Mr. Hal's Stan Manga Reviews (P.3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 27, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

可愛い…

cute...

無自覚ストーカーしてしまう御子柴が可愛い…でもキャラに病み感はないので、ストーカーと言っても重くなくて安心して読めました。アイドルなのに素は口の悪いハルのギャップもツボ。これから距離が近付いていくのかな？続き楽しみにしてます！

Mikoshiba, who unwittingly stalks, is cute... but the characters aren't addictive, so I was able to read it without worry because it wasn't heavy even if I said stalker. The gap between Haru, who is an idol and has a bad voice, is also a pressure point. I wonder if the distance is getting closer from now on? I'm looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ストーカーはやめよう

Let's stop stalking

This review contains spoilers. すごく面白いけど、ストーカー盗撮ダメ絶対派なので星4です御子柴がそもそもハルがゲイビ◯チな事を知らない筈ない！と思ったりもしましたが、まぁ良しとして。ハルがデレた後が可愛くて最高です。御子柴はスパダリの予感しかありません。

This review contains spoilers. It's really interesting, but it's 4 stars because stalkers don't do voyeurism, so it's 4 stars. There's no way Mikoshiba didn't know that Haru is gaibi! I also thought, but that's fine. It's so cute and awesome after Haru got rid of it. Mikoshiba only has a premonition of spadari.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

This review contains spoilers. ファンの域を超えた、自宅玄関への差し入れ＆盗撮といったストーカー行為を、榛名が全て肯定的に受け入れていたので、明るい雰囲気で楽しく読ませて頂きました。御子柴の控えめな愛情表現も、榛名のデレた感じも凄く可愛かったです。

This review contains spoilers. Haruna positively accepted all stalking acts that went beyond the realm of fans, such as offering to the front door of her home and voyeurism, so I enjoyed reading it in a cheerful atmosphere. Mikoshiba's modest expression of affection and Haruna's sense of being a delle were so cute.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

可愛い

pretty

ストーカーだけど頼り甲斐があってお人好しで可愛いストーカーでした。最後は2人が幸せになれてよかったです！

Although he was a stalker, he was a reliable, friendly, and cute stalker. I'm glad the two of them were happy at the end!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 21, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

絵の期待を裏切らない実はイケメン

The picture doesn't disappoint, actually, he's a handsome guy

最初の話の流れはちょっと掴みどころなくて、でも、徐々に2人の距離が縮まっていくと、イイ感じでした。もうちょっと、2人の心情変化が対比しやすかったら、話にすっと話に入り込めたのかも。でも楽しめました。

The flow of the first episode was a bit difficult to grasp, but as the distance between the two gradually shrank, it felt good. If it had been a little easier to contrast the emotional changes between the two, they might have been able to quickly get into the conversation. But I enjoyed it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 25, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

食わす嫌い

I don't like to feed you

This review contains spoilers. 表紙にひかれなくて読まずにいましたが、読んでみたら面白かった！ストーカーというか、芸能人受の大ファン攻め。チャラめの受けが変化していくのがキモでした。周りのキャラとの会話のテンポ等、楽しませ方のセンスがいい作家さんです。絵も綺麗で、攻めが普段さえないのに実はイケメンなのもツボでした。続きがあるならよみたいな。

This review contains spoilers. I didn't read it because I wasn't attracted to the cover, but it was interesting to read it! Stalkers, or rather, big fan attacks entertainers. The key was that the reception of the challenge was changing. He is an artist with a good sense of how to entertain, such as the tempo of conversation with the characters around him. The picture was beautiful, and the fact that he was actually a handsome guy even though he didn't usually attack was also a pressure point. It would be nice if there were more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ストーカーも人柄次第？

Do stalkers also depend on personality?

