's not an ordinary feeling; I think it's Konishi sensei's work! but it's a bit difficult

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

思っていたよりアッサリ

Faster than I expected

This review contains spoilers. 死んでしまった妹の春の姉の夏美と、春の恋人だった冬悟の恋愛話です。春のSNS発見は確かに呪いだなと思いましたが、実際には親からの呪縛の方が２人を苦しめていたのでは？と思ったり。ラストで、家出をして新しい人生を歩みだす２人を見て、とても綺麗にまとまっているなと思いました。正直な感想として、面白い、というよりは良く出来ているな、という印象です。

This review contains spoilers. This is a love story between her younger sister Haru's older sister Natsumi, who has died, and Fugo, who was Haru's lover. I thought the spring SNS discovery was certainly a curse, but in reality, the spells from their parents tormented them both? or something like that. At the end, I saw two people running away from home and starting a new life, and I thought they were very nicely organized. As an honest impression, I have the impression that it is well-made rather than interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買い

Buy the artist

This review contains spoilers. 病床の妹が、勝手に姉に向けている黒い気持ちが怖い。無味無臭の毒のような悪意？が呪いに感じられてゾッとします。残された二人には、幸せになって欲しいです。

This review contains spoilers. I'm afraid of the dark feelings my younger sister is giving to my sister in her bed without permission. Malice like tasteless, odorless poison? It feels like a curse and I'm horrified. I want the two people left behind to be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 14, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

気になって気になって

I'm worried I'm worried

一気読みしてしまいました。暗くて重い話ですが何度も読み返したくなるような作品です。

I read it all at once. It's a dark and heavy story, but it's a work that makes you want to reread it over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

正に呪い

Exactly curse

暗かったけど話は面白かった。ただ、人物の描きわけ苦手なんかなぁと感じた。来世は〜のメイン２人と同じ顔、雰囲気。主人公の好きな顔があるのかな

It was dark, but the story was interesting. However, I felt like I wasn't good at drawing people. The next life has the same face and atmosphere as the two main people in... I wonder if the main character has a favorite face

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 28, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

2人の想いが切ないっ

the feelings for the two of them are sad

「来世は他人がいい」とは雰囲気が違いますね。雰囲気もキャラクターも静かな感じです。恋愛を持つことに罪悪感を感じていることも、見ていて辛い。ただ、最後の雰囲気が好きでした。

The atmosphere is different from “others are good in the next life.” Both the atmosphere and characters are quiet. It's also painful to watch that they feel guilty about having a relationship. However, I loved the atmosphere at the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 06, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

納得のいく展開とラスト

Convincing developments and endings

悲劇からの始まりで、こんな悲しいお話、綺麗にまとまるの？？？と、途中すごく心配でしたが、とても納得のいく展開とラストで、すごい作家さんだなぁ！と改めて思いました。今後もずっと応援したい作家さんです。

It started with a tragedy, and can such a sad story come together neatly??? I was really worried along the way, but it was a very convincing development and end, and he's an amazing writer! I thought about it again. This is an artist I want to continue to support in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 01, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

いつもなぜか作者買い

I always buy the author for some reason

This review contains spoilers. この作者さんのキャラには感情移入出来ないことが多いのですが、何故かいつも根こそぎ買ってしまいます。自分が死んだ後なら恋人が誰と付き合おうが良いじゃん(相手が姉でも)って妹には思うし、姉の妹への愛情が重過ぎるしで、共感できるトコはあまり無い。でもきっとこの異常感を気に入ってる気がしてます。(来世は〜の方なんてもっと異常ですが、エキセントリックでどっちも好きです。)

This review contains spoilers. I often can't empathize with this author's characters, but for some reason I always buy them out of the blue. My sister thinks it's okay for her lover to go out with after I die (even if my partner is my older sister), and my sister's love for her younger sister is too heavy, so there aren't many places I can sympathize with. But I'm sure they like this sense of aberration. (The next life is even more abnormal, but it's eccentric and I like both.)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 24, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

