THE SCENE OF MY RUMSPRINGA Manga Reviews (P.3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

幸せを考えさせられるお話。

A story that makes me think about happiness.

This review contains spoilers. 文化の違い。幸せとは色々な形があり、正解はなく、その時々に立つ岐路で自分の思いのままに進むのか、違う道をいくのか、、、どちらの幸せを選んでも幸せかも知れないし、後悔の嵐かもしれない。純粋なハッピーエンドでは無いお話に、考えさせられる。私の中で、1番きもちにより添えたのは、意外にもダニーだった。

This review contains spoilers. Cultural differences. Happiness comes in many forms, and there is no right answer, and no matter which happiness you choose, whether you go the way you want or go on a different path at the crossroads you stand at from time to time, you may be happy, or it may be a storm of regrets. It's a story that doesn't have a pure happy ending, and it makes me think. Surprisingly, it was Danny who helped me the most.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

衝撃的

impacting

とても良いです。知らない文化を知れて、色んな形の幸せがあることを考えさせられます。ハッピーエンドともバッドエンドともとれぬ、儚い結末で読了後の余韻がとてつもない作品です。

It's very good. I learned about a culture I didn't know, and it made me think that there are many forms of happiness. It is a work with an ephemeral ending that cannot be taken as a happy ending or a bad ending, and the afterglow after reading is tremendous.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らしかったです。

It was amazing.

親愛なるジーンへを読みたくてシリーズ初めのこちらを購読。本作を読んでからの方がより親愛なる～の理解が深まるとのことで挑み？ましたが、素晴らしかったです。アーミッシュについても初めて知りました。何を書いてもこの素晴らしさを上手く表現できる自信がありません。人生は選択の連続で、得れば失うものもあるけれど自分が選んだ選択を信じる事、大切な人と生きていく尊さ、苦しさの様なものがテオとオズ、ダニーとクロエたちの物語から伝わってきました。ハンカチ必須です。綺麗なだけじゃない、苦しい愛の物語だと思いました。ラストは爽快で、物語の彼ら、彼女に心からのエールを送りたい！！

I wanted to read Dear Gene, so I subscribed to the first one in the series. Are you taking on the challenge because it is said that you will have a deeper understanding of Dear ~ after reading this work? But it was great. I also learned about the Amish for the first time. No matter what I write, I don't have the confidence to be able to express this awesomeness well. Life is a series of choices, and if you gain, there are things you lose, but things like believing in the choices you have made, the preciousness and suffering of living with loved ones have been conveyed from the stories of Theo, Oz, Danny, and Chloe. A handkerchief is essential. I thought it was not only a beautiful story, but also a painful love story. The last one was exhilarating, and I want to send my sincere cheers to them and her in the story!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 09, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

異国系BLの金字塔。自分自身の願いのため

The gold standard for exotic BL. For my own wishes

80年代アメリカ。アーミッシュという宗教的な移民の村には洗礼前に、ラムスプリンガという通常許されない規律から開放される期間がある。その青春時代に村から出たテオと、街で働くオズの、宗教や境遇を超え惹かれ合い、自身の願いを見つけるお話。テオがかなり抜けた性格で、序盤は心配になりましたが、後半男見せます。親や誰かのためじゃなく、自分はどうありたいか、幸せとは何か、考えさせられました。テオを想う皆の気持ちが胸に迫ります。ぜひ異国を感じながら、覚悟を決めた彼らの、永遠に忘れない情景を目にしてください。ストーリー◎トップクラス。異国系最強。画力○キャラ◎エロ○黒線やトーン。少なめです。

80s America. In a religious immigrant village called the Amish, there is a period of freedom from the ordinarily unforgivable discipline called ramspringa before baptism. It's a story about Theo, who came out of the village in his youth, and Oz, who works in the city, who are attracted to each other across religion and circumstances, and find their own wishes. Theo has a pretty weak personality, and I was worried at the beginning, but I'll show you the man in the second half. It made me think about what I want to be and what happiness is, not for my parents or anyone else. Everyone's feelings for Theo come close to their hearts. Please take a look at the scene they will never forget while feeling a foreign country and making up their mind. Story ◎ Top Class. Exotic people are the strongest. Drawing power ○ characters ◎ erotica ○ black lines and tones. It's less.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