気弱で優しいストーカー×ビ●チなアイドル。はじまりは微妙だったけど、恋人になっていく過程が良かった。ストーカーする必要がなくなった攻はただの優しい男だし、受も恋人ができてビ●チじゃなくなり、ラブラブで微笑ましいCPに。これから先、2人の関係性がどうなっていくのか楽しみです。

A timid and kind stalker x crazy idol. The beginning was subtle, but the process of becoming lovers was good. Attack who no longer needs to be stalked is just a kind man, and since Uke has a lover, he's no longer a friend, and he's a lovey-dovey and smiling CP. I'm looking forward to seeing what the relationship between the two will look like in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いキャラ

Funny characters

This review contains spoilers. 主人公がオタクでストーカーなのに対象のアイドルからアタックされるなんてありえない(笑)。でも面白かった。

This review contains spoilers. Even though the main character is an otaku and stalker, it's impossible to be attacked by the target idol (laughs). But it was interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 14, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ひもひひーれふふぁ？……バカ♡

string hehe hehe huh? ... stupid ♡

体だけは好みとか、下衆アイドルのHALをこよなく愛する御子柴君。ストーカー行為は怖いけど愛が溢れてて、面白かった！私は表紙も好きだけどなぁ〜♡

Mikoshiba-kun loves the lowly idol HAL so much that he likes only the body. Stalking was scary but full of love, and it was fun! I like the cover too~ ♡

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 08, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ストーカーからの

From a stalker

恋人ってのは無理があるけど、漫画なので普通に読めました。絵が好きでは無かったけど続きが気になります。

Lover is impossible, but since it's a comic, I was able to read it normally. I didn't like the picture, but I'm worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

手前じゃないw

it's not in front lol

あらすじの｢ストーカー一歩手前｣には、いや、それをストーカーっていうんだよ、と思いながら読んでみました。思ってたより楽しくてよかったです。HALが私の思い描くアイドルでよかったです！アイドルには裏で性格悪くあって欲しいアイドルオタクですw

I read the synopsis “Stalker One Step Ahead,” while thinking that no, it's called a stalker. I'm glad it was more fun than I expected. I'm glad HAL is my dream idol! I'm an idol nerd who wants idols to have bad personalities behind the scenes lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 17, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

何か純粋で素敵です(*^▽^)/★*☆♪

Something pure and wonderful (*^▽^)/★ * ☆♪

邪だらけなアイドルが純粋過ぎるファンと絆を築くところがいいですね(*ﾟ∀ﾟ人ﾟ∀ﾟ*)♪

It's nice that evil idols build bonds with fans who are too pure (**) ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

ストーカー設定笑えました。しかも暗さがなく、何だか微笑ましく。する側もされる側もあっさりしたところが読みやすかったです。

The stalker settings made me laugh. What's more, there's no darkness, and it's kind of smiling. It was easy to read because it was easy to read on both the doing side and the doing side.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 12, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ふたりとも極端です！

They're both extreme!

ストーカーとアイドルなんですが、ふたりとも違うところでぶっ飛んでます！自分のものさしでの善悪の線引きが凄くて、考え方が極端なんです。ふたりともなので、話が通じてるのかどうか？ってくらいなんですが、ふたりともバカなので何とかなってるのが不思議な関係です。ストーカーから恋人に…ってラブロマンスやら感動やらはありませんが、笑えますね！マネージャーやグループの２人がHALに理解があり、アホで迷惑かけそうなのに愛されキャラなんだなぁと感じます。

They're stalkers and idols, but they're both flying off in different places! The line between right and wrong with my own yardstick is amazing, and my way of thinking is extreme. It's both of them, so I wonder if the conversation is getting through? That's about it, but they're both stupid, so it's a strange relationship that they're doing something. From stalker to lover... there's no such thing as a love romance, but it's funny! The manager and the two people in the group understand HAL, and I feel that they are characters that are loved even though they are stupid and seem to cause trouble.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 04, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

かわいいおとぎ話

cute fairy tale

絵も上手だし、ストーリー展開もスムーズで読みやすく、ほっとできるようなかわいいお話でした。少女漫画じゃない点もよかったです。二人がだんだんと信頼を深めていくところが自然な流れで描かれていて、漫画らしいおもしろさがありました。続きがあるなら読みたいです。ただ、BLらしいドラマ性が感じられないこの表紙はあまりよくないですね。まとめる時は画力を生かしてもっと目を引く、きれいな表紙にした方が読者も増えるだろうと思います。