春の呪い

Spring Curse

This review contains spoilers. 何故だか引き込まれる作品。妹の好きだった婚約者の惹かれ合う話。そんなことは許されないと想いを封じようともがく部分が、現実的で良かった。重いというか、楽しい内容の話ではないけれど、他の作品も含め、続きが気になってしまう。

This review contains spoilers. It's a work that draws me in for some reason. A story about my sister's favorite fiancee being attracted to each other. I'm glad that the part where I struggle to seal my feelings when such things are not allowed is realistic. It's not a heavy, or rather, fun story, but I'm worried about the continuation, including other works.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 18, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

生きるってこうゆうこと。

This is what it means to live.

矛盾や不安をいーっぱい抱えた状態でも共に生きようと思える相手に出会えたのは幸福だと思うな。春の呪いを共に背負う覚悟を持つ過程がリアルで、いや、実際はもっと想像にも及ばないほど苦しいんだろうな～って漠然としか分からないけど様々な愛の形があるんだって素直にそう思いました。最後の振り返っても居ない春の呪いに2人で出した答えが妙に心に残りました。死んだ人は実際に居なくなる。生きてるってことはそれだけでおもいが呪いになる事もあれば生きる糧になる事もあるんだって色々考えさせられた物語でした。

I think I'm happy that I was able to meet someone I would like to live with even when I had so many contradictions and insecurities. The process of being prepared to carry the Spring Curse together is real, and I honestly thought that there are various forms of love even though I only vaguely understand that in reality it would be more painful than I could even imagine. Strangely enough, the answer the two of them gave to Haru no Curse even when looking back at the end stuck in my mind. Dead people will actually be gone. It was a story that made me think a lot about being alive that alone, feelings can be a curse, and there are times when it is food for life.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

まさに｢春の呪い｣

Exactly “Spring Curse”

春というタイトルは季節を指す言葉かと読む前は思っていたのですが、亡くなった妹の名前だったのです。そして呪いが題材というわけでもなく。死人に口なし…。死者に謝りたいことがあっても、もう許しを乞う機会すらないのです。罪悪感を抱えたまま、今後一生知ることはできない死者の気持ちに怯えて生きなければならない。罪の意識で自ら｢春｣という存在の｢呪い｣にかかるのです。正直絵柄は全く好きじゃありませんし、絵が上手いとも思えません…。物凄い男前という設定の冬吾も、描写で初めて｢あ、イケメンの絵なんだコレ｣と思っちゃいました。そんなわけで私は全然好きになれない絵柄です。が、物語の題材や、描写の仕方など惹き込まれるものがあり、この作家さんが人気なことに頷けるなぁと思うだけの魅力は感じました。妹が死んだことはとても悲しいのに、妹の彼氏であった冬吾に惹かれてしまった夏美の気持ちも、妹と半ば政略結婚のように付き合っていた冬吾が夏美に惹かれていた気持ちも理解できる。妹の春がそんな二人に気づき始めて、大好きな姉だったはずなのに、彼のこととなると私が死んだとしてもくっつくなんて許さないと思う気持ちもとてもリアルだなと思いました。｢お姉ちゃんと幸せになってね｣なんて言い出すお綺麗な物語の方が世の中には多いと思います。その分余計にリアルだなと思いました。だからこそ辛いし、でも死んだ彼女がこれからを生きる彼らの思いを縛り付ける権利もなくて…。それでもやっぱり春を思うとこれからも生き続ける二人はずっと辛いと思います。この呪いから解き放たれることはきっとないだろうと。二人に呪いを残して死んでいった春はズルいと思うし、春が亡くなって二人で生きる道を選んだ夏美と冬吾も春からすればズルいと思います。春が亡くならなければ、この先何年たとうとも夏美と冬吾が付き合うなんて未来はなかっただろうなと思います。この二人が不倫とかするとは思えないし。人生何があるか分からないし、春が死んでしまって、こんな未来になったんだろうな、と。何気ない日常の物語が、沢山のメッセージを持ってリアルに綴られている。そんな作品に感じました。