何度も読み返す大好きな作品

Favorite work that I reread over and over

ストーリーについても素晴らしいのですが、単純にテオのThe可愛い年下へたれわんこ攻めという属性が最高。真っ直ぐでオズが大好きな安心できる攻めだからかなり障害は大きかったけど愛の力で解決したなぁと感じます。十分えっちなシーンあるのですがふたりのえっちなシーンをもっと見たかった〜

The story is also great, but simply Theo's attribute of attacking the cute younger one is the best. It's a straight, reassuring attack that Oz loves, so the obstacles were pretty big, but I feel that they were solved with the power of love. There are scenes that are eccentric enough, but I wanted to see more eccentric scenes between them ~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

親愛なるジーンからきました

I'm here from dear Gene

先に親愛なるジーンを読んでこちらに。全てを捨てる決意をしたテオを後悔することないように人生を送って欲しいと願いました。王道のラブストーリーでした

Read Dear Gene first here. I wanted Theo to live his life so he wouldn't regret it when he made up his mind to throw everything away. It was a royal love story

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ストーリー重視！

Focus on the story!

一気に購入しましたが、ストーリが良すぎて本当に感動しました。この作品だけの物語性があるので王道に飽きた方はぜひこれを読んでみてください！

I bought it all at once, and the story was so good that I was really moved. There is a story unique to this work, so if you're tired of the royal road, be sure to read this!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵な作品

A wonderful piece

This review contains spoilers. ハリウッド映画にありそうな素敵な話でした。変わっていく僕を嫌いになる？かな？素敵なセリフでした。ジーンを少し読んで悲しくなったので不安でしたが最後は心が温かくなる素敵な作品でした。

This review contains spoilers. It was a wonderful story that seemed like something out of a Hollywood movie. Are you going to hate me as I change? maybe? That was a wonderful line. Reading Gene made me sad, so I was uneasy, but at the end it was a wonderful work that warmed my heart.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

世界観が素敵

The view of the world is wonderful

世界観がとっても素敵で、一気に作者さんのファンになりました。珍しいテーマだと思うのですが、難しすぎることはなくお話に引き込まれました。

The view of the world was so wonderful, and I quickly became a fan of the author. I think it's an unusual theme, but it wasn't too difficult and I was drawn into the story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

何回読んでも泣く…

I cry no matter how many times I read it...

全てが大好きです。ストーリーも絵もすけべシーンも……レビューも内容も何も知らないで読んでみてください。ぜひこのストーリーの世界を堪能してください。こんな素敵なお話を読めて幸せです。作者様に感謝……

I love everything. The story, the pictures, the amazing scenes... please read without knowing the reviews, content, or anything. Please enjoy the world of this story. I'm happy to read such a wonderful story. Thanks to the author...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

神作品

God's work

This review contains spoilers. すごく考えさせられる作品でした。もっと早くに読めば良かった…それぞれみんなの心情が痛いほど伝わってきて何度ウルッときたことか。先生もあとがきで言ってたように、定番ド王道なんだけど全くマンネリしないのがやはりすごい。読み進めるうちに世界観に入ってしまいます。親愛なるジーンを読む前にこちらをと軽い気持ちで読みましたが余韻がすごいです。

This review contains spoilers. It was a really thought provoking work. I wish I had read it sooner... how many times was it that each one painfully conveyed everyone's feelings and made me cringe. As the teacher said in the afterword, it's still amazing that even though it's a standard road, they don't get into a rut at all. As I read on, I fell into a worldview. I read this with a light feeling before reading Dear Jean, and the afterglow is amazing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 15, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らしかった。。。

It was great...

