Mr. Hal's Stan Manga Reviews

Lucie Nona

Report

Jun 06, 2025 (PST) | Total Reviews: 148

Cute , sweet, and at tad of stalking

This review contains spoilers. I like the lines between acceptable and inappropriate in this comic. The main leads are each cute in there own way. I read to six and I hope to get more. The acceptance from each of their non-public faces really makes this sweet.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 23, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵な彼氏ができはってよろしおすなー♡

I'm glad to have a wonderful boyfriend ♡

いいなぁ。素敵な彼氏だなぁそりゃハルくんも落ちちゃうなぁ。ストーカーしちゃうくらい好きなのに、素の彼はもっともっと魅力的とかたまらないですね。メンバー間でフェチぶっちゃけシーンが何気に好きでした。

That's great. he's a wonderful boyfriend, well, Haru-kun would fall for him too. I like him so much that he stalks him, but his real boyfriend is even more charming and irresistible. I really liked the fetishist scene between the members.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

思った以上に良かった笑

it was better than I thought lol

表紙でぱっと見期待してなかったのだが、面白かった。ハルもおかしな奴なんだけどだんだん恋する乙女みたいになってくの可愛いし、御子柴イケメンかよだし、実際ヒーローになってるし公認カップルなのこっちも嬉しい笑。愛重々カップルで仲良くしてほしいな

I wasn't expecting to take a quick look at the cover, but it was interesting. Haru is also a funny guy, but he's cute as he gradually becomes like an otome in love, Mikoshiba is a handsome guy, and they're actually a hero, and they're an official couple lol. I want the Aishige couple to get along well

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

謙虚すぎるストーカー

A stalker who is too humble

This review contains spoilers. 御子柴はHALのストーカーだったが、謙虚すぎますね。それが、HALの心を射止めた要因でしょう。『美しい彼』がすごく好きなので少し似てるとも思いました。『美しい彼』は本屋大賞を２回もとった作者が書いた小説で大作ですし、それに比べるとどうしても話は薄くはなるのは仕方ないですよね。比較して申し訳ないです。ですが、こちらはこちらで元々芸能人とストーカーの設定だったり、ちょっとした設定は違うのでこれはこれで有りかなと。芸能人のHALが絆されていくとこや御子柴が仕事面にも真面目にとりくむようす、何かを目撃してもまずはこれは、、と一度良い方に考えるところなど、人間的表現は描かれていると思います。メンバーにも公認となり、これからもがんばれそうなHALくんでした。

This review contains spoilers. Mikoshiba was HAL's stalker, but he's too humble. That was probably the factor that captured HAL's heart. I really like “The Beautiful Guy,” so I thought they were a little similar. “The Beautiful Guy” is a novel written by an author who has won the Bookstore Award twice, and it's unavoidable that the story gets thin compared to that. Sorry for the comparison. However, this is where the settings are originally for celebrities and stalkers, and the settings are slightly different, so I wonder if this is the case. I think it depicts human expressions, such as places where celebrities HAL are bonded, how Mikoshiba takes work seriously, and places where they think in a good way once even if they witness something, this is the first thing to do. HAL-kun was officially recognized by the members, and it seems like HAL will continue to do his best.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 08, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かったです！

That was interesting!

ドロドロ執着系かと思いきや、ベタベタワンコ系でしたガッツリストーカーしてるのに、尚且つ据え膳食わず一ファンとして応援する姿勢にグッときましたサクッとハッピーエンドで良かったです！

I thought they were obsessed with being muddy, but even though they were sticky-doggy guts talkers, I was surprised by their attitude of cheering as a fan without putting down a meal. I'm glad it had a quick and happy ending!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 13, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

すごく面白い！

It's so funny!

This review contains spoilers. アイドルのハル君のファンで生真面目なストーカー御子柴君のハラハラBL、凄く良かったです！マネージャー伊藤さんやアイドルメンバーのmaki君達もハル君の良い仲間でチームワーク良く2人の恋を応援してあげてて心温まりました！

This review contains spoilers. The harahara BL of Mikoshiba-kun, a serious stalker who is a fan of the idol Haru-kun, was really good! Manager Ito and idol member Maki-kun were also good friends with Haru and they had good teamwork to support their love, which was heartwarming!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

セリフ回しがうまい

Good at spinning lines

YouTubeで途中まで見て、でもタイトルがわからなくて必死に検索してたどり着きました。セリフ回しがとにかく上手く、言葉の選び方が秀逸。ただ、一つ一つのエピソードが面白いだけに、もっとページ数を増やしてエピソードに深みを持たせていたらなあ、とそこだけが残念。絵も上手く、その時々の感情を表情で描き分けられる実力派ですね。

I watched it halfway through on YouTube, but I didn't understand the title, so I desperately searched for it and arrived. They are really good at turning the lines, and the way they choose words is excellent. However, since each episode is interesting, I wish they had increased the number of pages even more to add depth to the episodes, which is the only shame. They are also good at drawing, and they are talented people who can draw emotions from time to time with facial expressions.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 05, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公がめっちゃかわいい。

The main character is so cute.