Before I read that the title Haru is a word indicating the season, I was wondering if it was the name of my sister who passed away. And it's not like curses are the subject. dead people don't talk... Even if there are things I want to apologize to the dead, I don't even have a chance to ask for forgiveness anymore. While feeling guilty, we must live frightened by the feelings of the dead that we will never know for the rest of our lives. With a sense of guilt, they themselves fall under the “curse” of existence called “spring.” To be honest, I don't like the design at all, and I don't think I'm good at drawing... Fuygo, who is set to be extremely handsome, also thought “Oh, this is a picture of a handsome man” for the first time in the depiction. That's why I don't like the design at all. However, there were things that drew me in, such as the subject of the story and the way it was depicted, and I felt that it was so appealing that I could nod that this writer was popular. Even though I'm so sad that my little sister died, I can understand Natsumi's feelings of being attracted to Fuygo, who was her younger sister's boyfriend, and the feeling that Fuygo, who had a relationship with her sister in a half-political marriage, was attracted to Natsumi. My younger sister Haru began to notice these two people, and even though they must have been my favorite older sister, I thought that when it came to him, the feeling that they wouldn't allow me to stick together even if they died was also very real. I think there are many beautiful stories in the world that say, “Be happy with your older sister.” I thought that was extra real. That's why it's so hard, but when she died, she didn't have the right to bind their thoughts to the future... Even so, when I think about spring, I think it will be much harder for the two of them to continue living from now on. I'm sure they won't be freed from this curse. I think Haru, who left a curse on the two of them and died, was cheating, and I think Natsumi and Fuygo, who chose to live together after Haru passed away, would also cheat if they started. If Haru hadn't passed away, I don't think there would be a future for Natsumi and Fuygo to be in a relationship for years to come. I don't think these two are going to have an affair. I don't know what life holds, and Haru is dead, and I wonder if the future is like this. A casual everyday story is realistically spelled out with many messages. I felt like it was such a work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 01, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

題材は重いけど…

The subject is heavy, but...

来世は…からこの本も知って購入。一気に読み終えました。タイトルが絶妙だなぁという感じで、重いんだけど、どんどん引き込まれて、途中で読むのをやめられない。正直、絵が苦手だったのですが、それでもこの作者さんの今後は追いかけてしまう事になりそうです。

I also learned about this book from Next Life... and bought it. I finished reading it all at once. I felt like the title was exquisite, and although it was heavy, I was drawn in more and more, and I couldn't stop reading it along the way. To be honest, I wasn't good at painting, but even so, it seems like I'll be chasing this artist in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 30, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

本当に「春」の呪い。

It really is a “spring” curse.

This review contains spoilers. 読んだらその意味が分かる、「春の呪い」。タイトルが秀逸です。ヒロイン「夏美」と、夏の妹「春」の婚約者だった「冬吾」の独白をメインに、そこに時おり春のいる回想シーンを混じえながら、季節の移り変わりと共に小説のような物語が進んで行きます。早い段階から読者には両思いであると分かっているのに、夏美は妹を裏切る罪悪感から、冬吾は家の呪縛に縛られていて本音を出さず、終始どんよりとした暗い雰囲気を纏っています。そしてそれがこのお話の不思議な魅力にもなっていました。他の方も書かれていますが、2巻からこの独特な空気感が少し薄れて軽いテンポになってしまったように感じました。あれだけ長くウジウジ悩んでいたのに、急に思い切りが良くなってしまい、あの葛藤は何だったのかと…。それでも冬吾が人生で唯一望んだ夏美と共に前に進めたのは良かったし、この本を購入して後悔は無いです。可能であれば読み切りでも何でもいいのでその後の２人が見たいです。