フォロー様がたのレビューが「親愛なるジーンへ」に彩られ胸熱です。。と、本棚見返してみたら、な、なんとラムスプリンガが未購入！えー！！BL買い漁っていた頃に漏れてしまっていたのか。がーんと言う事で、急いで購入。ラムスプリンガの試し読みだけで凄く印象深くて、出だししっかり覚えていました。親愛なる1巻やラムスプリンガを読むまでアーミッシュも知らなくてあまり縁のない世界ですが、共感しまくり素晴らしい作品でした。私が言うまでもなく神作品。桜田先輩から吾妻先生に入ったので、振り幅に敬服します。

The reviews from the followers were colored “Dear Jean,” and I'm excited. When I looked back at the bookshelf, wow, I hadn't bought Lamb Springa! Eh!! I wonder if it missed it when I was shopping for BL. Hmm, so I bought it in a hurry. I was really impressed by just the trial reading of Lamb Springa, and I memorized it well when I first started. It's a world where I didn't know the Amish until I read Dear Volume 1 and Ramspringa, and I had a lot of sympathy for it, and it was a wonderful work. Needless to say, it's a divine work. I joined Azuma senpai from Sakurada-senpai, so I admire the amplitude.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 15, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

シリーズ3冊で、完結です💯

It's a series of 3 books, and it's complete 💯

今作＋｢親愛なるジーンへ｣2冊＝3冊で完結です。｢親愛なる〜｣2巻目は、通常版と特装版がありますのでご購入の際は気をつけて下さい⚠今作で、恋に落ちた方は、言うまでもなく“特装版”をおすすめです。時系列的には、｢親愛なる〜｣が過去になりますが、今作から読むことでラムスプリンガとはどういうものか、背景と設定が詳しくわかります。特にこのシリーズは、今作→｢親愛なる〜｣→今作…と無限ループで楽しめる作品です。また、｢親愛なる〜｣では若い時のオズがチラチラと隠れて登場してたり、テオもチラッと隠れて登場してます。ウォーリーを探せ、みたいに見つけた時の喜びはきゅんです❤️吾妻先生の遊び心、粋な計らいが素敵です。

This work plus “Dear Gene” 2 books = 3 books is complete. The second volume of “Dear ~” has a regular edition and a special edition, so please be careful when purchasing ⚠ If you have fallen in love with this work, needless to say, I recommend the “Special Edition.” Chronologically, “Dear ~” is in the past, but by reading from this work, you can understand in detail the background and settings of what Lamb Springa is. In particular, this series is a work that you can enjoy in an infinite loop with this work → “Dear ~” → this work... Also, in “Dear ~,” Oz when he was young appears in hiding, and Theo also appears in a sneak peek behind closed doors. Like Looking for Wally, I'm happy when I find it ❤️ Azuma sensei's playful sense of fun and stylish plan is wonderful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

好き

likes

気付いたら涙がボロボロ溢れていました。この漫画自体に郷愁を感じて胸が熱くなりました。少し時間を開けて、新鮮な気持ちでまた読み直したい作品です。

Before I knew it, my tears were in tatters. My heart was heated because I felt nostalgic about this comic itself. It's a work I want to open up a bit and reread it again with a fresh feeling.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

変わっていく自分

My changing self

知り合いだらけの小さな街に暮らすオズと、文化や社会を断絶し家族と仲間だけで独自のコミュニティを形成した村から来たテオ。全く違う環境にいたのに不思議と気が合って一緒にいる二人。アーミッシュの世界を通して自分にとって本当に必要なのは何かが見えてきます。オズやテオ、ダニーやクロエそしてジーン、それぞれの夢や幸せが良い方向にいくといいな。

Oz, who lives in a small town full of acquaintances, and Theo, who came from a village that cut off culture and society and formed a unique community with only family and friends. Even though they were in a completely different environment, they strangely got along and stayed together. Through the Amish world, I can see what I really need. I hope the dreams and happiness of Oz, Theo, Danny, Chloe, and Gene go in a positive direction.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