The pictures were good, the storyline was smooth and easy to read, and it was a cute story that made me feel relieved. It was also nice that it wasn't a girls' manga. The way the two gradually deepened their trust was depicted in a natural way, and it was interesting like a comic. I'd like to read if there's more. However, this cover where you can't feel the drama typical of BL isn't very good. When putting it together, I think the number of readers will increase if you make use of your drawing power to make a more eye-catching, beautiful cover.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 02, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

BLぽくない表紙。

A cover that doesn't look like BL.

表紙の雰囲気とよく分からないタイトルだったので、サイコパス系のサスペンスだと勝手に思って読んだらBLでした(笑)登場キャラの性格や見た目が分かりやすくて好感が持てます。題材はストーカーで犯罪なのに、なんだか優しい世界で面白かったです。

It was a title I didn't really understand about the atmosphere on the cover, so I thought it was psychopath suspense and it was BL (laughs). The personalities and looks of the characters that appear are easy to understand, and I like them. Even though the subject is stalking and crime, it was kind of interesting in a kind world.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 24, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

これは良いストーカー(笑)

this is a good stalker (lol)

This review contains spoilers. 御子柴がストーカーなのに常識あって良い人なのが面白いwハルも最初はワガママなのかな？と思ったら素直で裏表無くて憎めないタイプで可愛かった。というか一応ストーカーだった相手に心広すぎ(笑)盗撮も弁当の件もあっさり受け入れてて笑ったwこの二人とても相性良いよね。ストーリーも読みやすくて面白かった！メンバーと伊藤さんも良いキャラしてて好き！

This review contains spoilers. Even though Mikoshiba is a stalker, it's interesting that he has common sense and is a good person, I wonder if W-Haru is also selfish at first? When I thought about it, they were the type that was straightforward, had no two sides, and couldn't be hated, and they were cute. Or rather, I had too much heart for someone who was my stalker for the time being (laughs) they easily accepted the voyeurism and bento incident and laughed lol these two are very compatible. The story was also easy to read and interesting! The members and Mr. Ito also have good characters and I like them!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

何だかなぁ～♪

I wonder what it is~ ♪

１巻読んだときはないわぁ～…と、思っていましたが、物は試しに続きを読んだら結構いけちゃいました(笑)サブキャラたちが面白すぎる♪アイドルなのに自然体過ぎるしマネージャーなんてカッコよすぎる(笑)是非とも拗らせすぎのメンバー2人のスピンオフも♪

I thought I hadn't read volume 1 wow... but after reading the other stuff as a test (lol) the subcharacters are too interesting ♪ even though they're idols, they're too natural and the manager is too cool (lol) there are also spin-offs of the 2 members who are definitely too relentless ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 02, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ほんわかもの

Warm fuzzy things

アイドルのストーカーネタですが、面白かったです。ほんわかボーイズラブで、たのしめますよ

It's an idol stalker story, and it was interesting. I'm having fun with Warm Boys' Love

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

節度あるストーカー笑

moderated stalker lol

This review contains spoilers. 御子柴さんが純粋なファンでストーカーだけど節度あるストーカーでいいキャラでした。はじめはアイドルハルくんの性格悪そう〜と思っていましたが話が進むに連れ、男前でかわいいく好きになりました。普段わんこな攻めがコスプレの延長線プレイの時にS気たっぷりに豹変したシーンが特によかった。、

This review contains spoilers. Mikoshiba-san was a pure fan and stalker, but she was a good character as a moderated stalker. At first, I thought the idol Haru-kun seemed to have a bad personality, but as the story progressed, I fell in love with him for being handsome and cute. I especially liked the scene where the usual doggy attack suddenly changed when playing as an extension of cosplay, with plenty of sense of selfishness. ,

Helpful

Reviews for Mr. Hal's Stan Manga