This review contains spoilers. If you read it, you'll understand the meaning of “Spring Curse.” The title is excellent. Mainly based on the monologue of the heroine “Natsumi” and “Fugo,” who was the fiancee of Natsu's younger sister “Haru,” the novel-like story progresses as the seasons change, while occasionally mixing recollection scenes with Haru in it. Readers know from an early stage that they have both feelings, but due to the guilt of betraying her younger sister, Fuygo is bound by a house spell and doesn't reveal her true intentions, and has a dark, overcast atmosphere from beginning to end. And that also became the mysterious appeal of this story. Other people have also written it, but I felt that this unique atmosphere faded slightly from volume 2 and became a light tempo. Even though I had been bothering about it for so long, I suddenly got better at it, and I wonder what that conflict was... Nevertheless, it was good that Fuygo was able to move forward with Natsumi, the only thing he wanted in his life, and I have no regrets buying this book. If possible, I'd like to watch the next 2 people because anything is fine, even if it's one-off.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 27, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ずっと気になってました。

I've always been curious about it.

他の方のレビューにもありましたが、小説のような流れでストーリーが進んでいると思いました。絵はあまり好みではありませんが、内容で★4。

There were reviews from other people, but I thought the story was progressing in a novel-like manner. I don't really like the picture, but in terms of content ★ 4.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 24, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

言い得て妙なタイトル

Strange title that can be said

This review contains spoilers. 「来世は他人がいい」でファンになり作者買いです。丁寧かつ淡々としたモノローグの心理描写が小説のようで印象的。ずるずるお話の中に引き摺り込まれました。特徴的な絵柄の女の子がいつも好みじゃなくて残念だけど、男は独特な色気がある感じで好きです。場面の切り替えや、切り取り方が上手い。会話の間などの独特な空気感や緊張感も映像作品観てるみたいです。主人公の妹への過剰な愛情と執着にある背景や、自我を封印して生きてきた冬吾の人物像の裏にある見えない呪縛、モヤモヤしたものがくっきりと見えて来て、常に淡々として無機質だった冬吾の感情が夏美の前で溢れ出た場面とか胸がザワッとした。キュンじゃなくてザワッと。女としての本音を隠したまま逝った妹の情念を知った時の夏美にも。重いだけのお話は嫌なので、2人の何処か抜けた空気感が救いに感じました。完結してるけど…その後が凄く見たい！読み切り短編でも良いから何とかならないかなぁ?

This review contains spoilers. I became a fan of “Other People Will Be Good in the Next Life,” and I'm buying the author. The careful and bland psychological depiction of the monologue looks like a novel and is impressive. I was drawn into the sly story. It's a pity that I don't always like girls with characteristic patterns, but I like men because they have a unique sex appeal. Good at changing scenes and cutting. The unique atmosphere and sense of tension, such as between conversations, also seem to be watching video works. The background of the protagonist's excessive love and obsession with his younger sister, the invisible spells behind Fuygo's figure who has sealed his ego, and the fuzzy things were clearly visible, and the scenes where Fuygo's feelings, who were always indifferent and inorganic, overflowed in front of Natsumi, and I was so excited. It's not Kyun, it's Zahaha. Also for Natsumi when she learned about her sister's feelings when she passed away while hiding her true intentions as a woman. I don't like stories that are just heavy, so I felt that the two of them had lost somewhere was a relief. It's complete, but... I really want to see what comes after that! even a short one-off story is fine, so I wonder if something can be done?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

2人をもうちょっと見たかったな〜

I wanted to see the two of them a little more~

こう言う話好きです。自分は絶対出来ないから、せめて本の中でも幸せになる人の姿が見えて、、、、嬉しいです。でも短いですね！もうちょっと見たかった！

I like stories like this. I can never do it myself, so at least I'm happy to see people who make them happy in books... But it's short! I wanted to see it a little more!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 25, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが読みたい

I want to read more

重いテーマがちりばめられてるけど、主人公の性格に惹かれてあっという間に読み終えました。面白かった。

It's studded with heavy themes, but I was drawn to the main character's personality and finished reading it in no time. That was interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

重たくて卑怯。なにより苦しい。

Heavy and cowardly. Above all, it's painful.