深い感動

Deeply moved

This review contains spoilers. アーミッシュをこの作品で初めて知りました。本当に良いアメリカ映画を観たような、深い感動が押し寄せます。色々思いが溢れますが、うまく言葉にできません。時代背景や宗教、家族、夢と挫折、同性愛。全ての事柄、登場人物が必然に絡み合って、非常にドラマチックです。そして、運命の出会いってこういうことなんだな、と。余談ですが、ドラマCDの小冊子のその後の彼らもすごく良くて。2人が幸せに暮らしてるんだな、と幸せな気持ちになりました。この作品に出会えて良かった！

This review contains spoilers. I first learned about the Amish through this work. I was deeply moved, as if I had watched a really good American film. I have a lot of thoughts, but I can't put them into words. Historical background, religion, family, dreams and setbacks, homosexuality. All the events and characters are inevitably intertwined, and it's very dramatic. Also, I thought, this is what a fateful encounter is like. As an aside, they were also really good after the drama CD booklet. It made me feel happy that the two of them are living a happy life. I'm glad I came across this work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 20, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

優しい人間が優しさ以外の感情を抱く時。

When kind people have feelings other than kindness.

面白かったです。BLはただのテイストでどちらかといえばヒューマン系の話だと思う。優しさ以外の感情を持ってはいけない人間が本当に幸せなのか？問いかけられています。また全てを捨ててもたった一つの愛が欲しいなら、その時点で愛は残酷であるとも思いました。お話としてはテオの成長がただただ豊穣で快い作品です…。

That was interesting. BL is just a taste; if anything, I think it's a human story. Are people who are not supposed to have feelings other than kindness really happy? The question is being asked. Also, if you want only one love even if you throw everything away, I thought love would be cruel at that point. As for the story, Theo's growth is simply a fruitful and pleasant work...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

才光る先生

Talented teacher

題材からもう攻めてる。香夜先生の知識量にあっぱれ。人も背景も絵がとても美しいし、構成やストーリー全てが完璧です。ミュージカルオタなので途中ちらっと「コーラスライン」が出てきたところでテンション上がりました⤴スピンオフの「親愛なるジーンへ」も大好きで続きが待ち遠しい…

I'm already attacking from the subject. Let yourself be carried away by Kaya-sensei's knowledge. The people and background are very beautiful, and the structure and story are all perfect. I'm a musical otaku, so my tension went up when “Chorus Line” came up halfway ⤴ I love the spin-off “Dear Jean” and I can't wait for the continuation...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 26, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

映画みたような感覚

Feels like watching a movie

80年代のアメリカ、アーミッシュのラムスプリンガーという期間に絡めた秀逸なストーリーでした。おバカそうに見えて、実は色々分かっているのでは？って感じのテオはずるいなぁ。すごい稀有なキャラクター。いろんな作家さんがおすすめしてた作品なだけあって、すんごい良かった。最後、気づいたら感動して涙出てました

It was an excellent story about America in the 80s and the Amish Lamb Springer period. It looks stupid, but you actually know a lot, don't you? Theo, who feels like that, is sly. A very rare character. It was really nice because it was just a work recommended by various artists. At the end, when I noticed it, I was moved and burst into tears

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

読んでよかったと思える作品

Works I'm glad I read

メインの2人だけじゃなくて、どのキャラクターにも感情移入しやすくて、とてもエモーショナルな気持ちにさせられた。読んでいる間も何度か涙したけど、読了後にも悲しみとか嬉しさとか感動とか、いろんな感情でじわじわ泣けてくる作品。

It was easy to empathize with all the characters, not just the two main characters, and it made me feel very emotional. I cried a few times while I was reading it, but even after reading it, it slowly made me cry with all kinds of emotions, such as sadness, joy, and emotion.

Helpful

Reviews for THE SCENE OF MY RUMSPRINGA Manga