This review contains spoilers. 最初はストーカー…ヤンデレなのか？ホラーなのか…と、思って読み始めたのですが、めちゃくちゃかわいいいい意味で少しズレたカップルで楽しく読むことができました。みこしばくんがHALさんのこと本当に好きなことが伝わってきてキュンキュンするし、HALさんの器の大きさにメロメロになりました。お弁当美味しそうに食べてくれる所と、写真許してあげるくだりが特に好きです。何回も読み返したい作品に出会えて嬉しいです。

This review contains spoilers. Stalker at first... was it a yandere? I started reading it because I thought it was horror... but I enjoyed reading it with an insanely cute couple that was slightly out of place in a good sense. The fact that Mikoshiba-kun really likes HAL was conveyed, and I was thrilled, and I was dumbfounded by the size of HAL's vessel. I especially like places where they eat delicious bento boxes and I forgive them for photos. I'm happy to come across a work that I want to reread over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 20, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

予想外な話

An unexpected story

真面目謙虚ストーカー×アイドルいい意味で予想を裏切ってくれた内容です！御子柴いいすごく好き。ストーカーものなのに薄暗いところはなく、くすっと笑えるところもあって、おもしろく読めました。終わったのが残念！もっと読みたかった。

Serious Humble Stalker x Idol The content betrayed my expectations in a good sense! Mikoshiba is good, I really like it. Even though it was a stalker, there were no dim places, and there were places where I was able to giggle, so it was an interesting read. Too bad it's over! I wanted to read more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 08, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

表紙

FrontPage

表紙から想像してた話だともっと怖いストーカーだったんだけど、そうではなかったです。御子柴やったね！

The story I had imagined from the cover was an even scarier stalker, but that wasn't the case. Mikoshiba did it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 17, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かったー

That was interesting

読みホにて。初めての作家さん。男性アイドルHALの大ファンゆえに、行動がストーカー化してくる御子柴くんのお話。すごくテンポもノリもよく、サクサク読めました！面白かった！ストーカーは怖いけど、結局HALを夢中にさせたのスゴイ！

Read it in Ho. My first time as a writer. This is a story about Mikoshiba-kun, whose actions become stalkers because he is a big fan of the male idol HAL. The tempo and focus were really good, and I was able to read it quickly! That was interesting! Stalkers are scary, but it's amazing that they made HAL crazy after all!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 18, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

わーおもしろい

Wow that's interesting

テンポ良くサクサク読めて、絵もきれいで面白かったー。私もこのカッコイイ表紙が好きです。みこしばカッコイイ。。。もっともっと読んでいたい二人でした。続きを期待してまーす！

I was able to read it quickly at a good tempo, and the pictures were beautiful and interesting. I love this cool cover too. Mikoshiba is cool... They were two people who wanted to read more. I'm looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

自己評価の低い攻めちゃん?

Attack-chan who has a low self-esteem?

芸能人のHALは顔の認識なくいい体だなぁとしか覚えてないけど、マスコミから助けてもらったきっかけで気になり出した由一にだんだんとゾッコンになっていきます?ハマってどんどん読んじゃいました！面白かったよー‼

I only remember that the entertainer HAL has a nice body without facial recognition, but he gradually becomes overwhelmed by Yuichi, who started to worry about it after getting help from the mass media? I've been reading more and more about Hama! That was interesting ‼

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 09, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

とても良い！！

very good!!

絵も良くて話も面白くてサクサク読めました！もっと読みたい?２人の今後のラブラブが気になります?

The pictures were good, the story was interesting, and I was able to read it quickly! Want to read more? Are you curious about the love love between the two of them in the future?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 08, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

タイトルの通り。

As the title suggests.

御子柴さん…思いが実って良かった‼︎ハルも最初は体だけを見て気に入ってたけど、御子柴さんの人柄と熱い思いにどんどんの好きになってく過程も良い。

Mikoshiba-san... I'm glad my thoughts came true ‼ ︎ I liked Haru by looking only at her body at first, but the process of falling more and more in love with Mikoshiba-san's personality and passion is also good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 03, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

いいカラダのストーカー

Stalker with a good body

絵が綺麗でとても読みやすかったです?ストーカーだけど陰湿な感じは無くてとても楽しく読めました♪

Was the picture beautiful and very easy to read? It's a stalker, but it wasn't insidious and I enjoyed reading it so much ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

すっごいよかった

That was so good

御子柴君のストーカーぶりは健気（笑）二人の会話や仲間の言葉に笑って読み終わった後にスッキリする

Mikoshiba-kun's stalker is healthy (lol) I laugh at the conversations between the two of them and the words of my friends, and I feel refreshed after I finish reading

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 01, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

表紙を見た時は、ヤバいストーカーでダークな話かと思ったけど全然違ってました。普通に優しい人でした。あと、ちゃんとした社会人だった。やってる事はモロにストーカーだけどね･･･HALくんが恋に落ちてく感じもよかった。お似合いの2人でした。

When I saw the cover, I thought it was a dangerous stalker and a dark story, but it was completely different. He was usually a kind person. Also, he was a proper member of society. What they're doing is stalking Moro, but... it also felt good that HAL fell in love. They were two good matches.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

This review contains spoilers. 御子柴さんファンで家も近くにして毎日ドアノブにかけるぐらいなのに1回目誘われてもしないのちょっと笑っちゃいました。とても面白かったです。

This review contains spoilers. I was a fan of Mikoshiba and I laughed a little bit at not being invited the first time even though I was close to my house and put it on the doorknob every day. It was very interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 29, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

愛がある

There is love

ストーカーはだめだけど一生懸命HALくんのファンをする御子柴くんが可愛くて可愛くて…もっさりしてるだけでイケメンだし体バキバキだしHALくんも好きになるわ…HALくんがだんだん御子柴くんを好きになっていくのがキュンとくるストーリーでした。

Stalking is no good, but Mikoshiba-kun, who works so hard as a fan of HAL, is cute and cute... just because he's lumpy up, HAL-kun is a good-looking guy, his body is fluttering, and HAL-kun falls in love with it... it was a thrilling story where HAL gradually fell in love with Mikoshiba-kun.

Helpful

Reviews for Mr. Hal's Stan Manga