This review contains spoilers. 二冊とも読みました。概ね、面白かったです。話としてはスッキリまとまってて、無駄にひきのばすこともなく。恋愛というよりも家族ものに近いですね。ファミリードラマというほどハートフルで暖かい内容ではないですが。読んだ感じ、昔の昼ドラを見ているような感覚がありました。セリフ回しとか、好き嫌いは別れると思います。私は好きですが、違和感かんじる方もそれなりにいるのではないかな。この作品に難点を言うならばストーリー展開です。主人公である姉の思い込みばかりでストーリーが展開されている印象が強くて、後半はあまり感情移入できませんでした。ラストはご都合主義にスムーズにいきすぎて、何ともあっさりしている。ああいう展開ならば母親にとめられても父親にすべてを暴露した上でやりきるくらいに重くあって欲しかったです。そこで父親のエゴを糾弾して欲しかった。姉妹の心の歪みを産んだのは不倫の果てに元妻から娘二人を奪った、義母と父親のお花畑な恋情にほかならないのだから。不義の罪を糾弾すべきは育ての母だけでなく、父親にこそあるのに。そこをスルーされてしまっているのが消化不良でした。妹の呪いがあるのならそれは姉だけでなく、姉への罪悪感を持たせる原因になった父や義母、弟にも分け合うべきだと思いました。くどいですがストーリー展開は途中まで本当に良かったです。なのでラストがあんなふうにサクサクいってしまったのが残念でなりません。絵柄は他の方も書かれていたとおり見やすくてお上手なので特筆しません。星の数はストーリーのみの評価です。酷評のような感想になりましたが、作品としてはとても好きです。良かっただけにこのような評価となりました。重い内容が大好物な私の過剰な期待があったのでこのような書き方となりましたが、読む価値は充分にあります。ストーリー漫画がお好きならば。作者ご本人がこのような感想をお読みになることはないとおもいますが、今後の作品も期待しています。

This review contains spoilers. I read both books. Overall, it was interesting. As a story, it's neatly organized, and there are no unnecessary distractions. It's more like a family thing than a love affair. The content isn't as heartwarming and heartwarming as a family drama, though. I felt like I was reading it, and I felt like I was watching an old daytime drama. Like spinning lines, I think likes and dislikes will break up. I like it, but I think there are some people who feel uncomfortable. If I had to say anything difficult about this work, it would be the story development. I had a strong impression that the story unfolded with only the assumptions of the older sister, who is the main character, and I couldn't really empathize with it in the second half. The last one went too smoothly due to the principle of expediency, and it was so easy. If it were that kind of development, I wanted it to be so heavy that even if I was stopped by my mother, I would make it through after revealing everything to my father. So I wanted them to denounce my father's ego. What gave birth to the sisters' distortions of heart was none other than the flowery romance between mother-in-law and father, who took their two daughters from their former wife at the end of an affair. It is not only the mother who raised the child, but also the father who should denounce unjust crimes. What got through that was indigestion. If there is a sister's curse, I thought it should be shared not only with my older sister, but also with my father, mother-in-law, and younger brother who caused me to feel guilty about my older sister. It's tough, but the story development was really good until halfway through. So it's a pity that the last one went so quickly. The design is as easy to see as other people wrote it, and they are good at it, so I'm not going to mention it in particular. The number of stars is for stories only. I got the impression that it was a bad review, but I really like it as a work. I received this kind of evaluation just because it was good. It was written this way because I had excessive expectations that heavy content is my favorite, but it's well worth reading. If you like story comics. I don't think the author himself will read this kind of impression, but I'm looking forward to future works.

Helpful

Reviews for Haru's Curse Manga